info
Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss
About cable modem firmware updates
25 views
Skip to first unread message
John Corliss
Feb 12, 2015, 7:06:53 PM2/12/15
to
Just learned today that I am not allowed to update my cable modem's
firmware. Also, I have no say in whether or not my ISP updates that
firmware!
"It's the standard."
"It's common industry practice."
etc.
Does this business model bother anybody else? Doesn't anybody else see
where this can lead?
What's to stop, say, Arris, from deciding that it's time for SB6141
owners to buy a new modem and in order to force them to do that, release
a firmware update which slowly decreases the modem's functionality until
it quits working?
And if this precedent is established, what about things like "smart tvs"
and other objects connected to the vaunted "internet of things"?
Yep, Joe Blow has owned his refrigerator for two years now. Time for him
to get a new one. ***ZAP*** Refrigerator start cooling less and less
efficiently each day until it doesn't work at all.
First, there was planned obsolescence with cars wherein the
manufacturers deliberately engineered components to wear out much sooner
than they should. Now, if this crap is allowed to continue without being
challenged, the consumer will be allowing manufacturers to remotely
disable equipment and force buying of newer models.
If ISPs want to treat cable modems like they own them, then they SHOULD
own them and the end user shouldn't have to purchase or rent them.
--
John Corliss
firmware. Also, I have no say in whether or not my ISP updates that
firmware!
"It's the standard."
"It's common industry practice."
etc.
Does this business model bother anybody else? Doesn't anybody else see
where this can lead?
What's to stop, say, Arris, from deciding that it's time for SB6141
owners to buy a new modem and in order to force them to do that, release
a firmware update which slowly decreases the modem's functionality until
it quits working?
And if this precedent is established, what about things like "smart tvs"
and other objects connected to the vaunted "internet of things"?
Yep, Joe Blow has owned his refrigerator for two years now. Time for him
to get a new one. ***ZAP*** Refrigerator start cooling less and less
efficiently each day until it doesn't work at all.
First, there was planned obsolescence with cars wherein the
manufacturers deliberately engineered components to wear out much sooner
than they should. Now, if this crap is allowed to continue without being
challenged, the consumer will be allowing manufacturers to remotely
disable equipment and force buying of newer models.
If ISPs want to treat cable modems like they own them, then they SHOULD
own them and the end user shouldn't have to purchase or rent them.
--
John Corliss
Message has been deleted
John Corliss
Feb 13, 2015, 1:37:54 PM2/13/15
to
Elmo P. Shagnasty wrote:
>
> Ever notice your battery life seriously declining right around two years?
I don't have a cell phone. Never have. Batteries have a life span
though. I know the rechargeable ones I use with my camera are retaining
their charge less than when I first got them.
--
John Corliss
> John Corliss wrote:
>>
>> Just learned today that I am not allowed to update my cable modem's
>> firmware. Also, I have no say in whether or not my ISP updates that
>> firmware!
>>
>> "It's the standard."
>> "It's common industry practice."
>> etc.
>>
>> Does this business model bother anybody else? Doesn't anybody else see
>> where this can lead?
>>
>> What's to stop, say, Arris, from deciding that it's time for SB6141
>> owners to buy a new modem and in order to force them to do that, release
>> a firmware update which slowly decreases the modem's functionality until
>> it quits working?
>
> dude, that's the cell phone industry model for many years now.
>>
>> Just learned today that I am not allowed to update my cable modem's
>> firmware. Also, I have no say in whether or not my ISP updates that
>> firmware!
>>
>> "It's the standard."
>> "It's common industry practice."
>> etc.
>>
>> Does this business model bother anybody else? Doesn't anybody else see
>> where this can lead?
>>
>> What's to stop, say, Arris, from deciding that it's time for SB6141
>> owners to buy a new modem and in order to force them to do that, release
>> a firmware update which slowly decreases the modem's functionality until
>> it quits working?
>
>
> Ever notice your battery life seriously declining right around two years?
I don't have a cell phone. Never have. Batteries have a life span
though. I know the rechargeable ones I use with my camera are retaining
their charge less than when I first got them.
--
John Corliss
tech...@gmail.com
Jun 28, 2015, 11:58:35 AM6/28/15
to
2. Certain firmwares are required for CERTAIN cmts's which are the cable companies property and not yours, so it is best to let them update the firmware for you so they use the CORRECT one.
3. The modem manufacturer actually works with the cable mso to develop the firmware updates, and last I knew they do not release them to retail purchases anyway.
4. Whats to stop arris fromn killing your purchased modem? The Federal Trade Commission, https://www.ftc.gov/, unless they'd like to stop being allowed to sell their product on US soil. Not to mention how would they prevent killing the MSO's modems they bought from them too, in which case they'd be shooting themselves in the foot becasue I guarantee you its a bigger market than selling them in Best Buy.
0 new messages