Hey Blair, How about some pictures showing your windlass project?
David, I did a week long cruise to Chestertown in October. I anchored out each night in 10 to 15 ft of water and hauled the anchor each morning by hand. My anchor is a Mantus 2, it weighs 35 pounds and I have 18 feet of chain. I use a 20 pound kellet lowered till it just touches the bottom, to improve holding, reduce sailing back and forth, and keep the rode well away from wrapping round the keel. So my method in the morning is to start the engine, I position a bucket of water on the fordeck, bring up the kellet first, wash it off, then pull the anchor rode so the bow is pointed at the anchor, and give it a good tug so the boat glides up over the anchor. Usually, part of the chain is on deck which I clean as I pull it up. I cleat it off here with the rode taught and vertical, and sometimes the boat's momentum frees the anchor. If the anchor is buried well, and resists, I walk back to the cockpit and nudge the shifter into forward to break out the anchor, then back to neutral, and then I go forward and haul up the rode and anchor, clip on the safety line, and then motor away. I had trouble in Chestertown where I tried to anchor three times and couldn't penetrate the bottom. The anchorage is small and crowded and two other boats went aground before they could power off. I went aground once, motored off and decided to anchor further downriver and passed a TowBoatUS on my way.. Another boater told me there must be a hard patch or heavy grass in that spot, keeping anchors from penetrating. Nobody was successful there.
I would like to have a windlass, but I think I would want the control at the helm so I could work it with the engine helping. At Chestertown, I had to to haul up the rode and anchor while drifting toward the shallows. Not good. In fact there was a full keel Baba 40 with a manual windlass aground and he looked totally baffled as to what to do. .I tried three times, but it would not penetrate and we dragged, till I decided to go somewhere else. If I had windlass controls at the helm and an electric windlass, I could retrieve the anchor while using the engine to hold position against the wind. It would give me better control.
I anchored easily in the Corsica River in a beautiful spot and enjoyed a nice Stormy Weather as the sun set behind the wooded shoreline. It's not so hard to work the anchor rode without a windlass, especially if you cleat off the line. If you pull up on the line when it's taught, you have a 30:1 advantage and can break the anchor out of soft stuff. For harder stuff, I use the engine and it's easy peasy. I'm no macho man, I never fight it. Sometimes a passing boat sends a wake that lifts the bow enough to break free the anchor. Or high winds send a swell that bounces the bow.
I'd like to install an anchor locker and windlass and controls at the helm. But I'd rather spend the money on a topdown furling assymetrical A2 and a Code Zero.
Chuck S