what do u feel?

[Prasad Chikshe]

A friend told me 2write my comment on Munni badnam hui & Shila ki Jawani. Just searched youtube videos & found that 1st song is uploaded 2months back & minimum 16,70,875 people saw that (1,04,429 per week) .2nd song 2weeks back & 17,13,488 people saw(8,56,744 per week) then 4comparison I saw Indian National Anthem which was uploaded 4years back & minimum 1,227,446 people saw that one(5900 per week)..what do u feel?

--
Prasad Chikshe
Jnana Prabodhini,"Madhu-Smruti"Keshav Nager,Ambajogai,431517
Mobile No:-+919421373536
Phone No:-02446248912

[Girish Karhade]

Hi,

First of all we should not compair our National Anthem with this kind
of meaningless things around us. Basically Our National Anthem has its
own respect, which we should not even think to ever compair it with
any other things.

I feel their is no comparision in between these two things , Not at all.

You can compair the songs with another songs but not with our National Anthem.

Whom so ever they are trying to do so , i feel they are wrong.

Thanks & Best Regards

Girish Karhade
Ambajogai

> --
> अंबाजोगाई प्राइड ग्रुप - संघटनात्मक प्रगती !
> सामर्थ्य आहे चळवळीचे, जो जो करील त्याचे, परंतु तेथे भगवंताचे अदिष्ठांन
> पाहिजे !
> AMBAJOG...@googlegroups.com
> unsub...@googlegroups.com
> 356 Members, 1 Owner, 3 Managers.
>

[Prasad Chikshe]

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Prasad Chikshe <prasad...@gmail.com>
Date: Tue, Nov 30, 2010 at 5:45 PM
Subject: Re: APG what do u feel?
To: Girish Karhade <girish...@gmail.com>


We did comparison with some other song like "e mere watan ke logo" and songs from 3 idots....they are far far behind now comment....

On Tue, Nov 30, 2010 at 5:43 PM, Prasad Chikshe <prasad...@gmail.com> wrote:

Comparision is not .....here girish...the target is the song...If u want to compair any song with the two one.....and see the out come and comment....I do have respect for national Antham.....As I though Nathional antham will be greatest hit....but infortunately rating is not accept it .....

[avinash deoshatwar]

i think there is a mismatch for comparison...not for the obvious respect we all have for the national anthem but regarding the kind of material that is being viewed on youtube. 

national anthem is a thing that we should inculcate in our personality and it's not necessary to see it on youtube. Even the most nationalistic of people might not be seeing it on youtube. even a r rehman's 'vande mataram' might have had more hits than the national anthem [jana gana mana].

so probably national anthem is not the best choice for comparison with munni and the other song. we could have compared it with one of most melodious songs of lata mangeshkar or sometihng similar.