I have to agree with a larger cold plate being much more efficient. This summer I had the opportunity to monitor a 12V refrigeration system which utilizes a below water plate to dump heat. The boat was on the hard all summer so cooling was very inefficient. Often pushing the limits of solar and worn out batteries ready for replacement.
When the refrigeration temperature was set low enough to keep ice cube trays frozen solar kept up and low temps were maintained. Raising the temperature setting on the thermostat seemed to increase energy usage to the point where solar, poor heat dispersion and weak batteries could not keep up and the temps kept climbing. Plugging in a battery charger was the only way to cool down the refrigerator. Once down to the lower setting solar would maintain the temperature which was baffling. After watching this occur several times I finally realized at the lower setting ice remained frozen and less energy was used. When raising the thermostat setting ice trays would partially melt and then refreeze every cycle requiring much more energy usage.
This seems to coincide with the results of your larger cold plate by avoiding phase change from liquid to solid which is very energy intensive. Once launched with new batteries installed I know to keep the refrigerator set fairly low to conserve energy. Counter intuitive to what I would have expected.
Jerry Brisson
Bristol 32 - Athena