Should we make implementation public ?

[suraj chhetry]

Hi All,
Good Evening !

I have multi module maven project where data-module,service-module and ui-module are present.I have written test for data module which is working fine but I am facing problem while testing service layer because in order to test service layer I have to make UserDaoImpl public which I don't want to do.So is there better way we can do with CDI-Unit.

abc-data-module
public interface UserDao{
  public void addUser(User user);
}
@Named
UserDaoImpl implements UserDao{}

abc-service-module
public interface UserService{
}

@Named
UserServiceImpl implements UserService {
   @Inject
   private UserDao userdao;
}

Thanks
Suraj

[Adrian Mitev]

I think your design is conceptually wrong. See here for more info - http://www.codingthearchitecture.com/2015/03/08/package_by_component_and_architecturally_aligned_testing.html