Fw: Shame! ayurvedic Spa For Madani A terrorist, Crumbs For 26/11 Hero NSG Commando

[neelesh dubey]

 

 

 

Please read and forward do not forget read the last line by the commando which display the bravery and sacrifice they make to protect us.

Defence Minister AK Antony on Wednesday ruled out introduction of Indian systems of medicine in the Armed forces saying the Armed Forces Medical Services (AFMS) system is based on the allopathic system of medicine.

Replying to a question by BJP MP Chandan Mitra in the Rajya Sabha, the Minister said in a written reply that the feasibility of introduction of the Indian systems of medicine in the armed forces was repeatedly studied by various committees and they did not recommend their inclusion. 

Mitra had asked whether Indian systems of medicine have not been introduced in the armed forces and the scientific reasons for not including these systems besides steps taken by the Government to reimburse expenses on Ayurvedic treatment of the army personnel who opt for this system.

Antonysaid combat medical and surgical requirements are the pivot on which the structure of the AFMS revolve.

He also said the Government has not taken steps to reimburse expenses for Indian systems. The AFMS is responsible for providing comprehensive medical care to Services personnel.

This question came in the backdrop of the Army disallowing reimbursement of Ayurvedic treatment of PV Manesh, a National Security Guard (NSG) commando who was wounded during the firefight with terrorists in the 26/11 Mumbai terror carnage.  Manesh was awarded Shaurya Chakra for his act of bravery.

Manesh was in coma for six months after he was hit by a grenade and discharged from the Army hospital with left side fully paralysed. He then underwent Ayurveda treatment and recovered.  He is currently incurring an expense of `5,000 on Ayurvedic treatment per month and has sought reimbursement from the Army. The Army has refused it saying Ayurveda is not approved under the defence medical system. The Karnataka Government is forced to cough up huge sums on spa treatment of Bangalore blast accused Abdul Nasser Madani, but the authorities are not ready to reimburse a paltry Rs 5,000 a month on Ayurvedic treatment of a NSG commando, who was paralysed in the Mumbai 26/11 operations, reports The Pioneer.

Shaurya Chakra awardee PV Manesh from Kannur was paralysed after he was hit by a grenade in his head during the terror attack on Oberoi Hotel in Mumbai. But before a grenade fell on his helmet, he shot dead a terrorist. A splinter is still lodged in his brain.

 

 

http://www.indiatvnews.com/news/India/Shame_Spa_For_Madani_Crumbs_For_Hero_NSG_Comman_-9287.html

 

Shame! Spa For Madani, Crumbs For 26/11 Hero NSG Commando

[ Updated 20 Jul 2011, 15:31:34 ]

Manesh recalls that his commando team was airdropped on the roof of Hotel Oberoi in the early morning hours of November 28, 2008.

“We started from the top and raided each room. We rescued around 40 people who were trapped inside their rooms. When I reached Room No 203, I sensed the presence of terrorists. After blasting the doors when I first entered, I saw the tip of an AK47 rifle behind a curtain. In a split second, I fired and killed that terrorist. Then I saw the second man hurl grenade at me. Shooting him, I dived to catch the grenade. But it fell on my helmet,” he narrated his near-death experience.

His Shaurya Chakra citation says: “For his undaunted valour, resolute determination and dedication towards the mission beyond the call of duty, Naik PV Manesh was awarded ‘Shaurya Chakra.”

But now Manesh has been forgotten by the nation. His employers will not reimburse his treatment cost citing “blind rules” and he can’t even get a confirmed train ticket. All because, like Madani, he can’t hire top lawyers to argue his case for Ayurvedic treatment.

Manesh says his doctors have advised that Ayurveda was his last hope. “I have to travel by train every fortnight to a hospital 300 km away in Ottapalam in Palakkad district for treatment, which costs `2,000 every time,” he said.

“Some time I don’t get train reservations. I was once even asked by the ticket collector to get off the train,” he said.

Talking to The Pioneer on phone from his home village Azheekode in Kannur, Manesh narrates his sad tale.

