'Never seen anything like this': Inside Indonesia's LGBT crackdown

[qy]

(CNN)In less than 18 months, being gay in Indonesia has gone
from widely tolerated to just plain dangerous.

An unprecedented wave of police raids, vigilante attacks, and
calls for the criminalization of homosexual sex have left many
in the country's LGBT community fearing for their safety.

"(Gay Indonesians) are exhausted and they're horrified," Kyle
Knight, a Human Rights Watch researcher with the LGBT rights
program, told CNN.

"Even the activists I know who started the very first
organizations in the 1980s say they've never seen anything like
this."

It's a dark turn for a country that for decades prided itself on
its diverse, heterogeneous society.

The world's largest Muslim democracy, Indonesia is often
considered something of a bulwark of tolerance amid growing
conservatism elsewhere in the Islamic world.

But that perception is now shifting, amid increasing verbal
attacks on minority groups and the growing implementation of
Islamic bylaws by regional governments.

In less than two weeks, two young men were seized by vigilantes
who burst into their home in Aceh province, then taken to
authorities who caned them for having homosexual sex.

In a separate incident, later in the month, attendees at an
alleged gay party in a Jakarta sauna were arrested and images of
their faces were disseminated online by Indonesian police.

Homosexual sex is not illegal in the majority of Indonesia,
except in the extremely conservative province of Aceh. Jakarta
is not part of any province; it is controlled by the central
government.

One week ago, West Java Police Chief Anton Charliyan announced
that he would create a special taskforce to crack down on LGBT
people.

"They will face the law and heavy social sanctions. They will
not be accepted by society," he said.

Homosexuality tolerated, not accepted
It wasn't always this way.

Despite being a Muslim-majority country, only small parts of
Indonesia — such as Aceh province — follow strict Islamic law.

Same-sex relations have never been illegal either, even if a
2013 Pew survey found that 93% of the country refused to accept
homosexuality.

Jonta Saragih a former LGBT activist from Sumatra, now studying
in the UK, said while his family weren't quick to accept him
when he came out, Indonesians used to have a live and let live
attitude to their country's LGBT population.

"[Even] a few years ago, when I was in Jakarta, though
homosexuality was not recognized by the law, there was no one
talking about it," he told CNN.

Indonesian human rights activist Tunggal Pawestri corroborates
this notion that homosexuality was previously frowned upon but
tolerated.

"Since my childhood I was told that LGBT people are sinful,
being a homosexual is sinful but of course ... it doesn't mean
you have to criminalize them," she said.

So what changed?

Gay rights worse than 'nuclear war'
The problems began in early 2016, when a number of high-profile
Indonesian politicians, including several government ministers,
suddenly started to make unprompted attacks on Indonesia's LGBT
community.

Among them was the Defense Minister, Ryamizard Ryacudu, who said
Indonesia's LGBT movement was more dangerous than "a nuclear
war."

"In a nuclear war, if a bomb is dropped over Jakarta, Semarang
will not be affected -- but (with LGBT rights) everything we
know could disappear in an instant -- it's dangerous," he said,
according to the state Antara news agency.

Soon, the country's medical professionals joined in. The
Indonesian Psychiatrists Association issued a statement in
February saying people who were gay or bisexual had "psychiatric
problems."

By August, a group of conservative activists had taken a case to
the Constitutional Court to call for homosexual sex to be made
illegal in Indonesia.

Knight said it's hard to tell why the sudden wave of anti-LGBT
feeling swelled up across the country, but where it was heading
appeared much clearer.

"This is fueled not just by bigotry and misunderstanding but by
public officials ... I think that's the really scary thing as we
go forward. It's fair game to go after LGBT people in
Indonesia," he said.

More than a dozen gay dating apps, including Grindr, were banned
in Indonesia in late 2016, Jonta said, making it harder for gay
men and women to communicate with each other.

"(I have) some good friends ... we started discussing these
issues on social media, eventually some of them deleted me on
Facebook. They said we are not friends anymore," Jonta said.

Conservative Islam is a growing political force in Indonesia.
The arrest and later conviction of former Jakarta governor
Basuki 'Ahok' Tjahaja Purnama in April this year, on charges of
blasphemy, followed huge protests instigated by conservative
groups.

Pawestri blamed vocally conservative politicians and an
"irresponsible" media for the rise in anti-LGBT rhetoric.

"Before LGBT Indonesians had quite a lot of confidence, now
they're very careful and cry to me, calling me at night. We've
been trying to do whatever we can to avoid (criminalization),"
Pawestri said.

Showdown at the Constitutional Court
Criminalization might be closer than most would expect.

Since August, a team of lawyers has been arguing in Indonesia's
Constitutional Court, on behalf of 12 individuals, to change the
criminal code.

Prosecution legal team spokesman, Feizal Syahmenan, told CNN
they would like three articles changed in the criminal code --
one to outlaw sex outside of marriage, one to outlaw homosexual
rape and one to outlaw homosexual sex entirely.

Two of those 12 individuals are members of the AILA, the Family
Love Alliance, a prominent conservative Islamic group.

Syahmenan told CNN homosexuality is just not Indonesian.

"All of these three (laws) are totally wrong and against
Indonesian norms and values," he said. "We're not trying to push
for implementation of Sharia (Islamic) law."

If the Constitutional Court finds in favor of criminalization,
it would still need to be passed by Indonesia's Parliament
before it would take effect, but Knight said it would put huge
public pressure on the country's politicians to follow through.

"There are some dark storm clouds on the horizon. If you read
the transcripts on the hearings that have taken place since last
August, you don't see (judges) pushback from the bench (on
witnesses) ... they ask more questions, 'tell us more about the
evils of homosexuality'," he said.

"It's ominous, it's very, very threatening."
Hearings concluded in February, with a verdict expected after
June, according to Syahmenan.

Where is Joko Widodo?
One politician who has been mostly silent amid the ongoing
discrimination against LGBT citizens in Indonesia has been
Indonesian President Joko "Jokowi" Widodo.

When he was elected in 2014, there was a huge sense of optimism
around Widodo who was considered a "progressive force" for the
nation.

But amid the nationwide crackdown on LGBT people, the president
has only spoken out once in their defense.

"There should be no discrimination against anyone," Widodo told
the BBC in October 2016, adding "the police must act" against
any attempts to harm LGBT people.

But he then added that in Indonesia, "beliefs (generally) do not
allow (LGBT), Islam does not allow it."

Human rights activist Pawestri said many gay Indonesians have
been disappointed by Widodo's lackluster defense of their
rights. "LGBT people realize that his silence means no
protection from the government, and this is totally unjust," she
said.
Even if Widodo wanted to help, Knight said it could cost him
huge political capital, something he might be reluctant to spend
ahead of his 2019 reelection campaign.

"(They) could really do a lot of good by coming out and issuing
a statement of support ... They're taking a very cowardly and
silent stance, letting it go forward ... Until someone puts a
lid on this, it's going to keep unraveling," he said.

Battle for Indonesia's soul
Knight said nothing will change until those in authority stand
up for the rights of gay citizens across Indonesia.

"We need some leadership here ... Is there any chance [the
crackdown] is going to stop? Of course, but it's going to take a
constitutional court actually upholding the constitution, it's
going to take members of the cabinet stepping out and saying,
'no this is not how we behave,' it's going to take the
President," he said.

Syahmenan said the battle over the gay Indonesians' rights was
about reaffirming "Indonesian norms and values," adding legal
same-sex relations were a relic of colonial rule.

He said gay and lesbian people are a danger to the future of
Indonesia. "Look at the children, they like to imitate or copy
what the adults do. If they see free sex practices or LGBT, they
may think that the practices are something fun and cool," he
said.

Despite the current situation, Jonta still believes the future
could be bright for Indonesia's LGBT citizens.

"I have this willingness to continue to fight for a better
Indonesia. To fight for inclusiveness. Of course it will be more
difficult for us to continue the work of human rights," he said.

"We are getting oppressed, even our social media and our
websites ... but I would say I'm still optimistic."

http://www.cnn.com/2017/05/31/asia/indonesia-lgbt-
rights/index.html