Risk posed by 'garage geneticists': Fears amateur scientists using DNA editing technology may cause harm
The Nuffield Council on Bioethics warns of risks posed by 'biohackers'
A new report says cheap gene editing kits can be bought online for £100
These can be used to alter the properties of living bacteria or yeast
Biohackers could create something harmful deliberately or accidentally
By Richard Gray for MailOnline
Published: 12:04 EST, 30 September 2016 | Updated: 12:04 EST, 30 September 2016
e-mail
33 shares
27
View
comments
Amateur scientists toying with powerful gene editing technology in their garages could pose a future risk to human health and the environment, a new report warns.
It highlights a growing trend for so-called 'biohackers' who use new technology to modify the DNA in living organisms outside of traditional research institutions.
While most of these groups of amateur researchers are attempting to solve problems like creating new flavours of beer, some could do more harm.
A new report has warned that powerful gene editing technology (stock picture) could pose a risk in the future as more people get their hands on cheap kits that allow them to alter the properties of living organisms
The report by the Nuffield Council on Bioethics points to £100 kits that can effectively 'cut and paste' DNA in yeast or bacteria to alter their properties.
HOW DOES CRISPR WORK?
CRISPR-Cas9 technology precisely changes target parts of genetic code.
Unlike other gene-silencing tools, the CRISPR-Cas9 system targets the genome's source material and permanently turns off genes at the DNA level.
The DNA cut – known as a double strand break – closely mimics the kinds of mutations that occur naturally, for instance after chronic sun exposure.
But unlike UV rays that can result in genetic alterations, the CRISPR-Cas9 system causes a mutation at a precise location in the genome.
When cellular machinery repairs the DNA break, it removes a small snip of DNA. In this way, researchers can precisely turn off specific genes in the genome.
This technology, known as CRISPR-Cas9, can be used without needing a high level of scientific knowledge, unlike other gene editing techniques, which need expensive equipment and specialist training.
The Nuffield Council on Bioethics said the 'comparatively low cost, ease of use and availability' of these new gene editing kits, which can be purchased online, meant they were accessible to unregulated users.
This raises the prospect that scientists could either deliberately or accidentally create an organism that could be harmful if released into the environment.
It added: 'These may include DIY 'garage' scientists, school and undergraduate students, and others with an interest in biological research and the possibilities - whether potentially beneficial or harmful - raised by genome editing.'
The report comes just weeks after a leading molecular biologist at Oxford University warned that the technology could be used to develop new types of biological weapons.
Indeed the FBI is so concerned about the activities of biohackers it has set up a special branch within its Weapons of mass Destruction Directorate to engage with them.
RELATED ARTICLES
Previous
1
Next
So long Rosetta: Spacecraft ends its historic 12-year... Teddy Ruxpin is back! New version of hit 1980s toy revealed... Nasa's Curiosity rover reveals how DIRT on the surface of... The ugly truth: Having friends who are less attractive than...
Share this article
Share
33 shares
There is a flourishing biohacking community in many parts of the world with amateur groups getting together to develop home-made approaches to studying biology.
FBI WARNINGS OVER GENE EDITING TECHNOLOGY
The FBI has concerns about how this might be used and is attempting to engage with scientists working in this area to help establish ways of tackling potential risks.
Supervisory Special Agent Edward You from the FBI's Weapons of Mass Destruction Directorate said last year: 'Synthetic biology poses some incredible benefits, but there are some risks involved too.
'Now is the time to be able to identify the vulnerabilities and then start setting up mitigation measures.'
In 2010, Mr You warned that as technologies for editing genomes and conducting biological research become less expensive, the risks involved will increase.
He said: 'You're having the barrier of entry to do something mischievous, or actually outright nefarious, getting lower, so individuals or groups will be able to conduct potential harm more so than before.'
For example, one group in London want to fiddle with yeast to alter the flavour of beer, which apparently one group based in London is already attempting.
Biohackers in Japan hope to reintroduce a gene into blue carnations sold in Japan to revert them back to their natural white state.
Another group is hoping to use CRISPR technology to re-engineer yeast to produce a protein found in milk called casein to create a new type of vegan cheese.
The Nuffield report stated CRISPR-Cas9 was even being used by school pupils in a synthetic biology contest called the International Genetically Engineered Machine competition.
Hugh Whittall, director of the Nuffield Council for Bioethics, said: 'There is no evidence that we've seen that there are people with things going on in their garages, but ... this is one of the things that we need to be aware of, be conscious of the possibility.
'It goes back to this question of whether the control mechanism in terms of the supply of the kits and materials is adequate.'
CRISPR-Cas9 was introduced in 2012 and is rapidly transforming biological research.
The system uses certain proteins that allow DNA to be cut and edited at precise, targeted locations.
Human reproduction and livestock farming were identified as two key areas of concern by the Nuffield Council. Both will be the subject of further inquiries by dedicated working parties.
Nuffield Council member Karen Yeung, Professor of Law and director of the Centre for Technology, Ethics and Law at King's College London, said: 'One of the features of this technology is it makes it more accessible to a broader range of users.
'This however has the knock on effect that it may be more difficult to keep a watching brief and monitor effectively what's actually being done in these areas.
