2 QGIS Proposals for your comments

31 views
Skip to first unread message

Emma Hain

unread,
Sep 17, 2026, 8:29:45 PMSep 17
to QGIS Australia User Group
Hi All
Please find below 2 proposals that you may wish to comment on. Please use this email chain to respond:
I have attached each of the full proposal as pdf. 

AGM Matter Arising 2: Recovery of voting member status after PSC service

Summary


The proposal calls for a change to section 5.6 of the QGIS Charter to allow people who are elected to the PSC to recover their previously held voting member status after their PSC role ends.


Full proposal


Section 5.6 of the QGIS Charter states that a voting membership will remain valid until:

  • The voting member resigns

  • There is a motion raised from within the voting membership, and passed vote by the voting membership to remove the member

  • A voting member gets elected to the PSC in which case voting membership of the new PSC member will be relinquished and a new voting member will be elected in the new PSC member’s place. Outgoing PSC members that were previously voting members will need to be re-elected into the voting membership should they wish to return to their former role.


It is being proposed that the phrase 

“A voting member gets elected to the PSC in which case voting membership of the new PSC member will be relinquished and a new voting member will be elected in the new PSC member’s place”


Is changed to

“A voting member gets elected to the PSC in which case voting membership of the new PSC member will be paused and a new voting member will be elected in the new PSC member’s place”


This change would allow people who serve in the PSC to recover their status as a voting member after their PSC service is over, without the need to be re-elected.



Context 


Section 5 of the QGIS Charter regulates the General Meetings of the QGIS Foundation. You can read it in full on the QGIS.org website. 


AGM Matter arising 3: Improving transparency in the PSC’s financial decisions

Summary

This proposal advocates for the establishment of formal rules in the QGIS Charter to cover when and how money can be disbursed by the PSC. 


Full proposal

Dear QGIS Developers and Community, QGIS has been growing fast and has become something that could never have been imagined when the first commits were made more than 20 years ago. As the project evolves, new challenges are emerging, and increasingly the PSC is being asked to make decisions that involve money.


As the frequency of these decisions increases, we would like to explore ideas on how to keep things transparent, especially in cases where the PSC members may stand to benefit from the decisions.   


So far, we have tried to be transparent on the use of funds by publishing clear breakdowns of expenditures in our annual financial reports, recording decisions in PSC meeting minutes, and publicly disclosing potential conflicts of interest. In the long term, we propose the incorporation of formal rules into the QGIS statutes to cover when and how money can be disbursed by the PSC. 


Here it should be noted that the PSC is made up entirely of volunteers and that, like many other QGIS volunteers, some PSC members have their own companies that are dedicated to solving QGIS-related issues.  This creates a potential for situations where the PSC has to approve an expense and one of the members, or a company they have an interest in, is considered the best provider of a solution. 


To navigate these situations, we looked at how other open-source communities handle them and found some good inspiration in a recent Fedora discussion. A couple of points are worth highlighting: 

  • A healthy community should assume good faith and avoid “automatic distrust” where an individual’s vote or decisions are censored by default simply because they align with their personal interests  

  • It is natural in an open source community to have individuals whose professional and personal interests coincide with those of the project because these interests are often what leads them to volunteer in the first place

  • There should be a clear distinction between cases where there is a “happy coincidence” between the person’s interests and those of QGIS and cases where a person tries to influence the project’s decisions for personal gain

  • Situations where a decision maker stands to gain from the decision should be documented, and the rationale for the decision explained clearly


Based on this, and also keeping in mind our desire to keep the community lean and avoid excessive bureaucracy, we would like to propose a system where expenses are divided into four categories:


  1. Budgeted expenses: These are expenses that are voted for and approved by the community during the AGM each year.  

  2. Emergencies: Cases where time is of the essence and the PSC has to use its discretion to solve an urgent problem

  3. Small expenses: Expenses under a certain threshold (to be defined) that the PSC votes on and that are registered in the PSC meeting minutes.  

  4. Other: Expenses that are larger than the small expenses threshold and are not contemplated in the budget. In these cases, the PSC will vote to make funding available and put out a public call via blog, feed etc. 


Of these, the “emergencies” and “other” categories are the ones that require the most attention since they are unplanned, significant expenses.  We would propose to record these expenses in the PSC meeting minutes and mandate the inclusion of the reasoning behind the expense and the choice of provider. 


Additionally, as we have been doing, all expenses should be recorded in the yearly financial statements to provide full transparency to the community, even for the expenses that were already approved or were below the small expenses threshold.


Kind regards
Em

Emma Hain — Product Manager/Senior GIS Analyst
em...@north-road.com
https://north-road.com North Road
Cartography • Development • Spatial Analysis


north-road.com

QGIS User Conference
5-6 October, LAAX, Switzerland
FOSS4G 2027
August 23 – 29, Bristol, UK

2026-03-Finance_Dispersal.pdf
2026-02-PSC-vote.pdf

Emma Hain

unread,
Sep 17, 2026, 8:42:37 PMSep 17
to QGIS Australia User Group
Here is the one I missed - sorry 

Matter Arising 1: Double voting prevention

Summary 

The proposal calls for an amendment to section 5 of the QGIS Charter to prevent a single person from being nominated as a voting member in more than one category and therefore having the ability to cast more than one vote. 


Full proposal


Section 5 of the QGIS Charter sets up four different voting-member categories: User Group, Community, OSGeo and Honorary, each with its own election process. But nothing actually stops one person from holding a seat in more than one of these at the same time. 


It is being proposed that no individual should be able to hold more than one voting membership at once, regardless of category. If someone already holds a seat and becomes eligible for another, they'd give up the first one before taking the second, same as the PSC / voting member exclusivity rule already works.


A few reasons this seems worth doing:

  1. It keeps things consistent with the PSC precedent instead of leaving a loophole right next to it

  2. It promotes the involvement of more people in the project.

  3. It doesn't look good to third parties and potential funders. An open governance structure that visibly allows vote-stacking is a bad look for a project that depends on volunteer trust, even if at the moment it is done in good faith. Sorting this now avoids ever having to explain why it was allowed.


This change should be easy to implement by checking at nomination time, so there shouldn’t be any added overhead.






Context 


Section 5 of the QGIS Charter regulates the General Meetings of the QGIS Foundation. You can read it in full on the QGIS.org website. It establishes four categories of voting members

  1. QGIS User group voting members - Each country-level group democratically elects a representative to vote on their behalf. Only country-level user groups recognized by the PSC are eligible.

  2. QGIS Community voting members - The charter establishes that there should be an equal number of user group voting members and community voting members. Any active QGIS community member will be eligible for nomination, and votes are cast by the established QGIS committers

  3. One OSGEO representative voting member - One voting member representing the OSGeo Foundation, put forward by the OSGeo board

  4. Honorary voting members - Honorable members are individual persons who receive special acknowledgment for extraordinary achievements in the QGIS project   


The proposal mentions a “PSC / voting member exclusivity”. This is a reference to section 5.6 of the charter that regulates voting member terms and states that:


 [when] a voting member gets elected to the PSC in which case voting membership of the new PSC member will be relinquished and a new voting member will be elected in the new PSC member’s place. Outgoing PSC members that were previously voting members will need to be re-elected into the voting membership should they wish to return to their former role.”


Kind regards
Em

2026-01-DBLE-vote.pdf

Adam Steer

unread,
Sep 18, 2026, 11:24:51 PMSep 18
to australian-qg...@googlegroups.com
Hey Emma

Thanks for communicating these matters broadly. I have a typical academic's "question, more like a comment" :D about matter 3 - transparency in financial decisions.

A lot of corporate governance material around real or perceived conflicts of interest exists already - has the QGIS PSC considered this? Because conflicts of interest with financial decisions can become a legal matter as well as an internal community matter.

In the case of QGIS it would be looking at Swiss law right? 

I'm not super comfortable with the idea of voting members being able to vote on issues which are financial decisions benefiting them. And a COI must always be declared so that any discussion around the issue is framed appropriately. This might be seen as against the idea of trusting community members, however it's an important guardrail. Yes we trust *you* and you must also trust *us*.

I don't agree with the language of "censoring by default". Recusal from a discussion isn't censorship. The last two points about happy coincidences and documenting - well, all these lessons have been learned before and ended in corporate governance bodies coming to the conclusion that voting members in a board or organisation who stand to gain from a decision should recuse themselves from that decision.

Food for thought.

Regards,

Adam


--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "QGIS Australia User Group" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to australian-qgis-use...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion, visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/australian-qgis-user-group/CACGKw0Z20s724NwX2e3U02PNcoudodBxj4brkrrO0Z9zc6T7EA%40mail.gmail.com.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages