Hypocrisy emanating from Dr. Shabbir's books/ messages, exposed by his own words

[Shakeel Ahmad]

Assalamo Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahe Wa Barakatahu. Hope and pray that this mail finds you in the best of health and eiman, insha-Allah! May Allah bless you with good health, lots of wealth, peace, prosperity and happiness!

Hypocrisy emanating from Dr. Shabbir’s books/ messages, exposed by his own words

1.       “ISLAM AS I UNDERSTAND (English and Urdu)
This little book is power packed with Qur’anic verses and authentic sayings of the exalted Prophet.”

From where did you get these “authentic sayings”, Dr. Shabbir?

2.       “A SELECTION OF AHADITH
(Sayings attributed to the exalted Prophet that pass the Criterion of Qur’an. English and Urdu together). These sayings were committed to writing centuries after his demise, and all of them are based on hearsay.”

After your “long” research, Dr. Shabbir, you could not find out that many ahadith that collectors found were existing as written records!! You must have come across referenced material on such ahadith, but accepting them does not serve your purpose, so you would ignore them completely and call “all” as hearsay!! But, you did compile (or pick from those compiled by those you consider as your enemies) “authentic ahadith” yourself!!
You claim “We have chosen only those sayings that are in complete harmony with this Criterion.”

Did Bukhari, Muslim, and similar of those collectors you curse today not do the same (chose those sayings that they could authenticate as per strict criteria set by them, and which did not violate the essence of Quran)? Those revered collectors of ahadith never cursed, abused, and maligned the character of other collectors, because their eiman was in better harmony with Quran than yours. What commandment of Quran allows you to demonize the character of those who indulged in similar research as you are indulging in. Your main contention in your hate-messages against them is that they made such an attempt 2/3 hundred years after the prohpet’s time. What about your own time-line? Is it not height of hypocrisy, Dr. Shabbir, that centuries later you compile “authentic ahadith” yourself?

Dr. Shabbir, in group messages boasting of your own books, like this: “Extensively researched and generously referenced, the book effectively demolishes the widely accepted “norms” and reveals the truth in a convincing style. Spellbinding!” 

And this: “This is a most beautiful book, pleasing to the eye and challenging the mind. A swift, scintillating intellectual journey …”

And this: “Father Of The Nation by Shabbir Ahmed, M.D. is the most popular biography of this great man.”

Dr. Shabbir, the translator and interpreter of Quran forgot (ignored deliberately) the following and similar ayah: Self-praise (boasting of one’s own writings – which Islamic attribute from Quran allows you this, Dr. Shabbir? Verily, Allah does not like such as are proud and Boastful. (Quran, Chapter #4, Verse #36)

3.       “So, this is the Salaat or Namaaz of Hadith. Can you pray at all according to Hadith? If you claim Hadith tells you the method of Namaaz, then, which one is the greater riddle – Hadith or your thinking?”

So, what is your method of namaaz, Dr. Shabbir? And your method of salaat? And, where did you deduce the methodologies from, Dr. Shabbir? You can deduce the methodologies 1400 years after the prophet, and we must trust you, while the people who went around the globe collecting the information 2 or 3 hundreds after the prophet must be condemned for doing so!! What a height of hypocrisy, Dr. Shabbir!!

4.       ["Hadithe Muhammad" is FRAUD. It is Hadith according to Bukhari et al]

Your forefather, Bukhari, was fraud because he did exactly the same thing as you are doing today!! Exploring the truth, defying the information available during his time, and venturing into a mission to find the truth, from those who could be trusted, trying to authenticate them through unbroken chains, testing them with Quran as the fundamental of faith; did Bukhari, Muslim, and their cult not do the same, Dr. Shabbir? You are using far more conjecture, emotional drama, than any proper structured research. You claim to be right doing the same thing as the respected collectors - although, your effort does not travel beyond the anti-Islam pages on internet; and you claim that all your forefathers before you, who travelled this earth centuries before you were frauds!! How could there be two parameters for the same mission, Dr. Shabbir!! What a height of hypocrisy, Dr. Shabbir!!

You term "Hadithe Muhammad" as FRAUD!! Trillions of shame upon you, Dr. Shabbir for the derogatory terms used for hadith of Muhammad, Sallallaho Alaihe Wasallam. When you tell us about ahadith in your own book, they must be believed as REALLY TRUE, REALLY AUTHENTIC, etc. When they come from your forefathers who tried to use far better parameters to authenticate them, you term them as FRAUDS!! Your words actually do nothing more than exposing HYPOCRICY embedded in them – your claim of intellectual brilliance actually authenticates HYPOCRICY far more than anything else.

If your campaign to malign all those who helped Islam reach the masses, helped them understand the meaning of their existence in this world, meaning of peace, love and humanity, is for financial benefits, declare this to us, and we would ignore all your messages, trash them, rather than react to your nonsense. Otherwise, fear Allah, and don’t exploit the minor differences of opinions to generate fitnah followed by internecine wars.

 

May Allah bless you with true success of this world as well as of the hereafter!

----
PS: Actions may not always bring happiness; but there is no happiness without action, so act we MUST.
---------
Wishing you and all your loved ones greatest of times ahead!
Aspiring 2 c u happy!

Shakeel Ahmad
B.Tech (IIT BHU), MBA (XLRI), PMP
Dubai, United Arab Emirates

Remember, growing older is mandatory. Growing up is optional.
 
We make a Living by what we get, we make a Life by what we give.

If you fill your heart with regrets of yesterday and the worries of tomorrow,
you have no today to be thankful for.

On Fri, Mar 21, 2014 at 1:47 AM, SHABBIR AHMED <drsh...@bellsouth.net> wrote:

Shaukat Omari Bhai,

Even your name is wonderful.

I honor you and all members.

This is your student's Bookstore at www.ourbeacon.com.

Ourbeacon.com

Discussion about Islam

Skip to content

• Home
• BookStore
• Contact Us
• Forum
• Old Forum
• Youtube
• Free Library

BookStore

Ourbeacon Products
By:*Dr. Shabbir, Florida

QXPv (THE QUR’AN AS IT EXPLAINS ITSELF (Fifth Edition)
English translation, understanding and tafsir

QXPv with ARABIC TEXT (THE QUR’AN AS IT EXPLAINS ITSELF (Fifth Edition)
English translation, understanding and tafsir

QXP Audio
The entire QXP English translation is read by Mujtahid Iran in 24 CDs. It is a great company when you are driving, doing chores or just relaxing.

THUS SPEAKS THE QUR’AN
This little book is a compilation of the fundamental teachings and principles of the Qur’an citing oft-quoted verses.

WHO WROTE THE QUR’AN?
The book is decorated with accolades from 150 non-Muslim scholars about the Qur’an. It gives you 45 scientific proofs of the authority and authenticity of the Book. Finally, it relates a beautiful biography of the exalted Prophet.

THUS SPEAKS THE BIBLE (A critical study that lets the Bible explain itself)
This is a most beautiful book, pleasing to the eye and challenging the mind. A swift, scintillating intellectual journey through the Bible gives the reader a highly enjoyable and informative analysis of the most widely read book in the world. With comments from over 150 top Judeo-Christian scholars, THUS SPEAKS THE BIBLE lets the reader explore the Scripture as never before.

THE CRIMINALS OF ISLAM (English and Urdu)
A book of this kind has never been written before. It took courage to write this book and it will take courage to read it. One of our most popular books, The CRIMINALS OF ISLAM unveils the true faces of the revered ‘stalwarts’ of Islam that emerged in the last one thousand plus years. The ‘Imams’, ‘Historians’, ‘Ulema’, ‘Sheikhs’, ‘Sufis’ and ‘Maulanas’, all have made a mockery of the glorious Islam. They converted the beautiful Message revealed to the exalted Prophet into the counterfeit, alien and deplorable manmade Islam as we see today. This manmade religion, as opposed to Ad-Deen (Islam: The Benevolent Social System of Life), is not at all lovable, to say the least. The reader will become enlightened about why and how the once thriving Islam has shriveled into a most miserable state worldwide in the last several centuries.

WHEN IS THE MESSIAH COMING? (English and Urdu)
The entire world, almost every nation and religion, is waiting for the last Savior at the end times. He is supposed to bring the ultimate victory to his respective people and a reign of peace and prosperity to earth. But his objective will not be achieved without fighting the most colossal and enormously bloody wars in which his enemies will be totally annihilated. Ironically, Muslims are waiting for not one, but two, of such giants, Jesus Christ and Imam Mahdi to join hands and give them the universal victory over all peoples. What is the truth? Get a clear logical answer with no ifs, ands, or buts.

ISLAM AS I UNDERSTAND (English and Urdu)
This little book is power packed with Qur’anic verses and authentic sayings of the exalted Prophet. The book glitters with comments from over 150 renowned non-Muslim, mostly western, scholars. The greatest Islamic thinker of the last millennium, Allama Sir Muhammad Iqbal (d.1938) was planning to write a book under the above title but his untimely demise deprived us from another masterpiece from him.

FATHER OF THE NATION
(Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the Founder of Pakistan. Chronology and a brief comparison with M.K. Gandhi.Together with Urdu biography)
“Few individuals significantly alter the course of history. Fewer still modify the map of the world. Hardly anyone can be credited with creating a nation-state. Mohammad Ali Jinnah did all three.” (Professor Stanley Wolpert of California begins his biography of Quaid-e-Azam M.A. Jinnah, the founding father of Pakistan, with the above remarks). Father Of The Nation by Shabbir Ahmed, M.D. is the most popular biography of this great man. A long TV serial was produced based upon his book in the year 2001 in Islamabad.

A SELECTION OF AHADITH
(Sayings attributed to the exalted Prophet that pass the Criterion of Qur’an. English and Urdu together)
There are about 1.4 million reported sayings of Prophet Muhammad (S) in circulation today. These sayings were committed to writing centuries after his demise, and all of them are based on hearsay. The chains of narration are often very long: He heard it from him who heard it from him who heard it from her, and so on, that the exalted Messenger said this or something like this. Knowing full well that the only unaltered book with Muslims is nothing but the Qur’an, and according to irrefutable internal evidence in the Book, the Prophet would say or do nothing against this Divine Revelation. We have chosen only those sayings that are in complete harmony with this Criterion.

HASHISH FROM QADIAN
All about Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, Qadianiyyat or Ahmadiyyat

ISLAM: THE TRUE HISTORY AND FALSE BELIEFS
(Including KARBALA: FACT OR FICTION? KARBALA — is also available in Urdu)
Numerous books have been written in the name of History of Islam during the last one thousand years. But actually, they have been the Histories of Muslims. The Muslim Histories have revolved around the rulers and their ways. The first ever “History” was written by “Imam” Tabari on hearsay alone about 300 years after the exalted Prophet. The later historians have been copying him with impunity. ISLAM:

THE TRUE HISTORY AND FALSE BELIEFS, without missing out on personalities, succinctly displays the glorious Islam gradually declining from its astonishing pinnacle to the ritualistic and irrational manmade religion. Extensively researched and generously referenced, the book effectively demolishes the widely accepted “norms” and reveals the truth in a convincing style. Spellbinding! What a relief of enlightenment it will be to the open-minded, and what a shock to the blind follower! Please get ready for a bumpy, roller-coaster intellectual ride.

