Groups
Sign in
Groups
Clean Code Discussion
Conversations
Labels
ASP
BDD
BuilderPattern
CSharp
Codestyle
Competition
Cucumber
DDD
Design
E18
E19
E21
E7
Ep19
Fitnesse
FolderStructure
IO
IntegrationTests
JavaCaseStudy1
MVC
Output
REST
RESTful
Refactoring
Requirements
Servlet
Specification
TDD
UI
UseCase20
UseCases
UserStories
ValueObject
abstract
acl
advice
application
architecture
arguments
attribut
authorization
boundary
business
channel
class
classes
clean
clean-arch
clean-architecture
clean_architecture
cleancode
code
coding
components
controller
convention
csv
database
delivery
dependency-injection
dependency-inversion
dependency-rule
dip
dotNET
drivers
dynamically
ebi
enforcement
entities
entity
error-handling
file
framework
frameworks
freenode
function
function-arguments
functions
fw-and-drivers
gateway
i18n
images
interactor
interface
interface-adapter
irc
isp
javascript
kohana
language
limit
liskov
logic
lsp
mentoring
method
mistakes
mock
modules
mutation
name
naming
nodejs
objects
observer
observerPattern
ocp
oop
parameter
patterns-and-practices
permission
persistence
photos
php
pitest
presenter
programming-practices
query
random
readability
report
repository
reverse-engineering
roles
rspec
rubyrogues
rules
sample
security
small
solid
srp
statically
style
teaching
test
testing
thick-client
typed
update
upload
usecase
user
validation
values
variable
variables
views
web-service
About
Send feedback
Help
Clean Code Discussion
Contact owners and managers
1–30 of 633
Welcome to the Clean Code discussion group. Here we discuss the Clean Code video episodes that appear on
cleancoders.com
.
The rules are simple:
No advertising.
No swearing.
No name-calling.
Be respectful and nice.
The only way to go fast, is to go well.
Sign up for the
Clean Coders Slack workspace using this link
.
Mark all as read
Report group
0 selected
vivek poddar
, …
Dave Schinkel
9
7/25/17
Clean architecture with node.
Hi Juan, Thanks for sharing the link but it feels somewhat incomplete to me. The author says that
unread,
Design
advice
architecture
mentoring
Clean architecture with node.
Hi Juan, Thanks for sharing the link but it feels somewhat incomplete to me. The author says that
7/25/17
vivek poddar
,
Łukasz Duda
5
8/12/16
Representing collections in DDD and clean architecture.
I think there is a greater confusion, what about the domain logic? I have listed some here https://
unread,
DDD
Design
architecture
mentoring
repository
Representing collections in DDD and clean architecture.
I think there is a greater confusion, what about the domain logic? I have listed some here https://
8/12/16
vivek poddar
,
Stefan Bradl
4
8/1/16
Where to put data read from file.
PFA, github link for more reference. https://github.com/aryehof/quote-service/tree/read-quote-json On
unread,
DDD
Design
architecture
repository
Where to put data read from file.
PFA, github link for more reference. https://github.com/aryehof/quote-service/tree/read-quote-json On
8/1/16
Mik Wings7
,
Norbert Nemes
2
5/30/16
How to practice TDD within a DDD project?
That's a togh one. If you watch Uncle Bob's Java case study, they went by doing TDD first and
unread,
DDD
Design
Refactoring
TDD
How to practice TDD within a DDD project?
That's a togh one. If you watch Uncle Bob's Java case study, they went by doing TDD first and
5/30/16
Srikanth Venkatesh
, …
Jacek Bilski
9
1/26/16
Doesn't dependency inversion lead to code duplication?
Hi Jacek Bilski, You mentioned, that there are different modules that are different subsets of those
unread,
Design
dependency-inversion
patterns-and-practices
programming-practices
solid
Doesn't dependency inversion lead to code duplication?
Hi Jacek Bilski, You mentioned, that there are different modules that are different subsets of those
1/26/16
vivek poddar
,
Sebastian Gozin
5
8/19/15
Mananging static data in the code base.
Eh about string literals, deliberately instantiating string objects in Java. I believe there are some
unread,
Design
Refactoring
architecture
cleancode
mentoring
programming-practices
Mananging static data in the code base.
Eh about string literals, deliberately instantiating string objects in Java. I believe there are some
8/19/15
Dave Schinkel
, …
Sebastian Gozin
15
9/4/15
Delivery Independent Use Cases - Service APIs - Feedback
He thinks negative tests are just test for checking for when the server completely bombs. I said no,
unread,
BDD
Design
REST
UseCases
architecture
components
Delivery Independent Use Cases - Service APIs - Feedback
He thinks negative tests are just test for checking for when the server completely bombs. I said no,
9/4/15
vivek poddar
, …
Dave Schinkel
11
8/25/15
Architecture for project involving mainly third party APIs
Hi Dave, since every service may have different results but I want this to be transparent to the
unread,
Design
architecture
mentoring
Architecture for project involving mainly third party APIs
Hi Dave, since every service may have different results but I want this to be transparent to the
8/25/15
Reed Law
, …
Norbert Nemes
17
3/3/15
Clean Architecture: too many layers of indirection?
Me too :). I'm a noob to the whole thing myself and there still are quite a few spots that I'
unread,
Design
TDD
architecture
Clean Architecture: too many layers of indirection?
Me too :). I'm a noob to the whole thing myself and there still are quite a few spots that I'
3/3/15
w3bj...@gmail.com
,
Frédéric Bouquet
4
2/12/15
Architecture : Why do we need request data-structure ? alternative
Hello Frederic, I'm responding to Uncle Bob's clean architecture advice where Request
unread,
Design
clean-architecture
interface
Architecture : Why do we need request data-structure ? alternative
Hello Frederic, I'm responding to Uncle Bob's clean architecture advice where Request
2/12/15
Facundo Javier Gelatti
, …
Sebastian Gozin
5
1/24/15
Interactor for "multi-step" use case
There is such a thing as local storage though. So the possibility of system crashes isn't
unread,
Design
UseCases
architecture
interactor
Interactor for "multi-step" use case
There is such a thing as local storage though. So the possibility of system crashes isn't
1/24/15
Julien
, …
unclebob
5
1/10/15
Design advice : How to add the UI ?
Hello, here is a new idea that I had yesterday : What about using id instead of an object ? I could
unread,
Design
UI
architecture
boundary
cleancode
modules
Design advice : How to add the UI ?
Hello, here is a new idea that I had yesterday : What about using id instead of an object ? I could
1/10/15
Gabriele Tondi
, …
Sebastian Gozin
8
12/9/14
To decouple or not to decouple
Yes, I agree that the model changes which suggests changing the transport mappers. But I don't
unread,
Design
UseCases
architecture
gateway
observer
observerPattern
To decouple or not to decouple
Yes, I agree that the model changes which suggests changing the transport mappers. But I don't
12/9/14
Miguel Lavigne
, …
Frederik Krautwald
9
11/17/14
Where to declaring you Exceptions in a Clean Architecture
Of course there is an obvious error. The presentation component cannot instantiate the interface
unread,
Design
cleancode
error-handling
Where to declaring you Exceptions in a Clean Architecture
Of course there is an obvious error. The presentation component cannot instantiate the interface
11/17/14
Lee
, …
unclebob
4
11/2/14
architecture advice in c#
Hello Thanks for the replies. So in essence, in this scenario, I should create a GUI-less application
unread,
Design
architecture
architecture advice in c#
Hello Thanks for the replies. So in essence, in this scenario, I should create a GUI-less application
11/2/14
Christian B
, …
Gareth Wedley
13
9/8/14
Who does the redirect in an web application implemented in Clean Architecture?
Yeah I agree with you that its about what each use case means. I see authenticate as purely a command
unread,
Design
UseCases
architecture
boundary
clean
controller
interactor
php
presenter
Who does the redirect in an web application implemented in Clean Architecture?
Yeah I agree with you that its about what each use case means. I see authenticate as purely a command
9/8/14
jk
,
Jakob Holderbaum
3
8/24/14
Components in a Rails App
First I want to point out that what the rails community calls a presenter and what clean architecture
unread,
Design
architecture
components
framework
presenter
Components in a Rails App
First I want to point out that what the rails community calls a presenter and what clean architecture
8/24/14
clean_coder_student
, …
Łukasz Duda
16
7/12/14
Code review/architecture feedback please…
Thanks for the links, they look interesting. Yeah, I think most patterns are a consequence of
unread,
Design
MVC
cleancode
interface
modules
programming-practices
Code review/architecture feedback please…
Thanks for the links, they look interesting. Yeah, I think most patterns are a consequence of
7/12/14
Alexander Wirz
, …
James Green
7
4/4/14
Single Responsibility and Object Oriented Programming
@James I think you made a great point about the terminology. "user" is probably to
unread,
Design
oop
solid
srp
Single Responsibility and Object Oriented Programming
@James I think you made a great point about the terminology. "user" is probably to
4/4/14
Илья Фофанов
, …
witali mik
12
3/24/14
Logging and Clean Code
i personally use the logger inside my controllers but not inside my interactors, since my controllers
unread,
Design
architecture
error-handling
patterns-and-practices
programming-practices
solid
Logging and Clean Code
i personally use the logger inside my controllers but not inside my interactors, since my controllers
3/24/14
Milad Bourhani
2/7/14
PresenterCallbacks and ViewCallbacks with JSF
Hi everybody, I'd like to ask you a question about how to implement MPV+interactor using JSF. The
unread,
Design
UseCases
architecture
interactor
PresenterCallbacks and ViewCallbacks with JSF
Hi everybody, I'd like to ask you a question about how to implement MPV+interactor using JSF. The
2/7/14
Andreas Schaefer
, …
Bennie Copeland
12
1/24/14
Value Objects in a Clean Architecture
On Wednesday, January 22, 2014 6:23:35 PM UTC+1, Bennie Copeland wrote: annotation: In
unread,
Design
FolderStructure
ValueObject
architecture
components
ebi
entity
Value Objects in a Clean Architecture
On Wednesday, January 22, 2014 6:23:35 PM UTC+1, Bennie Copeland wrote: annotation: In
1/24/14
Zamith
,
Uncle Bob
3
12/12/13
Naming and structure in the Clean Architecture
Yes, maybe it was fine. It just felt odd, I wasn't sure if was being driven by the use cases, or
unread,
Design
architecture
naming
srp
Naming and structure in the Clean Architecture
Yes, maybe it was fine. It just felt odd, I wasn't sure if was being driven by the use cases, or
12/12/13
Andreas Schaefer
,
Breno Sarkis
2
9/10/13
UseCase 2.0
Wow, nice! I didn't know about it, thanks for sharing! On Tuesday, September 10, 2013 10:37:47 AM
unread,
Design
Requirements
UseCase20
UseCases
architecture
testing
UseCase 2.0
Wow, nice! I didn't know about it, thanks for sharing! On Tuesday, September 10, 2013 10:37:47 AM
9/10/13
Bennie Copeland
,
Uncle Bob
2
8/21/13
Clean architecture and c++
In general, it is the interactors that deal with the complexities of transaction management. They
unread,
Design
architecture
programming-practices
Clean architecture and c++
In general, it is the interactors that deal with the complexities of transaction management. They
8/21/13
Илья Фофанов
,
Uncle Bob
2
8/5/13
Independent deployability and development of components
1. Our team seats in one room and consists of 5 developers. We have access to all source code and our
unread,
Design
cleancode
components
Independent deployability and development of components
1. Our team seats in one room and consists of 5 developers. We have access to all source code and our
8/5/13
Jop van Raaij
7/23/13
EP: 19, part2 - the Venn diagram
Hi Uncle Bob, A question/remark on the Venn diagram at the end in episode 19, part 2. I like this
unread,
Design
TDD
EP: 19, part2 - the Venn diagram
Hi Uncle Bob, A question/remark on the Venn diagram at the end in episode 19, part 2. I like this
7/23/13
Jop van Raaij
,
Uncle Bob
2
7/12/13
Sharing models and logic between applications/projects
I would not separate the GeoLocationConverter from the Location into separate components until some
unread,
Design
Refactoring
TDD
Sharing models and logic between applications/projects
I would not separate the GeoLocationConverter from the Location into separate components until some
7/12/13
Terence McGhee
, …
Frederik Krautwald
6
6/18/14
Clean Architecture... Say What Now?
The controller calls the boundary for the interactor. Since the interactor implements that boundary,
unread,
Design
architecture
Clean Architecture... Say What Now?
The controller calls the boundary for the interactor. Since the interactor implements that boundary,
6/18/14
Boas Enkler
, …
Jop van Raaij
11
11/24/13
Thoughts and oppinions about TDD and database related parts of an application
I'm at the point I have a memory based version of the repository interface: fast unit tests to
unread,
Design
TDD
architecture
cleancode
testing
Thoughts and oppinions about TDD and database related parts of an application
I'm at the point I have a memory based version of the repository interface: fast unit tests to
11/24/13