Thanks David. Our boat, a Bristol 35.5c, had a Bruce 33 lb when we bought her in 2004. This anchor worked well in similar depths, wind speeds, bottom sand and mud etc.
Until one memorable afternoon, when a dark cloud front came across the horizon, which rolled us almost 90 degrees, visibility in the rain was less than 5'. Later in the afternoon, the nearby Coast Guard vessel reported they had seen a peak wind at over 80 mph. A sailboat anchored near us pegged their wind meter at over 77 mph. We had the engine running in neutral, then shifted into idle, when we knew we were slowly dragging, just enough to keep from dragging as the wind slowly came down to 25+ mph.
After that episode, we decided to upgrade our anchor to a Manson Supreme 35 lb, for our Bristol 35.5c. We have not had that 70+ mph winds since, and have not dragged anchor in the more usual 25 to 35 mph brief wind fronts since 2005. We also increased our rode to 145' chain and another 130' 5/8" twisted nylon for deeper water. If the bottom marks from the chain indicate the chain was swinging an arc all the way to the anchor, we mark that chart to let out more rode for that anchoring area in future visits.
We also carry a Danforth 1000 as a kedge, and a Fortress 37, which we have rarely deployed, except if gusts over 35 mph are forecast. Most strong winds are a shift from the Southwest to Northwest. So if 35+ mph winds are forecast, we leave the Manson Supreme, well dug in to the prevailing southwest breeze, and set the Fortress to the northwest to handle a wind shift.
We agree with you: Dragging is not tolerated and alarms are set.
Fair winds,
Marilyn
"Adena" Bristol 35.5c