CTSOC Bulletin

6 views
Skip to first unread message

Barry Smith

unread,
Oct 9, 2025, 10:12:33 AM (5 days ago) Oct 9
to Hogan William R, John Beverley, Federico Donato, Ali Hasanzadeh, alanrut...@gmail.com, Alec Sculley, Alexander Bartnik, Alexander Diehl, Anna Maria Masci, Anuwat Pengput, apta...@gmail.com, Austin Liebers, Bjoern Peters, bl...@u.northwestern.edu, Natalie Gazzo, Gregory DeFranco, Mathias, Chi Hua Lu, cristia...@gmail.com, Crystal Tomlin, damaya...@gmail.com, Diane Schwartz, William D., Elena Milivinti, Fabricio Rodrigues, Finn Wilson, ga.ub...@gmail.com, Giacomo De Colle, glfo...@gmail.com, Gloria Sanso, hector...@gmail.com, Hunter Clark, Jaron Cheung, Jinjun Xiong, Jonathan Vajda, jonmc...@gmail.com, Joshua Billig, Lauren Mabe, Lindsay Cowell, mark.p...@cbp.dhs.gov, Melissa Van Norden, Michael Rabenberg, Naveed Shah, Olivia Hobai, Peihong Xie, Peter Elkin, Rachel Mavrovich, Rachel Stephens, Ram Samudrala, Regina Hurley, Scheuermann, Richard (NIH/NLM) [E], Robert Krieter, Ross Koppel, Samuel Eskew, Sean Kindya, Sebastian Duesing, Skyler Resendez, sydney...@gmail.com, Timothy Murphy, tmp...@gmail.com, Wenjin J. Zheng, Werner Ceusters, Yongqun He, Zackary Falls, Yu Lin, Fabian Neuhaus, Janna Hastings, obo-d...@googlegroups.com, isaacs...@u.northwestern.edu, James Egan, L Bates-Rodriguez, daniel...@utoronto.ca, bfo-d...@googlegroups.com, semant...@googlegroups.com, ontolog-forum, Claudio Masolo, luca.b...@loa.istc.cnr.it, Stefano Borgo, iuris.mo...@unipd.it, Roberta Ferrario, Koslicki Kathrin, Richard Ohrbach, Sonia Sharma, Sam Border, Fabricio Henrique Rodrigues
Thank you all once again for your support for our CTSOC Kickoff meeting in Buffalo last month. One goal of CTSOC is to promote collaborations across CTSA hubs regarding development and application of ontologies. 

One goal of CTSOC is to create an environment for CTSA-related ontologies that would be analogous to the OBO Foundry, for example in that all CTSOC ontologies would satisfy the OBO Foundry principles.

Fabricio Henrique Rodrigues
fabricio....@inf.ufrgs.br

has been appointed Post-Doc in the UB CTSA informatics hub to support the achievement of this goal. He will be in touch with some of you to explore ways in which he can be of assistance in contributing to this goal.
With greetings
Barry 


Asiyah Yu Lin

unread,
Oct 9, 2025, 10:00:02 PM (5 days ago) Oct 9
to STEFANO BORGO, Bjoern Peters, Barry Smith, William R Hogan, John Beverley, Federico Donato, Ali Hasanzadeh, alanrut...@gmail.com, Alec Sculley, Alexander Bartnik, Alexander Diehl, Anna Maria Masci, Anuwat Pengput, apta...@gmail.com, Austin Liebers, bl...@u.northwestern.edu, Natalie Gazzo, Gregory DeFranco, Mathias, Chi Hua Lu, cristia...@gmail.com, Crystal Tomlin, damaya...@gmail.com, Diane Schwartz, William D., Elena Milivinti, Fabricio Rodrigues, Finn Wilson, ga.ub...@gmail.com, Giacomo De Colle, glfo...@gmail.com, Gloria Sanso, hector...@gmail.com, Hunter Clark, Jaron Cheung, Jinjun Xiong, Jonathan Vajda, jonmc...@gmail.com, Joshua Billig, Lauren Mabe, Lindsay Cowell, mark.p...@cbp.dhs.gov, Melissa Van Norden, Michael Rabenberg, Naveed Shah, Olivia Hobai, Peihong Xie, Peter Elkin, Rachel Mavrovich, Rachel Stephens, Ram Samudrala, Regina Hurley, Richard Scheuermann, Robert Krieter, Ross Koppel, Samuel Eskew, Sean Kindya, Sebastian Duesing, Skyler Resendez, sydney...@gmail.com, Timothy Murphy, tmp...@gmail.com, Wenjin J. Zheng, Werner Ceusters, Yongqun He, Zackary Falls, Fabian Neuhaus, Janna Hastings, obo-d...@googlegroups.com, isaacs...@u.northwestern.edu, James Egan, L Bates-Rodriguez, daniel...@utoronto.ca, bfo-d...@googlegroups.com, semant...@googlegroups.com, ontolog-forum, Claudio Masolo, luca.b...@loa.istc.cnr.it, iuris.mo...@unipd.it, ROBERTA FERRARIO, Kathrin Koslicki, Richard Ohrbach, Sonia Sharma, Sam Border, Fabricio Henrique Rodrigues
I understand the strength of unitication.
However, the OBO foundry is Open Biological and Biomedical Ontology Foundry, and the CTSA is more inclined to be clinical. There is a small gap. Perhaps you could open a subspace for all CTSOC ontologies on the OBO Foundry server? 