SIR, YOU SAID IT!
(What the great non-Muslim scholars have to say about Islam, the Qur’an and Prophet Muhammad. Includes numerous irrefutable scientific evidences that the Qur’an cannot be a product of human mind and that it is most certainly the Word of God)
This is a booklet addressing Islam lovers as well as haters, filling the formers’ hearts with fresh conviction and joy, and softening the misguided hearts, melting away their unfair hatred against Islam, the Qur’an and the exalted Prophet.

DUAL ISLAM
The True Islam compared with the rampant Manmade, Counterfeit Religion

THE EXALTED PROPHET MUHAMMAD
A brief but unique biography of Prophet Muhammad (S) by Shabbir Ahmed, M.D.

ISLAM FOR THE JUNIOR
English and Spanish. A little warehouse of knowledge for children and the beginners.
Dr. and Mrs. Farida Shabbir Ahmed’s youngest child Aisha was only 9 years old when she wrote this lovable book under guidance. Children seven years and above easily read and understand this book, and even the grown-ups find it very informative and inspiring.

THE IDEAL PROPHET
A brief biography of the exalted Prophet Muhammad.
Aisha was eleven when she wrote this delightful and informative, yet brief, biography of Prophet Muhammad, under supervision. Once again, children seven years and above can easily read and understand this lovely work. Discerning parents and schools around the globe have made Aisha Ahmed’s books mandatory reading for kids. Her beautiful booklets are being reprinted again and again.

A HISTORY OF PROPHETS
The Qur’an gives the histories of 20 prophets and their people. The histories focus on the causes of rise and fall of nations. Thus the Qur’an is the first ever book on the ‘philosophy of history’.

A MAN OF THE NOBLEST CHARACTER
Who else but Muhammad (S)? See why he is beyond reproach.

URDU BOOKS:

QUR’AN KHUD APNI NAZAR MEIN
Urdu translation, understanding and tafsir by Dr. Shabbir Ahmed

KARBALA KI HAQEEQAT

IBTIDAI ISLAM KI SACHCHI TAREEKH

ISLAM KAY MUJRIM

BARG-E HASHISH
All about Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, Qadianiyyat or Ahmadiyyat

ISLAM MERI NAZAR MEIN

MEIN CHRISTIAN KYUN NAHIN HOON

KALKI AWTAR AUR MUHAMMAD SAHIB

MASEEH-O-MAHDI KUB AA RAHAY HEIN?
The entire world, almost every nation and religion, is waiting for the last Savior at the end times. He is supposed to bring the ultimate victory to his respective people and a reign of peace and prosperity to earth. But his objective will not be achieved without fighting the most colossal and enormously bloody wars in which his enemies will be totally annihilated. Ironically, Muslims are waiting for not one, but two, of such giants, Jesus Christ and Imam Mahdi to join hands and give them the universal victory over all peoples. What is the truth? Get a clear logical answer with no ifs, ands or buts.

CHRISTIE SE AMENA TAK
Why and how an American Caucasian lady became Amena from Christie.

BAZM-E KEHKASHAN-1 and BAZM-E KEHKASHAN-2
An encyclopedia of knowledge on very diverse subjects. Questions and answers that Dr. Shabbir Ahmed addressed in 15 years.

AHAT
A collection of newspaper columns written by Mrs. Farida Shabbir Ahmed

DASTAK 1,2 and 3
A collection of newspaper columns written by Dr. Shabbir Ahmed

HAMARAY QUAID-E AZAM
A beautiful biography written by Dr. Shabbir Ahmed

NAI SADI NAYA ALF
What is in store for the world and the Muslim Ummah in the new century and the new millennium?

FIKR-E-CHAMAN
Collection of Dr. Shabbir’s poetry

• Donation

  

Ourbeacon.com

Proudly powered by WordPress.

 

Shabbir Ahmed, M.D.

drsh...@bellsouth.net

www.Ourbeacon.com (Be sure to check out the new and old Forums!)
http://www.galaxydastak.com/cgi-bin/bbs60x/webbbs_config.pl
www.youtube.com/drshabbir2
6440 NW 53 ST
Lauderhill, FL 33319
954-746-2115

---

From: Shaukat Omari <taur...@gmail.com>
To: "drsh...@bellsouth.net" <drsh...@bellsouth.net>
Cc: "hani...@hotmail.com" <hani...@hotmail.com>; Kaukab Siddique <ksidd...@aol.com>; "qasee...@yahoo.com" <qasee...@yahoo.com>; "smj...@hotmail.com" <smj...@hotmail.com>; "jimm...@gmail.com" <jimm...@gmail.com>; "butsh...@gmail.com" <butsh...@gmail.com>; "iqbal...@hotmail.com" <iqbal...@hotmail.com>; "global-r...@googlegroups.com" <global-r...@googlegroups.com>; "ghulam...@yahoo.com" <ghulam...@yahoo.com>; "rana.humay...@gmail.com" <rana.humay...@gmail.com>; "zain...@hotmail.com" <zain...@hotmail.com>; "ilya...@gmail.com" <ilya...@gmail.com>; "malik_kh...@hotmail.com" <malik_kh...@hotmail.com>; "doctor...@yahoo.com" <doctor...@yahoo.com>; "jk...@safeeon.com" <jk...@safeeon.com>; "nusrat...@gmail.com" <nusrat...@gmail.com>; "imran...@yahoo.co.uk" <imran...@yahoo.co.uk>; "irt...@yahoo.com" <irt...@yahoo.com>; "iemr...@yahoo.com" <iemr...@yahoo.com>; "imrahee...@gmail.com" <imrahee...@gmail.com>; "haseeba...@hotmail.com" <haseeba...@hotmail.com>; "khale...@yahoo.co.uk" <khale...@yahoo.co.uk>; "kamrana...@yahoo.com" <kamrana...@yahoo.com>; "oria...@yahoo.com" <oria...@yahoo.com>; "hasham...@gmail.com" <hasham...@gmail.com>; "javaid.a...@gmail.com" <javaid.a...@gmail.com>; "int...@atc-fred.com" <int...@atc-fred.com>; "imrankh...@yahoo.com" <imrankh...@yahoo.com>; "jalal....@gmail.com" <jalal....@gmail.com>; "iqbal...@yahoo.com" <iqbal...@yahoo.com>; "pakwata...@gmail.com" <pakwata...@gmail.com>; "irad...@gmail.com" <irad...@gmail.com>; "hasan....@gmail.com" <hasan....@gmail.com>; "khansh...@hotmail.com" <khansh...@hotmail.com>; "abuha...@gmail.com" <abuha...@gmail.com>; "kash...@yahoo.com" <kash...@yahoo.com>; "vka...@etazenath.com" <vka...@etazenath.com>; "imran...@gmail.com" <imran...@gmail.com>; "k_k...@hotmail.com" <k_k...@hotmail.com>; "jazoo...@yahoo.com" <jazoo...@yahoo.com>; "aziz...@gmail.com" <aziz...@gmail.com>; "humza...@hotmail.com" <humza...@hotmail.com>; "hammad....@yahoo.com" <hammad....@yahoo.com>; "imrana...@hotmail.com" <imrana...@hotmail.com>; "i.a-...@hotmail.com" <i.a-...@hotmail.com>; "imran.a...@gmail.com" <imran.a...@gmail.com>; "iftekh...@gmail.com" <iftekh...@gmail.com>; "kais...@gmail.com" <kais...@gmail.com>; "hashim...@hotmail.com" <hashim...@hotmail.com>; "khan...@msn.com" <khan...@msn.com>; "ilya...@gmail.com" <ilya...@gmail.com>; "kanwa...@hotmail.com" <kanwa...@hotmail.com>; "qureshi...@hotmail.com" <qureshi...@hotmail.com>; "kash...@gmail.com" <kash...@gmail.com>; "nafm...@gmail.com" <nafm...@gmail.com>; "latif.m....@gmail.com" <latif.m....@gmail.com>; "net...@gmail.com" <net...@gmail.com>; "farruk...@yahoo.com" <farruk...@yahoo.com>; "aamirl...@aamirliaquat.com" <aamirl...@aamirliaquat.com>; "aap...@yahoo.com" <aap...@yahoo.com>; "aijaz_...@hotmail.com" <aijaz_...@hotmail.com>; "akh...@gmail.com" <akh...@gmail.com>; "bani_...@rocketmail.com" <bani_...@rocketmail.com>; "bazme...@googlegroups.com" <bazme...@googlegroups.com>; "fareed.si...@gmail.com" <fareed.si...@gmail.com>; "i...@islam.ca" <i...@islam.ca>; "imti...@yahoo.com" <imti...@yahoo.com>; "javed....@aaj.tv" <javed....@aaj.tv>; "masji...@gmail.com" <masji...@gmail.com>; "moder...@yahoo.com" <moder...@yahoo.com>; "nafeesh...@hotmail.com" <nafeesh...@hotmail.com>; "newj...@iamc.com" <newj...@iamc.com>; "nizmo...@gmail.com" <nizmo...@gmail.com>; "pakist...@bellnet.ca" <pakist...@bellnet.ca>; "qasima...@hotmail.com" <qasima...@hotmail.com>; "quranan...@gmail.com" <quranan...@gmail.com>; "rubina...@rogers.com" <rubina...@rogers.com>; "ijazs...@hotmail.com" <ijazs...@hotmail.com>; "shakeel_...@yahoo.com" <shakeel_...@yahoo.com>; "ta...@hotmail.com" <ta...@hotmail.com>; "truei...@live.ca" <truei...@live.ca>; "umah...@hotmail.com" <umah...@hotmail.com>; "mike_...@yahoo.com" <mike_...@yahoo.com>; "ibrahim...@gmail.com" <ibrahim...@gmail.com>; "qurananda...@gmail.com" <qurananda...@gmail.com>; "dr.muft...@gmail.com" <dr.muft...@gmail.com>; "min...@yahoo.com" <min...@yahoo.com>; "hassa...@hotmail.com" <hassa...@hotmail.com>; "abida.r...@gmail.com" <abida.r...@gmail.com>; "intif...@gmail.com" <intif...@gmail.com>; "aftabkh...@yahoo.com" <aftabkh...@yahoo.com>
Sent: Thursday, March 20, 2014 2:37 PM
Subject: Re: {GRP} "Hadithe Muhammad" is FRAUD. It is Hadith according to Bukhari et al

Dear GRP Members - A WARNING TO YOU

I have tried to tell you that the Mad Doctor (M.D. Shabbir Ahmad Is not only one who has got it all wrong but is trying his best to create Turmoil within the Muslim community.

Today he is attacking the Hadith but tomorrow I expected he will try to find fault with the Quran. 

