WHAT IS SO GREEN ABOUT GREEN BUILDINGS!!!!!!!

5 views
Skip to first unread message

Chandoo

unread,
Jun 6, 2006, 12:43:50 PM6/6/06
to cbs...@googlegroups.com
DEAR CBSARCH MEMEBRS,

I am hereby attaching the entire text of my article on green buildings through this for your reading and hence giving me valuable comments if i went wrong at any instance. I apologise for my previous attempt of just sending a link, which i am now enlightened, is not encouraged. Here goes my article.


WHAT IS SO GREEN ABOUT GREEN BUILDINGS!!!!!!!


Thesis is a one time hectic schedule in the life of an architecture student. This involves a great deal of surfing books, internet and other reports to get the right topic that interests you and which is in your perspective "something different". This was the same mindset with which I began my hunt for thesis topics. I ran several hundreds of searches online to find that one topic which I like. My basic idea was to take up an office complex design as my thesis, because the earlier semester I had done one and had fallen love with the designing process and found it a little easier to handle office complex (well the ease was due to the fact that I was still in my college and the pressure is far lesser than what a real practice brings in and also that I faired well in the previous attempt).I had some luck but again was not up to the mark.

Finally the schedule was put for me to submit my synopsis. This was the real hectic, hurry burry time when I ran amok and then through one of my friends learnt about the project proposal in my hometown for a habitat center. This topic struck me. Earlier that semester we were touring North India and had happened to visit the Indian Habitat Center, was really impressed by the design principles and the energy efficiency principles and the way the whole project was sculpted out as one whole entity. This led me to take up the project. The next phase after project selection was crucial because it was the part where I had to choose my special topic without which my synopsis was not going to be approved. The chief who did the approvals was not particularly impressed by idea to take up energy efficiency as he felt that it weighted less and he suggested me "GREEN BUILDINGS". Wow!!!!!!!!! That was the first time I heard about such a topic and was really thrilled at first thought, because my peers were running into various special topics that were catchy and sounded good (Most of the students feel that their thesis topics should be catchy and sound good, at least to what I have seen and realized from my peers).
The lines were straightened out and I prepared myself to get down to the road to thesis. The first step which gave me more reason to love my thesis topic was the case study selection part, during which I found out that the highest rated green building as per the LEED was in India and the second best too was in India and the fact that a lot more green buildings were proposed in India. This was a great feeling, which is inexplicable, as you have to feel those emotions you undergo when you realize that your country stands first in this field, which you have elected as your thesis topic. I was really excited about the topic.

The first question was what is a green building? Who has coined this term and for what apparent reasoning? And why has this become an upcoming fashion in the construction industry especially commercial office spaces? Some of these above questions of were automatically answered when I understood what LEED is. So what is LEED???

LEED stands for Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design. The next subsequent question was what its relation to Green Buildings was. So it goes like this, LEED was created to Define the meaning of "Green Building" by chalking out a standard of measurement which was to be followed by the aspirants of Green Buildings. Their main idea was to stimulate a competition within player's world wide, by awarding credits based on the standards of measurement, which was common to the entire world. Hence raise the consumer awareness of green building's benefits to the earth. Hence the players began to compete as a Platinum award from LEED (The highest being platinum, the next gold and then the silver) means the whole world is going to recognize that building and not jus that building but the company which has run the show in the evolution of that building. This concept has interested me due to the fact that it has levied an entire set of rules, which governs the entire design process and puts a check on the entire construction of the building.

The major points which ear marks this are the following-
Water Conservation.
Waste management.
Renewable energy resources.
Re-use or use of recycled material thereby reducing the impact on the nature.
Energy efficiency – which encourages the use of solar cells and other renewable resources.
Hence after I received a gist on what Green Building business was, I proceeded to collect data on several book studies which were readily available online. The book studies helped me understand how the theories based on green buildings were composed into a song in the form of rated buildings. However the term Green Building has intrigued me on its rising demand, the way it entered into the present day practice. Well just a thought to it made me realize that this was no sudden discovery but it was always a part of Architecture, it's the right approach to actual practice and bringing out the best of the architects. If we just set apart some time and put ourselves in a thinking process what were the skeleton of this new concept one would realize that this is the correct mode of operandi for a design i.e., climatic approach to design, energy efficiency and the water efficiency.

Instead of having a motive to achieve the LEED's award why don't all of us (I mean responsible architects) take an oath that we should follow those principles and not commercialize our attempts and try and make understand our clients what are the essentials for the space we choreograph for them. But present days the awareness is there, but because of the name the company/person earns if his/her building is an accredited Green Building. This not be the reason but the fact that Green Buildings should be the popular but it should be an untold song which run in our sub conscious mind day in and day out.

Let us try and bring in a green building in every attempt of ours and at least follow the basic principles to not earn fame but to supply a wholesome product rather space to the clients who are to made aware that their banking on us has been proved worthy when they realize what we have tried to sculpt of their piece of land by the sheer experience they get when they live/use it. When we do such exercise we would automatically become pioneers in saving the earth of its depletion in resources and hence bring about the balance in nature and all of us would become not just Architects but ECO-ARCHITECTS!!!!!!!!!!!!

Well these were some of my experience which I gained through my study on green building which I did as an exercise for my thesis study topic. Rather than students taking it up as their thesis topics it would be more desirable if the think tank take in steps to introduce this as a core subject in our architecture stream so it benefits all of the young aspirants and future eco-architects.


if anybody would like to register their comments on my view your are most welcome to do so by going to my blog throgh the below link.
http://the6thsensenonsense.blogspot.com/2005/12/what-is-so-green-about-green-buildings.html


I thank the reader for investing their valuable time on what i had to say.
Regards,
--
ANOOP MENON
PH: +919884365567

SAM PONRAJ

unread,
Jun 7, 2006, 12:47:50 AM6/7/06
to cbs...@googlegroups.com
Some time ago every one was talking about buildings
with glass facade and Aluminum facade with centralized
air conditioning system. Even some of the buildings
won the award from our institution.
Where was the green building concept at those times ?
Do we have an institution that copies the west ???
Are we copycats ????

As Mr.Jaisim rightly said we have lot of examples of
green building in our own country in the past and also
now lot of sensible architects are doing their best to
develope the concept.
Why do we have to follow a ranking system from another
country ?
Do our Institution have Backbones to stand up and
develope our own system ????
Can we think of a building that doesn't use Electeric
current ??

regards
sam.

WE BUILD THE NATION

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com

Prof. Ar. .Jaisim

unread,
Jun 7, 2006, 6:10:50 AM6/7/06
to SAM PONRAJ, cbs...@googlegroups.com
I love this discussion - Sam
 
The only point I have to add NOW , is what is wrong with electricity. Let us have plenty of it but use it wisely.
 
Leave Individuals alone , we will make electricity out of thin air - "Atlas shruged".
 
Nuclear power - understood and respected can energise a whole neighborhood from a unit the size of an OIL barrel for years. ( quote - Dr. Rajarammanna - during a personal talk with him - long ago)
 
Leave Individuals alone and free them from your national politics and JUST WATCH
 
jaisim

Benny Kuriakose

unread,
Jun 7, 2006, 10:05:59 PM6/7/06
to cbs...@googlegroups.com
Our vernacular architecture buildings are the best green buildings, uses lowest energy per sq.m. or per sq.ft. of occupancy. Many of the so called green buildings use much more energy than that.
 
6% of the world's population consumes 35% of the world's resources.
 
What we need is not an international sustainable architecture, but an Indian Sustainable Architecture which takes lessons from our traditional techniques and materials as both Prof. Jaisim and Mr. Sam Ponraj have pointed out.
 
With Best Regards,
 
Benny Kuriakose.

Aparna

unread,
Jun 8, 2006, 1:51:16 PM6/8/06
to CBS Arch
well heloo to everyone.....i am writing here for the first time but
anyways ....this is Aparna here..a student of architecture now in 5th
yr....i have been a member of this group and keep reading the posts as
when i get time from my college schedule and i really love the
coversations but this was a topic i couldnt resist writing. well
actually Green buildings and energy efficiency are the topics that
thrill me..i seriously dont know y...but i just like them truely. I
very well agree to what u all have said that these principles r seiosly
not just for earning name or profits but these should be applied in
each n every space we design.Its not a formality tht we are doing by
applying these principles...well i don't think so but we gotto conserve
our very much depleting resources but on top of that what i feel is the
quality of space that is generated has an amazing feeling which we
can't even generate with those closed rooms having artificial lights n
ventilating systems(well this is wht i feel).well ofcourse whr
necessary we gotto provide those...no hassles.
we can actually see how the air could be made cool using passive
systems in our old traditional buildings.....for eg:Amer fort whr u can
actually feel the cold air from the tunne can be taken as a small
example n thr are n number of examples available here in india
itself.These principles were being used by ou ancestors but we never
realised.The streets of Jaisalmer,Jaipur planning, Hawa Mahal, we can
see them in all most every building.well these cannot be categorized
under green buildings though but they still use some energy efficiency
principles. well i must say that thr r still places in India which do
apply these things in practica..such as Auroville n those i think can
truely be called as green buildings.The way they use their
materials,harvest water,manage their waste,its simply amazing..well i
havent been there but whatever i have heard n read n seen pics from
that i feel this n will definitely land up at that place to see it one
day very soon.
well i got an exposure abt green buildings from the green building
conference tht was held here in Delhi the last year and read abt it
alot for writting an essay in it abt green buildings which also got
selected in the top12. well thn i also had a chance to do my training
whr in i got more exposed to energy efficiency principles. so that ways
i got a brief idea abt these are so interesting that i still want to
study abt these n more importantly learn to apply these in practical.
well now is my 5th yr and i am really stuck up to choose a thesis
topic but i want to do something in this refernce only.So pls if anyone
could help me in suggesting some suggested projects really
interesting...it would really help me.

shankar narayan

unread,
Jun 9, 2006, 10:08:55 AM6/9/06
to Prof. Ar. .Jaisim, cbs...@googlegroups.com
Have you noticed that the LEED system has come into India along with 'their' type of buildings-the 'conditioned glass box'. So it is like the baby coming with the bathwater. In that context I have nothing against the LEED as it is today- applicable to a default AC space and in trying to see how you can save after you have spent.
An interesting aside is that the CII centre in Hyderabad- Platinum LEED- cost Rs.10 crore for 20000 sft of space- a staggering Rs5000/- per sft whereas a normal building in HYD costs rs 500/- per sft. If you calculate the environmental costs of all the material that has gone into the extra Rs4500/- to make it eco-friendly, you come back to where you started!
Shankar Narayan


"Prof. Ar. .Jaisim" <jai...@gmail.com> wrote:
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages