Re: SLP of Punjab & Sind Bank stands dismissed

[Ramesh Sehgal]

Dear Sir,

When Banks are not taking cognizance of the Judgements of Hon'ble Supreme Court, then to know about such Judgement is just mental satisfaction.

Our leaders should get power from such Judgements of Hon'ble Supreme Court and help the hapless compulsorily retired officers for getting them their legitimate retiral dues.

Hope against hopes.

R K Sehgal

91-9990217028, sehgal...@yahoo.com

---

From: K. R. Narayanan <krnaray...@gmail.com>
To: Jaya Kumar <jk9759_...@yahoo.com>; ccjagad <ccj...@gmail.com>; pad_1948 <pad_...@yahoo.com>; srinivas Desai <desa...@gmail.com>; Ramesh Sehgal <sehgal...@yahoo.com>; vishwanath.shet <vishwan...@yahoo.com>; Subraya Padanthaya <msp...@gmail.com>; rangas...@yahoo.com
Sent: Saturday, 23 April 2016 3:37 PM
Subject: Re: SLP of Punjab & Sind Bank stands dismissed

forwarding a mail received from CBROA for information REGARDS   NARAYANAN 9909023665

On Sat, Apr 23, 2016 at 12:32 PM, Canara Bank Retired Officers' Association <cbro...@gmail.com> wrote:

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: aiabpara. maharashtra <aiabparam...@gmail.com>
Date: Sat, Apr 23, 2016 at 6:39 AM
Subject: Fwd: SLP of Punjab & Sind Bank stands dismissed
To: kskr...@yahoo.co.in, Chandrakant Bhaiwal <ckbh...@yahoo.com>, narayan...@rediffmail.com, scsin...@yahoo.co.in, "Trichur A. Vaidyanathan" <tav...@gmail.com>, prakash sethiya <pmse...@gmail.com>, erh...@yahoo.co.in, uma sharma <sharm...@gmail.com>, Anuradha Cowlagi <anucowl...@gmail.com>, Juliet Dsouza <sou...@gmail.com>, babari...@yahoo.com, Kishor Kankaria <kankari...@gmail.com>, ashish soman <ashis...@gmail.com>, Ajit Shetye <ajitsh...@gmail.com>, Pradeep Choudhary <pkch...@gmail.com>, kpm...@hotmail.com, Vilas Puranik <vppur...@gmail.com>, shriram amberkar <shriram...@gmail.com>, Vijay Patil <vdp...@yahoo.com>, sat...@gmail.com, Prabhakar koshe <koshepr...@gmail.com>, Mangesh Pisat <mm.p...@gmail.com>, vilasve...@yahoo.com, arun_...@hotmail.com, Morvine dsouza <morvin...@gmail.com>, meh...@rediffmail.com, Sushant Cowlagi <sushi1...@gmail.com>, Vinay P <vin...@gmail.com>, vmtha...@gmail.com, pkank...@gmail.com, Vasudev Hegde <hbf...@gmail.com>, Natarajan N <natara...@gmail.com>, Natarajan Subramanian <nat...@yahoo.com>, jpgup...@gmail.com, amarjit singh dhingra <dhingra...@rediffmail.com>, Nilesh Thorat <nilesh...@gmail.com>, mbp...@yahoo.co.in, Dnyandev Ghule <dnya...@gmail.com>, sudhir khanolkar <sudhirmk...@gmail.com>, opgup...@yahoo.com, sbsm...@yahoo.com, mahade...@yahoo.co.in, nalin...@yahoo.co.in, nalin...@gmail.com, lad....@rediffmail.com, rkm1...@yahoo.com, vijay...@sunlife.com, anjana desai <ad25...@yahoo.co.in>, Sushma Nerurkar <sushma....@gmail.com>, malpeka...@yahoo.co.in, Pratibha Dange <pratib...@yahoo.com>, anjali...@hotmail.com, bvra...@yahoo.co.in, madhav...@yahoo.com, karunat...@gmail.com, valuer...@gmail.com, madhus...@hotmail.com, krna...@gmail.com, snatr...@gmail.com, sham...@yahoo.com, ks_o...@yahoo.com, Zarina Shaikh <sheikh...@gmail.com>, anirudd...@gmail.com, Pratibha Salvekar <pratibhas...@gmail.com>, savita raykar <savita...@gmail.com>, Balkrishna Nayak <bana...@gmail.com>, shala...@rediffmail.com, Nagaraj R <rajsri...@gmail.com>, Venkatramani Krishnamurthy <kvram...@gmail.com>, afbh...@tata.com, rbhattac...@yahoo.com, nayak...@yahoo.com, MANISHA SHAH <macwe...@hotmail.com>, suha...@rocketmail.com, subhash...@yahoo.co.in, pb...@yahoo.com, Ghanshyam Rajiwadekar <srajiw...@gmail.com>, Vinod Hemdev <vinod...@gmail.com>, dham...@yahoo.com, John Louis <johnlo...@gmail.com>, K S Sastry <kssa...@hotmail.com>, Kalpana Powale <powale...@gmail.com>, Chitra Vartak <chitra...@gmail.com>, sudh...@rediffmail.com, har...@yahoo.com, Lalitha Shankar <lalithash...@gmail.com>, Anand Mahadkar <mahad...@gmail.com>, PRITI NABAR <pritin...@gmail.com>, Godfrey Misquitta <gmisq...@gmail.com>, sujatas...@yahoo.in, ganesannat...@yahoo.com, Dattatraya Naik <naik...@gmail.com>, mul...@yahoo.com, ARUN DEOJI <arun...@yahoo.in>, Anjana Nalawade <anjanana...@gmail.com>, Asmita Pawar <asmita...@gmail.com>, Pournima Mainkar <pournima...@gmail.com>, Anil Dhamankar <aniljay...@yahoo.co.in>, Anita Kadegaonkar <anitakad...@gmail.com>, suja...@yahoo.co.in, Varun Verma <capta...@yahoo.co.in>, meena nayak <meena...@gmail.com>, Vimla Rose <maa...@gmail.com>, Asmita Dev <asmi...@gmail.com>, Vijay Sarfare <vijaysar...@gmail.com>, akgup...@yahoo.in, pervez patel <patel....@gmail.com>, Vilas khamborkar <khambor...@gmail.com>, bv...@yahoo.com, kgb...@gmail.com, khare_...@yahoo.co.in, Hemant Koul <hemant...@gmail.com>, kher...@gmail.com, Shishir Kunder <kunder...@yahoo.com>, Amarnath Agarwal <amar.ag...@gmail.com>, Jayashree Bondre <bondre.j...@gmail.com>, p.a.ve...@hotmail.com, kishin kundnani <kish...@gmail.com>, sulbha jayade <sulb...@yahoo.co.in>, kaver...@gmail.com, Mohan Chougule <mohan.c...@gmail.com>, Ganesh Sonavane <ganesha...@gmail.com>, Meenal Sule <meena...@gmail.com>, Savita Mattey <savita...@gmail.com>, Mithilesh Kumar <kumarmit...@gmail.com>, Bikash Lal Ghosh <bikashl...@gmail.com>, Vinayak Patil <vina...@gmail.com>, rajend...@yahoo.com, Bhanudas Joshi <josh...@gmail.com>, Kashmira Sidhwa <kas...@gmail.com>, pmah...@yahoo.com, Shilendra Kumar bhardwaj <bhard...@hotmail.com>, b_chh...@yahoo.com, legal...@rediffmail.com, jamb...@yahoo.co.in, Nityanand Singh <Singh...@gmail.com>, krishna...@rediffmail.com, dsde...@gmail.com, Bhaskar Iyer <iyer.b...@gmail.com>, Kuresh Motiwala <ksp...@gmail.com>

MUMBAI, MAIL NO. 2016/

41OF 23.04.2016

CAMP: SAN FRANCISCO (U.S.A.)

​GOOD NEWS TO ALL CRS BANK EMPLOYEES​

​DEAR FRIENDS,​

SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION filed  by Punjab & Sind Bank in Supreme Court against pension option to CRS retirees stand dismissed by the Supreme Court

​ as per the Supreme Court Order attached.​

Copy of judgement is posted below...

​...................​

Now let us hope that CRS

​Bank ​

employees will get justice soon by extending second/another pension option to them, which was denied on account of 9th bipartite settlement/agreement.

​Let us also hope that Bank Resignees and all left out Bank employees will also get justice by extension of pension option to them at the earliest by upholding principles of natural justice and equity.​

​with best wishes​

​, ​

[Ramesh Sehgal]

Dear All,

It is a good heartening news that Hon'ble Supreme Court has dismissed the SLP filed by Punjab & Sind Bank and thus Compulsorily Retired Officer, Mr Surinderjit Singh, is entitled for retiral dues such as Pension, Leave Encashment, etc.