Thanks,
Asiyah

On Thu, Oct 9, 2025 at 3:43 PM STEFANO BORGO <stefan...@cnr.it> wrote:
Dear all,
please remove my email address from this exchange.  
Thank you for your understanding. 
Best
Stefano



On 9 Oct 2025, at 17:07, Bjoern Peters <bpe...@lji.org> wrote:


I am happy to hear that adherence to OBO principles is adopted as a goal! The most straightforward approach would be to ask for ontologies to be submitted to the OBO group, and to pass the dashboard / community review. I hope that is the plan, rather than adopting some parallel infrastructure? 

- Bjoern
--
Bjoern Peters
Professor
La Jolla Institute for Immunology
9420 Athena Circle
La Jolla, CA 92037, USA
Tel: 858/752-6914
Fax: 858/752-6987
http://www.liai.org/pages/faculty-peters

Bill Hogan

unread,
Oct 11, 2025, 8:54:47 AM (3 days ago) Oct 11
to Melissa Haendel, lini...@gmail.com, Bjoern Peters, Barry Smith, John Beverley, Federico Donato, Ali Hasanzadeh, alanrut...@gmail.com, Alec Sculley, Alexander Bartnik, Alexander Diehl, Anna Maria Masci, Anuwat Pengput, apta...@gmail.com, Austin Liebers, bl...@u.northwestern.edu, Natalie Gazzo, Gregory DeFranco, Mathias, Chi Hua Lu, cristia...@gmail.com, Crystal Tomlin, damaya...@gmail.com, Diane Schwartz, William D., Elena Milivinti, Fabricio Rodrigues, Finn Wilson, ga.ub...@gmail.com, Giacomo De Colle, glfo...@gmail.com, Gloria Sanso, hector...@gmail.com, Hunter Clark, Jaron Cheung, Jinjun Xiong, Jonathan Vajda, jonmc...@gmail.com, Joshua Billig, Lauren Mabe, Lindsay Cowell, mark.p...@cbp.dhs.gov, Melissa Van Norden, Michael Rabenberg, Naveed Shah, Olivia Hobai, Peihong Xie, Peter Elkin, Rachel Mavrovich, Rachel Stephens, Ram Samudrala, Regina Hurley, Richard Scheuermann, Robert Krieter, Ross Koppel, Samuel Eskew, Sean Kindya, Sebastian Duesing, Skyler Resendez, sydney...@gmail.com, Timothy Murphy, tmp...@gmail.com, Wenjin J. Zheng, Werner Ceusters, Yongqun He, Zackary Falls, Fabian Neuhaus, Janna Hastings, obo-d...@googlegroups.com, isaacs...@u.northwestern.edu, James Egan, L Bates-Rodriguez, daniel...@utoronto.ca, bfo-d...@googlegroups.com, semant...@googlegroups.com, ontolog-forum, Claudio Masolo, luca.b...@loa.istc.cnr.it, iuris.mo...@unipd.it, ROBERTA FERRARIO, Kathrin Koslicki, Richard Ohrbach, Sonia Sharma, Sam Border, Fabricio Henrique Rodrigues
Great discussion! 

So my thought is that we will likely be working on new ontologies, and in doing so, we commit to following OBO principles. We will also likely subsequently submit these ontologies to OBO Foundry for inclusion. And of course in following OBO principles, we will be reusing OBO ontologies.

And +1 to Melissa's point that there are significant clinical ontologies already in OBO. Would add OGMS, MAXO, and DrOn as exemplars.

Bill

On Thu, Oct 9, 2025 at 9:55 PM Melissa Haendel <mel...@tislab.org> wrote:
Hi all, we already have domains (here health) to navigate the existing ontologies, it seems to work fine for Monarch’s clinical ontologies. Perhaps if folks are not finding what they are looking for they can suggest more granular categories? 

