"beach cleaning" vs shorebirds

Skip to first unread message

Soheil Zendeh

Aug 2, 2023, 1:19:23 PM8/2/23
to mabird, Arlington Birds, Boston Birds

Long-distance migratory shorebirds are beginning their south-bound journeys right now. Many females, after laying eggs, leave the business of incubating eggs and tending the very young to males, so we get a first wave of mostly adult female shorebirds arriving from the arctic and near-arctic, heading to the southern US, Caribbean, Central America and South America. 

The shorebird refueling stopovers for the remainder of these epic journeys are our coastal (and some inland) wetlands and beaches. 

The good news over the past weekend, from Tim E. who monitors Winthrop Beach:
"On a positive note, we had the following counts at Winthrop Beach.
500-550 Semipalmated Sandpipers
100-150 Semipalmated Plovers
12 Black-bellied Plovers
2 Ruddy Turnstones
4 Sanderling 
20 Piping Plovers (3chicks)
5 Killdeer 
Also our Oystercatcher population will make appearances from time to time."

Winthrop Beach is easily accessible by car or public transportation, and parking is very easy. There are even public showers and restroom facilities!

Now the bad news: migratory shorebirds returning from the arctic are running into our beaches which are extra people-crowded due to the extra hot weather. When these migratory flocks try to land and replenish their fuel for the rest of their journeys, they run into crowds of people, dogs and marauding Peregrines; those are certainly problems for these birds. And now, more than ever, DCR crews are also out with huge machines "cleaning" the beach of wrack, the very food resource these birds need.

Here is what Linda Pivacek, who has been monitoring Nahant beaches for decades, wrote recently:

"I noticed that Nahant/Lynn Beach has had the seaweed wrack lines cleared every day.  I was hoping that DCR would stop this, at least in part... say half the beach.  The many shorebirds that I see fly by daily do not land as there is none of the food they need after thousands of miles of migration. DCR realized that the Piping Plovers needed the wrack and thus stopped beach clearing earlier in the season. Now that the plover chicks have fledged, it's back to 'normal beach cleaning'."

I have similar stories from Lauretta Woods; she watched the beach-cleaning equipment scrape the beach right up and through a flock of feeding sandpipers.

Tim E., the gent with the Winthrop Beach counts above, wrote:
"They were raking the beach at Winthrop this morning before 6am with the machine. I was hoping to catch an overnight rare visitor at dusk. A group of Piping Plovers from other beaches have been congregating in that spot."

The problem is that the Conservation staff in DCR (Department of CONSERVATION and Recreation) does not have much sway with the Recreation folks. Yes, DCR has to toe the line with federal and state laws regarding Piping Plovers, but once they're gone, the beach-cleaning crowd wins out.

What we can do is begin to put public pressure on the agency to reverse this. Please write! Address your email to the Community Relations contact at in...@massparks.govGo ahead and use Linda's words from the letter above, or relate your own experience. Let them know that migratory shorebirds have a constituency. This is a way we can strengthen the hand of our conservation allies within the agency.

Also mention that the wrack being taken does not appear to pose any public safety hazard or risk to human health so you are confused about why the natural build-up of organic debris is being regularly removed.

If you have friends who could be persuaded to write on behalf of migratory shorebirds, forward this request to them.

If you are a member of a conservation or nature-study organization, consider bringing this up with the Board of the organization and have them write to DCR management. 

Shorebirds, like many other groups of organisms on the planet, are under intense pressure right now; their numbers have been declining sharply for several  decades. We need to take action to prevent additional massive population declines.

Thanks all. We have August, September and October shorebirds to look forward to. I hope there are shorebirds to count!

Soheil Zendeh
Lexington, MA 02421

Joan & John

Aug 8, 2023, 12:42:39 PM8/8/23
to sohz...@gmail.com, mabird, Arlington Birds, Boston Birds
I got "in...@massparks.gov not a valid email address" error message when I tried to send them an email. Anyone else get that and is there another email address?
Joan Hazard
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Boston Birds" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to bostonbirds...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/bostonbirds/CABfm929ihttNaPbgpVaMDU-H5UNT4dFvt%3DB9HW2c4Pzj%2BYubDw%40mail.gmail.com.

Soheil Zendeh

Aug 8, 2023, 2:21:27 PM8/8/23
to Massbird, Arlington Birds, bosto...@googlegroups.com, Bostonsh...@googlegroups.com



My apologies for sending out a bum email address last week with my note (below) about beach cleaning and its effects on shorebirds. I know some people wrote to that address and their emails bounced. Here is the correct one:


mass....@mass.gov - Bill Hickey, DCR Community Relations,


In addition, I have the following emails for highers up in DCR; it could be useful to copy your note to these folks:

brian....@mass.gov - DCR Commissioner 

eric.s...@mass.gov - Director of Ecology 

jorge...@mass.gov - Senior Coastal Ecologist 

env.in...@mass.gov - Rebecca Teppers, Secretary of Environment and Energy 


Since my email went out, I have received various supportive responses -- I thank y'all for expressing your concerns.


Here is some additonal information that might be helpful for you to have and, if you choose, to use in your emails: Seaweed, when it washes up on a beach, becomes wrack; and wrack is an integral part of beach self-restoratrion. As the wrack rots and mixes with sand, it essentially fertilizes the sand, making it a medium where dune plants can grow and stabilize the beach against erosion. So without the natural deposition of wrack, or if it is removed, the beach is destabilized. Towns and state agencies are trying to stabilize beaches in order to prevent damage to structures and homes behind those beaches. They are wasting public money and making beaches and beach erosion worse, not better, when they remove wrack.


Again, thanks everyone for showing support for our abused coastal wetlands and beaches and for shorebirds.


Soheil Zendeh

Reply all
Reply to author
0 new messages