Pass on Benefit of any Spectrum Price Cut: Sistema to DoT
JOJI THOMAS PHILIP NEW DELHI : ET
Russia’s
Sistema has demanded that any cut in base price for airwaves in
auctions should be extended to it, a move that may thwart the Centre’s
efforts at slashing the reserve price for third round of spectrum
auctions. Sistema-Shyam (SSTL), which offers mobile phone services under
the MTS brand on the CDMA technology platform, is the lone participant
in the second round of airwaves sale that begins on March 11. The Centre
was forced to restrict the upcoming spectrum auctions to just the 800
MHz band used by CDMA operators as there were no bidders for the other
frequencies. The government had earlier planned to sell unsold spectrum
in the 1800 MHz band from last year’s auctions in four circles — Delhi,
Mumbai, Karnataka and Rajasthan — along with a portion of airwaves held
by incumbent operators in the 900 MHz band, during the March 2013 sale.
The
Supreme Court had directed the government last week to sell all
airwaves vacated by companies whose permits were quashed by the apex
court in February last year and the move has forced the government to go
in for a third round of airwaves sales, the timelines for which are yet
to be finalised.
“Our participation in the ensuing auction is with a
clear understanding that the relative price band will not be disturbed.
Fairness and equity warrants that in the event Government of India
takes a decision to reduce the reserve price in any of the 2G bands, the
benefit of the price so reduced be extended to Sistema-Shyam by way of
refund, adjustment on the excessive price paid by SSTL,” the company
said in a March 4 communication to the telecom department.
Sistema
said the decision to participate in the March 11 auctions were taken
with ‘huge pain’, as it had to ‘simultaneously decide on closure of
operations in other circles’ where it decided not to play a part in the
airwaves sale. “We had to shrink our footprint as the reserve price has
been so steep and not making any economic sense. The decision to close
some of these circles are primarily due to the high reserve price,
causing inconvenience to customers, loss of jobs for direct and indirect
employees, loss of capital employed, huge dent on the image of Sistema,
directly impacting the MTS brand,” the company’s communication added.
Sistema’s communication comes even as the panel of ministers on spectrum
headed by finance minister P Chidambaram is looking at reducing the
base price for the third round of spectrum auctions. The empowered group
of ministers on Wednesday decided that it would decide on base price for airwaves with regard to future auctions only after the conclusion of the March 11 sale.
Sistema
further said that India was a highly competitive market and relative
advantage or disadvantage in spectrum prices had huge financial impact
on companies. “We once again reiterate that the telecom department
should consider reduction in reserve price for 800 MHz spectrum in case
it is considering reduction in 1800 MHz and 900 MHz irrespective of
participation in auction for the 800 MHz band,” the company said.
SistemaShyam,
which has a customer base of over 14 million across 22 circles, had
lost 21 of its mobile permits in the February 2012 Supreme Court order
in the 2G-spectrum allocation case that impacted several operators. The
company, which is the sole telecom operator in the country that uses
only 800 MHz for its services, had stayed away from the first round of
spectrum auctions in November citing high reserve price.