It is hereby mentioned that Canara Bank has filed three SLPs ( C ) No 28315, 26623 & 30252 of year 2011 and Hon'ble Supreme Court on 25th Aug, 2015 has dismissed all these three SLPs of Canara Bank along with three other SLPs of OBC, PNB and Syndicate Bank and the Judgement of Hon'ble Supreme Court has made the Compulsorily Retired Officers entitled for payment of retiral dues such as Pension and Leave Encashment, etc.

But the Banks are not taking cognizance of these Judgements and are not deciding for payment of retiral dues to the Compulsorily Retired Officers in the similar placed cases. 

Thus the concerned General Managers, Executive Directors and CMDs of the banks be blamed for contempt of Orders of Hon'ble Supreme Court. They should be charge-sheeted and given the punishment of Compulsory Retirement. Then they will realise the pains of the sufferings of the Compulsorily Retired Officers who are struggling to get payment of their legitimate retiral dues for such a long time.

In my case I am struggling to get payment of my retiral dues for last more than seven years. I have come to know that one Mr K R Narayanan is suffering to get his retiral dues even for more number of years as he is around 70 years now and has not got his legitimate retiral dues. There are many others like Mr PNP Haran, who are yet to receive their legitimae retiral dues.

Non payment of retiral dues have put these compulsorily retired officers in many untold financial, mental and social sufferings. They are not in a position of living a dignified life. When these officers have worked for their respective beloved banks and for some mis-doings/lapse, they have been placed under Compulsory Retirement, they have got one punishment. Now they are going through undecided other punishment of not getting the payment of their respective legitimate retiral dues. Non payment of their retiral dues have made them to live a life of neglected person in the society.

This is against the Natural Justice.

Their should be pragmatic and humanitarian approach and the already suffering compulsorily retired officers should not be dragged to other problems.

If the payment of retiral dues are not received during the life time, then what is the use if such payments are made after the extinguishment of that hapless retired officer. 

Will the concerned authorities in the banks, leaders of the retirees associations/unions look into cases of compulsorily retired officers ON PRIORITY and take action that legitimate retiral dues are paid to the concerned retired officers without any inadequate delays.

Hope good sense will prevail upon on the concerned and we, the hapless compulsorily retired officers will get redressal of our grievances and will get payments of our legitimate retiral dues.

R K Sehgal, 91-9990217028, sehgal...@yahoo.com

--
Visit our blog site http:://bankpensioner.blogspot.com
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "bankpensioner" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to bankpensione...@googlegroups.com.
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/bankpensioner.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

[K V Venkataramana]

Dear Sri Sehgal,

Please forward copies of your grievances to PMO and FM. I feel this is sheer injustice done to CRS employees by IBA/UFBU.

Regards,

K V Venkataramana

--

K V Venkataramana

[R.K. Pathak]

Mr. Vora,

I think you have forgotten to mention about my advice and providing the pension payment proof of Andhra Bank resignee to you, which led to favourable order in favour of Petitioner. The idea of filing Caveat was also given by me.

Regards

Pathak R K

On Sunday 24 April 2016, virander vora <vkv...@gmail.com> wrote:

Mr Bhullar
May i correct you in what you have said.
This is not the first SLP to be dismissed by Hon SC.In Jan 2015,  2 review petitions filed by Andhra Bank bearing No 34889, 35449 of 2013 were dismissed by Hon SC.
I regret to point out that except for writing couple of formal letters, none of the unions have pursued the matter with IBA.
Had it been taken in all seriousness by retiree organisations and more particularly by UFBU,the matter would have been settled by now.
I don't know whether you know Mr Surenderjit or not but i know him very well. He is a poor man struggling to meet both ends. I arranged for filing of his caveat both in HC and SC,which has resulted in quick decision of his case.
I trust at least now you people will come forward to help other similarly placed officers to get their legitimate dues.
Regards
Vohra  

On Apr 24, 2016 6:23 PM, "K B Ballur" <ball...@gmail.com> wrote:

Dear Sri Sehgal Sir,

We have gone through your correspondence which reflects the anger, anguish you are having for the inordinate delay in  getting an option for pension. Immediately after getting the text of the Supreme Court order against the SLP filed by the Management of Punjab 7 SIndh Bank, we have taken up the issue with our Management. As the Supreme Court judgement is petitioner specific our Bank has written to IBA about the implications of the judgement. You are aware of the fact that every bank will act on the advice of IBA in such matters. We are awaiting the response of the heartless IBA.In the meanwhile, our apex organisation AIBPARC is pursuing the matter with IBA. We have prevailed upon the leadership of AIBOC also to mount presuure on IBA in the background of the Supreme Court setting aside the SLP of P&S Bank against the orders of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana High Court.

We are following up the matter with all seriousness and we will keep you informed of the further developments. Kindly bear with us for some more time.

With best wishes and regards.

Yours sincerely,

K B Ballur

General Secretary

On Sun, Apr 24, 2016 at 9:27 AM, Ramesh Sehgal <sehgal...@yahoo.com> wrote:

Dear All,

It is a good heartening news that Hon'ble Supreme Court has dismissed the SLP filed by Punjab & Sind Bank and thus Compulsorily Retired Officer, Mr Surinderjit Singh, is entitled for retiral dues such as Pension, Leave Encashment, etc.

It is hereby mentioned that Canara Bank has filed three SLPs ( C ) No 28315, 26623 & 30252 of year 2011 and Hon'ble Supreme Court on 25th Aug, 2015 has dismissed all these three SLPs of Canara Bank along with three other SLPs of OBC, PNB and Syndicate Bank and the Judgement of Hon'ble Supreme Court has made the Compulsorily Retired Officers entitled for payment of retiral dues such as Pension and Leave Encashment, etc.

But the Banks are not taking cognizance of these Judgements and are not deciding for payment of retiral dues to the Compulsorily Retired Officers in the similar placed cases. 

Thus the concerned General Managers, Executive Directors and CMDs of the banks be blamed for contempt of Orders of Hon'ble Supreme Court. They should be charge-sheeted and given the punishment of Compulsory Retirement. Then they will realise the pains of the sufferings of the Compulsorily Retired Officers who are struggling to get payment of their legitimate retiral dues for such a long time, when these compulsorily retired General Managers, Executive Directors and CMDs of banks do not get their retiral dues for such considerable time.

In my case I am struggling to get payment of my retiral dues for last more than seven years. I have come to know that one Mr K R Narayanan is suffering to get his retiral dues even for more number of years as he is around 70 years now and has not got his legitimate retiral dues. There are many others like Mr PNP Haran, Mr Virendra Chhabra, ect who are yet to receive their legitimate retiral dues.

Non payment of retiral dues have put these compulsorily retired officers in many untold financial, mental and social sufferings. They are not in a position of living a dignified life. When these officers have worked for their respective beloved banks and for some mis-doings/lapse, they have been placed under Compulsory Retirement, they have got one punishment. Now they are going through undecided other punishment of not getting the payment of their respective legitimate retiral dues. Non payment of their retiral dues have made them to live a life of neglected person in the society.

This is against the Natural Justice.

Their should be pragmatic and humanitarian approach and the already suffering compulsorily retired officers should not be dragged to other problems.

If the payment of retiral dues are not received during the life time, then what is the use if such payments are made after the extinguishment of that hapless retired officer. 

Will the concerned authorities in the banks, leaders of the retirees associations/unions look into cases of compulsorily retired officers ON PRIORITY and take action that legitimate retiral dues are paid to the concerned retired officers without any inadequate delays.

Hope good sense will prevail upon on the concerned and we, the hapless compulsorily retired officers will get redressal of our grievances and will get payments of our legitimate retiral dues.

R K Sehgal, 91-9990217028, sehgal...@yahoo.com

---

MUMBAI, MAIL NO. 2016/

[R.K. Pathak]

[virander vora]

Yes Pathakji I acknowledge that it was on account of your guidance that we filed the caveat.
I am thankful to you.
Regards
Vohra

[L S RAMAN]

This again an evidence to ahow that the ultimate relief lies in the hon Supreme Court and nither the UFBU nor thr IBA help the poor retirees.There is no alternative but to implememt tne verdict,Still the wicked IBA wpuld try to delay tha matter,Let us see.

Dr.L.S.Raman.

[virander vora]

[Kailash Verma]

[ashok aggarwal]

with this judgement other banks also should pay retiral dues to all similarly placed persons.hope good sense will prevail upon.