Israel's new top spy: Iran bomb possible in 2 years
By Dan Williams
JERUSALEM | Tue Jan 25, 2011 2:50pm EST
JERUSALEM (Reuters) - Sanctions have not held up Iran's nuclear
program and it could produce bombs within two years, Israel's new
top spy said on Tuesday, staking out a conservative timeline in
the face of rosier U.S. assessments.
The remarks by Major-General Aviv Kochavi, chief of military
intelligence, also appeared aimed at asserting authority over the
rival Israeli espionage agency Mossad, whose departing chief said
this month Iran might not have nuclear arms before 2015.
"The sanctions have had an impact on the Iranian economy, but they
have had no impact on Iran's nuclear program," Kochavi said in his
first briefing to an Israeli parliamentary defense panel,
according to its spokesman.
"The question is not when Iran will have a bomb but rather how
much time until the Supreme Leader decides to escalate" uranium
enrichment, Kochavi said, referring to a currently low-purity
project that Iran says is for peaceful energy needs.
"Based on their infrastructure and the technical know-how and
uranium they have, within a year or two after he makes that
decision, they will have nuclear weapons."
Western officials tend to see potential Iranian military nuclear
capability at mid-decade -- whether due to Tehran's policies,
foreign sabotage or U.S.-led sanctions biting into key funds and
"The most recent analysis is that the sanctions have been working.
They have made it much more difficult for Iran to pursue its
nuclear ambition," U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said on
A senior U.S. Treasury official, Stuart Levey, told Reuters on
January 12 that sanctions had "significantly" discouraged
investment in Iran's energy sector.
MIFFED AT MOSSAD
The American remarks followed a briefing to reporters to mark the
retirement of Mossad director Meir Dagan, in which he said Iran
"will not achieve a nuclear bomb before 2015, if that," because of
its domestic ferment and foreign pressure.
Though military intelligence has traditionally enjoyed precedence
over the Mossad in setting Israel's strategic assessments,
ex-general Dagan's words resonated widely given his acclaimed
eight-year tenure and reputation for hawkishness.
Political sources said Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
was upset at Dagan's public pronouncement, which some analysts
said might have undermined Washington's drive to spearhead greater
diplomatic pressure on Tehran.
In what seemed to be an effort to make amends, the former
spymaster has since said Iran could "bolt" forward with its
uranium enrichment, cutting the timeline to a bomb.
An Israeli official who attended Kochavi's briefing and who is
familiar with intelligence affairs voiced belief that the general
had Dagan in mind when he spoke.
"This is a new head of military intelligence, so he's making very
clear what the national estimate is, despite what we heard
recently from the Mossad," the official said.
A career infantryman, Kochavi assumed his current post last month.
His predecessor, Amos Yadlin, has been reticent about the Dagan
flap, not least as the Mossad chief had counseled against Israel
attacking Iran preemptively. Yadlin was among the eight F-16
pilots who bombed Iraq's atomic reactor in 1981 -- a precedent
Israelis cite in making veiled threats against Iran.
According to Kochavi, the first Iranian bomb, if built, would be a
crude device with limited means of deployment.
A nuclear warhead that could be mounted on a long-range missile
"could still take (Iran) several years to develop," Kochavi said,
according to the parliamentary spokesman. (Writing by Dan
Williams; Editing by Sonya Hepinstall)