[FEATURE REQUEST] Custom path for group_vars and host_vars in ansible.cfg

[muff...@gmail.com]

Hi all,

I've been wondering on how am I going to move the contents of my group_vars and host_vars to a different location then I found https://github.com/ansible/ansible/issues/13051 which basically was rejected.

My use case is mainly to have a better organization of my configurations. Since I was able to specify a custom location for my inventory and roles_path as stated also in the above link, I also wanted to set a custom location for my group_vars and host_vars.

Currently, my Ansible directory tree looks like this:

ANSIBLE_DIR=/etc/ansible

$ANSIBLE_DIR/ansible.cfg
$ANSIBLE_DIR/main.yml
$ANSIBLE_DIR/environment/{development,staging,production}
$ANSIBLE_DIR/roles/{defaults,files,handlers,meta,tasks,templates,vars}/

Then, I want to have my group_vars and host_vars to be located at:

$ANSIBLE_DIR/vars/{groups,hosts}/

I find it messy (sorry) if my group_vars and host_vars are located inside the $ANSIBLE_DIR/environment/ directory. Thus, I want to move it to some other place.

Thank you and I hope you will consider this feature request.

Kind regards,

Muffin

[Mark Kusch]

+

Waiting for it since I'm using Ansible (which is quite some time).

# kraM

> --
> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Ansible Development" group.
> To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to ansible-deve...@googlegroups.com.
> For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.


--
kraM

Think can be useful if someone is needing some thinking about something.

gpg --recv-keys 0x6C215719

[Marc Petrivelli]

+

I agree this would be a nice feature.  Forcing group_vars and host_vars to be relative to your inventory file/script was shorted sighted.  It's super sloppy but you can work around this with sym links.  Shamefully, I have done this.

[Rahul Raj Purohit (RRP)]

Hi All,
As much as I hate to bring an old thread back to life, I have to as I've failed to find workarounds for this issue.
Based on my inventory file, I would like to keep the group_vars dir in multiple locations instead of the same single directory as it makes it harder to maintain.
So instead of 

group_vars

├── db_in

├── db_servers

├── db_us

├── in_servers

├── us_servers

├── web_in

├── web_servers

└── web_us

I would like to have something like (or any other suggestions/workaround to make things more organised) below:

group_variables

├── db-servers-grp

│ ├── db_in

│ └── db_us

├── general-grp

│ ├── db_servers

│ └── web_servers

├── region-grp

│ ├── in_servers

│ └── us_servers

└── web-server-grp

├── web_in

└── web_us

This way I can have in my ansible.cfg file the following variable:

group_vars_dirs = group_variables/db-servers-grp, group_variables/general-grp, group_variables/region-grp, group_variables/web-server-grp

This would help in scalability when there are thousands of regions or even sub-regions

I have an inventory as below (This is a sample of a larger inventory of around 2000 hosts):

all:

children:

web_servers:

children:

web_us:

hosts:

web_us_example1:

web_us_example2:

web_us_example3:

web_in:

hosts:

web_in_example1:

web_in_example2:

web_in_example3:

db_servers:

children:

db_us:

hosts:

db_us_example1:

db_us_example2:

db_us_example3:

db_in:

hosts:

db_in_example1:

db_in_example2:

db_in_example3:

us_servers:

children:

web_us:

db_us:

in_servers:

children:

web_in:

db_in:

I would appreciate any feedback at all.

Thanks,
Rahul Raj Purohit

[Brian Coca]

You can just develop your own "vars plugin" that does this, the
current host_vars/group_vars is implemented via the host_group_vars
plugin included in core
https://docs.ansible.com/ansible/latest/collections/ansible/builtin/host_group_vars_vars.html.
You can even disable the one shipped with core in favor of your own.
--
----------
Brian Coca (he/him/yo)