Under 20 We Card/Teenage (minyan) Wasteland?
10 views
Skip to first unread message
mordy
Jul 6, 2018, 3:03:35 PM7/6/18
to iChabura
The Parsha discusses of the Mussaf offerings
Torah Temima on Sefer Shmos 30,13 cites the Besamim Rosh (aka Kizvei HaRosh aka Kasa d’Harsina-nusach Rabbeinu) in 89 who says women are not obligated in tefilas mussaf since they were exempt from donating the requisite 1/2 shekel used to purchase the Korbanos
*Indeed Mishna Berura in 106,4 cites the Tzlach who rules women are not obligated in mussaf though he also cites Magen Giborim who argues
Torah Temima says based on the Besamim Rosh and based on the Rishonim who say the 1/2 shekel was only on obligation on men over the age of 20 it stands to reason that young men from 13-20 should not be able to lead mussaf services as they themselves were not obligated to participate in said offerings.(thus doing away with bar mitzvah boys 2nd half performance, teen shabbos, youth minyan etc)
Torah Temima leaves the issue as a tzarich iyun
Pretty sure Rabbeinu thinks the whole thing is a non starter
Torah Temima on Sefer Shmos 30,13 cites the Besamim Rosh (aka Kizvei HaRosh aka Kasa d’Harsina-nusach Rabbeinu) in 89 who says women are not obligated in tefilas mussaf since they were exempt from donating the requisite 1/2 shekel used to purchase the Korbanos
*Indeed Mishna Berura in 106,4 cites the Tzlach who rules women are not obligated in mussaf though he also cites Magen Giborim who argues
Torah Temima says based on the Besamim Rosh and based on the Rishonim who say the 1/2 shekel was only on obligation on men over the age of 20 it stands to reason that young men from 13-20 should not be able to lead mussaf services as they themselves were not obligated to participate in said offerings.(thus doing away with bar mitzvah boys 2nd half performance, teen shabbos, youth minyan etc)
Torah Temima leaves the issue as a tzarich iyun
Pretty sure Rabbeinu thinks the whole thing is a non starter
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages