On 1/11/2013 11:38 AM, Jim Thompson wrote:
> I'm not yet forced in Win7, but my question is, will Win7 allow me to
> install Eudora in its own folder that is NOT under "Program Files" ??
You will find that even the Eudora installer
lets you put Eudora programs anywhere,
and also lets you put "mail" (user data) anywhere.
It's only the _consequences_ of where you put stuff
that may turn out to be problematic,
not that anyone prevents you from building your home,
for example, right over a toxic waste dump site :)
Google's "Chrome" web browser seems to serve as an example
of a creative way of installing without sacrificing too much
in terms of security. I've seen some installations where
a user's set of program files for Chrome goes into his/her
own private Windows "profile" (below "Documents and Settings"
for Windows 2000 and XP, or below "Users" for Vista, W7 and W8),
rather than under a single system-wide "Program Files" area.
You could do the same for Windows 7/8, if you wish,
but for what goal do you not want to put Eudora's programs
in the safest and most guarded of all system locations?
The "user data folder" for Eudora normally defaults,
in the installer, unless biased by an earlier installation
that's been remembered in the Registry, to the choice called
"User's Application Data folder." In my opinion, that's the
best and safest location to use on the drive containing Windows,
so I suggest altering that default only when you need
to put it on a different drive.
You can always create a Windows "shortcut" to your "Data" folder,
on your desktop of anywhere else, so that you can jump right
to that directory any time you want -- this instantly solves
the so-called "problem" of the default location having a
"hidden" directory above it, when then becomes moot.
Eudora itself also provides a "shortcut" that you can simply click,
in version 7.1, to open your "Data" path, which again renders
completely moot any concerns about "finding" the data directory.
When you install all other programs under Windows,
do you similarly look for non-default places to put
their program files and/or user data? If not,
why treat Eudora any differently?
The only thing that, aside from reduced security,
may cause problems to Eudora, is if you try to use
system-protected locations (e.g. Program Files areas)
to store user data, because Windows now fiercely protects
those areas, trying not to let you write or update anything
in those areas, by re-directing any such writing, without even telling
the application program, into another private area of the current user's
Windows profile. This is what makes everything act as if running normally,
but you get various spurious error messages, and then one day
you can't even find your mail, your settings, or your address books,
and they're not even in what you thought was your backup -- that's
when you go into shock and finally realize that the original installation
was mismanaged, at which time it's more difficult to straighten out.
No matter where you install Eudora program files, I would always
make sure not to put user data under any folder containing program files;
just recognize that when installing any application that involves original,
never-changing program files, and later involves ever-changing user data,
that modern practice strongly indicates that these two file collections
should be independent of one another, nor have one within the other.
The very language "install Eudora in its own [single?] folder" already shows
an obsolete line of thinking, not practiced by any modern software,
where the distinction between programs vs. data areas didn't exist,
and malevolence being targeted through computers
was not one of the basic facts of life.
Nature figured this out long ago, by the way, at least for humans,
by installing their brain inside a separate, hard skull :)
--