Hi @paper1111. I am the author of the renatoathaydes/CeylonFX project.
As the README of my project said, I was looking for someone to continue with the project after my own interests drifted elsewhere. I also asked anyone interested to please contact me so that we could arrange a proper transfer of the code to a new repository.
I put a reasonable amount of effort in getting that project to where it is now, and @gavinking also contributed to it, so I would expect the commit history to be kept in the new project (or at least some attribution mentioned in the README if that was not at all possible).
However, what you have done so far was to copy the code to a new repository, making silly mistakes along the way like committing class files, without any attribution to the original authors, claimed ownership of an account named CeylonFX which other people might reasonably believe is connected to the Ceylon project itself (from what I know so far, you are not part of the Ceylon team) and just made a pull request to my project, without any explanation, requesting that my README link to your new project.
You don't seem to understand how open source works. You can't do what you did and expect other developers to just go along with it. Besides the value we place on technical contributions, courtesy is a important part of working with others in open source.
Whether or not you have the right to own the CeylonFX account (which I never tried! I was in touch with the Ceylon team the whole time I worked on CeylonFX under my own account, but I would not have suggested moving the project to the CeylonFX account until it was in a usable state and ready for contributions from the community, which my project just wasn't yet), I think is a matter for the Ceylon team and RedHat... But the code that you moved to the CeylonFX project is not yours and you did not ask if you could take it!
To solve this problem, I suggest that you, first of all, make sure that the Ceylon team is happy for you to own this GitHub account at all.
If that's ok with them, I suggest you delete the project history completely and move the original project's commit history and files properly to the new repository. If you don't want to do that, feel free to start from scratch, of course!
Renato Athaydes
On Tuesday, 9 May 2017 16:29:03 UTC+2, paper1111 wrote:
Well yes, its old, but I made the repo now!