I understand from an e-mail that he is an Ahmedi or Qadiani. It does not really matter what he believes in or what he practices. But here is where the  Surah 109 of the Quran - Kafiroon may apply BUT  as I mentioned earlier. The Ahmedis on their own confessions have accepted that they are not Muslims. Though they still try to fool the good and kindhearted  Muslims and try to find sympathy by claiming persecution. 

That he believes in God I give him credit,.I am sure none of the members will have any objection to him being a Ahamadi "Here I can say with tolerance "to him his religion and to us ours" Ahmadi it is but not MUSLIM. At least the Bahais have the courage to say they are Bahais and not Muslims. The Ahmadis unfortunately cannot give up the cloak that they hides under. 

His path  as being part of the GRP is to turn you away from your religion if it is Islam. Otherwise it does not matter.If he is not an Ahmadi or a Qadiani my thousand fold apologies. But I see that he has not contradicted an earlier allegation. Silence can be taken as acceptance

The Almighty tells us to beware of those who reject faith and try to misguide. Stay away from them they will only try to deceive. .

I am not saying all this for no reason, but anyone who attacks the Hadith of the Prophet (pbuh) to this extent and belittles him through misinterpreting Hadith must have an agenda. This agenda on the surface does not seem right. Beware and take what the Mad Doctor says with a Pinch of salt.  

Another thing I request of you members of GRP is not to fuel his articles by comments or rebuttals. His articles must fall on deaf ears and will ultimately disappear. 

My advice is what Allah tells us in Surah 4 Verse 89

• They but wish that ye should reject Faith, as they do, and thus be on the same footing (as they): But take not friends from their ranks until they flee in the way of Allah (From what is forbidden). But if they turn renegades, seize them and slay them wherever ye find them; and (in any case) take no friends or helpers from their ranks;-

I would like to close with verses from the Quran that relate to the authority of the Prophet (pbuh)  Giving sanctions to his Sunnah, and his conduct as exemplary. Both reaching us through the Hadith that we have with us today. We are instructed that:

“Ye have indeed in the apostle of God a beautiful pattern (of conduct), for any one whose hope is in God and the final day…”           (33 : 21)

“He will make lawful for them all good things, and prohibit for them only the foul, and will relieve them of their burden and the yokes which they used to wear, so it is those who believe in him, honor him, help him, and follow the light which is sent down with him, it is they, who well prosper.” (7 : 157)

 “ It is not fitting for a believer, man or woman, when a matter has been decided by God and His Apostle , to have any option about their decision : If any one disobeys God and His Apostle, he is indeed on a clearly wrong path”.            (33:36)

“And those who disobey God and His Apostle and transgress His limits will be admitted to a fire, to abide therein and they shall have a humiliating  punishment”           (4 : 14)

PLEASE READ THESE VERSES CAREFULLY. AND IF YOU HAVE ANY DOUBT ABOUT ANY HADITH. JUST LEAVE IT ALONE IT WILL NOT HARM YOU OR YOUR EFFORT TO ATTAIN THE CHERISHED GOAL THAT EVERY BELIEVER ASPIRES FOR.

Shaukat

On Tue, Mar 18, 2014 at 10:45 PM, SHABBIR AHMED <drsh...@bellsouth.net> wrote:

SECTION 22

DOES HADITH EXPLAIN THE METHOD OF RITUAL PRAYER?

Mullahs insist that Ahadith explain the detailed, uniform method of Namaaz. But go through the 1.4 million conjectures called Hadith and this will happen to you.   

Details online: DUAL ISLAM (Dr. Shabbir's translation of DOU ISLAM (Two Islams) by the top ranking scholar, Fazil Deeniyaat Dr. Ghulam Jeelani Barq) in the Library of Ourbeacon.com.

THE HADITHI PUNCH LINE – NAMAAZ

Let us now deal with the top Hadithi punch line. Cast any doubt on the Hadith literature before any so-called Muslim and the knee jerk response will be, “Oh, how can we pray without Hadith? The Qur’an does not tell us how to perform Namaaz.”

[PARADOX: Less than 5% Muslims ‘perform’ or ‘offer’ Namaaz five times a day, and that too, without understanding. Yet, everybody argues about it. Less than 1% of them have ever tried to understand the Qur’an in full. Hardly 1% ever read its complete translation in their language. True, the Qur’an does not explain the method of Namaaz. Did Allah forget? Or, are we missing something? Does SALAAT mean NAMAAZ? Or, are they two different entities? Is it possible that Namaaz is a minor part of SALAAT? The answers can be found in ISLAM: THE TRUE HISTORY AND FALSE BELIEFS by Dr. Shabbir Ahmed.]

THE QUESTION IS: Do the 1.4 million Ahadith give us a complete, unified, method of NAMAAZ (How to pray, ‘perform’ or ‘offer NAMAAZ)? The answer is a resounding NO!

–    Please remind yourself of the famous, weird tale of the Prophet (S) ascending to heavens to meet with Allah, the so-called Me'raaj (the word is non-existent in the Qur'an). Is not Allah Omnipresent? If He is present everywhere, then, does space travel to meet with Him make any sense?

The "Imams" of Hadith want us to believe that Allah ordained 50 ritual prayers daily for Muslims on that occasion. As the exalted Prophet was descending from the highest sky, Prophet Moses told him of the impossibility of the situation and sent Muhammad (S) back again and again. Imagine the Prophet (S) bargaining with God! Repeated visits to and fro then bring the number down to 40, 30, 20, 10, (elsewhere, from 50 down to half – 25 – and again to another half – 12.5 – and so on – 6.25 Namaaz), finally to 5 (why not 3.125?)! Allah also said, “These are five and these are fifty. I do not alter My Word.” Read again. Moses a. s. wanted him to make one more trip but Muhammad (S) said, “I feel shy of my Lord” (to go back and bargain any further).

Was this Hadith, in addition to promoting ritualism, fabricated to prove the superiority of Moses a. s. over Muhammad (S) and even God? Only an extremely gullible mind would accept this nonsensical story. (See Bukhari, Vol. 1, Kitab-us-Salaat, p. 215, Hadith 339 for exact details.)

So, neither Allah nor Rasool had any idea of human limitations. Had Moses not intervened, the Ummah would be praying a non-stop 24 hours day and night. Thank Moses a. s. for being the instructor of Allah and Rasool. Thank him for saving Islam from their blunder. What mockery! Think: Allah also said, “These are five and these are fifty. I do not alter My Word.”

But the story has just begun. Let us see a little more closely what Hadith has to offer about teaching us NAMAAZ.

[Please note again that Dr. Barq does not give the publishers’ names. So, the page numbers can vary.]

–    Hazrat Anas said: The Prophet (S) used to do a new Wudhu (ablution) for every Namaaz. (Bukhari, Vol. 1, p. 35)

–    Contradiction – Hazrat Ibn Abbas said: Rasool (S) slept for a while – went to the Masjid and prayed (‘offered’ Namaaz) without Wudhu. (Bukhari, Kitabul Wudhu)

–    The Sahaba of Rasool (S) used to ‘perform’ Namaaz without Wudhu after waking up from sleep. (Muslim with Fathil Mulhim, p. 500)

Is Ghusl (bath) mandatory after intercourse?

–    Hazrat Usman said: If a man withdraws before ejaculation, let him wash the genitals and make Wudhu (No bath necessary!). (Bukhari, Vol. 1, Kitabul Wudhu, p. 164, Hadith 176)

–    Bath becomes mandatory after penetration. (Muwatta, p. 22)

–    Rasool (S) said: When a man sits between the woman’s legs and pushes hard, Ghusl (bath) becomes mandatory with or without ejaculation. (Muslim, Vol. 1, Bab-il-Wudhu, p. 485) (Thanks for being so explicit!)

–    Ubbi bin Ka’ab asked Rasoolullah (S), “If a man engages in intercourse and withdraws before ejaculation, should he take bath?” He replied, “He should do Wudhu and pray.”

[Now what conclusion can we reach if any? Would the great men who conquered 1/3rd of the world and ruled peoples' hearts in 100 years and became teachers of humanity, indulge in such trivia and nonsense?]

–    Rasool (S) said, “Renew Wudhu after eating anything cooked on fire.” (Muslim, Vol. 1, p. 486)

–    BUT, Ibn Abbas says, “Rasoolullah ate a roasted goat shoulder and then prayed without ablution.” (Ibid. p. 488)

–    Hazrat Bilal was ordered to say two Takbeers in Azaan and one in Iqaamat. (Muslim, Vol. 2, p. 2)

Why do Muslims say two Takbeers in Iqaamat? There must be another Hadith contradicting this one.

–    When asked what to recite after Surah Fatihah in Namaaz, Abu Hurairah said, “Reciting any Surah is good but Al-Fatihah is sufficient.” (Muslim, Vol. 2, p. 31) The Imams of FIQH maintain that Al-Fatihah alone will invalidate Namaaz.

–    Hazrat Umar used to recite “Subhaana kallahumma … ” loudly. (Ibid. p. 38) The Imams tell us to recite it in the heart.

–    Hazrat Anas said, “I prayed behind Rasoolullah, Abu Bakr, Umar and Usman. They used to begin Namaaz with Al-Fatihah.” No Subhaana kallahumma ... (Ibid.)

–    When the pulpit was built in Masjid Nabawi, the Rasool (S) climbed on it, turned to the Qiblah, said Takbeer and people got arranged in columns. After recitation, he bowed on his knees, then came down, prostrated on the ground, then again climbed on the pulpit. He did bow (did rukoo’) again and then came down for prostration on the ground. (Bukhari, Vol. 1, p. 53)

What! Say that again.

–    Rasoolullah picked up his daughter Zainab’s little girl Amama and began praying. When he went into Sajdah (prostration) he placed her on the ground and when he got up, he picked her up again. (Bukhari, Vol. 1, p. 69).

Why no Muslim does anything like that? – Contradicting Ahadith and Fiqh.

–    If someone passes in front of a praying person, stop him. If he doesn’t stop, kill him because he is Shayitaan. (Bukhari, Vol. 1, p. 68)

–    BUT – Abdullah Ibn Abbas said, “I rode a she-ass to MINA. Rasoolullah (S) was leading the prayer. I passed before some praying ones and got off from the animal and joined the prayers. (None objected!) (Ibid. p. 107)

–    Hazrat Sa’ad bin Abi Waqaas used to pass from in front when the prayer was on. (Muwatta 55)

–    No harm is done to prayers if someone passes from in front. (Muwatta 55)

–    Rasoolullah said, “The prayer is broken if a woman, a donkey or a dog come in front.” (Muslim, Vol. 2, p. 111)

AGAIN, THE QUESTION IS: Do the 1.4 million Ahadith give us a complete, unified, method of NAMAAZ (How to pray, ‘perform’ or ‘offer’ NAMAAZ? The answer is a resounding NO!)

–    Hazrat Ayesha said, “You (narrators) have made us donkeys and dogs. By Allah! I used to be lying in front on the rug while Rasoolullah prayed. (Muslim, Vol. 2, p. 111)

–    Bukhari (Kitab-us-Salaat, Vol. 1, p. 93) narrates four Ahadith that the Rasool (S) used to raise his hands up to the ears before bowing and also on rising from ‘Attahayyaat ... ’

Why don’t the majority of Muslims do it?

–    Rasoolullah used to combine Zuhr, ‘Asr, Maghrib and ‘Isha prayers without duress or travel. (Muwatta 51, Muslim Vol. 2, p. 265)

Why can't we do it? Because of other contradictory Ahadith and the Fuqaha, the 'Jurists'.

–    Mu’aawiyah bin Hakam was praying with Rasool (S). A praying one sneezed and I said the customary blessing, ‘Yarhamakallah’. The Rasool (S) told me after prayers, “Human words are not permissible during Salaat.” (Muslim, Vol. 2, p. 126)

–    BUT – Once, the Satan came before Rasoolullah during Namaaz and the Rasool (S) said three times, “Allah’s curse be upon you!” (Muslim, Vol. 2, p. 131)

Human words! How’s that? And how about depicting the “Satan” as a physical entity rather than the Qur’anic ‘selfish desire’?

–    The Rasool (S) was praying ‘Isha. After rising from rukoo’ he said, “O Allah! Have mercy on 'Ayyaash bin Abi Rabia’ah and other poor Muslims. Grasp the Al-Mudhar Tribe and send famine on them.” (Muslim, Vol. 2, p. 236)

Human words! Aren't they? Did the exalted Prophet, Mercy for the Worlds, ever pray for doom? He always prayed for guidance of people and wished well for all.

–    Rasoolullah never used to raise hands in prayers except when praying for rains. (Bukhari, Vol. 1, p. 125)

He always raised hands during any du'a. (References … too many to point.)

–    Rasoolullah used to offer prayers with shoes on. (Bukhari, Vol. 1, p. 55)

[Can we? The Mullah drives out even a non-Muslim from the Masjid if he is wearing shoes.]

–    Sahaba used to pray even when bleeding from an arrow. (Bukhari, Vol. 1, p. 32, Ibn Majah, Muslim, Nisaai & many other sources)

–    Oozing of blood from anywhere in the body nullifies Wudhu and Salaat. (Same sources and Fuqaha)

–    Hazrat Anas states that Rasool (S) used to pray the briefest complete Namaaz. (Muslim, Vol. 2, p. 86)

–    The Rasool (S) used to scold people who led long prayers. (Two Ahadith, Muslim, Vol. 2, pp. 84, 85)

–    BUT, Hazrat Anas states that Rasool (S) stood still so long after bowing (rukoo’) that the watcher thought he forgot to proceed. The same used to happen after Sajdah (prostration). (Muslim, Vol. 2, p. 87)

–    Abu Saeed Khadri narrates: Rasoolullah’s prayer used to be so long that supposing the noon prayer has begun. A man walks to the graveyard of Baqee’, comes back home, makes ablution and goes to the Masjid. And he finds him still leading the first raka’at (unit). (Muslim, Vol. 2, p. 48)

Then there are innumerable contradictions in what du’as the exalted Messenger used to recite and teach at each point in Namaaz. (See Bukhari, Vol. 1, pp. 99-104; Muslim, Vol. 2, pp. 43, 48, 90)

[Dr. Ghulam Jeelani Barq has cited only a very few (2-3%) of the contradictions found in the books of Hadith about Namaaz, but I think, he has made the point.]

So, this is what the Hadith teaches us about Namaaz:

1.       If you have been snoring in sleep, you need not do Wudhu. Sorry, you do need Wudhu.

2.       Cooked food will break your ablution, but, the roasted goat won’t.

3.       Bleeding does not spoil Wudhu and prayers. Sorry, it does.

4.       If there is no ejaculation, bath is not necessary. Sorry, it is necessary.

5.       You can combine the noon, afternoon, evening and night prayers. Sorry, you cannot.

6.       Don’t raise your hands for du’a. Do raise your hands for du’a.

7.       Before Rukoo’, raise your hands to the shoulders. No, don’t.

8.        Pray two units after ‘Asr. No, don’t.

9.       You can pray with your child in your lap. You can’t do that. (FIQH)

10.   You can keep climbing up and down the stairs during Namaaz. (No way! FIQH)

11.   Only Al-Fatiha is enough for Namaaz. Sorry, it’s not enough.

12.   ‘Allah humma’ can be read aloud. No, it cannot be read aloud. But, you can pray without it. No, never! You can’t pray without it.

13.   You may curse the Satan during Namaaz and pray for or curse others. No, never!

14.   Say anything after At-Tahiyyat that you want. No, only say this and this.

15.   Kill anyone passing in front of the Namaazis, but leave alone Hazraat Abdullah Ibn Abbas and Sa’d bin Abi Waqas.

16.   If a woman, donkey, or dog passes from in front, the Namaaz is broken. But if your wife is lying down on your prayer rug right in front, never mind.

So, this is the Salaat or Namaaz of Hadith. Can you pray at all according to Hadith? If you claim Hadith tells you the method of Namaaz, then, which one is the greater riddle – Hadith or your thinking?

 

Shabbir Ahmed, M.D.

drsh...@bellsouth.net

www.Ourbeacon.com (Be sure to check out the new and old Forums!)
http://www.galaxydastak.com/cgi-bin/bbs60x/webbbs_config.pl
www.youtube.com/drshabbir2
6440 NW 53 ST
Lauderhill, FL 33319
954-746-2115

---

From: KHAN MOHAMMED HANIF <hani...@hotmail.com>
To: Kaukab Siddique <ksidd...@aol.com>
Cc: "drsh...@bellsouth.net" <drsh...@bellsouth.net>; "qasee...@yahoo.com" <qasee...@yahoo.com>; "smj...@hotmail.com" <smj...@hotmail.com>; "jimm...@gmail.com" <jimm...@gmail.com>; "butsh...@gmail.com" <butsh...@gmail.com>; "iqbal...@hotmail.com" <iqbal...@hotmail.com>; "global-r...@googlegroups.com" <global-r...@googlegroups.com>; "ghulam...@yahoo.com" <ghulam...@yahoo.com>; "rana.humay...@gmail.com" <rana.humay...@gmail.com>; "zain...@hotmail.com" <zain...@hotmail.com>; "ilya...@gmail.com" <ilya...@gmail.com>; "malik_kh...@hotmail.com" <malik_kh...@hotmail.com>; "doctor...@yahoo.com" <doctor...@yahoo.com>; "jk...@safeeon.com" <jk...@safeeon.com>; "nusrat...@gmail.com" <nusrat...@gmail.com>; "imran...@yahoo.co.uk" <imran...@yahoo.co.uk>; "irt...@yahoo.com" <irt...@yahoo.com>; "iemr...@yahoo.com" <iemr...@yahoo.com>; "imrahee...@gmail.com" <imrahee...@gmail.com>; "haseeba...@hotmail.com" <haseeba...@hotmail.com>; "khale...@yahoo.co.uk" <khale...@yahoo.co.uk>; "kamrana...@yahoo.com" <kamrana...@yahoo.com>; "oria...@yahoo.com" <oria...@yahoo.com>; "hasham...@gmail.com" <hasham...@gmail.com>; "javaid.a...@gmail.com" <javaid.a...@gmail.com>; "int...@atc-fred.com" <int...@atc-fred.com>; "imrankh...@yahoo.com" <imrankh...@yahoo.com>; "jalal....@gmail.com" <jalal....@gmail.com>; "iqbal...@yahoo.com" <iqbal...@yahoo.com>; "pakwata...@gmail.com" <pakwata...@gmail.com>; "irad...@gmail.com" <irad...@gmail.com>; "hasan....@gmail.com" <hasan....@gmail.com>; "khansh...@hotmail.com" <khansh...@hotmail.com>; "abuha...@gmail.com" <abuha...@gmail.com>; "kash...@yahoo.com" <kash...@yahoo.com>; "vka...@etazenath.com" <vka...@etazenath.com>; "imran...@gmail.com" <imran...@gmail.com>; "k_k...@hotmail.com" <k_k...@hotmail.com>; "jazoo...@yahoo.com" <jazoo...@yahoo.com>; "aziz...@gmail.com" <aziz...@gmail.com>; "humza...@hotmail.com" <humza...@hotmail.com>; "hammad....@yahoo.com" <hammad....@yahoo.com>; "imrana...@hotmail.com" <imrana...@hotmail.com>; "i.a-...@hotmail.com" <i.a-...@hotmail.com>; "imran.a...@gmail.com" <imran.a...@gmail.com>; "iftekh...@gmail.com" <iftekh...@gmail.com>; "kais...@gmail.com" <kais...@gmail.com>; "hashim...@hotmail.com" <hashim...@hotmail.com>; "khan...@msn.com" <khan...@msn.com>; "ilya...@gmail.com" <ilya...@gmail.com>; "kanwa...@hotmail.com" <kanwa...@hotmail.com>; "qureshi...@hotmail.com" <qureshi...@hotmail.com>; "kash...@gmail.com" <kash...@gmail.com>; "nafm...@gmail.com" <nafm...@gmail.com>; "latif.m....@gmail.com" <latif.m....@gmail.com>; "net...@gmail.com" <net...@gmail.com>; "farruk...@yahoo.com" <farruk...@yahoo.com>; "aamirl...@aamirliaquat.com" <aamirl...@aamirliaquat.com>; "aap...@yahoo.com" <aap...@yahoo.com>; "aijaz_...@hotmail.com" <aijaz_...@hotmail.com>; "akh...@gmail.com" <akh...@gmail.com>; "bani_...@rocketmail.com" <bani_...@rocketmail.com>; "bazme...@googlegroups.com" <bazme...@googlegroups.com>; "fareed.si...@gmail.com" <fareed.si...@gmail.com>; "i...@islam.ca" <i...@islam.ca>; "imti...@yahoo.com" <imti...@yahoo.com>; "javed....@aaj.tv" <javed....@aaj.tv>; "masji...@gmail.com" <masji...@gmail.com>; "moder...@yahoo.com" <moder...@yahoo.com>; "nafeesh...@hotmail.com" <nafeesh...@hotmail.com>; "newj...@iamc.com" <newj...@iamc.com>; "nizmo...@gmail.com" <nizmo...@gmail.com>; "pakist...@bellnet.ca" <pakist...@bellnet.ca>; "qasima...@hotmail.com" <qasima...@hotmail.com>; "quranan...@gmail.com" <quranan...@gmail.com>; "rubina...@rogers.com" <rubina...@rogers.com>; "ijazs...@hotmail.com" <ijazs...@hotmail.com>; "shakeel_...@yahoo.com" <shakeel_...@yahoo.com>; "ta...@hotmail.com" <ta...@hotmail.com>; "truei...@live.ca" <truei...@live.ca>; "umah...@hotmail.com" <umah...@hotmail.com>; "mike_...@yahoo.com" <mike_...@yahoo.com>; "ibrahim...@gmail.com" <ibrahim...@gmail.com>; "qurananda...@gmail.com" <qurananda...@gmail.com>; "dr.muft...@gmail.com" <dr.muft...@gmail.com>; "min...@yahoo.com" <min...@yahoo.com>; "hassa...@hotmail.com" <hassa...@hotmail.com>; "abida.r...@gmail.com" <abida.r...@gmail.com>; "intif...@gmail.com" <intif...@gmail.com>; "aftabkh...@yahoo.com" <aftabkh...@yahoo.com>
Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 11:22 AM
Subject: {GRP} Re: Hadithe Muhammad, pbuh, attacked by Pervaizi Shabbir of Florida. Here we strip Shabbir of his lies. Re: FOR MUNKIREEN-E-QUR'AN - Please study with an open mind.

I would like to say that Persian term ‘namaz’ or any other substitute word in English or for that matter any language can not adequately convey the exact depth and vastness of its meanings.

 

I do appreciate that namaz is limited not only to mechanical aspect of obedience to Allah but salah (Arabic term) is equally important feature of ‘nizam-e-rabbubeyyat’ that often goes unappreciated. This aspect is stressed by GA Parwez but both aspects are inter-connected. Without acting on twin aspects (Salah & namaz) full potential and benefit cannot be realized

 

The namaz demonstrate unity amongst believers. Also it’s crucial to be alert and understand exact meanings of the contents during namaz otherwise, it deemed annulled.

 

It is rare that I would praise Saudis but I must admit when they took away four ‘massallas’ from Ka’ba, it was a greatest achievement by Saudi Monarchy. At lease by doing so they achieved conformity in prayers. Prior to that different sects used to prayer separately, according to their particular method. That practice was completely against Quranic teachings. 

 

Similarly, when Allamah G.A. Parwez says that nobody has a right to change the way Muslims pray except, if we are lucky to re-establish broken link with khilafat-e-Rashida. It would be Amir-ul-Momaneen through consultation with Ummah who will have right and authority to unify single method of prayer. Any further individually devise separate method of namaz that would add new firqah. I do not buy that khilafat will ever translate in to reality. I tend to agree with the solution given by a great Muslim mind Allamah Iqbal. Who bestows the very same responsibility to the Islamic Parliament. 

 

Let me bring to your attention that according to ‘Sunnis’ – (between Muqalad and ahle-hadith); there are major differences in method and contents of five time daily namaz.

For instance, I have a book before me; “Tuziah-al-Kalam fi wajoub al qirat khalf al-Imam” penned by Maulana Irshad Al-Haque Asri, a prominent Ahl-e-Haith ‘alim, in two momentous volumes spread over 1,340 pages.

“…Some people (meaning Ahl-e-Hunaaf) believe that it is not compulsory to read Sura Fateh in namaz. It’s clear that those who do not consider it important to include Sura Fateh. How could they then permit their muqtadi to recite it?” Page-14 

 

In contrast Hanfi ‘Alim - head of Darul-Aloom Maulana Tayyub concluded in his “Ahsan Al-Kalam” that reading Sura Fateh behind Imam was an innovation. Maulana Tayyub in condemnation of Ahl-e-Hadith went as far as – 

“Imam ke pechche surah Fateh pardne waloun ke munh main aag” – Translation: (Fire on the faces of people who recite Sura Fateh behind the Imam.” Quoted by Maulana Asri p-16.

“in sirri namazoun main bhi Imam ke pechche qirat karna, na tu jayez hai aur na mustahib; phir zaroori kahan se ho gya?”

 

According to firqa Ahle-Hadith they do not consider any namaz valid, if Sura Fateh is omitted.

It is a fact that there is no hadith compilations that unanimously agree on a single set of standardise namaz. We must be in debit to fuqaha who brought some conformity rather than Ahadith literature.

 

If method of namaz was just a matter of minor difference, them Maulna Asri sahib wouldn't write 1,342 pages on a single aspect of sura Fateh? concluding ahle Hunnaf’s prayers as invalid?

 

I can quote from Bukhari and Muslims some major discrepancies as to the huge difference in method of prayers. Just for an example; namaz can be read without wudu. No Muslim would agree to pray namaz without wudu?

 

According to Qur’an firqabandi is shirk (6:159, 3:105 & 30:31-32). Allamah Parwez was that careful against firqabandi and any alleged innovation in namaz. In mid-fifties a firqa in Lahore propagated that namaz should be read in Urdu. Allamah at that time was in Karachi but in order to counter this fitna; he printed man-size posters and banners and put them up in Lahore city to warn Muslims against a new conspiracy against Islam. He stated that only namaz in Arabic language was valid.

 

The reason of discontent between G.A Parwez and Jama’t-e-Islami’s Mawdoodi sahib was of fundamental importance. Mawdoodi actively preached against formation of an Islamic state – Pakistan, despite agreeing to the principle that Muslims are a separate nation from Hindus. Where as Parwez was one of the active founders of the movement that fought against Hindu majority and British authoritarian rulers for independence. Despite, Maudoodi's condemnation and labeling of fatwa kufr on founder of Pakistan, Jinnah. When Pakistan become reality, Mawdoodi with his ant-raj jumped on the band wagon to destabilise newly created Islamic state, on behest of Maha-Atma Gandhi-ji. Gandhi just before crucial vote of independence presided Jama't-e Islami conference; approved and praised Maudood's stand on anti-partition. 

Parwez through Tolu-e-Islam kept critical eye on activities of Jama’t and alway challenged Mawdoodi sahib’s wrong and 'ever changing' version of Islam, based on his ill-thought and poor understanding of Qur’anic principals, values and teachings.

 

I can understand Mawdoodi sahib’s stance against Parwez for the above reason. I have also read Mawdoodi’s literature and I can show you many contradictions. He changed his view to suit his political aims without any hesitation. However, with Grace of God he miserably failed in his mission and conspiracy against the pristine Islam that was met with same damning curse. As long as Quad-e-Azam and Iqbal’s dream of Islamic welfare state remains before us, there is always a chance that people of the land one day establish a modern Islamic state based on Qur’anic principles. What I know about Jama’t-e-Islami from that I have no doubt that as long as they have any say they would not allow Pakistan to become an Islamic state.

 

Not long ago Mawdoodi sahib’s son Farooq Mawdoodi stated that Jama’t-e-Islami has changed and it is deviating from the principal of his illustrious father. He said that division of India was wrong. His father, not surprisingly, even went further than Dr Farooq.

Here is evidence and admission from Mawdoodi sahib’s himself as to why Pakistan can not become Islamic state.

کتاب وسنت کی کوئ تعبیرممکن نہیں جو پبلک لا ٴکےمعاملےمیں حنفیوں، شیعوں اوراہل حدیث کےدرمیان مقفقََ الیہ ہو۔

“KITAB AUR SUNNAT KI KOI TA’BEER MUMKIN NAHEN JO PUBLIC LAWS KE MUA’MLAY MEIN HANFEYUN, SHE’YUN AUR AHL-E-HADITH KE DARMEYAN MUTFUQUN ALYE' HO”

Translation: "On the basis of Qur’an and Sunnah there is no interpretation possible that in matters of public laws Haafii, Shia’ and Ahle-hadith would unanimously agree upon” Statement of Syed Abu 'ala Maudoodi. Source: Jama’t-e-Islami’s organ ASIA newspaper dated 23/08/1970.

 

Before his admission he scolded and bad mouthed proponents of the same view. A poet expressed his dismay and frustration on the cunning ways that Mawdoodi sahib employed in pursuit of cheap political gain. 

Is daur maen har baat buhat khoub huye hai - Har aik tamanna meri masloob huye hai,

dewaar ki har eent pe likha hai mera naam, ta’meer magar AAP se mansoub huye hai. Translation: Alas! Present day wrong ideals have gained prominence - None of my wishes come to fruition. Hall mark of my effort is evident but construction is dedicated to some else. Even now JI continue to peruse impossible goal. 

Despite all this, Mawdoodi remained Hamaleen-e-hadith having the same view as G.A Parwez. Parwez was the weaker opponent compare to Jinnah and Iqbal therefore, it was fairly easy to paint him as a munker-e-hadith. If fact Amir Ahle Hadith stated in his book "hujjeyat-e hadith" that Maududi's concept of Hadith was more damaging to Islam than Parwez's view. Syed Maududi promoted himself as "mizaj shanas-e rasool", therefore, he become ultimate authority to reject any Hadith that didn't fit in to his faulty vision of Islam. Whereas Parwez's principal stand on authenticity criteria of hadith was largely based on the Quranic teachings. He would cast doubts on any contradictory Hadith that is wrongly attributed to Prophet and was against teaching of the Quran.

 

Sir Syed Ahmed Khan, Dr Allamah Iqbal and Quad-e-Azam, Muhammad Ali Jinnah -  were big giants of Islamic revivalism who changed the landscape of Muslim India.  Until recently Mawdoodi was known as anti-Muslim freedom movement of Pakistan but the prince Machiavelli is fast gaining credit for creation of Pakistan.

Ironically, Mawdoodi is hailed as one of the founders of Pakistan. Everyone knows that it’s a lie and deceit but Jama’t-e-Islami propaganda is so well drummed up that even some prominent Jama’t-e-Islami officials claim, without a shame, that Mawdoodi was champion of the cause of Pakistan independence.

Sent from my iPad

On 12 Mar 2014, at 00:31, "Kaukab Siddique" <ksidd...@aol.com> wrote:

Asalamu alaikum Dear Muslims

I analyzed the lies Shabbir told about Hadithe Ayesha, r.a. about menstruation. He simply moved on to his next bunch of lies. He never admits his blunders. This is a well known pervaizi tactic.

 

Anti-Hadith Polemic: A look at the claim that the Prophet, pbuh,  Forbade the Narration of Hadith

by Kaukab Siddique, PhD

Chairperson, Dept. of Languages & Literature, Interim.

hadithandwomen.wordpress.com
  

One of the basic points the munkireen (rejecters) of Hadith make is that the Prophet (pbuh) himself had forbidden the writing of Hadith. They even quote the Prophet (pbuh) on this and those who don't know are very impressed.
Now note the following points:

1. If the rejecters' view of the Qur'an was right (that it has everything in it, even the details), they would have been able to bring a verse from the Qur'an which would say: Hadith of the Prophet is not needed when you have the Qur'an.
They cannot bring such a verse.
So what do they do? They bring a hadith to support their view!
2.  It is a sign of their dishonesty that they do not quote the whole hadith. Here is the complete Hadith. I have italicized the part the rejecters quote:

 From Sahih Muslim: "Abu Sa'eed Khudri narrates from the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be on him: Do not write anything from me and whoever has written anything from me other than the Qur'an should erase it, and narrate hadith verbally from me: there is no harm in that (in Arabic WA HADATHU 'UNNI WA LA HARAJ), and whoever deliberately tells a lie about me should make his place in hellfire."

Would it be wrong to assume that the rejecters have made a place for themselves in hellfire by falsifying these words of the Prophet (pbuh) by quoting only half the hadith.

Entire books have been written on this subject by the scholars of Islam. (One easily available in Urdu is IBN MAJA AUR 'ILM-e-HADITH by Muhammad Abdur Rasheed Naumani. I read this about 20 years back.)

The Prophet (pbuh) and later Abu Bakr (ra) did not want the words of the Qur'an and the words of the Hadith to get mixed up with each other. Hence the WRITING ONLY of Hadith was stopped. Remember that the reciters of the Qur'an and the narrators of the Hadith were the same people, the companions of the Prophet (Allah be pleased with them). In the early stages, the danger of the two writings getting mixed up was very real.

Even then the ban on writing was not complete. There are numerous narrations which indicate that when a companion (sahabi) expressed difficulty in remembering the Hadith, the Prophet (pbuh) not only allowed him but encouraged him to write it down. Thus many Hadith continued to be written though memorization was the general rule in those early days.

Every companion of the Prophet, including 'Umar and Ali (Allah be pleased with them), depended on the Prophet's interpretation, explanation and implementation of the Qur'an (what we call Hadith of the Prophet). Every teaching of the Qur'an was elaborated by the Sahaba on the basis of the Prophet's Hadith. Thus those who attack the Hadith are attacking the entire history of Islam. They are trying to destroy the credibility of the Sahaba, who also are the transmitters of the Qur'an, and thus these munkireen do the work of the Jews to uproot Islam.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

-----Original Message-----
From: SHABBIR AHMED <drsh...@bellsouth.net>
To: syed Ahmed <qasee...@yahoo.com>; Jon Shah <smj...@hotmail.com>; Jimmy jamshaid <jimm...@gmail.com>
Cc: Kaukab Siddique <butsh...@gmail.com>; iqbal sheikh <iqbal...@hotmail.com>; global-right-path <global-r...@googlegroups.com>; ghulam_yusuf <ghulam...@yahoo.com>; rana.humayun.rasheed <rana.humay...@gmail.com>; zainsyed <zain...@hotmail.com>; ilyas272 <ilya...@gmail.com>; malik_khurramshan <malik_kh...@hotmail.com>; doctorforu123 <doctor...@yahoo.com>; jkhan <jk...@safeeon.com>; nusrat.kamal <nusrat...@gmail.com>; imran123_42 <imran...@yahoo.co.uk>; irtaza1 <irt...@yahoo.com>; iemran11 <iemr...@yahoo.com>; imraheelhussain <imrahee...@gmail.com>; haseebaamir571 <haseeba...@hotmail.com>; khaleq_hyd <khale...@yahoo.co.uk>; kamranarshad500 <kamrana...@yahoo.com>; oriank317 <oria...@yahoo.com>; hashammughal1 <hasham...@gmail.com>; javaid.ahmed.cbm <javaid.a...@gmail.com>; intisar <int...@atc-fred.com>; imrankhan_1117 <imrankh...@yahoo.com>; jalal.noorzai <jalal....@gmail.com>; iqbalidrees <iqbal...@yahoo.com>; pakwatan.karim <pakwata...@gmail.com>; iradat123 <irad...@gmail.com>; hasan.pervez <hasan....@gmail.com>; khanshuja163 <khansh...@hotmail.com>; abuhasan3k <abuha...@gmail.com>; kash_nis <kash...@yahoo.com>; vkamal <vka...@etazenath.com>; imranjunani <imran...@gmail.com>; k_kazi <k_k...@hotmail.com>; jazoo52000 <jazoo...@yahoo.com>; azizirfan <aziz...@gmail.com>; humza_aamer <humza...@hotmail.com>; hammad.khan2289 <hammad....@yahoo.com>; imranakram79 <imrana...@hotmail.com>; ksidd37398 <ksidd...@aol.com>; hanif_mo <hani...@hotmail.com>; i.a-khan <i.a-...@hotmail.com>; imran.ansari63 <imran.a...@gmail.com>; iftekhar.hai <iftekh...@gmail.com>; kaisrani <kais...@gmail.com>; hashimattari <hashim...@hotmail.com>; khan0427 <khan...@msn.com>; ilyasmdgh <ilya...@gmail.com>; kanwarhayat <kanwa...@hotmail.com>; saeed qureshi <qureshi...@hotmail.com>; kashifhaf <kash...@gmail.com>; nafmor08 <nafm...@gmail.com>; latif.m.chaudhery <latif.m....@gmail.com>; netvert <net...@gmail.com>; farrukhabidi <farruk...@yahoo.com>; aamirliaquat <aamirl...@aamirliaquat.com>; aapka10 <aap...@yahoo.com>; aijaz_khwaja <aijaz_...@hotmail.com>; akhbaar <akh...@gmail.com>; bani_hashim <bani_...@rocketmail.com>; bazmeqalam <bazme...@googlegroups.com>; fareed.siddique123 <fareed.si...@gmail.com>; iit <i...@islam.ca>; imtiazat <imti...@yahoo.com>; javed.ghamidi <javed....@aaj.tv>; masjideomar <masji...@gmail.com>; moderate53 <moder...@yahoo.com>; nafeeshard_212 <nafeesh...@hotmail.com>; newjersey <newj...@iamc.com>; nizmohamed <nizmo...@gmail.com>; pakistanpost2 <pakist...@bellnet.ca>; qasimabbas15 <qasima...@hotmail.com>; quranandhadiths <quranan...@gmail.com>; rubinafaisal <rubina...@rogers.com>; Ijaz Sheikh <ijazs...@hotmail.com>; shakeel_ahmed886 <shakeel_...@yahoo.com>; tah67 <ta...@hotmail.com>; trueislamss <truei...@live.ca>; umah.hai <umah...@hotmail.com>; mike_ghouse <mike_...@yahoo.com>; ibrahim.hayani <ibrahim...@gmail.com>; quranandahadith2020 <qurananda...@gmail.com>; dr.mufti.farhan <dr.muft...@gmail.com>; minayet <min...@yahoo.com>; hassanhansi <hassa...@hotmail.com>; abida.rahmani7 <abida.r...@gmail.com>; intifada4u <intif...@gmail.com>; aftabkhan11554 <aftabkh...@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tue, Mar 11, 2014 2:33 pm
Subject: FOR MUNKIREEN-E-QUR'AN - Please study with an open mind.

Respected Sisters and brothers,

Studying without preconceived notions is a great blessing.

SOME CONTRADICTIONS IN AHADITH

 

 

Strangely enough, there are many "Ahadith" that go against other "Ahadith"! I found 300 examples this weekend only. In fact, the Hadith literature is loaded with countless contradictions.                                  

 

1.  Write only Quran:

It was narrated from Abu Sa'eed al-Khudri that the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "Do not write anything from me; whoever has written anything from me other than the Qur'an, let him erase it. " (Narrated by Muslim, al-Zuhd wa'l-Raqaa'iq, 5326)

 

Write both Hadith and Quran:

The prophet ordered Amr Ibn Aas to write everything that he spoke. (Hanbal 2/162)

 

2. Uphold Quran and my Family:

“I leave for you what if you hold up to, you will never be misguided, the book of God and my family.” Muslim 44/4, Nu2408; Ibn Hanbal 4/366; Darimi 23/1, nu 3319.

 

Uphold Quran and my Sunnah:

“I leave for you what if you hold up to, you will never be misguided, the book of God and my Sunnah.” Muwatta, 46/3

 

Uphold Quran only:

“I leave for you what if you hold up to, you will never be misguided, the BOOK OF GOD." Muslim 15/19, nu 1218; Ibn Majah 25/84, Abu dawud 11/56.

 

3. Wash body parts once:

Narrated Ibn 'Abbas: The Prophet performed ablution by washing the body parts only once. (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 4, Number 159)

 

Wash body parts twice:

Narrated 'Abdullah bin Zaid: The Prophet performed ablution by washing the body parts twice.( Bukhari Volume 1, Book 4, Number 160)

 

4. Make no distinction among messengers:

Ibn 'Abbas, may Allah be pleased with them, reported: Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: It is not proper for a person that he should say that I am better than Yunus (Jonah) son of Matthew.

[Hadith number in Sahih Muslim [Arabic only] 4382

 

Make distinction among messengers:

I am the most honorable messenger; on the Day of Judgment, only I will think of my people. (Bukhari, 97/36)

 

5. The Prophet did not urinate standing:

If someone says to you that the Prophet urinated standing, don’t believe him. (Sunen Nisai)

 

The Prophet urinated standing:

The Prophet went to the garbage dump of a tribe and urinated standing.

(Bukhari)

 

6. Do not cross your legs:

Gaber Ibn Abdullah said, “The messenger of God prohibited a man from crossing one leg over the other while lying down on his back " (Moslem)

 

Cross your legs:

Ebada Ibn Tameem said, his father said that he saw the messenger of God lying down on his back in the mosque while crossing his legs." (Moslem)

 

7. Do not drink standing up:

Abu Hurayra said, the messenger of God said, "Do not drink while standing up, if someone forgot and did it, he should vomit what he drank."

(Sahih Moslem)

 

Drink standing up:

Ibn Abbas said, "The messenger of God drank from the water of Zamzam while standing up...."(Sahih Moslem)

 

8. Do not turn to Mecca during urination:

You must not turn yourself to Mecca while you are urinating or defecating.(Hanbal)

 

May turn toward Mecca during urination:

Having witnessed that certain people avoided turning toward Mecca while urinating or defecating, the Prophet had his toilet designed pointing to Mecca to avoid pandering superstitions. (Bukhari)

 

9. Kissing does not violate one's fast:

The Prophet kissed his wife when he was fasting. (Ibn Qutayba-Defense of Hadith)

 

Kissing violates one's fast:

When he was asked if one’s fast would be considered violated, the Prophet answered in the affirmative. (Ibn Qutayba-Defense of Hadith)

 

10. Drawing blood violates fast:

Drawing blood violates a fast.(Tirmizi Fast, Abu Davud Fast, Bukhari Fast)

                                                        

Drawing blood does not violate fast:

Blood was drawn from the Prophet while observing the fast.

(Abu Davud Fast, Tirmizi Fast, Bukhari Medicine)

 

 

Shabbir Ahmed, M.D.

drsh...@bellsouth.net

www.Ourbeacon.com (Be sure to check out the new and old Forums!)
http://www.galaxydastak.com/cgi-bin/bbs60x/webbbs_config.pl
www.youtube.com/drshabbir2
6440 NW 53 ST
Lauderhill, FL 33319
954-746-2115

---

From: syed Ahmed <qasee...@yahoo.com>
To: Jon Shah <smj...@hotmail.com>; Jimmy jamshaid <jimm...@gmail.com>
Cc: Kaukab Siddique <butsh...@gmail.com>; iqbal sheikh <iqbal...@hotmail.com>; "global-r...@googlegroups.com" <global-r...@googlegroups.com>; "ghulam...@yahoo.com" <ghulam...@yahoo.com>; "rana.humay...@gmail.com" <rana.humay...@gmail.com>; "zain...@hotmail.com" <zain...@hotmail.com>; "ilya...@gmail.com" <ilya...@gmail.com>; "malik_kh...@hotmail.com" <malik_kh...@hotmail.com>; "doctor...@yahoo.com" <doctor...@yahoo.com>; "jk...@safeeon.com" <jk...@safeeon.com>; "nusrat...@gmail.com" <nusrat...@gmail.com>; "imran...@yahoo.co.uk" <imran...@yahoo.co.uk>; "irt...@yahoo.com" <irt...@yahoo.com>; "iemr...@yahoo.com" <iemr...@yahoo.com>; "imrahee...@gmail.com" <imrahee...@gmail.com>; "haseeba...@hotmail.com" <haseeba...@hotmail.com>; "khale...@yahoo.co.uk" <khale...@yahoo.co.uk>; "kamrana...@yahoo.com" <kamrana...@yahoo.com>; "oria...@yahoo.com" <oria...@yahoo.com>; "hasham...@gmail.com" <hasham...@gmail.com>; "javaid.a...@gmail.com" <javaid.a...@gmail.com>; "int...@atc-fred.com" <int...@atc-fred.com>; "imrankh...@yahoo.com" <imrankh...@yahoo.com>; "jalal....@gmail.com" <jalal....@gmail.com>; "iqbal...@yahoo.com" <iqbal...@yahoo.com>; "pakwata...@gmail.com" <pakwata...@gmail.com>; "irad...@gmail.com" <irad...@gmail.com>; "drsh...@bellsouth.net" <drsh...@bellsouth.net>; "hasan....@gmail.com" <hasan....@gmail.com>; "khansh...@hotmail.com" <khansh...@hotmail.com>; "abuha...@gmail.com" <abuha...@gmail.com>; "kash...@yahoo.com" <kash...@yahoo.com>; "vka...@etazenath.com" <vka...@etazenath.com>; "imran...@gmail.com" <imran...@gmail.com>; "k_k...@hotmail.com" <k_k...@hotmail.com>; "jazoo...@yahoo.com" <jazoo...@yahoo.com>; "aziz...@gmail.com" <aziz...@gmail.com>; "humza...@hotmail.com" <humza...@hotmail.com>; "hammad....@yahoo.com" <hammad....@yahoo.com>; "imrana...@hotmail.com" <imrana...@hotmail.com>; "ksidd...@aol.com" <ksidd...@aol.com>; "hani...@hotmail.com" <hani...@hotmail.com>; "i.a-...@hotmail.com" <i.a-...@hotmail.com>; "imran.a...@gmail.com" <imran.a...@gmail.com>; "iftekh...@gmail.com" <iftekh...@gmail.com>; "kais...@gmail.com" <kais...@gmail.com>; "hashim...@hotmail.com" <hashim...@hotmail.com>; "khan...@msn.com" <khan...@msn.com>; "ilya...@gmail.com" <ilya...@gmail.com>; "kanwa...@hotmail.com" <kanwa...@hotmail.com>; saeed qureshi <qureshi...@hotmail.com>; "kash...@gmail.com" <kash...@gmail.com>; "nafm...@gmail.com" <nafm...@gmail.com>; "latif.m....@gmail.com" <latif.m....@gmail.com>; "net...@gmail.com" <net...@gmail.com>; "farruk...@yahoo.com" <farruk...@yahoo.com>; "aamirl...@aamirliaquat.com" <aamirl...@aamirliaquat.com>; "aap...@yahoo.com" <aap...@yahoo.com>; "aijaz_...@hotmail.com" <aijaz_...@hotmail.com>; "akh...@gmail.com" <akh...@gmail.com>; "bani_...@rocketmail.com" <bani_...@rocketmail.com>; "bazme...@googlegroups.com" <bazme...@googlegroups.com>; "fareed.si...@gmail.com" <fareed.si...@gmail.com>; "i...@islam.ca" <i...@islam.ca>; "imti...@yahoo.com" <imti...@yahoo.com>; "javed....@aaj.tv" <javed....@aaj.tv>; "masji...@gmail.com" <masji...@gmail.com>; "moder...@yahoo.com" <moder...@yahoo.com>; "nafeesh...@hotmail.com" <nafeesh...@hotmail.com>; "newj...@iamc.com" <newj...@iamc.com>; "nizmo...@gmail.com" <nizmo...@gmail.com>; "pakist...@bellnet.ca" <pakist...@bellnet.ca>; "qasima...@hotmail.com" <qasima...@hotmail.com>; "quranan...@gmail.com" <quranan...@gmail.com>; "rubina...@rogers.com" <rubina...@rogers.com>; Ijaz Sheikh <ijazs...@hotmail.com>; "shakeel_...@yahoo.com" <shakeel_...@yahoo.com>; "ta...@hotmail.com" <ta...@hotmail.com>; "truei...@live.ca" <truei...@live.ca>; "umah...@hotmail.com" <umah...@hotmail.com>; "mike_...@yahoo.com" <mike_...@yahoo.com>; "ibrahim...@gmail.com" <ibrahim...@gmail.com>; "qurananda...@gmail.com" <qurananda...@gmail.com>; "dr.muft...@gmail.com" <dr.muft...@gmail.com>; "min...@yahoo.com" <min...@yahoo.com>; "hassa...@hotmail.com" <hassa...@hotmail.com>; "abida.r...@gmail.com" <abida.r...@gmail.com>; "intif...@gmail.com" <intif...@gmail.com>; "aftabkh...@yahoo.com" <aftabkh...@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, March 11, 2014 1:21 PM
Subject: Re: Hadith vs. Qur'an

And remember that no blasphemy can be committed against a Human-being but Blasphemy can only be committed against GOD.

Unquote: Read TABBAT YADA ABI LAHABINWWATAB, then tell what you learned. Abu leheb committed blasphemy against Rasoolullah Sallallaho A'laihi wa sallam, he and his wife died and both are being cursed by Allah, His messenger, sahabah, and all muslims for centuries and bith would end in jahannam.

On Tuesday, March 11, 2014 9:16 AM, Jon Shah <smj...@hotmail.com> wrote:

Dear brothers who submit to (GOD) ALLAH alone.

One more point to ponder.

Whose status is greater-
Prophet    or    Messenger ?
(Nabi)                   (Rasool)

Prophet is given Scripture
 Messenger is commanded to tell people to follow ALLAH's guidance as per the Scripture.

Why does Quran say to obey ALLAH  and obey the Rasool (Messenger).
Nowhere in the Quran does it say to obey ALLAH and obey Nabi.

Praise be to GOD, Lord of the universe.
Jalal bin Sadiq.
*** This message has been sent using QMobile A10 ***

 Jimmy jamshaid <jimm...@gmail.com> wrote:

You are not a good Muslim if you think "Hadees have not become superior to the Qur'aan"..............they have. Remember "Blasphemy Laws in Pakistan" are to KILL anybody who criticizes Muhammad but NOT to kill anybody who criticizes ALLAH. 

So you decide who is considered superior............Muhammad or Allah. Remember, Governor Salman Taseer was killed for allegedly criticizing inhuman Blasphemy Laws of Pakistan, which forbid criticism of Muhammad but not Allah. Christans worship JESUS instaed of GOD. Same thing.And dirty murderer of ST has been made into a Hero!!! Shameless lot.

And remember that no blasphemy can be committed against a Human-being but Blasphemy can only be committed against GOD.

Mr Fundo Freak Qaseem..........you are deranged & worshipping Humans.Muslims adore & follow HADEES more than the Qur'aan & I am right. So, apologize.

On Mon, Mar 10, 2014 at 12:44 PM, syed Ahmed <qasee...@yahoo.com> wrote:

Yeah,according to your deranged thinking.

On Monday, March 10, 2014 11:00 AM, Jimmy jamshaid <jimm...@gmail.com> wrote:

FYI, during his lifetime Muhammad forbade any "writing of Hadees/Muhammad's deeds & sayings" lest they the Hadith become superior to the Qur'aan, which they have............

On Sun, Mar 9, 2014 at 9:12 PM, Kaukab Siddique <butsh...@gmail.com> wrote:

Iqbal sahib

You wrote:

"One of these innovations is the volumes and volumes of Hadith books written some 200 years after the death of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh). These hadiths are sayings that are attributed to the prophet. There are many hadiths that either contradict the Qur’an or don’t make any sense at all. While these may be some genuine hadiths that don’t contradict the Qur’an, there is no way to prove their authenticity even if the collectors of hadiths may claim "

 

You are not known as  a scholar of hadith.

How did you find this out?

On Fri, Mar 7, 2014 at 12:38 PM, iqbal sheikh <iqbal...@hotmail.com> wrote:

Hadith vs. Qur’an

Does Hadith explain the Qur’an or the Qur’an explains what Hadith is all about? The religion of Islam (Submission) today misunderstood by the world. One reason for this is the fact that for centuries this beautiful religion has been unduly presented to the world through the so-called Muslim people, scholars, and countries that do not act or function in an Islamic manner, according to teaching of the Qur’an. The result of centuries-long ignorance is obvious. Not only has the religion of Islam been given a bad name, but also Muslims all around the world today are suffering the consequences of abandoning the teachings of the Qur’an, in favor of  innovations that have nothing to do with the religion of Islam.

One of these innovations is the volumes and volumes of Hadith books written some 200 years after the death of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh). These hadiths are sayings that are attributed to the prophet. There are many hadiths that either contradict the Qur’an or don’t make any sense at all. While these may be some genuine hadiths that don’t contradict the Qur’an, there is no way to prove their authenticity even if the collectors of hadiths may claim so. Only Allah (SWT) knows what the truth is.

Hadith to Explain the Qur’an!

Some say we need the Hadith to explain the Qur’an because the Qur’an is too difficult to understand. Why do people who find it difficult to understand a single volume of Allah (SWT)’s revelation feel it necessary to refer to 50 volumes of Hadith books for clarification! Would Allah (SWT) revel a message so difficult to understand, yet expect people to follow it?

This does not make sense. Furthermore, Allah (SWT) tells us in the Qur’an many times: “we made the Qur’an easy to learn, does any of you wish to learn?” (54:17, 22, 32, 40). Doesn’t Allah (SWT) know what He is talking about? Doesn’t He know His creatures’ abilities?

It is almost impossible for anyone to go through all the books of Hadith without getting confused and totally lost, especially if the person wants to examine what each different sect has to offer. That's why the so-called Islamic universities offer academic degrees in studying Hadith to raise “learned men” of the religion. These students literally waste their time to learn all the details of living their lives in accordance with the supposed sayings and deeds of the prophet.  

The religious rules and regulations based on such innovations contain and cover literally every aspect of life from walking, eating, laughing, sleeping - almost anything one can think of. The rules such as how to use the bathroom and what to do in there! The details are too gross and shocking to mention.

Appalling Hadiths

There are even grosser sayings and deeds attributed to the prophet regarding his sex life, preferences and sexual desires. Didn’t these so called narrators have anything else to do but peek in the Prophet’s private life? How could such perverse narrators be considered reliable sources of information? These are the type of people who produced such blasphemous and incredible lies against a prophet to Allah (SWT)! More incredible is the hypocrisy of the religious “experts” who supposedly follow these lies out of love and respect for the prophet!

There are also many silly things in written in the books of Hadith such as whether one should drink a glass of water standing or sitting? Why should anyone care? Why are these kinds of  irrelevant details important to some people? Because these people are completely ignorant about the essence of the religion of submission, and thus they think the religion is a bunch of rules and regulations on the petty details of life. They make the religion difficult for themselves while being proud of having difficulties and misery as part of their devotion to their “religion.” Which religion or Allah (SWT) are they devoting themselves to?

It cannot be the same One who clearly stated in the Qur’an that HE made the religion easy for us, that He did not reveal the Qur’an to make things difficult for us (20:2).

Insult to Prophet Muhammad (pbuh)

Indeed, the Hadith books are full of contradictions, subtle or clear insults and  blasphemies to Almighty Allah (SWT) as well as the prophet himself. What kind of a messenger would Muhammad (pbuh) be if he did or said some of the things that were attributed to him?

Muhammad (pbuh) lived by the Qur’an and he was an example for us. Anyone who followed the Qur’an which came through his mouth would not utter such blasphemous or ridiculous sayings. Such sayings, of course, cannot be but plain lies and conjecture. Would Muhammad (pbuh) ever blaspheme against Allah (SWT) say that Allah (SWT) created the heavens and the earth for his sake, and that Allah (SWT)’s throne was made up of his light? Would the prophet ever ask people to praise himself, instead of praising Allah (SWT), the Almighty, when the Qur’an clearly says that all praises belong to Allah (SWT)? Never, ever. This is clearly stated in the following verse:

Never would a human being whom ALLAH (SWT) blessed with the scripture and prophethood way to the people, “Idolize me beside ALLAH (SWT).”

Instead, he would say, “Devote yourselves absolutely to your Allah alone,” according to the scripture you preach and the teachings you learn. (3:79)

Allah (SWT) Does Not Run Out of Words

If Allah (SWT) wanted to be more specific about how we must live our lives, He could have sent down volumes and volumes of revelations on how we should sleep, how we should cook, eat or drink, and which dress we should wear and so on. He surely tells us that if the oceans were ink, and the trees were made into pens, He would not run out of words (31:27). But it is Allah (SWT)’s mercy that He wants us to follow only what He specified in His revelations, and use our common sense, knowledge and wisdom for the rest of the details of life. However people insist on making their lives miserable as their so-called religious leaders and “learned” scholars shackle them with satanic teaching and innovations.

Hadith Exposed in the Qur’an

Allah (SWT) condemns the Hadith by name in the Qur’an, and informs us that it is a blasphemous

fabrication (45:6-7). He says that the Qur’an is one consistent source since it’s His Word. There is no contradiction in it. If it were from other than Allah (SWT), as Hadith books are, they would have found in it numerous contradictions (4:82)

 Hadiths can be useful for historical perspective, but they should not be used for establishing religious practices. Doing so does not mean one dislikes or does not obey the prophet Muhammad (pbuh). On the contrary, it indicates that he or she respects him and Allah (SWT)’s revelations that came through his mouth.

 After all it is Allah (SWT) we are all suppose to please. The Qur’an teaches us that when the judgment day comes and everything is brought forward, the prophet will be disappointed by what has been done to the message that he delivered. He will say, “my people have deserted the Qur’an” (25:30). Therefore, following or upholding baseless Hadiths is something neither Allah (SWT) nor His messengers want us to do:

Among the people, there are those who uphold baseless Hadith, and thus divert others from the path of ALLAH (SWT) without knowledge, and take it in vain. These have incurred a shameful retribution. (31:6)

As a matter of fact, Allah (SWT) and His messengers want us to follow the Word of Allah (SWT) as the only source of religious guidance, otherwise we will end up disputing and dividing ourselves (3:103). The Qur’an is Allah (SWT)’s word in truth and justice; a blessing and beacon for those who want to submit to the Lord of the Universe, the Almighty. It’s Allah (SWT)’s commandment that we should read it from cover to cover (73:4). Are we waiting for somebody to explain Allah (SWT)’s message to us while we can read it for ourselves? Therefore, read what your Creator wants to tell you for your own sake! Read it in a language that you can understand. When Allah (SWT) says that He made the Qur’an easy to learn, He means it.

He is the One who controls the hearts and minds of the people and guides them accordingly (28:56). He is teacher of the Qur’an for those who turn to Him (55:2).

ALLAH (SWT) has revealed herein the best Hadith; a book that is consistent, and points out both ways (to Heaven and Hell). The skins of those who reverence their Lord cringe there from, then their skins and their hearts soften up for Allah (SWT)’s message. Such is Allah (SWT)’s guidance; He bestows it upon whoever wills (to be guided). As for those sent astray by Allah (SWT), Nothing can guide them, (39:23)

Why do they not study the Qur’an carefully? If it were from other than ALLAH (SWT), they would have found in it numerous contradictions. (4:82)

All praises be to Allah (SWT), Lord of the Universe.

 A. Arif

--
Mission of Global-Right-Path is to Educate Muslim Ummah in the light of the Quraan and Authentic Hadeeth, to face all the internal and external challenges, as well as to become a Great Revolutionized Leader to work for Global Revolution to serve the humanity in a balanced way to stabilize the Global World.
http://global-right-path.net16.net
.
Spiritual Doctors are Treating Spiritual Patients, so Please be Patience.
Change yourself according to the Quraan, NOT reverse.
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google
Groups "Global-Right-Path" group.
To post to this group, send email to
global-r...@googlegroups.com
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
global-right-p...@googlegroups.com
For more options, visit this group at
http://groups.google.ca/group/global-right-path
http://global-right-path.net16.net
.
What will be Your Answer, if Allah will Question on the Day-of-Judgment, because of rejecting the Quraanic Messages ?????
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Global-Right-Path" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to global-right-p...@googlegroups.com.
To post to this group, send email to global-r...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

--
Mission of Global-Right-Path is to Educate Muslim Ummah in the light of the Quraan and Authentic Hadeeth, to face all the internal and external challenges, as well as to become a Great Revolutionized Leader to work for Global Revolution to serve the humanity in a balanced way to stabilize the Global World.
http://global-right-path.net16.net
.
Spiritual Doctors are Treating Spiritual Patients, so Please be Patience.
Change yourself according to the Quraan, NOT reverse.
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google
Groups "Global-Right-Path" group.
To post to this group, send email to
global-r...@googlegroups.com
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
global-right-p...@googlegroups.com
For more options, visit this group at
http://groups.google.ca/group/global-right-path
http://global-right-path.net16.net
.
What will be Your Answer, if Allah will Question on the Day-of-Judgment, because of rejecting the Quraanic Messages ?????
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Global-Right-Path" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to global-right-p...@googlegroups.com.
To post to this group, send email to global-r...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

--
Mission of Global-Right-Path is to Educate Muslim Ummah in the light of the Quraan and Authentic Hadeeth, to face all the internal and external challenges, as well as to become a Great Revolutionized Leader to work for Global Revolution to serve the humanity in a balanced way to stabilize the Global World.
http://global-right-path.net16.net
.
Spiritual Doctors are Treating Spiritual Patients, so Please be Patience.
Change yourself according to the Quraan, NOT reverse.
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google
Groups "Global-Right-Path" group.
To post to this group, send email to
global-r...@googlegroups.com
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
global-right-p...@googlegroups.com
For more options, visit this group at
http://groups.google.ca/group/global-right-path
http://global-right-path.net16.net
.
What will be Your Answer, if Allah will Question on the Day-of-Judgment, because of rejecting the Quraanic Messages ?????
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Global-Right-Path" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to global-right-p...@googlegroups.com.
To post to this group, send email to global-r...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

[shakeeluae]

Dear Dr.M.Mukhtar Alam Sb,

Assalamo Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahe Wa Barakatahu. Hope and pray that this mail finds you in the best of health and eiman, insha-Allah! May Allah bless you with good health, lots of wealth, peace, prosperity and happiness!

Your talk of path of moderation with reference to Dr. Shabbir is yet another sign of hypocrisy. Dr. Shabbir is the one who uses abusive language against anyone and everyone of the popular Muslim scholars of the past, who are respected for their hard work, spitting hateful fire against Hadith collectors who shed their sweat and tears through hard work, through scientific methods that cannot be challenged even today. Is this your moderation, or height of hypocrisy, sir? Your boss is the one who is cursing even a reader, calling her mushrik, just because she dares to respond to his abusive and derogatory campaign. This is your moderation, sir!! What a height of hypocrisy, your majesty!! 

May Allah bless you with true success of this world as well as of the hereafter!

----
PS: Actions may not always bring happiness; but there is no happiness without action, so act we MUST.
---------
Wishing you and all your loved ones greatest of times ahead!
Aspiring 2 c u happy!

Shakeel Ahmad
B.Tech (IIT BHU), MBA (XLRI), PMP
Dubai, United Arab Emirates

Remember, growing older is mandatory. Growing up is optional.
 
We make a Living by what we get, we make a Life by what we give.

If you fill your heart with regrets of yesterday and the worries of tomorrow,
you have no today to be thankful for.

On Fri, Mar 21, 2014 at 9:29 PM, DrMuhammad Mukhtar Alam <nafm...@gmail.com> wrote:

Dr Shabbir is not at all evil. Straightjacket characterisations must be avoided. Look here in this news http://www.radianceweekly.com/278/7812/occupy-wall-streetdemonstration-of-the-deprived-of-the-developed-nations/2011-10-30/muslim-world/story-detail/remove-language-targeting-muslims-from-dhs-bills-cair.html

There is a need to ensure some cleansing of the instruction capital that are clearly against the spirit of Qur'aan. Dr Shabbir has denounced the false report on Sayyeda Ayesha. He is not writing against Qur'aan. We can have debates for being on the path of moderation and being the people of the centre NOT belong to the extremes.

Dr.M.Mukhtar Alam  

http://slideshare.net/mukhtaralam

http://transitionurbanindia.ning.com

http://imedaindia.ning.com

http://ecostrategiccommunicators.ning.com

On Fri, Mar 21, 2014 at 10:12 PM, Abida Rahmani <abida.r...@gmail.com> wrote:

Asa br. Shakeel 

It is good that you started a great and knowledgable discussion. Br. Shabbir should reply accordingly.

You are absolutely right that we are contemporary Muslims and fitna is greater than murder.

I hope and pray that we are joined together against evil forces.

Ws,
Abida

--
Sent from Gmail Mobile