Hi Melissa,
My wife and I just got back from a week-long trip to Cinnamon Bay. We were also first-timers, and we had a great time and definitely learned a lot of lessons.
We chose to rent a car for the week, and we are very glad we did. Hiking around the island is wonderful, but we loved having the ability to just get up and go whenever we pleased. We rented from Amalie Car Rental. I cannot overstate how happy we were with them. They wait for you at STT baggage claim, so you can grab your luggage, sign the papers, and be on your way. At the end of your stay you give them a call and tell them when you will be arriving at the airport to leave, and they meet you there to pick it up. They have no problem with taking the car to St John, although as some others have stated I believe if you get a flat you are on your own to fix it. Book your car ASAP, you have nothing to lose.
Our meals averaged about $50 per, with a high of around $90, but we were trying to stay on a budget. We were slightly shocked after ordering two mixed drinks at the campsite restaurant and receiving a bill for $25. It is VERY easy to spend copious amounts of money on food in St John. We liked Skinny Legs, the Tap Room at Mongoose Junction, and Woody's. Most meals we made ourselves. We would grab lunch ingredients at the Dolphin Market or Starfish every morning on our way to the "beach of the day", then grab dinner ingredients, rum, wine, etc. on the way back to camp. With a good cooler in the car the food stayed cold the entire day, and we always had refreshments wherever we were. Fresh food (meat, vegetables, fruit) was cheapest, being about the same as mainland, processed and snack foods were about double mainland prices.
We were able to mail supplies to the campsite, which they will hold for you for a flat $5 until your arrival. Since you will be in a cottage, you may not need this.
The most important thing we learned as that many of the other campers have been coming to Cinnamon Bay for many years, and most people enjoy telling their experiences and giving advice. Ask your fellow campers what their favorite places are, where to go and what to do, and you will usually get some really great and informed answers, at least I know we did!
We hope that our two cents has helped! Enjoy you trip and happy travels!
Travis & Aimee
On Mar 21, 2014 11:01 AM, "Melissa Nicole" <
melissa...@outlook.com> wrote:
>
> We booked our flight and cottage today! I am so darn excited! We couldn't get a good view/beachfront cottage but I am NOT complaining! We'll be placed in one of the cottages #1-6. Hope the area in the camp is almost as nice and beach cottages.
>
> So, can anyone tell me where is cheapest to rent a vehicle? Will we want it for the whole week? And can we get one when we get into St. Thomas or Cruz Bay or should we call around and reserve before we get there? How far ahead for a reservation?
>
> Is Jeeping-it the ONLY way to go?
>
> We will be bringing $1,500 for fun cash with us (2 people)...think that will be enough to buy some groceries, gas, explore the island, eat out MAYBE once a day? - or should we bring more? Trying to stay within a budget but I highly doubt we will. Haha!