Cheers, Melissa 


From: obo-d...@googlegroups.com <obo-d...@googlegroups.com> on behalf of Asiyah Yu Lin <lini...@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, October 9, 2025 6:59:46 PM
To: STEFANO BORGO <stefan...@cnr.it>
Cc: Bjoern Peters <bpe...@lji.org>; Barry Smith <ifo...@gmail.com>; William R Hogan <hog...@gmail.com>; John Beverley <john...@buffalo.edu>; Federico Donato <fdo...@buffalo.edu>; Ali Hasanzadeh <a.hasanzad...@gmail.com>; alanrut...@gmail.com <alanrut...@gmail.com>; Alec Sculley <alec...@buffalo.edu>; Alexander Bartnik <adba...@buffalo.edu>; Alexander Diehl <add...@buffalo.edu>; Anna Maria Masci <ama...@mdanderson.org>; Anuwat Pengput <anuw...@buffalo.edu>; apta...@gmail.com <apta...@gmail.com>; Austin Liebers <acli...@buffalo.edu>; bl...@u.northwestern.edu <bl...@u.northwestern.edu>; Natalie Gazzo <ncg...@buffalo.edu>; Gregory DeFranco <gjde...@buffalo.edu>; Mathias <mbroch...@uams.edu>; Chi Hua Lu <chih...@buffalo.edu>; cristia...@gmail.com <cristia...@gmail.com>; Crystal Tomlin <cmto...@buffalo.edu>; damaya...@gmail.com <damaya...@gmail.com>; Diane Schwartz <di...@buffalo.edu>; William D. <dun...@ufl.edu>; Elena Milivinti <emil...@buffalo.edu>; Fabricio Rodrigues <fr...@buffalo.edu>; Finn Wilson <finn...@buffalo.edu>; ga.ub...@gmail.com <ga.ub...@gmail.com>; Giacomo De Colle <gdec...@buffalo.edu>; glfo...@gmail.com <glfo...@gmail.com>; Gloria Sanso <gsa...@buffalo.edu>; hector...@gmail.com <hector...@gmail.com>; Hunter Clark <hcc...@buffalo.edu>; Jaron Cheung <cheu...@buffalo.edu>; Jinjun Xiong <jin...@buffalo.edu>; Jonathan Vajda <jva...@buffalo.edu>; jonmc...@gmail.com <jonmc...@gmail.com>; Joshua Billig <jlbi...@buffalo.edu>; Lauren Mabe <lmwi...@buffalo.edu>; Lindsay Cowell <Lindsay...@utsouthwestern.edu>; mark.p...@cbp.dhs.gov <mark.p...@cbp.dhs.gov>; Melissa Van Norden <mcva...@buffalo.edu>; Michael Rabenberg <mrab...@buffalo.edu>; Naveed Shah <nsh...@buffalo.edu>; Olivia Hobai <oih...@buffalo.edu>; Peihong Xie <peih...@buffalo.edu>; Peter Elkin <elk...@buffalo.edu>; Rachel Mavrovich <rmav...@buffalo.edu>; Rachel Stephens <rast...@buffalo.edu>; Ram Samudrala <r...@compbio.org>; Regina Hurley <rhur...@buffalo.edu>; Richard Scheuermann <richard.s...@nih.gov>; Robert Krieter <rekr...@buffalo.edu>; Ross Koppel <ross...@buffalo.edu>; Samuel Eskew <samuel....@gmail.com>; Sean Kindya <ski...@buffalo.edu>; Sebastian Duesing <sjdu...@buffalo.edu>; Skyler Resendez <skyl...@buffalo.edu>; sydney...@gmail.com <sydney...@gmail.com>; Timothy Murphy <mur...@buffalo.edu>; tmp...@gmail.com <tmp...@gmail.com>; Wenjin J. Zheng <Wenjin....@uth.tmc.edu>; Werner Ceusters <wceu...@gmail.com>; Yongqun He <yong...@gmail.com>; Zackary Falls <zmf...@buffalo.edu>; Fabian Neuhaus <fneu...@ovgu.de>; Janna Hastings <janna.h...@uzh.ch>; obo-d...@googlegroups.com <obo-d...@googlegroups.com>; isaacs...@u.northwestern.edu <isaacs...@u.northwestern.edu>; James Egan <james...@gmail.com>; L Bates-Rodriguez <lbat...@buffalo.edu>; daniel...@utoronto.ca <daniel...@utoronto.ca>; bfo-d...@googlegroups.com <bfo-d...@googlegroups.com>; semant...@googlegroups.com <semant...@googlegroups.com>; ontolog-forum <ontolo...@googlegroups.com>; Claudio Masolo <claudio...@loa.istc.cnr.it>; luca.b...@loa.istc.cnr.it <luca.b...@loa.istc.cnr.it>; iuris.mo...@unipd.it <iuris.mo...@unipd.it>; ROBERTA FERRARIO <roberta....@cnr.it>; Kathrin Koslicki <kathrin....@unine.ch>; Richard Ohrbach <ohr...@buffalo.edu>; Sonia Sharma <soni...@buffalo.edu>; Sam Border <spbo...@buffalo.edu>; Fabricio Henrique Rodrigues <fabricio....@inf.ufrgs.br>
Subject: [obo-discuss] Re: CTSOC Bulletin
 
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "obo-discuss" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to obo-discuss...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/obo-discuss/CADBWCHaKYJguw-FQWQXDi9nMvAmhR06jGpnBMXz-QXFfZMQbkA%40mail.gmail.com.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages