Re: Not so, Mr. Paul. 何瑞元曾主張兩個公報意味著台灣島始終必須和平統一﹗ Taiwan was placed on a flight-path for > eventual unification with the PRC

[Dr. Michael Yeun]

Indeed! Some people are still living in 20 century.

On Fri, Jul 15, 2022 at 2:44 AM David Chen <davidch...@hotmail.com> wrote:

沒什麼好辯護的，都已是過時的老東西，請向前看，與時俱進吧！

美國政府在道德上是很虧欠台灣人民的！

---

寄件者: Paul Risenhoover <americanform...@gmail.com>
寄件日期: Friday, July 15, 2022 2:23:34 PM
收件者: Dr. Michael Yeun <drmich...@gmail.com>
副本: Fredrick Jacksson <davidch...@yahoo.com>; Martin Tsai <taiw...@hotmail.com>; Lin Wencheng <wen...@gmail.com>; Freeman Huang <free...@gmail.com>; Key Wu <aki...@verizon.net>; 台灣日報編輯部 <davidy...@gmail.com>; 郭正典 教授 ( Dr. CD Kuo ) <cdk...@gmail.com>; Matsumoto Kuroyuki <lat...@gmail.com>; Johnny Huang PSOS <pso...@gmail.com>; RWH (Taipei <rwh.m...@gmail.com>; Jerome Keating <taiw...@hotmail.com>; Fazen Gaten <gaten...@gmail.com>; 蔡 明法主委 <niec...@yahoo.com>; Chi-yuan Tsai <yuan...@gate.sinica.edu.tw>; 副本： David Chen <davidch...@hotmail.com>; 陳儀深 <c...@gate.sinica.edu.tw>; maysing yang <maysi...@gmail.com>; Coenblaauw <coenb...@aol.com>; Michael Green <mj...@georgetown.edu>; gvand...@gwu.edu <gvand...@gwu.edu>; gvan...@gmu.edu <gvan...@gmu.edu>; ma...@nccu.edu.tw <ma...@nccu.edu.tw>; tsi...@tsil.org.tw <tsi...@tsil.org.tw>; taiwa...@msa.hinet.net <taiwa...@msa.hinet.net>; M-S...@warwick.ac.uk <m-s...@warwick.ac.uk>; wehs...@pchome.com.tw <wehs...@pchome.com.tw>; wc...@ntu.edu.tw <wc...@ntu.edu.tw>; vwch...@nccu.edu.tw <vwch...@nccu.edu.tw>; eusatai...@gmail.com <eusatai...@gmail.com>; sww...@mail.nhu.edu.tw <sww...@mail.nhu.edu.tw>; ishi...@nccu.edu.tw <ishi...@nccu.edu.tw>; isia...@gmail.com <isia...@gmail.com>; is...@ccu.edu.tw <is...@ccu.edu.tw>; t...@tttank.org <t...@tttank.org>; pf...@pf.org.tw <pf...@pf.org.tw>; p...@pf.org.tw <p...@pf.org.tw>; ser...@taef.org <ser...@taef.org>; kuoc...@tmu.edu.tw <kuoc...@tmu.edu.tw>; shi...@ntu.edu.tw <shi...@ntu.edu.tw>; niensh...@gmail.com <niensh...@gmail.com>; maga...@ndu.edu.tw <maga...@ndu.edu.tw>; his...@nccu.edu.tw <his...@nccu.edu.tw>; ww...@nccu.edu.tw <ww...@nccu.edu.tw>; bria...@nccu.edu.tw <bria...@nccu.edu.tw>; fub...@nccu.edu.tw <fub...@nccu.edu.tw>; inds...@indsr.org.tw <inds...@indsr.org.tw>; t...@ketagalan.org.tw <t...@ketagalan.org.tw>; keta...@ketagalan.org.tw <keta...@ketagalan.org.tw>; hcch...@ntu.edu.tw <hcch...@ntu.edu.tw>; 江世雄 <kou...@mail.cpu.edu.tw>; 202002...@gmail.com <202002...@gmail.com>; taiwannewc...@tnc-ref.org.tw <taiwannewc...@tnc-ref.org.tw>; z980...@email.ncku.edu.tw <z980...@email.ncku.edu.tw>; wsh...@mail.ntpu.edu.tw <wsh...@mail.ntpu.edu.tw>; hong.l...@gmail.com <hong.l...@gmail.com>; crl...@dep.pccu.edu.tw <crl...@dep.pccu.edu.tw>; wl...@drnh.gov.tw <wl...@drnh.gov.tw>; 黃育旗 <ps...@ms12.hinet.net>; 張揚聲 <cys...@gmail.com>; sgi091...@yahoo.com.tw <fong...@yahoo.com>; Cheng Kuang Chen <chengku...@gmail.com>; 12311ccm <1231...@gmail.com>; jacktcg8386 <jackt...@gmail.com>; wong lillian <lillia...@gmail.com>; 陳翠屏 <tp12...@gmail.com>; armita chung <hsinc...@gmail.com>; geonomist <geon...@juno.com>; George T. Chang <g25...@gmail.com>; Neng-Hsiang Wang <nhwa...@yahoo.com>; ya bo soong <ybs...@yahoo.com>; Kaichang Chang <kaich...