Jack and all,
I sail in similar conditions as Jack in SWFL and do use my single line
reefing occasionally, but I will try your jib and/or main alone schemes
next time I need to.
On this list over the years there has been much discussed about single line
reefing and I have tried a few different arrangements. However, I am most
satisfied with the setup I have now. I have posted a pic on my Owners
Gallery,
https://c320.org/mediagallery/media.php?f=0&sort=0&s=20251029161419405.
This is a marked up view on an image taken from the list that someone
posted probably decades ago. I believe the line routing is just as it was
when my boat was delivered in 1994.
My analysis of a friction free reefing system shows that tension T on the
cockpit reefing line would result in a force T downward at the tack cringle
and an angled force 2T downward and aft at the clew cringle. In reality,
there is friction and that is what most people seem to fight with this
system. The small sheaves in the front and rear of the boom (can't
remember exactly how small and I am not at the boat at the moment)
don't help, but not much we can do about those (but I haven't really
thought much about it). But what I call the "balancing block" inside the
middle of the boom has tiny sheaves and is a main friction source, IMHO.
So, I fashioned a balancing block with a couple of single blocks I bolted
together. I sized them (don't remember how big) so they would just fit
into the hole at the end of the boom. I also have a store-bought block
that I bought from Vela years ago (Seasure 29.60) but I have never
installed it since my homemade arrangement is still working.
Another modification I made to the original setup was to add a strap to the
outside of the boom so I could knot off the line coming down from the aft
cringle at somewhat of an angle, rather than coming straight down and
tying around the boom per original setup. This pulls the aft end of the
sail farther back as it is being reefed, more so than if this line came
straight down and tied off around the boom. This helped tremendously in
keeping the foot of the reefed mainsail tight.
I currently simply run the clew reefing line through its cringle, although
others would add a block here to reduce friction further. I have such a
block, just have not bothered to install it.
Some have suggested doing away with the balancing block entirely and I
tried that. I was not satisfied with the resulting reduced forces at both
tack and clew due to having all system friction combined in one line. The
balancing block ensures that whatever tension force T applied to the tack
cringle is the same as that applied to the clew cringle. And in the case
of the clew cringle, running the line though and back down to the boom
results in an angled 2T force there. This is all before friction, of
course, but now tack and clew line frictions stand on their own, rather
than being added together in the case of removing the balancing block.
Also sorry about my pic in owners gallery being rotated. Been a while
since I uploaded anything and I recall I could not figure out how to rotate
with the gallery. Furthermore, I couldn't even figure out how to delete
the image and try again. D'Oh! Maybe someone could help me with this.
Frank Ross
Beta Wave #206
Naples, FL