Split package warning, but both the two bundles reported are the same bundle
1,339 views
Skip to first unread message
Dan Gravell
Aug 20, 2014, 12:02:34 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
I'm getting the following warning on a bnd file:
Split package, multiple jars provide the same package:com/elsten/osgi
...
Package found in [Jar:com.elsten.bliss.bundle, Jar:com.elsten.bliss.bundle]
...
Had to type that in so might be a small inaccuracy, but the repeated bundle name is not a typo. What does this indicate? I would expect to see two or more different bundles in that line, those being the source of the different versions of the package.
Thanks,
Dan
BJ Hargrave
Aug 20, 2014, 12:10:31 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
It indicates that bnd finds the named package in two jars on your -buildpath. So bnd is warning you. You can address this with the bnd ‘’-split-packages” directive on your Private-Package or Export-Package statement.
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "bndtools-users" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to bndtools-user...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
--
BJ
BJ
Dan Gravell
Aug 20, 2014, 12:18:10 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
Right, so the "Package found in" line should just be ignored, and I'll have to hunt the other one down myself?
Dan
BJ Hargrave
Aug 20, 2014, 12:29:36 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
Both lines are from the same diagnostic message [1]. Is it possible the named jar is in your -buildpath twice? The displayed jar name does not include the full path.
What is the full text of the displayed message?
Dan Gravell
Aug 20, 2014, 12:33:58 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
Too much to type!
You can see the bundle is in the class path twice there... is that the problem and if so, how to remove?
Dan
BJ Hargrave
Aug 20, 2014, 12:37:42 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
It is only a problem for Private-Package and Export-Package if you don’t specify the -split-package directive to tell bnd how to handle finding 2 copies of the package.
You could also edit your bnd file to not put the bundle twice in the -buildpath. :-)
Dan Gravell
Aug 20, 2014, 12:42:48 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
It's not in the -buildpath twice. In fact, it isn't even in there once... this is on the bnd file for com.elsten.bliss.bundle.
BJ Hargrave
Aug 20, 2014, 12:46:23 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
So are you saying that the project to build the com.elsten.bliss.bundle bundle has the jar for that project on its class path? Twice? Seems quite odd to me. What does your bnd file look like?
Dan Gravell
Aug 20, 2014, 12:51:05 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
-buildpath: org.apache.commons.lang,\
osgi.core;version=4.3.0,\
com.elsten.bliss.platform;version=latest,\
com.elsten.bliss.model;version=latest,\
com.elsten.bliss.api;version=latest
Private-Package: com.elsten.osgi
Bundle-Version: 0.0.32.${tstamp}
#Bundle-Version: 0.0.0.201211121101
Bundle-Activator: com.elsten.osgi.Activator
-sources: false
Import-Package: org.apache.felix.scr;version=1.6.0,\
*
BJ Hargrave
Aug 20, 2014, 12:57:11 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
ok. What does “java -jar bnd.jar debug” say for the project? Have the project as the current directory and use the bnd.jar you are using to build the project.
Dan Gravell
Aug 20, 2014, 1:01:42 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
$ java -jar /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/cnf/plugins/biz.aQute.bnd/biz.aQute.bnd-2.1.0.jar debug
Plugins [com.elsten.bliss.bundle, java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor@5cf8fdd3[Running, pool size = 0, active threads = 0, queued tasks = 0, completed tasks = 0], java.util.Random@5ee05754, , aQute.bnd.maven.support.Maven@2ed4e99c, bnd-cache, Release, Local, Bndtools Hub, /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/cnf/buildrepo r/w=true]
Repos [bnd-cache, Release, Local, Bndtools Hub, /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/cnf/buildrepo r/w=true]
Workspace []
-failok [false]
BJ Hargrave
Aug 20, 2014, 1:07:08 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
Quite an old version of bnd. Not much debug info. :-(
What is you try the latest bnd jar from https://bndtools.ci.cloudbees.com/job/bnd.master/lastSuccessfulBuild/artifact/dist/bundles/biz.aQute.bnd/biz.aQute.bnd-latest.jar to run the debug command. It will (hopefully) provide much more useful info.
Dan Gravell
Aug 20, 2014, 1:20:10 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
Yeah, a lot more!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Workspace Workspace [bliss]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Included Files - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/cnf/ext/defaults.bnd
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/cnf/ext/repositories.bnd
Base - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss
Properties - -sources=true
javac=javac
project.bootclasspath= {p-bootclasspath;:}
project= {basedir}
project.testpath= {p-testpath;:}
-sourcepath= {project}/src
javac.target=1.5
javac.debug=on
src=src
project.allsourcepath= {p-allsourcepath;:}
project.buildpath= {p-buildpath;:}
java=java
-verbose=true
-pluginpath= {plugindir}/biz.aQute.repository/biz.aQute.repository-2.0.2.jar
bin=bin
build= {workspace}/cnf
p= {basename; {project}}
project.name= {p}
plugindir= {workspace}/cnf/plugins
project.output= {p-output}
target-dir=generated
project.dependson= {p-dependson;:}
-plugin=aQute.bnd.deployer.repository.LocalIndexedRepo; name=Release;
local= {workspace}/cnf/releaserepo;pretty=true,aQute.bnd.deployer.repository.LocalIndexedRep
o; name=Local;
local= {workspace}/cnf/localrepo;pretty=true,aQute.bnd.deployer.repository.FixedIndexedRepo;
name=Bndtools Hub;
FileRepo; name=Build; location= {workspace}/cnf/buildrepo
project.sourcepath= {p-sourcepath;:}
-releaserepo=Release
target= {project}/ {target-dir}
javac.source=1.5
Workspace - Workspace [bliss]
Plugins - Workspace [bliss]
java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor@2de0a562[Running, pool size = 0, active threads = 0,
queued tasks = 0, completed tasks = 0]
java.util.Random@7789dc75
Maven [m2=/home/gravelld/.m2]
Settings[/home/gravelld/.bnd/settings.json]
bnd-cache
ResourceRepositoryImpl [cache=/home/gravelld/.bnd/caches/shas,
indexFile=/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/cnf/repo.json, ]
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/cnf/buildrepo r/w=true
Release
Local
Bndtools Hub
Repos - bnd-cache
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/cnf/buildrepo r/w=true
Release
Local
Bndtools Hub
Projects in build order - com.elsten.util
com.elsten.bliss.model.api
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.api
com.elsten.bliss.model
com.elsten.bliss.policy.coverart.lookup.api
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.dto
com.elsten.musicbrainz
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.common
com.elsten.bliss.policy.coverart.lookup.common
com.elsten.util.test
com.elsten.bliss.model.test
com.elsten.musicbrainz.test
com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.auto
com.elsten.bliss.policy.parsed
com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.tagtype
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.tagsource.api
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.tagsource.impl
com.elsten.bliss.analytics
com.elsten.bliss.licence
com.elsten.bliss.platform
com.elsten.bliss.platform.test
com.elsten.bliss.osgi.system.osx
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.api.test
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.freedb
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.cache
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.cache.test
com.elsten.bliss.charge.api
com.elsten.bliss.ui
com.onemusicapi.common
com.onemusicapi.client
com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.auto.win.x86
com.elsten.adb
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.wikipedia
com.elsten.bliss.comparisontest
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.aggregateddb
com.elsten.jetty.osgi.boot
com.elsten.bliss.bootstrapbundle
com.elsten.bliss.policy.coverart.lookup.googleimages
com.elsten.bliss.updater
com.elsten.bliss.tools
net.contentobjects.jnotify.linux.x86
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.musicbrainz
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.acoustid
com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.auto.linux.amd64
com.elsten.bliss.stresstest
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.test
com.elsten.bliss.api
com.elsten.bliss.bundle
com.elsten.bliss.policy.parsed.test
com.elsten.bliss.logging
com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.auto.test
com.stripe
net.contentobjects.jnotify.osx
com.elsten.bliss.osgi.system
jaudiotagger-trunk
com.elsten.bliss.policy.coverart.lookup.test
aws-java-sdk-1.4.7
com.elsten.bliss.untagged.acoustid
net.contentobjects.jnotify.win.x86
net.contentobjects.jnotify.win.amd64
net.contentobjects.jnotify
com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.tagtype.test
com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.auto.osx
com.elsten.bliss.untagged.onemusicapi
net.contentobjects.jnotify.linux.amd64
com.elsten.bliss.web.debug
com.elsten.bliss.ui.systemtray
com.elsten.bliss.configuration.file
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.onemusicapi
com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.auto.linux.x86
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Project com.elsten.bliss.bundle
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Included Files - null
Base - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle
Properties - Bundle-Activator=com.elsten.osgi.Activator
Bundle-Version=0.0.32. {tstamp}
Private-Package=com.elsten.osgi
Import-Package=org.apache.felix.scr;version=1.6.0,*
-sources=false
basedir=/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle
-failok=false
-buildpath=org.apache.commons.lang,osgi.core;version=4.3.0,com.elsten.bliss.platform;version
=latest,com.elsten.bliss.model;version=latest,com.elsten.bliss.api;version=latest
Target - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle/generated
Source - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle/src
Output - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle/bin
BuildFiles - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle/generated/com.elsten.bliss.b
undle.jar
Classpath -
Actions - {build=ReflectAction:[build], test=ReflectAction:[test], run=ReflectAction:[run],
clean=ReflectAction:[clean], release=ReflectAction:[release],
refresh=ReflectAction:[refreshAll], deploy=ReflectAction:[deploy]}
AllSourcePath - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.util/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.model.api/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.music.info.api/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.model/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.musicbrainz/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.musicbrainz.test/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.policy.coverart.lookup.api/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.music.info.dto/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.music.info.common/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.policy.coverart.lookup.common/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.auto/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.policy.parsed/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.tagtype/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.music.info.tagsource.api/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.music.info.tagsource.impl/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.analytics/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.licence/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.platform/src
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.api/src
BootClassPath -
BuildPath - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle/bin
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/cnf/localrepo/org.apache.commons.lang/org.apache.com
mons.lang-2.6.0.jar
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/cnf/buildrepo/osgi.core/osgi.core-4.3.0.jar
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.platform/generated/com.elsten.bliss
.platform.jar
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.model/generated/com.elsten.bliss.mo
del.jar
/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.api/generated/com.elsten.bliss.api.
jar
Deliverables - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle/generated/com.elsten.bliss.b
undle.jar
DependsOn - com.elsten.util
com.elsten.bliss.model.api
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.api
com.elsten.bliss.model
com.elsten.musicbrainz
com.elsten.musicbrainz.test
com.elsten.bliss.policy.coverart.lookup.api
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.dto
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.common
com.elsten.bliss.policy.coverart.lookup.common
com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.auto
com.elsten.bliss.policy.parsed
com.elsten.bliss.policy.tag.tagtype
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.tagsource.api
com.elsten.bliss.music.info.tagsource.impl
com.elsten.bliss.analytics
com.elsten.bliss.licence
com.elsten.bliss.platform
com.elsten.bliss.api
SourcePath - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle/src
RunPath -
TestPath -
RunProgramArgs -
RunVM -
Runfw -
Runbundles -
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sub-Builder com.elsten.bliss.bundle
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Included Files - null
Base - /home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle
Properties - Bundle-Version=0.0.32.201408201719
Service-Component=
project.dir=/home/gravelld/eclipse-workspaces/bliss/com.elsten.bliss.bundle
Contained - com.elsten.osgi=
Imported - com.elsten.bliss.platform.model=version="[2.0,3)"
org.apache.commons.lang=version="[2.6,3)"
org.osgi.framework=version="[1.6,2)"
org.apache.felix.scr=version="1.6.0"
Exported -
Referred - java.lang=
org.osgi.framework=
java.util=
com.elsten.bliss.platform.model=
org.apache.commons.lang=
java.math=
Bundle Symbolic Name - com.elsten.bliss.bundle
Execution Environments - J2SE6
Do Not Copy - CVS|\.svn|\.git|\.DS_Store
Git head -
Baseline repo - Release
Release repo - Release
BJ Hargrave
Aug 20, 2014, 1:28:34 PM8/20/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
Nothing looks odd there. I am not sure where to go from here. You are using an old (2.1.0) version of bnd, so I am unsure of what might be wrong. Not sure if you are able to step up to build with the current version to see how that goes.
Dan Gravell
Aug 21, 2014, 5:50:23 AM8/21/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
What I have found now is that there *is* another package with the same name in my workspace. So I might try fixing that and seeing what happens...
Yeah will move on to new version of bndtools which I assume includes an up to date bnd when 2.4.0 is released.
Dan
Yeah, a lot more!
...<font face="
Dan Gravell
Sep 4, 2014, 12:18:26 PM9/4/14
to bndtool...@googlegroups.com
I worked it out: the projects this affected had the class folder ("bin/") in the Java Build Path > Libraries tab. I removed that (obviously the class folder is still contributed by the "Bnd Bundle Path") and now no split package warnings.
Dan
...
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages