1.
Opening statement of the article: In 2016, India has been witnessing one of the
severest droughts after independence. --
this statement is not based on facts. This is like IPCC global warming type
sensationalization approach. The problem is, the government mis-using water
resources without understanding the vulnerability of monsoon rains. Even after IMD and others presented imminent
threat of deficit, governments did not looked at planning. In the case of Msharashtra, water is wasted
for private power plants -- no drought for them. In the two Telugu states
wasted water under the disguise of Pushkaralu and power production. This is
also true with other states.
That
is why we need a system to monitor the drought at national level instead making
statements from the air. I did this in several countries. In the case of Mazombique The President
released my note on the drought condition and bood aid requirement in 1987-88
crop season. Next day agriculture chief
from one province [like our states] released a press statement stating that his
provice is reeling under severe drought conditions. The President asked for my response on this.
I said this is the best province and needs no food aid. Then the officer was
dismissed from the post and asked another person to take over. All this
happened in less than an hour time.
2.
Regarding Telangana: Regarding the observations on Mission Kakatiya [or for
that matter Mission Bhagiratha] are only provide propaganda statements only.
Nobody wants to look at the data published by the government on agriculture
[year by year]. In Telangana the area under Tanks in 1955-56 was 4.44 Lha and
this was reduced to 2.28 Lha in 1999-00.
The same for undivided AP were 10.69 & 6.51 Lha. Can we expect the area under cultivation even
after de-silting the tanks double the area under cultivation? The Mission Kakatiya states that currently
the area under cultivation is 2.5 Lha and after the completion of the mission
it will rise to 5.0 Lha, which higher than that existed in 1955-56. Will be
possible.
Also,
out of 10 districts in Telangana, in two districts large number of tanks
disappeared with real estate ventures. Even the remaining tanks are encroached
large part. The same is the case with
other 8 districts in urban areas. So, with such scenario is it possible to
achieve the goal by wasting Rs. 25, 000
crores of public money -- major part is taken on loan to be paid by the
future governments.
De-silting
of the tanks is not new in this part of the country. This was carried out under different central
funded schemes. Prior to that, villagers used to do that by themselves.
Regarding
Mission Bhagiratha, the government is wasting Rs. 40,000 crores -- mostly
barrowed money and interests have to be paid by the future governments. The cost
would have been drastically cutdown if the government completed the 25
irrigation projects [near completion] undertaken by the previous
government. As they provide source of
sustainable water to the drinking projects.
The
scheme of Mission Bhagiratha is not new but in the past Puttaparthi Sai Baba
initiated the drinking water scheme in Anantapur district and Madak district.
Also NGOs initiated this projects in several villages. For Nalgonda, such scheme was initiated to
flouride effected villages.
In
the case of Hyderabad City water supply, the government unable to plug the
losses of 55% of the total water supplied due to leakages and filferages. We suggested many a times on this. Even in some parts the sewage is polluting
the pipe water supply. Even the new
pipelines were broken and diverted water meant to supply to Hyderabad. They also used poor quality of pipelines and
rust in no time and as well break. Even
the two reservoirs that supply water through gravity are being converted in to
real estate ventures.
Please
study the historical changes & realities before writing praising the
government. Otherwise it gives wrong signals to misuse of public funds also
give false feedback to the members of this group and others. In fact I wrore to
the Chief Secretary on this and as well on irrigation projects and asked him to
present a white paper, so that people understand the reality. But he hasn't even acknowledged my letter.
Dr.
S. Jeevananda Reddy
Dear All,
It is compiled by Bhim Singh Rawat of SANDRP, feedback is welcome.