On Friday, May 29, 2015 at 4:56:11 PM UTC-4, Bertel Lund Hansen wrote:
> Tony Cooper skrev:
>
> > When Simon Cowell was a judge on "American Idol" I liked to watch the
> > first few shows of the year because the truly bad performers were
> > often featured. Cowell was the only judge who ever provided a
> > realistic review of the performance. His were the only interesting
> > remarks.
Oh, sorry, I was referring to America's Got Talent. I've never seen a single
episode of Idol, The Voice, or their imitators.
> Yes, that is what the manuscript told him to do. There's a tough
the script
> guy, a soft guy, and two women one of whom is set up as slightly
> hostile to the tough guy.
Not in those days: it took Heidi Klum _plus_ Mel B. to "replace" Sharon
Osborne, and they're essentially useless. The original two men were S.C.
and David Hasselhoff. Then Piers Morgan replaced S.C. Then Howie Mandel
replaced The Hoff, and Howard Stern replaced P.M. when the latter was
unacccountably chosen to succeed Larry King as CNN's chatter-in-chief.
(Again, that refers to AGT.)
> I have seen maybe ten such shows, and the judges conform to this
> description in them all. Lots of sessions are available on
> YouTube - and there are some great performers among them.
>
> I like to watch it, and I follow our national show from start to
> the end for three reasons:
>
> It's often amazing and funny to see those who cannot sing at all.
>
> It's a thrill to hear those who can - and they are sometimes
> shockingly young.
>
> I like to hear the judges evaluation - especially those who are
> honest. So I agree with you that it's a relief to have someone
> like Simon Cowell to set the performers straight.
But only (one assumes) in pop areas. Has he "discovered" any jazz vocalists?
or classic Sinatra/Bennett/Clooney type singers?