The CRISPR gene editing technology has heralded a new era in the ability to edit and modify the genes of living organisms. Some biohacker groups have adopted the technology (CRISPR-CAS9 complex illustrated) to modify yeast and plants
The CRISPR gene editing technology has heralded a new era in the ability to edit and modify the genes of living organisms. Some biohacker groups have adopted the technology (CRISPR-CAS9 complex illustrated) to modify yeast and plants
'We identify that as a potential area of concern.'
In the field of human reproduction, gene editing has the potential to eliminate inherited diseases such as cystic fibrosis.
There are more than 4,000 known single gene conditions that are thought to affect around one per cent of births worldwide.
But producing babies from embryos whose inherited DNA has been altered is illegal in the UK and still highly controversial.
Critics point to the dangers of irreversible changes being passed onto future generations and the possible creation of 'designer babies'.
Prof Yeung, who will chair the Nuffield Council working party on reproductive applications, which meets for the first time next week, said: 'It is only right that we acknowledge where this new science may lead and explore the possible paths ahead.'
CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing can be used to edit the DNA in bacteria like Escherichia coli (pictured). While normally harmless in the cut, these bacteria can also cause food poisoning
CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing can be used to edit the DNA in bacteria like Escherichia coli (pictured). While normally harmless in the cut, these bacteria can also cause food poisoning
Genome editing in farm animals has already been proposed for pigs, sheep, cattle and chickens, raising questions of food safety and animal welfare.
Animals whose genes have been edited may fall into a grey legal area because it is not clear that their meat, eggs or milk would be classified as genetically modified food.
Potential applications of the technology included pigs protected against swine flu, chickens that only produced female offspring for egg production, and hornless cattle that could safely be kept in confined spaces.
Dr Andy Greenfield, from Oxford University, who chaired the review working group, dismissed suggestions that farmers might secretly make use of gene editing technology.
He joked: 'A kind of evil Old Macdonald? There are entry barriers. It's not that it's so easy to do that you can just have a shed at the end of the field.
'It would be difficult to do this secretly. It's not so quick and easy that it could be happening across Suffolk.'
Dr Greenfield was most concerned about 'frivolous' use of CRSPR-Cas9 gene editing.
'We don't really want to encourage frivolous cosmetic uses of a powerful technology when we have real needs right now,' he said.
Share or comment on this article
e-mail
33
shares
by Taboola Promoted Links
Secret Photos of The Clintons That Will Shock You
Frank151
How To Fix Your Fatigue (Do This Every Day)
Vital Reds Supplement
Why You Shouldn't Hate That Mom Who Does Everything Perfectly
Land O'Moms
This Is What You've Been Waiting For.
Happy Family
8 Celebs That Have Ruined Themselves
IntelliViral
Lady Gaga flashes breast in very short cropped top in Tennessee
Losing Weight is Easy With These 14 Small Changes to Your Diet
Burnin' Fat
A method used by most to pay down credit card debt at a rapid pace
NextAdvisor
Search For ANY High School Yearbook, It's Free
Classmates
Sam Worthington and Suzi Taylor star in Gettin' Square
Emilia Clarke struggles against strong Northern Irish Winds
Bradley Fighting Vehicles deployed in Samarra, Iraq in 2004
Pornography film displayed on billboard on busy Jakarta road
Country power couple Faith Hill & Tim McGraw BOTH get stars
NSW police teaming up with retail industry to stop shoplifters
Most watched News videos
Bulls head butt each other then die instantly from brutal blow
CCTV captures final tragic moments of Mirna Salihin's life
Funny Vine by Samuel Grubbs shows guy being brutally slapped
Brutal moment two buffalo hit each other head-on at village party
Soldiers attacked by knife wielding man at Israeli checkpoint
Prisoner appears to headbutt guard moments before execution
Is this proof that ballot boxes have been stuffed in elections?
George Clooney is left shocked after finding out about Brangelina
Teenager screams in agony as she is beaten by merciless gang
Dashcam shows dramatic outside lane crash on M6 motorway
Sickening footage shows ISIS shoot and behead 'spy' in Syria
Shocking footage from 'mass brawl involving up to 100 youths'
Kim Kardashian's robbers are caught on 'million-to-one' CCTV...
EXCLUSIVE: Kim Kardashian's personal bodyguard Pascal Duvier...
Now a video lays bare America's heroin epidemic: Laughing...
Hurricane of doom: Skull-shaped Matthew kills 11 in the...
Crimes against architecture? Design blunders of the hundreds...
PIERS MORGAN: That robbery was a wake-up call Kim. Time to...
'He always wanted to be a superhero': Six-year-old boy who...
Parents are found dead from 'heroin overdoses' in home with...
'We've never seen anything like this': Mother's boyfriend,...
EXCLUSIVE: Police were called to Tamar Braxton's Calabasas...
Something fishy? Man finds gruesome remains that look like a...
Playboy Playmate Kennedy Summers dumps NBA fiance Jeff...
MOST READ NEWS
Previous
Next
●
●
●
Comments (27)
Share what you think
Newest
Oldest
Best rated
Worst rated
View all
The comments below have not been moderated.
View all
The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.
We are no longer accepting comments on this article.
Who is this week's top commenter? Find out now
Read more:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3815998/Risk-posed-garage-geneticists-Fears-amateur-scientists-using-DNA-editing-technology-cause-harm.html#ixzz4MHetHqBG
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook