1st Critique - Be gentle LOL

62 views
Skip to first unread message

Troy Pudney

unread,
Oct 18, 2026, 8:18:14 PMOct 18
to QGIS Australia User Group
A map I produce for a monthly report on the location (suburb) that our new patients and existing patients come from. There is no template so I used my old UXO/EOD format tweaked to the data. Not set in stone and I change it up as I go if I see fit. End users do not provide feedback so it is a bit hard to make sure the information is getting across. So, feel free to let lose.
September 2026 HMU Numbers.jpg

Emma Hain

unread,
Oct 18, 2026, 8:55:04 PMOct 18
to australian-qg...@googlegroups.com
Hi Troy

Thanks for being courageous! It is an important map but with some challenges in showing the information. 

Here's my 2 bits:
1. Insets
I see you have a difficult problem with the areas outside Adelaide! Maybe split the map into 2 - show the greater extent in one and the Adelaide metr0/100km buffer zoneo in a smaller one and zoomed in (i.e. put Broken Hill into the bigger one)? 

2. Map Frames
I would probably have the whole map filling the left side and get rid of the white space between the red and black frames

3. Coords
some spacing issues - do they need to be on there? 


4. Information
Add in a bit of space between the map frame and the information (disclaimer, scale, logos etc)

5. Title
Repeated

6. Map Metadata
This information can be added next to your date and author if you want. I would make it all grey over black

7. Colours
a) Try to avoid using straight black - go for greys - so for black, use a dark grey
b) Try to use the branding colours of the hospital in decorations like map frames etc

8. North arrow and Scale bar
I usually have the following order:
North Arrow 
Scale Text
Scale Bar
Kilometres (Put the this closer to the scale bar - it is a bit far away)
Disclaimer

9. Logos
Put in lower right - right aligned or central

10. Legend
Use full words over Abbreviations
Remove underscores
User the same fontsize
Use proper case rather than all capitals unless there is some reason for it
Perhaps replace the numbers of cases with a little graph or piechart? Perhaps where the big north arrow is? 



On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 at 10:18, Troy Pudney <troy....@gmail.com> wrote:
A map I produce for a monthly report on the location (suburb) that our new patients and existing patients come from. There is no template so I used my old UXO/EOD format tweaked to the data. Not set in stone and I change it up as I go if I see fit. End users do not provide feedback so it is a bit hard to make sure the information is getting across. So, feel free to let lose.
September 2026 HMU Numbers.jpg

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "QGIS Australia User Group" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to australian-qgis-use...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion, visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/australian-qgis-user-group/c1bb019a-d54f-4e06-bfb9-2ed5eb3edf90n%40googlegroups.com.

Emma Hain

unread,
Oct 18, 2026, 8:57:01 PMOct 18
to australian-qg...@googlegroups.com
whoops forgot to put that map for reference
image.png

Rebecca Marks

unread,
Oct 18, 2026, 11:23:07 PMOct 18
to australian-qg...@googlegroups.com

This is some great feedback!

 

I’m also struggling a bit with the insets and the general scale and I almost missed the green point on the coastline.

 

What is the purpose of the data? Is it to display how far patients are traveling for the service provided? Is it often at this scale or is it usually reasonably close?

 

I wonder if a table or chart would be more appropriate than multiple insets. A close up map of the closer patients, an inset map with the further patients and a chart or table showing  percentage of your patients are within X distance of the unit

 

 

Kind Regards

 

Rebecca Marks

 

From: australian-qg...@googlegroups.com <australian-qg...@googlegroups.com> On Behalf Of Emma Hain
Sent: Monday, 19 October 2026 11:55 AM
To: australian-qg...@googlegroups.com
Subject: Re: [QGIS-Australia-User-Group] 1st Critique - Be gentle LOL

 

Caution: This is an external email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognise the sender.

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "QGIS Australia User Group" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to australian-qgis-use...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion, visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/australian-qgis-user-group/c1bb019a-d54f-4e06-bfb9-2ed5eb3edf90n%40googlegroups.com.

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "QGIS Australia User Group" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to australian-qgis-use...@googlegroups.com.

Troy Pudney

unread,
Oct 19, 2026, 8:28:00 AMOct 19
to australian-qg...@googlegroups.com
Team,

Thanks for the valuable input. I sat down, cried and then said to myself, "Troy, stop peeling the onions and get to work" All the points are valid, hence why I put myself out there to improve. To put the Print Layout template into perspective I used one from the plugin 'Layout Loader' created by Klas Karlsson, and ported over to QGIS4 by Davince Koyo after I posted on Reddit that it was not 4 compatible and Klas seemed to have stopped developing for a while. I have dropped my work around from the early suggestions.

Rebecca,
The data is for an end of month brief to highlight how spread out our catchment is. It follows comments that assumed our patients only came from the metro area. Our health system also uses a distance model for services, so you may be within the 100km buffer but it takes four hours to drive to get treatment. I also finished a time related travel map in 15 minute increments out to an hour. The report is full of tables and charts, just using this to make it a little more visually stimulating for the end reader.

Emma,

Here's my 2 bits:
1. Insets
I see you have a difficult problem with the areas outside Adelaide! Maybe split the map into 2 - show the greater extent in one and the Adelaide metr0/100km buffer zoneo in a smaller one and zoomed in (i.e. put Broken Hill into the bigger one)?


Yes, this is one of the problems that I have is we are such a vast State and our catchment area is 1.8 million square km, plus Darwin. I originally only inserted new persons starting that month but was asked if i could add all persons treated. I took your advice, have map 1 as Metro area, map2 as State level and all the months treatments in map 3 (added shaded catchment area as a visual context). Moved the Australia overview under the legend a filler, can more or remove it later.

2. Map Frames
I would probably have the whole map filling the left side and get rid of the white space between the red and black frames

Was a default from the original template. I have enlarged it to fill the space.

3. Coords
some spacing issues - do they need to be on there?


Another template default. I normally turn it off but forgot this time.
 
4. Information
Add in a bit of space between the map frame and the information (disclaimer, scale, logos etc)

Done

5. Title
Repeated


Not any more!

6. Map Metadata
This information can be added next to your date and author if you want. I would make it all grey over black


Done. Also dumped the date as the month and year are elsewhere.


7. Colours
a) Try to avoid using straight black - go for greys - so for black, use a dark grey
b) Try to use the branding colours of the hospital in decorations like map frames etc


But I like Black!!! I toned down the blacks. Forgot the legend.


8. North arrow and Scale bar
I usually have the following order:
North Arrow
Scale Text
Scale Bar
Kilometres (Put the this closer to the scale bar - it is a bit far away)
Disclaimer


Moved the north arrow to the top corner, out of the way. I know its convention, but if they do not now know where north is I am not going out of my way to teach them. LOL

9. Logos
Put in lower right - right aligned or central

Done. Once again used the temple locations


10. Legend
Use full words over Abbreviations
Remove underscores
User the same fontsize
Use proper case rather than all capitals unless there is some reason for it
Perhaps replace the numbers of cases with a little graph or piechart? Perhaps where the big north arrow is?

Abbreviations are what the medical staff recognise and to spell the shortened ones out gave me some formatting issues. One thing I have found is QGIS labeling and legend formatting can be a bit tricky. But I am coming from old ArcGIS, so there might be some muscle memory there... The names are from an Access Database export where all the text is uppercase, as are underscores. I removed all but that one manually. I did try to add a chart, but until Plotly works with QGIS for Mac (this is not Plotly fault I read today) the Print Layout chart builder is pretty crap. I placed the Australia insert in the white space as it looked empty. Also in the report I have charts breaking down all that data.

Critique Version 1.jpeg

Rebecca Marks

unread,
Oct 19, 2026, 6:14:33 PMOct 19
to australian-qg...@googlegroups.com

Nice! Yes for sure if you have other charts elsewhere no point doubling up.

 

The context explains why the map is so broad

 

 

Kind Regards

 

Rebecca Marks

 

 

From: australian-qg...@googlegroups.com <australian-qg...@googlegroups.com> On Behalf Of Troy Pudney
Sent: Monday, 19 October 2026 9:26 PM
To: australian-qg...@googlegroups.com
Subject: Re: [QGIS-Australia-User-Group] 1st Critique - Be gentle LOL

 

Caution: This is an external email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognise the sender.

 

Team,

--

You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "QGIS Australia User Group" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to australian-qgis-use...@googlegroups.com.

Juan Fernando Berrío

unread,
Oct 19, 2026, 8:02:56 PMOct 19
to australian-qg...@googlegroups.com
Hi Troy, 

Kudos to you for getting feedback from the community this way - you found a way to use us as leverage to improve the way you do things.  It takes a bit of discomfort to get better - it only means the process is working. 

Regards
Juan

Troy Pudney

unread,
Oct 20, 2026, 6:57:08 PMOct 20
to australian-qg...@googlegroups.com
Thanks Juan,

Coming from a Defence and photography background I found the best way to improve is get as much positive and negative feedback as possible.

Troy



--
Regards

Troy Pudney

Explosive Ordnance Disposal (EOD)
 
Is a science of vague assumptions based on debatable figures derived from inconclusive experiments, performed by persons of doubtful mental capability with instruments of problematic accuracy!
 

Ewen Hill

unread,
Oct 20, 2026, 7:24:14 PMOct 20
to QGIS Australia User Group
Hi Troy,
  Thanks for sharing your work and all you and your team do on diving patients. In version one and two, could you remove the Australian inset and replace this with the Central Australia inset but all of Australia?

  In the second edition, the SA state inset map - should that be the entire state to avoid the Mount Gambier's of the world being peeved?  The other thing is to possibly remove the all caps and reduce the width slightly to give you a bit more real-estate. I am not sure if the Australian map image is actually required. It does focus your eyes on it for the deep blue.

Loving this collab!

Ewen



Troy Pudney

unread,
Oct 21, 2026, 7:11:10 AMOct 21
to australian-qg...@googlegroups.com
Ewen,

Firstly, the State Government does not reconginse Mount Gambier, so why should I start. LOL... They are not forgotten, just have not seen any patients last month from there. Which is a reason why I started this map project. I have shared versions of it at the national and New Zealand level. What it does show is how centralised our health care is for those living close to major cities and how rural and regional health care misses out. Many of the same conditions, but no access. Something that is hard to visualise in a bunch of spreadsheet numbers.

And, I learnt something new. Others mentioning not having legend in uppercase. Well that is out of the database export, but I thought there has to be a way without running an excel formula to do it. And, there is, in the font tab between 'Text' and 'Buffer'.  Who would have thought reading the manual would produce answers (might be some other gems in it). 

 The Australia insert was a filler in the end. Saw a clip on YouTube linking the main maps to the overview and thought that looks cool. But, it turned into a bit like someone discovering all the PowerPoint transitions and using them all. I have removed it but have some extra void space. I might add a little legend on what each map covers. Or, and just thinking out loud, I might replace the insert with an outline of Australia with the shaded catchment area included, instead of it being on the All Treatment map. I'll play with it. Have shrunk the legend and stretched out maps a little, getting a 2/3 and 1/3 view. The central Australia view is only there because we had a Darwin patient. This month there is no one that far North.

I start getting the data together next week, so let us see how it turns out. And once again, thanks for the feedback.

Troy

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages