CFV: comp.dcom.frame-relay
Dave Cornejo
unmoderated group comp.dcom.frame-relay
Newsgroups line:
comp.dcom.frame-relay Technology and issues regarding Frame Relay
Votes must be received by 23:59:59 UTC, 22 September 1994.
This vote is being conducted by a neutral third party. For voting
questions only contact Dave Cornejo <da...@dogwood.com>. For questions
about the proposed group please contact Allen Robel <rob...@indiana.edu>
This CFV is also being sent to the cicso discussion mailing list
ci...@spot.colorado.edu
CHARTER
To provide a mechanism for the discussion of issues related to the
technology and application of frame relay in communications networks.
Topics expected to be discussed include (but are not limited to) the
following examples:
- frame relay standards and proposed standards
- applications of frame relay
- user experiences with frame relay
- relationship and comparison of frame relay to other technologies,
including asynchronous transfer mode (ATM), cell relay, SMDS,
X.25 packet switching, IP routing, ISDN, Broadband ISDN, etc.
- announcements of conferences, seminars, etc., related to frame relay
- news of the availability of frame relay products or services
- testing and interoperability of frame relay
- information related to performance and implementation of frame relay
- research findings
- activities of The Frame Relay Forum and other similar organizations
with activities related to frame relay
- sources of additional information regarding frame relay
This newsgroup is not intended to be a forum in which standards are
developed, although it may be expected to relate news pertaining to
standards and to the progress of recognized standards bodies.
This list will be gatewayed to the Frame Relay Discussion list
<frame...@indiana.edu>.
RATIONALE:
Given that Frame Relay is beginning to emerge as a mainstream WAN service,
and given that discussions of Frame Relay technology are appearing with
increasing frequency on other newsgroups such as comp.dcom.cell-relay, it
makes sense at this time to create a newsgroup to provide a home for
discussion of this technology.
HOW TO VOTE
Send MAIL to: vo...@dogwood.com
Just Replying should work if you are not reading this on a mailing
list.
The subject in your mail message must contain the name of the group to
allow your vote to be correctly handled by an automated vote-counter,
if you do not do this you will receive a message asking you to
resubmit your vote with the name of the group that you are voting for
in the subject line.
Please do not quote the entire CFV in your vote, it will confuse the
automatic vote counter and will earn you a duplicate vote message.
Your mail message should contain one of the following statements:
I vote YES on comp.dcom.frame-relay
I vote NO on comp.dcom.frame-relay
You may also ABSTAIN in place of YES/NO - this will not affect the
outcome. Anything else may be rejected by the automatic vote counting
program. The votetaker will respond to your received ballots with a
personal acknowledgement by mail - if you do not receive one within
several days, try again. It's your responsibility to make sure your
vote is registered correctly.
Only one vote per person, no more than one vote per account. No votes
will be accepted from system accounts (i.e. root, news, uucp) or
anonymous accounts. Addresses and votes of all voters will be
published in the final voting results list.
--
Dave Cornejo There is nothing so subtle
Dogwood Media as the obvious
Fremont, California
Dave Cornejo
unmoderated group comp.dcom.frame-relay
CHARTER
HOW TO VOTE
BOUNCED ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS:
MA...@netman2.cs.plym.ac.uk
t09504@sirius
boemia.pix.com.br!nelson
Dave Cornejo
unmoderated group comp.dcom.frame-relay passes 376:14
There were 376 YES votes and 14 NO votes, for a total of 390 valid votes.
There was 1 abstain and 7 invalid ballots.
For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and NO)
votes. There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes.
There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted. If no
serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the moderator of
news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly thereafter.
