Jackie et al,
Lots of facts.. Lots of rules & principles apply…. The character of the payments as to income depends on for whose BENEFIT these payments have been made…and for what were/are they made? ie Why were they made…
Charting the flow of payments may help!!! Give a description for each leg…
The answer to “why” is the most important question to ask & answer….
The answer to “WHAT” is also important to help characterize the value of the payment..
You say “No checks are ever received “ you also say payments were/are made thru Zelle.. why wouldn’t those payments be as good as cash…
It looks like there is an attempt to call it something it’s not…
Also the substance of any transaction rules over its form…
Hope this helps…
Phil