Hi Everyone,
I replaced both 4D flooded batteries with 4D-AGM batteries two years ago.
There have been several threads with thoughts about what is the best
battery solution for our boats, and this really comes down to the details
of how you use your boat and maintain charge on your batteries - no single
perfect answer here. However, when it is time to get these batteries on
and off the boat, I wanted to offer the method I used very successfully.
To get the batteries out from under the bench, I used the
technique reported by several others with rope and 2x4 over the locker.
Not much new to add to the other suggestions on this part of the effort.
Getting the battery off the boat, I used a technique which worked well and
I do not think this has been reported by others yet. For my situation, the
finger peer next to the boat is short, and it would be dangerous to think
about moving the battery over the lifeline adjacent to the shrouds.
Instead the front hatch was fully opened by removing the strut which limits
how far it can lift. It was tied off in a vertical position. The battery
was moved to the floor under this hatch by putting it on a small rug and
then dragging it into position directly under the hatch. I used a
spinnaker halyard to hoist the battery straight up through the hatch with
one person grinding using the one-way clutches and several wraps around the
winch, while a person on the deck guided the battery through the opening.
Once it cleared the hatch I was able to guide the battery to the foredeck
area, then over the bow pulpit and onto the dock directly in front of the
bow. The halyard carried the weight, and another control line was used to
pull it forward, while a third person stood on the foredeck to help guide
it. Then a hand cart was used to get it to the trunk of the car. The
halyard is high enough over the deck that it was easy to swing the battery
forward this distance. The same process was used to move the new AGM
batteries from the dock to the forward cabin. I weighed the new AGM
batteries at 120 pounds - others reported 160, either number is a
backbreaker!
I considered using the technique used to remove and reinstall the
Westerbeke 30B engine when we had that rebuilt. For that we used the gin
pole in the service slip at our club, and was able to lift it out the
companionway opening with the stairs removed, and then swing it over the
bed of a pickup truck. I think this would be the safest way, but at the
time I replaced the batteries the service slip was in high demand.
Whatever method is selected, hope it goes well!
Rich Allen
SV Destiny, 1995 Hull #265