CHARTER
comp.dcom.frame-relay Final Vote Ack
Voted Yes
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
/S=I.KAHN/DD.ID=I.KAHN/ADMD=TELECOM.CANADA/C=CA/@resonet.com
00028...@mcimail.com Jeff Betteker
00038...@mcimail.com Gregory A. Buchan
00051...@mcimail.com David Auerbach
73363...@compuserve.com Ron Hall [ROI]
a...@fcmc.com Abe Dresler (FCMC IR)
a...@forte.com David Ackerman
aj...@cc.bellcore.com Andy Mayer
al...@venus.nbg.sub.org Alexander Adolf
ali_j...@wiltel.com Ali Jalali
am...@actcom.co.il Amir Plivatsky
an...@trillium.com
An...@NYD.LEGENT.COM Anbu Alagarsamy
and...@tbit.dk Anders Pilegaard
andrewg...@pcmail.Strata.COM andrewg
ang...@lucas.emi.com Anglin
ans...@sce.carleton.ca Rukhsana Ansari
a...@acc.com Art Berggreen
art...@gateway.dircsa.org.au Arthur Marsh
atil...@sdcc10.UCSD.EDU Adam Tilghman
ATTDCS!DCSSFPO1!neup...@dcstm1.attmail.com
a...@proteon.com Arun V. Mahajan
b...@syndesis.com
ba...@csn.org Displaytech, Inc.
Barton...@camb.com
bas...@eureka.ucs.indiana.edu Peg Bassett
bat...@sequent.com Jim Battan
bdr...@ukelele.GCR.COM Bob Drach
bee...@tech.ascom.ch Reto Beeler
BENE...@tntv7.ntrs.com Tom Benes 312.630.6794
ben...@maths.lth.se Bengt Larsson
be...@athena.com Benjamin Cline
ber...@indiana.edu bernbom
bhu...@netcom.com Bud Huber
Bill=White%ECC%IM=H...@bangate.compaq.com
birc...@pilot.njin.net Dan Birchall
Biren...@csusa.ska.com Biren S. Patel
bk...@cass.ma02.bull.com Bosco Kwok
blake...@oz.bmd.trw.com Blake Chard
b...@craycom.dk Brian Munkholm
bow...@lucas.emi.com R.M. Bownes III
bpc...@shakti.ncst.ernet.in BHARAT PETROLEUM CORP. LTD. (EDP CELL)
BRAD...@krypton.ucs.indiana.edu T.C. Bradley, UCS
b...@moondance.livingston.com Brian Rice
Bryan_...@Novell.COM
butch....@tamu.edu Butch Kemper
b...@fns.com Bill W. Sprinkle
b...@hpqtdla.sqf.hp.com Brian Woodroffe
ca...@bettina.informatik.uni-bremen.de
CAR...@uthscsa.edu Brian Carr
c...@olddaisy.ee.und.ac.za Dave McConnell
c...@tctel.frmug.fr.net Christian.Chassan
che...@mathcs.emory.edu Shun Yan Cheung
cho...@wwtc.timeplex.com Anthony Chow
chr...@NMMC.Com Chris Cox W0/G4JEC
chris_wh...@wiltel.com Chris Whittenburg
chy...@hp4at.eunet.co.at Georg Chytil
cirs...@dkrz.d400.de Werner Cirsovius
cjm...@c3i.saic.com Carol J. Mathews
cl...@ameris.ameritech.com George H. Clapp
cle...@kn.PacBell.COM Charlie L Eyster
C...@ost.fr CHRISTOPHE MARIE
col...@lucas.emi.com Collins
cr...@netcom.com Chris Reed
c...@access.digex.net Clarke Ferber
c...@socrates.ed.asu.edu C. R. Oldham
c...@alert.com Craig Hollenbaugh
d...@dpcsys.com Dan Busarow
d...@prism.nmt.edu Dan Lunceford
da...@ae560.technion.ac.il D. Arbel
da...@alumni.caltech.edu Daniel R. Kegel
Danny=Pierce%ECC%IM=H...@bangate.compaq.com
da...@pcg.com Darin Wayrynen
dar...@is.rice.edu Darren Keith Bolding
data...@perth.dialix.oz.au Datacraft Technology
da...@rochgte.fidonet.org Dave Stoddard
da...@Newbridge.COM Dave Fowler
DA...@NETSOL.COM Dave Putman
da...@gv-gate.gvg.TEK.COM David C. White
dave_ge...@qmail.Newbridge.COM Dave Gellerman
dave_...@wiltel.com Dave O'Shea
David....@its.utas.edu.au David Cooper
dav...@qpsx.oz.au David Brown
david_...@wiltel.com David Barmann
davi...@ida.org Chuck Davisson
da...@meiko.co.uk David Wilson
dbru...@Tymnet.COM Dale Brunett
dbs...@metronet.com David B. Stewart
d...@panix.com David W. Crawford
dd...@ifs.osrhe.edu David Drexler
djm...@netcom.com Daniel J. McCoy
dk...@zz.win.net Dan Kok
d...@ketch.cc.bellcore.com lapier,david c
dmu...@cwa.com Dan Murphy
d...@mattrx.com Matthew J. D'Errico
do...@enzo.practic.com Don Hackler
don_j...@Clark-Comm.COM Don Jackson
dpic...@netcom.com Coastcom
dra...@Tymnet.COM Dick Rawson
dr...@Compatible.COM drew thomas
d...@fns.com David Liu
d...@ffm.deu.ubn.net Dragan B.Tosic
d...@falcon.mbsa.com Doug Maxey
dw...@bailey.com Derek McKearney
d...@wave.net.com Dale Francisco
ebc...@ebc.ericsson.se SG/EBC/FB/FF Eric Raquette 08-764 0206
ed...@chaph.usc.edu George Edmond Eddy
EDW...@RALVM29.VNET.IBM.COM David A. Edwards
ehe...@Newbridge.COM Ethan Henry
ejf...@indiana.edu Ed Furia
e...@cisco.com Steve Elias
en...@almaden.ibm.com
enn...@blackjack.dt.navy.mil Jay Ennis
epe...@CCTuP.entergy.com Earl Perkins
e...@tctel.frmug.fr.net Emeric.de.Saint.Roman
fieldday!sew...@kksys.com
flan...@fastcomm.com William "Bill" Flanagan
f...@trillium.com
Franco.Sc...@mail.esrin.esa.it Franco
Fr...@mindlink.bc.ca Frank I. Reiter
fra...@yu1.yu.edu Mervyn Frankel
fra...@MAIL.STATE.WI.US
fr...@lightside.com Fred Condo
ga...@vulcan.com Gary Tennyson
gebo...@workerb.emss.com Greg Boykin
GIRI...@blrv1.verifone.com Girish R Rayas, Netsys Blr
git...@shadow.net David L. Gitter,CNE - G&O Computer Tech
GJoh...@shlooc01.ottawa.mm2.shl.com JOHNSON Glenn
gl...@popco.com Glenn Fleishman
gne...@zynrgy.com Gary Nelson
gri...@almaden.ibm.com
g...@arch4.ho.att.com George V Mouradian +1 908 949 7671
ha...@terminus.ericsson.se Hakan Nohre
HA...@VM.BIU.AC.IL Hank Nussbacher
HAR...@INDYVAX.IUPUI.EDU James Harvey
hass...@wdn.com John Hasselkus
hay...@mnbp2.network.com Jeff D. Hayes
h...@ece.rice.edu Hubert Daugherty
he...@btr.btr.com Charles M. Heard he...@btr.com
h...@zippo.uwasa.fi Hannu Hirvonen
hi...@iquest.com Hugh Messenger
hol...@cbnewsm.att.com
HOLD...@Eisner.DECUS.Org Matt Holdrege
hpc...@eng.adaptec.com Huei-Ping Chen X-3387
h...@nms.telepost.no Hans Petter Holen
h...@brewhr.swb.de Heiko Rath
hub...@ptolemy-ethernet.arc.nasa.gov Kim Hubbard
hug...@logos.ucs.indiana.edu Larry J. Hughes Jr.
hw...@bronze.coil.com Henry Ware
hwor...@fastcomm.com Harlan Worchel
ia...@nwpeople.demon.co.uk Iain Baird
ia...@shiraz.jcorp.dialix.oz.au Iain Massey
ifr...@wimsey.com Ian Frazer
Igor.Me...@proteon.com
IMCCAL...@bfsec.bt.co.uk Irwin McCallister +44 232 894461
J.M...@ma02.bull.com John Luke Mills
j...@fns.com
ja...@Newbridge.COM James Watt
Jari....@hut.fi Jari M{kel{
ja...@gate.net Jason
j...@rain.org Jay Hennigan
jbe...@imtn.dsccc.com Joe Bedner
jbeu...@HK.Super.NET John Beukema
jbh...@kaiwan.com John Houston
jbl...@bfsec.bt.co.uk Raymond Blythe
JC...@almaden.ibm.com John Day
jc...@phoenix.wellfleet.com John Chao
jds...@vulcan.com Jerry D. Snead
jem...@wet.sbi.com Jem Day
jen...@craycom.com Bill Jensen
jfo...@dorsai.dorsai.org Joseph_Fortt
jge...@nbi.com Joe George
j...@nbn.com John Harkin
JKW...@sbu.edu Joseph Kwiatkowski x-2274
jl...@sgi.com Jay Lan
jmd...@kquest.com Jose M. daLuz
jmor...@bogomips.ee.ubc.ca John Paul Morrison
jo...@cutler.com John E. Babbitt Jr.
jo...@oxygen.house.gov John Schnizlein
john...@sgate.com Clarence Johnson
j...@nr-tech.cit.cornell.edu Joy Veronneau
jpr...@vulcan.com Jerry Pruett - BLS
jpur...@nei.com Joe Purcell
JS...@delphi.com
jst...@access.digex.net Jeffrey V. Steele
j...@indiana.edu Jon Dunn
j...@hpuerca.atl.hp.com Jim O'Shea
jwr...@halcyon.com Jon Wright
JWS...@oduvm.cc.odu.edu Jeff Spyker
kajo...@fedex.com Keith Johnson
ka...@whin.net
kat...@lion.dgt.co.il Moshe Katzir
kel...@hou.moc.com William M. Kelsey
k...@cc.bellcore.com politz,kenneth e
Kevin...@telematics.com Smith,Kevin
khaw...@vulcan.com Ken Hawkins - BLS
khe...@volksbits.com Ken Hester
kia...@shell.co.nz Christophe Boban
kin...@palenque.win-uk.net Henry King
kirc...@iowave.physics.uiowa.edu
kl...@nysernet.ORG K.A. Long
kma...@interop.com Kirsten Machi
kn...@jvnc.net Greg Knopf
KOE...@efvx1.dofn.de Thomas Koenig, Dornier GmbH, Abt. VFB512
kozl...@informatik.tu-muenchen.de Rolf Kozlowski
kre...@hns.com Larry Kreeger
kruc...@sal.cs.utah.edu Pete Kruckenberg
kum...@hill.com kumquat
L1...@ZFN.UNI-BREMEN.DE Martin Schroeder
la...@mhspo1.ucs.indiana.edu Lance Speelmon
Lee....@Census.GOV Lee Rian (TCO)
le...@Radius.COM Steve Lemke
LEO...@Arizona.EDU Aaron Leonard
ler...@cc.bellcore.com Steven Lerman
l...@upnet.se Lars Hanson
l...@solomon.technet.sg Lee King Young
lo...@boom.com Jonathan Heiliger
lo...@alter.net Louis A. Mamakos
l...@nautique.epm.ornl.gov Lawrence MacIntyre - 615.576.0824
ltz...@usr.com Lih-Shyng Tzeng
lu...@as-node.jena.thur.de Lutz Donnerhacke
m...@BlueRose.com M Carling
m...@ripco.com Mark A. Cnota
ma...@VNET.IBM.COM
ma...@maelstrom.timeplex.com Andrew G. Malis
ma...@comm.polymtl.ca Patrick Mambo
mand...@chi.ahc.ameritech.com Mike Andrews
mar...@sci.kuniv.edu.kw maraya altuwaijri
ma...@mvision.com Marc Albert (603) 529-1820
Mark.S...@Telebit.COM Mark S. Lewis
MA...@netman2.cs.plym.ac.uk Mark Steer
ma...@pulse.com Mark C. Orton
Mark_Sumn...@email.mot.com
mar...@bbn.com Martha Greenberg
mar...@trappist.net.com Martin Johnson
mat...@pgs-gw.hstn.expl.pgs.com
matt...@wpdis01.wpafb.af.mil Matthew J. Morrisey
m...@beatles.cselt.stet.it Maurizio Codogno
mbec...@mbeckman.com Mel Beckman
m...@dsbc.icl.co.uk Malcolm Mladenovic
m...@fns.com Martha B. Walsh
m...@eccsa.Tredydev.Unisys.com Matt Thul
mel...@pop.nih.gov Melvin J. Mason, Jr.
m...@ac.duke.edu Michael Grubb
mha...@interlog.com Matt Harrop
Michael...@gsi.fr Michael benton
mich...@MR.Net Michael Schonwetter
mic...@summa4.MV.COM Paul Michali
mi...@tn.com Mike Sanders
mi...@fdihq.com Micheal Scott Parkhurs
mle...@csd.uwo.ca Mike Esch
mon...@cs.indiana.edu Larry Mongin
mor...@trillium.com
m...@boers.no Morten Reistad
mus...@natasha.tele.iastate.edu Dan Engholm
mwe...@interaccess.com Mitch Weiss
nda...@io.org Nigel Allen
nel...@boemia.pix.com.br Nelson Murilo O. Rufino
nel...@crynwr.com Russell Nelson
n...@polaris.lasierra.edu Cheng Ng
n...@nrcnet.com Nathaniel Ingersoll
ni...@itc.cc.bellcore.com nici
nis...@clark.net Tom Nisbet
nmo...@wintermute.win.net Noel C. Morgan
no...@nas.nasa.gov Noemi E. Berry
OKER...@trslke01es.ntc.nokia.com Keranen Olavi
ow...@199.35.160.10 Owen Crowley
p00...@psilink.com Ric Fleisher
p01...@psilink.com phil reed
pa...@tokyo.rockwell.com Stephen [kiwin] PALM
pas...@mathworks.com
p...@tandem.com
patr...@hpqtdxa.sqf.hp.com Patrick Leask
pa...@cruz.com Paul Lind
pca...@la.net
PDE...@lds.loral.com Reply to: philip...@lds.loral.com
pe...@summa4.MV.COM Larry Peck
pet...@elec.uow.edu.au peter james vial
p...@galadriel.bt.co.uk
pl...@cdsmn.mn.org Doug Plate Sr.
pmar...@bfsec.bt.co.uk Paul Marquess
p...@amarina.ho.BoM.GOV.AU Paul Grainger
pol...@pluto.informatik.unibw-muenchen.de Armin Pollak
ppa...@wellfleet.com Peter Pappas,Wellfleet Engineering
pre...@infonet.com brian presley
rab...@fastcomm.com Robert Abbott
r...@ccmail.petronas.my Richard Dale
ra...@tavor.openu.ac.il Rafi Sadowsky
RAGARWAL%H...@LANDO.HNS.COM RENU AGARWAL
rag...@software.group.com Ragnar Paulson
raj...@trillium.com
r...@nynexst.com Ram Ramachandran
ra...@lachman.com Sudhakar Ramakrishna
ra...@acc.com Ravi Kiran Puvvala
rcha...@VNET.IBM.COM
r...@casc.com Ren
re...@imsi.com Rens Troost
ric...@corixia.demon.co.uk Richard Ashton
ri...@bcm.tmc.edu Richard H. Miller
riz...@asl.dl.nec.com Aleem Rizvan
rja...@netcom.com Richard James
rl...@xmission.com Ron Lenk
ro...@schiavone.com Robert Schiavone
r...@vitsemi.com Rob Eccles
rob...@indiana.edu Allen Robel
ro...@tekotago.ac.nz
ro...@Newbridge.COM Ron Jeffery
ron...@cisco.com Ronnie B. Kon
rp...@csuchico.edu Ron Pike
rpre...@dcc.uchile.cl Rodrigo
r...@mpd.tandem.com Robert Teisberg
rs...@ccmail.crosscomm.com Roger Slyk
rst...@cisco.com Robert Stout
ruf...@mbe.ece.wisc.edu Jeffrey Rufinus
rze...@smtplink.Coh.ORG ZELMAN, RON
S/@mtaho02
sad...@bfsec.bt.co.uk Stephen M. Adams
sar...@hou.moc.com Edward L. Sartore
SBALRAM%H...@LANDO.HNS.COM Srivibhavan Balaram Ext. 412
s...@trillium.com
schul...@fokus.gmd.de Henning Schulzrinne
sco...@cloud9.net Scott Drassinower
sco...@pepsi.com Lorditch, Scott
scs...@tvgurus.hdtv.zenithe.com Andrew Birner
sdag...@netrix.com sdaggett
sher...@lucas.emi.com Sherwood
ske...@ott.mpr.ca Brian Skerry
s...@Connectivity.com Samuel Lam
sk...@infi.net Steve Kurz
smi...@NMC.ED.RAY.COM Kevin Ruddy
smo...@svpal.org Steven Moreci
S...@tntv8.ntrs.com Steve Bonine
SRINIVASV%H...@LANDO.HNS.COM
s...@terminus.ericsson.se Steve Langstaff
sro...@tps.mcs.eds.com
ss...@netcom.com
SSM%H...@LANDO.HNS.COM
ste...@jtec.com.au Stephen Ma
st...@interaccess.com Steve Norton
st...@parc.xerox.com John Stidd
st...@ksu.ksu.edu Steve Davis
sull...@austin.asc.slb.com Jim Sullivan, Schlumberger, Texas
sundar_ku...@wiltel.com Sundar Kuttalingam
swe...@pine.ucs.indiana.edu Brent Sweeny
t09504@sirius Brian Chase
ta...@vs.ee Taavi Talvik
tedw...@src.umd.edu Thomas Grant Edwards
tfa...@triticom.com
t...@psp.co.uk Thomas F Lee
tglo...@cisco.com Tom Glodowski
t...@Cayman.COM Tom Pincince
tom.m...@gsfc.nasa.gov Tom Maufer
tomp...@100arw.mildenhall.af.mil tompkins
Torbjorn....@nll.se Torbj\vrn Johansson
tril...@tctel.frmug.fr.net Richard.Trilling
ub...@hns.com Urs Buob
uci...@brea.unocal.com Arnold G. Perez
uci...@brea.unocal.com Henry R. Sachs
vha...@cc.helsinki.fi Vesa Halkka
v...@terminus.ericsson.se Vijay Kanabar
vsi...@ics.forth.gr Siris Vasilios
VVENKATESAN%H...@LANDO.HNS.COM
VVENK...@hss.hns.com
w...@garnet.msen.com wal
wa...@oapd.oki.com Walt Weber
wa...@surf.neu.sgi.com Wayne Silver
w...@roka.net Wilhelm Buehler
we...@proffa.cc.tut.fi Junkkari Veli-Matti
wi...@Starbase.NeoSoft.COM Will Morse
wk0...@worldlink.com Thomas H. Jones
wl...@bnr.ca wayne (w.) ling
x14...@rubc.rz.ruhr-uni-bochum.de Malte Sander
yada...@gAlLiF.ersys.EDmonTON.Ab.Ca Dave Shariff Yadallee
YEBO...@prince.mm.wyeth.com Yeboah, Peter
yor...@halla.dacom.co.kr Youngok Rhee
zythera!li...@rednet.nbg.de Robert 'linus' Thona
Voted No
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
crou...@flidh103.delcoelect.com Kenneth P Crouch
e...@panix.com Emery Lapinski
fau...@randpo10c.bah.com Faunce Shawn
femi...@eskimo.com William Affleck-Asch
jgod...@rd.qms.com Jim Goddard
jo...@cs.indiana.edu John Lacey
j...@globalvillag.com John R. MacWilliamson
kh...@jtp.cs.nyu.edu Hasnain Khan
lag...@sunny.health.state.mn.us Elbert LaGrew
radr...@panix.com Rebecca Drayer
SIR...@waikato.ac.nz Sean Irvine
sma...@turing.toronto.edu Smarasderagd
stai...@bga.com Dwight Brown
swe...@cisco.com Ed Swenson
Abstained
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
m...@RedBrick.COM Maxime Taksar KC6ZPS
Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
00051...@mcimail.com Craig R. Smythe
! Conflicting votes
=us/@mtaho02
! Conflicting votes
b...@tnis.frmug.fr.net Bernard.Guillaumot
! No vote statement in message
ctk...@crsgi1.erenj.com Chuck Kenyon
! No vote statement in message
mcdu...@odi.com Keith McDuffee
! No vote statement in message
MSMAIL....@TSOD.LMIG.COM Stinson-Jeff
! No vote statement in message
o...@comtch.iea.com Reed Olson
! No vote statement in message