@yahoo.com>; Yao King Hsu <ykin...@yahoo.com>; chuck c hsu <chuck...@gmail.com>; Tze-jer Chuang <j7ch...@yahoo.com>; baker.woods <baker...@msa.hinet.net>; 佐野 由美子 <yumik...@gmail.com>; 何 瑞元 <rgro...@gmail.com>; 吳佳修 <show...@hotmail.com>; 吳 崑松 <bri...@gmail.com>; 呂 經理 <lk...@sbcglobal.net>; 松井 光彥 <licor...@gmail.com>; 林 由里 <54tai...@gmail.com>; 林 州長 <mlian98...@yahoo.com.tw>; 林 志正 <linw...@gmail.com>; 林 彥宏 <fine...@hotmail.com>; 林 義憲 <jack...@hotmail.com>; 林 德名 <ldm25...@gmail.com>; 洪 清森 <alo...@hotmail.com.tw>; 海洋 聽眾 <alx...@ms51.hinet.net>; 張 文彥 <prof...@gmail.com>; 張 啟中 <fu...@ms39.hinet.net>; 張 晴輝 <tchan...@aol.com>; 張德昭 <fafa...@gmail.com>; 連 平原 <ufli...@ms13.hinet.net>; 野口 一 <n-...@dream.ocn.ne.jp>; 陳 乃琪 <dell...@yahoo.com.tw>; 陳 秀琴 <mama1009...@yahoo.com.tw>; Yny...@aol.com <yny...@aol.com>; moe.fukada <moe.f...@yahoo.com>; kimjj <ki...@state.gov>; Jolan Hsieh <jolan....@gmail.com>; 蔣為文 <uib...@gmail.com>; 洪銘婉 <pehl...@gmail.com>; 基金會凱達格蘭 <abian...@gmail.com>; Taiwan Government <taiwangov...@gmail.com>; Allen Kuo <alle...@timebyte.com>; Moy, Kin W <mo...@state.gov>; John 2 Hsieh <john.hs...@statefarm.com>; Keiko Huang <keik...@yahoo.com>; 55三興 陳 <khhto...@yahoo.com.tw>; bhsieh2000 <bhsie...@yahoo.com>; nick.wu <nic...@sbcglobal.net>; home <ho...@fapa.org>; Thomas Ho <tombe...@yahoo.com.tw>; 曹長青 <cao...@gmail.com>; 蔡丁貴 <tkt...@ntu.edu.tw>; eastgateschool <eastgat...@aol.com>; gary5311125 <gary5...@gmail.com>; Michael Turton <tur...@yahoo.com>; David Taka Yang <formo...@gmail.com>; Mattel Hsu <matte...@gmail.com>; Gerrit van der Wees <ger...@fapa.org>; Kuochih Hong <kuoh...@yahoo.com>; 拉生 吳 <las...@yahoo.com.tw>; D.N. Chou <dnc...@gmail.com>; Kuo Victoria <victori...@hotmail.com>; 謝錫安 <unclege...@gmail.com>; ilovefomosa <ilove...@yahoo.com.tw>; 53 <sl...@schlin.com>; Daiwan <dai...@seed.net.tw>; kuangtsai <kuan...@hotmail.com>; Ayien Lee <ayien...@gmail.com>; 王太太 <bevery2...@gmail.com>; 盧怡蓉 <julio...@gmail.com>; lasvegaskuan <lasveg...@aol.com>; ysd <y...@ms16.hinet.net>; 謝德謙 <tekk...@gmail.com>; 蔡 照益 <syou...@yahoo.com.tw>; 35 <hhs...@yahoo.com>; Akamatsu Saburo <tch...@gmail.com>; Michael J. Fonte <michae...@mac.com>; tejen2000 <teje...@yahoo.com>; 奈 津子 <nan...@wm.pdx.ne.jp>; 林 永成 <yc...@ntc.com.tw>; 張 德昭 <fafa...@yahoo.com.tw>; stantonwa <stan...@state.gov>; mattel <mat...@mail2000.com.tw>; DPP 國際事務部 <dppfo...@gmail.com>; 蔡英文 主席 ( DPP ) <chair...@dpp.org.tw>; 管碧玲 委員 ( DPP ) <kuanb...@gmail.com>; uibunoffice <uibun...@gmail.com>; uibuntw <uib...@yahoo.com.tw>; jasonpan <jaso...@mail2000.com.tw>; 潘 Jason <jason...@yahoo.ca>; omass123 <omas...@hotmail.com>; 凱達格蘭工作室 <keta....@msa.hinet.net>; 果真Selika <sov...@gmail.com>; 老 塵 <eleg...@hotmail.com>; 洪茂雄 <hu...@nccu.edu.tw>; abc093...@gmail.com <abc093...@gmail.com>; 77972592 <a7797...@gmail.com>; 081...@mail.fju.edu.tw <081...@mail.fju.edu.tw>; omi...@hotmail.com <omi...@hotmail.com>; Peng Dennis 彭文正李晶玉 <youma...@gmail.com>; oushush6 <oush...@aol.com>; klc...@ntu.edu.tw <klc...@ntu.edu.tw>; lhs...@gmail.com <lhs...@gmail.com>; denny.ko <denn...@gmail.com>; lindacyliu <linda...@gmail.com>; Raymond Chuang <raysc...@gmail.com>; ad hoc itic <itic....@gmail.com>; luby liao gmail <luby...@gmail.com>; secu...@ms75.hinet.net <secu...@ms75.hinet.net>; yclin38 <ycl...@yahoo.com.tw>; choujenny <chou...@comcast.net>; pcychow2011 <pcych...@hotmail.com>; 林月輝 <tcg...@gmail.com>; Patrick Huang <pathu...@aol.com>; Tcg Washington <respect...@gmail.com>; huashanchi <huash...@aol.com>; peter lin <tcg...@gmail.com>; khin...@gmail.com <khin...@gmail.com>; estherec.chen <esther...@yahoo.com>; 王豐琢 <taiwana...@aol.com>; hue...@gmail.com <hue...@gmail.com>; mcwe...@yahoo.com.tw <mcwe...@yahoo.com.tw>,ban...@hotmail.com <mcwe...@yahoo.com.tw>; mcwe...@yahoo.com.tw <mcwe...@yahoo.com.tw>,ban...@hotmail.com <ban...@hotmail.com>; awi...@gms.ndhu.edu.tw <awi...@gms.ndhu.edu.tw>; banhuakun tcg <tcg.ba...@gmail.com>; 宛儒 <flylook...@gmail.com>; yongsh...@yahoo.com.tw <yongsh...@yahoo.com.tw>; y0933...@yahoo.com.tw <y0933...@yahoo.com.tw>; Taitzer Wang <tai...@gmail.com>; aa0970...@gmail.com <aa0970...@gmail.com>; r0928...@yahoo.com.tw <r0928...@yahoo.com.tw>; Hwan Lin <hwa...@gmail.com>; tienchiaohsieh <tienchi...@gmail.com>; tcg...@gmail.com <tcg...@gmail.com>; hongch...@gmail.com <hongch...@gmail.com>; sgi091...@yahoo.com.tw <sgi091...@yahoo.com.tw>; 0472209...@gmail.com <0472209...@gmail.com>; 杜袓健 <atu...@gmail.com>; 黃 Jay (Irvine) <jayhua...@gmail.com>; BATA Editor <edito...@gmail.com>; YT Lee <yt...@gate.sinica.edu.tw>; a0982...@gmail.com <a0982...@gmail.com>; moz...@hotmail.com <moz...@hotmail.com>; Lisa Shih <shwu...@gmail.com>; pheinc650 <phei...@yahoo.com>; Tony Coolidge <taiwanc...@gmail.com>; ic6...@yahoo.com.tw <ic6...@yahoo.com.tw>; John Hsieh <jckh...@gmail.com>; yin...@gmail.com <yin...@gmail.com>; 弓又 <le...@me.com>; cy...@sinica.edu.tw <cy...@sinica.edu.tw>; jmc...@mail.cjcu.edu.tw <jmc...@mail.cjcu.edu.tw>; ydshaw4016 <ydsha...@yahoo.com.tw>; grace103054 <grace...@gmail.com>; 張素梅 <cha...@ntu.edu.tw>; ngchuu...@msa.hinet.net <ngchuu...@msa.hinet.net>; Sandy Hsu <akik...@gmail.com>; pk7...@yahoo.com.tw <pk7...@yahoo.com.tw>; jungtsai <jung...@yahoo.com>; tgusa gov <tgus...@gmail.com>; Ingtek/張英哲 <ing...@gmail.com>; taispa...@gmail.com <taispa...@gmail.com>; Slin1231 <slin...@gmail.com>; kents...@gmail.com <kents...@gmail.com>; samue...@gmail.com <samue...@gmail.com>; Steve / Jenne Huang <shua...@yahoo.com>; 鄭川如 <087...@mail.fju.edu.tw>; 王仕賢 <tcg...@gmail.com>; paloma8794 <palom...@gmail.com>; ngti...@yahoo.com.tw <ngti...@yahoo.com.tw>; Nancy TCG <nicena...@gmail.com>; HonTiong d <hont...@mail.pct.org.tw>; clt19...@gmail.com <clt19...@gmail.com>; t11...@ntnu.edu.tw <t11...@ntnu.edu.tw>; Brian Chee-Shing Hioe <bch...@columbia.edu>; jiishieh <jiis...@yahoo.com>; tff...@gmail.com <tff...@gmail.com>; adol...@yahoo.com.tw <adol...@yahoo.com.tw>; bay-area-taiwanese-american <bay-area-taiw...@googlegroups.com>; PAUL HUANG <rich...@flash.net>; Hwan Lin <hw...@uncc.edu>; Jim Hwang <jimh...@infelligent.com>; jim.lillychen <jim.li...@gmail.com>; jim lee <jimle...@gmail.com>; Larson, Ingrid D <lars...@state.gov>; Mark Wuebbels <wuebb...@state.gov>; Moriarty, James F <moria...@state.gov>; Sea-Shon Chen <200...@gmail.com>; huang.s...@gmail.com <huang.s...@gmail.com>
主旨: Re: Not so, Mr. Paul. 何瑞元曾主張兩個公報意味著台灣島始終必須和平統一﹗ Taiwan was placed on a flight-path for > eventual unification with the PRC

 

Was Dr. Yeun present in the meeting at the Lawyer Chang Law Offices in Taipei ?

Of course it is the US president, and indeed under the Constitution he has plenary power over foreign affairs.   https://www.taipeitimes.com/News/editorials/archives/2005/03/19/2003246919

Reference is made to William E. Birkhimer, Military Government and Martial Law, 3rd edition (1914), Chapter IX "Laws Obligatory Within Occupied Territory," Section 141 "Plenary power, appoint war courts, judicially settled:"

Thus it has been solemnly determined that the authority of the President, and of commanders under him, for the establishment of courts in conquered territory is complete, limited only by the exigencies of service and the laws of war;  https://www.taiwanbasic.com/key/dc/fm2710p366.htm

unification does not necessarily entail prior shared sovereignty, as one might surmise would be needed for reunification... 

the US war planners thought that Taiwanese and Fukienese shared much in common culturally, linguistically, in religion... and those provide a solid basis for

popular sovereignty to lead to unification... 

Formosa has been under Japanese sovereignty for half a century. Although technically all Formosans, therefore, are enemy nationals, the State Department looks upon the Chinese Formosans and the Formosan aborigines as quite apart from the persons of Japanese blood who live on the island. It anticipates that the Military Governor will act generally on the assumption that the Chinese Formosans, who speak Chinese and are of Chinese or of mixed Chinese and aborigine origin, are to be restored to Chinese citizenship after the war, and that the tribal aborigines, who are akin to the non-Christian peoples of Northern Luzon, are neither Japanese nor Chinese, but more properly to be considered as wards of whatever government has control of the island.