“The right side of my body is completely paralysed. After year-long treatment at Army hospitals in Delhi and Mumbai, I returned to my hometown. All the doctors advised me to undertake Ayurvedic treatment. Ayurveda is the last resort for me and the treatment is helping,” he said.

“But unfortunately, my treatment expenses of `2,000 per visit can’t be reimbursed, simply because Army rules won’t permit such reimbursement for Ayurveda. It is not an approved treatment system in the forces. What am I to do? I have tried my level best,” laments the 35-year-old former NSG commando.

Manesh is now rehabilitated in his parent force Indian Army’s Madras Regiment as a Naik. The Army provides him full salary of a serving staff.

For the past one year, Manesh is undergoing treatment at Karuna Hospital in Ottapalam in Palakkad district, a well-known private Ayurveda hospital in the State. “They don’t take any consultation fee from me. But I have to pay `2,000 for medicines per visit. It would be fine, if the Government and forces reimburse the cost of Ayurvedic treatment. I believe in Ayurveda. I was wheel-chair bound when I reached the hospital one year ago. Now I can walk at least 100 metres at a stretch with the help of a walking stick,” says the brave soldier.

Manesh fumes when he talks about his railway journey to the hospital. “As I am a Shaurya Chakra awardee, the Army granted me free travel rail pass along with a companion. We are entitled first class travel. But the problem is we never get confirmed reservation. Doctors insist prompt attendance. Most of the time I travel on an unreserved ticket. I can’t stand for long time as my right side from head to leg is paralysed. Some people who recognise me offer their seats,” he said.

Then he went on to narrate what has left a deep wound on his psyche. “Once, I was asked to get out of the compartment, as I had no reservation. That was the day, I cursed myself. I thought for whom I have ruined my life,” says Manesh in a choking voice.

Manesh now lives at his ancestral home with his aged parents, unemployed wife Sheema, and their four-year-old son Yadukrishnan. “Now I am engaged in the construction of our new home. Recently I took a loan of Rs10 lakh from Federal Bank. I spend time with friends. It is sad to hear about the recent attack in Mumbai. It takes me to 26/11 operation days,” say Manesh.

Manesh fell down and his US made helmet was broken into three pieces. The terrorist who threw the grenade was neutralised by Manesh’s colleague. Manesh was in coma for four months. He regained the capacity to speak after six months. Three shrapnel pierced his head. Two were removed and Manesh lives with one inside his head now. “Let it be there. I am used to it,” laughs the brave soldier.

“I have no regrets in life. I am proud to get Shaurya Chakra,” he said, and then added, “I have a wish. I want to go to the Oberoi Hotel with my wife and kid once in my life. One day I will.”

 

 

0 #3 Dr.shekhar sharma 2012-09-06 15:16

it is very shamful. ayurveda is scientific and establish system of medicine , traditional system of india. our respected minister cannot understand the pain of brave NSG commando, who recovered through Ayurveda. our ministers will spend crores of rupees in celebration but not reambursing the charges of the treatment of the brave commondo!!!
jaago bharat jaago this minister will sell entire india and will finish the glourios tradition of our country

Please do not print this email unless it is absolutely necessary.
The information contained in this electronic message and any attachments to this message are intended for the exclusive use of the addressee(s) and may contain proprietary, confidential or privileged information. If you are not the intended recipient, you should not disseminate, distribute or copy this e-mail. Please notify the sender immediately and destroy all copies of this message and any attachments.

WARNING: Computer viruses can be transmitted via email. The recipient should check this email and any attachments for the presence of viruses. The company accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email.

www.sksindia.com

This message has been scanned for malware by Websense. www.websense.com

[andra murty]

It is not only shameful on the part of Indian Army authorities not to
grant reimbursement to this brave soldier. Rules are meant to help a
needy person and not meant for stopping any good action. If not
applicale as per rules the expenses cn be met out from Prime Ministers
relief fund or any such fund. I wonder whether any future brve persons
will take initiative in fighting for the country under the
circumstances

On 9/7/12, neelesh dubey <neel_...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
> Please read and forward do not forget read the last line by the commando
> which display the bravery and sacrifice they make to protect us.
> Defence Minister AK Antony on Wednesday ruled out introduction of Indian
> systems of medicine in the Armed forces saying the Armed Forces Medical
> Services (AFMS) system is based on the allopathic system of medicine.
> Replying to a question by BJP MP Chandan Mitra in the Rajya Sabha, the
> Minister said in a written reply that the feasibility of introduction of the
> Indian systems of medicine in the armed forces was repeatedly studied by
> various committees and they did not recommend their inclusion.
> Mitra had asked whether Indian systems of medicine have not been introduced
> in the armed forces and the scientific reasons for not including these
> systems besides steps taken by the Government to reimburse expenses on
> Ayurvedic treatment of the army personnel who opt for this system.
> Antonysaid combat medical and surgical requirements are the pivot on which
> the structure of the AFMS revolve.
> He also said the Government has not taken steps to reimburse expenses for
> Indian systems. The AFMS is responsible for providing comprehensive medical
> care to Services personnel.

> This question came in the backdrop of theArmy disallowing reimbursement of

> Ayurvedic treatment of PV Manesh, a National Security Guard (NSG) commando
> who was wounded during the firefight with terrorists in the 26/11 Mumbai
> terror carnage.  Manesh was awarded Shaurya Chakra for his act of bravery.
> Manesh was in coma for six months after he was hit by a grenade and
> discharged from the Army hospital with left side fully paralysed. He then
> underwent Ayurveda treatment and recovered.  He is currently incurring an
> expense of `5,000 on Ayurvedic treatment per month and has sought
> reimbursement from the Army. The Army has refused it saying Ayurveda is not
> approved under the defence medical system. The Karnataka Government is
> forced to cough up huge sums on spa treatment of Bangalore blast accused
> Abdul Nasser Madani, but the authorities are not ready to reimburse a paltry
> Rs 5,000 a month on Ayurvedic treatment of a NSG commando, who was paralysed
> in the Mumbai 26/11 operations, reports The Pioneer.
>
> Shaurya Chakra awardee PV Manesh from Kannur was paralysed after he was hit
> by a grenade in his head during the terror attack on Oberoi Hotel in Mumbai.
> But before a grenade fell on his helmet, he shot dead a terrorist. A
> splinter is still lodged in his brain.
>
>
> http://www.indiatvnews.com/news/India/Shame_Spa_For_Madani_Crumbs_For_Hero_NSG_Comman_-9287.html
>
> Shame! Spa For Madani, Crumbs For 26/11 Hero NSG Commando
> [ Updated 20 Jul 2011, 15:31:34 ]
>
>

> 0#3 Dr.shekhar sharma2012-09-06 15:16

> it is very shamful. ayurveda is scientific and establish system of medicine
> , traditional system of india. our respected minister cannot understand the
> pain of brave NSG commando, who recovered through Ayurveda. our ministers
> will spend crores of rupees in celebration but not reambursing the charges
> of the treatment of the brave commondo!!!
> jaago bharat jaago this minister will sell entire india and will finish the
> glourios tradition of our country
>

> ________________________________

> Please do not print this email unless it is absolutely necessary.
> The information contained in this electronic message and any attachments to
> this message are intended for the exclusive use of the addressee(s) and may
> contain proprietary, confidential or privileged information. If you are not
> the intended recipient, you should not disseminate, distribute or copy this
> e-mail. Please notify the sender immediately and destroy all copies of this
> message and any attachments.
>
> WARNING: Computer viruses can be transmitted via email. The recipient should
> check this email and any attachments for the presence of viruses. The
> company accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted
> by this email.
>
> www.sksindia.com
>
> This message has been scanned for malware by Websense. www.websense.com
>

> --
> Manage emails receipt at
> http://groups.google.com/group/bharatswabhimantrust/subscribe
> To post ,send email to bharatswab...@googlegroups.com
> http://www.rajivdixit.com - Rajiv Dixit audio and videos lectures.
> http://www.bharatswabhimanyatra.com - Swami Ramdev's Yatra Videos
> http://www.bharatswabhimantrust.org - Bharat Swabhiman Official website
>