The Marshall, Caroline and Marianas Islands, on the other hand, have been held by Japan only under mandate and the natives of these islands have never become Japanese nationals. They should be treated as wards of the military government. A number of Koreans may be found in the islands. If so, special consideration should be given them.

https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1944v05/d1208

As the Lawyerchang Law Offices, Hartzell repeatedly said that Hartzell personally believed that the two Communiques mean that Taiwan must and shall ultimately reunite with China, the PRC.

As the basis for his theory, he suggested that the President of the United States unilaterally controls American foreign affairs through what lawyers and Mr. Hartzell

correctly called "plenary powers". That means the President's One China "policy" would trump the Taiwan Relations Act, in the event that the Act contradicted the President's

plenary control over foreign affairs.

Hartzell explained his cogent theory in depth and with conviction.

"Of course it is the US president, and indeed under the Constitution he has plenary power over foreign affairs."  https://www.taipeitimes.com/News/editorials/archives/2005/03/19/2003246919

主張 does not mean strongly advocate, it merely means to hold a position. 政策主張 such as a policy position

or articulate a claim at law 原告主張

主張或陳述  

公務員懲戒委員會 107 年度 再 字第 2118 號公懲判決

臺灣高等法院 110 年度 矚上訴 字第 3 號刑事判決（143K）	111.05.13	國家安全法
	...政黨局」局長王育文對其表示支持之意，然衡諸被告甲○○、丁○○、戊○○之政治理念係主張兩岸統一，業經其等供陳在卷，則其等因政治理念及主張而與大陸地區人士親近友好，且易受到大陸地區有相同目標之人之支持甚或取得優惠資源，不難理解，但苟無具體事證相佐，尚不能以此逕予推認被...

讓主張統一族群，進入議會！ 反制台獨詐騙集團！ 臺灣高等法院 110 年度 選上訴 字第 2 號刑事判決

「被告刊登內容及自訴人相關主張整理」欄等偏激用語 臺灣臺北地方法院 110 年度 自 字第 49 號刑事判決

是追加起訴書主張此部分  臺灣臺北地方法院 108 年度 訴 字第 866 號刑事判決

臺灣臺北地方法院 107 年度 矚重訴 字第 1 號刑事判決（128K）	110.04.28	國家安全法
	...使人民有抉擇的權利，以奠基自由民主原則。而衡酌目前大陸地區之中共政權與我中華民國呈現敵對狀態，迄今，中共政權並未放棄「武力統一」之主張，在此局勢嚴峻之客觀環境下，自不容有人利用自由作為工具而攻擊民主的基礎

臺灣高等法院 109 年度 上易 字第 2126 號刑事判決（19K）	110.02.09	妨害名譽
	...足以破壞憲法所保障之基本權，依憲法第23條規定，自應予合理之限制，否則無異假言論自由之名，行惡意侮辱之實者，即有處罰之正當性，自難主張免責。（二）查： 1、被告與告訴人均為社群網站臉書社團「國防醫學院校友會」成員，其於108年1月30日因對於時任總統蔡英文言談內容

臺灣臺南地方法院 109 年度 選訴 字第 2 號刑事判決（32K）	109.12.29	違反公職人員選舉罷免法等
	...本院第378頁），足見被告系爭言論質疑代表中國國民黨參選第10屆臺南市第1選舉區立法委員之告訴人，亦有可能與同政黨之政治人物相同，主張兩岸關係應採取「九二共識」、「一國兩制」之說法，係有所本，揆諸前開說明，其所為即不具有真實惡意。④又衡酌候選人之政黨、政治理念、行...

臺灣新北地方法院 109 年度 訴 字第 52 號刑事判決（46K）	109.10.14	國家安全法
	...為適法（最高法院108 年度台上字第2669號判決意旨可資參照）。經查，被告之辯護人固爭執證人蔡良宗因調查員施以利誘之不正方法，而主張不具證據能力，且此不正詢問之效力延續至檢察官之訊問時云云。然而：㈠、據證人蔡良宗於調查局詢問時證稱：伊自從106 年1 月6 日被...

臺灣高等法院 高雄分院 109 年度 上訴 字第 121 號刑事判決（81K）	109.05.13	國家安全法
	...機關，下設聯絡局、調查研究局、邊防局及對外宣傳局等單位，主要負責進行調查研究外國軍隊政治情況、對台宣傳關於一國兩制、和平統一之政策主張、與敵對勢力的心戰策反陰謀活動、瓦解敵軍等工作。總政在上海市設有分局，以上海市人民政府第七辦公室（下稱上海第七辦公室）名義對外進行...

臺灣臺北地方法院 102 年度 易 字第 647 號刑事判決（41K）	104.05.08	妨害名譽等
	...告訴人張清溪亦非註冊法輪功商標與團體標章之人，益徵前述對於法輪功之批評，並不涉及告訴人張清溪個人權利甚明。是告訴人擴張其代表範圍，主張臺灣地區涉及法輪功事項均與渠等有關，實難憑採。

智慧財產法院 102 年度 民著訴 字第 53 號民事判決（34K）	103.04.17	侵害著作權有關財產權爭議等
	...條所定之比例原則（司法院釋字第 656 號解釋理由書參照）。（二）本件原告雖主張因被告侵害其著作人格權，而聲請將本判決書主文及原告主張之侵權事實內容，刊載於聯合報及蘋果日報全國版第 1 版下半頁一日。惟查，被告二人因過失而為本件侵害著作權之行為，侵害情節尚非重大，

On Fri, 15 Jul 2022 at 11:29, Dr. Michael Yeun <drmich...@gmail.com> wrote:

Paul Risenhoover wrote: 何瑞元曾主張中華人民共和國中央人民政府才是台灣島唯一合法政府，由兩個公報視........

No sir, Mr. Paul.

主張 in Mandarin Chinese means ADVOCATE STRONGLY in English, doesn't it? It seems that you have taken it from this section, "Taiwan was placed on a flight-path for eventual unification with the PRC. This can be viewed as a civil affairs agreement under the law of occupation and establishes the PRC as the legal government of Formosa and the Pescadores.? (See Note #2) 

I do not see how he advocates 中華人民共和國中央人民政府才是台灣島唯一合法政府. He was merely expressing his point of view regarding to the so-called "civil affairs agreement" and others.

Formosa was never part of China. Formosa was annexed by those foreign "Chinese" nations of Chin, but "legally transferred" to the Japanese Empire. Eventually, "illegally annexed" by the ROC-in-exile with help from the USA. Where did the "unification" come from, or will the "unification" take place?  

Michael Yeun

On Thu, Jul 14, 2022 at 2:21 AM Paul Risenhoover <americanform...@gmail.com> wrote:

何瑞元曾主張中華人民共和國中央人民政府才是台灣島唯一合法政府，由兩個公報視
為民事委任事宜，導致中共才是“台灣民政府”﹗﹖﹗ CIVIL AFFAIRS AGREEMENT
(但事實上美國二戰其間一直拒絕給予中華民國一份戰勝佔領區之民事委任政府協議，
參照國務院公開外交歷史資料手冊FRUS  https://history.state.gov/search?q=china+AND+%22civil+affairs+agreement%22&within=documents&sort-by=relevance  

16. Brig. Gen. George H. Olmsted, Civil Affairs Officer, China Theater.↩
17. In a report by the Joint Civil Affairs Committee of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, J. C. S. 999/5, September 10, 1945, it was concluded that, from a military point of view, a civil affairs agreement with the Chinese was not necessary; General Wedemeyer concurred. (Marshall mission files, lot 54–D270).)

何瑞元曾主張兩個公報意味著台灣島始終必須和平統一﹗ Taiwan was placed on a
flight-path for
>       eventual unification with the PRC

   This can be viewed as a civil affairs agreement under the law of
>       occupation and establishes the PRC as the legal government of
Formosa
>       and the Pescadores.? (See Note #2)

 As of February 1972, the viewpoint of the US government regarding
>       Taiwan's final political status changed from "undetermined" to "a
part
>
>       of China." In other words, Taiwan was placed on a flight-path for
>       eventual unification with the PRC. However the timetable for this
was
>       not specified, and was left up to negotiations between the
Taiwanese
>       and the PRC authorities. Hence, some persons would say that with
the
>       Shanghai Communique and the recognition of the One China Policy,
the
>       final political status of Taiwan appears to have changed. In fact,
>       whether "determined but unimplemented" is strictly equal to
>       "undetermined" is something for political analysts to discuss.
>
>       www.taiwanadvice.com/six/epage4.htm

My conclusion remains that Taiwan actually qualifies as US
>       "unincorporated territory" as of the ratification date of the SFPT
on
>       April 28, 1952. The sovereignty of Taiwan is currently held by the
>       United States.
>
>       www.3q2u.com/archives/2004/02/19/000343.php