On 2024-02-07 12:41, Adam Funk wrote:
> On 2024-02-06, lar3ryca wrote:
>
>> On 2024-02-06 06:12, Adam Funk wrote:
>>> On 2024-02-05, Bertel Lund Hansen wrote:
>>>
>>>> occam wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> You mean 'cock' and 'pussy'. Note, these mental images which only make
>>>>> sense in English. Just as images of 'Venus' and 'Mars' only make sense
>>>>> in astronomy department toilets.
>>>>
>>>> ... and to people who know the most basic about ancient Roman or Greek
>>>> religion.
>>>>
>>>>> I wonder if there are any universal symbols understood by everyone, by
>>>>> which I mean everyone on Earth.
>>>>
>>>> A simple drawing of persons with with genitals would do the trick.
>>>
>>> People complained about the nekkid humans on the Pioneer Plaque. Some
>>> people also complained about the prudish lack of vulva on it.
>>
>> I remember reading something, probably a short story, that had some
>> aliens finding the Pioneer Plaque and taking umbrage at just about
>> everything on it, and angering them enough to plan an invasion of Earth.
>>
>> Anyone know who wrote it?
>
> Does anything on either of these links sound close enough?
>
> <
https://www.reddit.com/r/scifi/comments/3o8mun/has_anyone_ever_written_a_story_about_aliens/>
Nothing rings a bell, not even in the links on that page, but it did
lead to a Wikipedia article entitled 'Message From Space', which in turn
prompted me to look up the 'Message From Space', a 1978 Japanese answer
to 'Star Wars'. This was supposed to be a serious SF film, but when I
saw it, it did not take too long before I started chuckling, then
laughing, much to the chagrin of my wife, who stopped trying to shush me
after I and the rest of the audience were laughing uproariously.
It got a lot of bad reviews at the time, but I consider it to be one of
the funniest SF films ever, in the same class as 'Galaxy Quest'.
See:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Message_from_Space
> <
https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/80359/short-story-space-probe-voyager-discovered-by-aliens>
Nothing there either. Thanks for trying.
If my (admittedly faint) memory serves, one of the reasons for umbrage
was the pulsar periods/coordinates from Earth (the long lines from the
origin) may have resembled either the aliens that found it or their enemies.
Thanks for trying.
> Here's something somewhat related that I found on the way:
>
> In Tetrahedra of Space, author P. Schuyler Miller employs sign
> language as a means of communication between aliens and
> humans. This is, however, not before having considered other
> methods such as drawings. A notable attempt from the novel is that
> the human in the story draws a diagram of the solar system to
> explain to the alien its heliocentric nature. This method is
> susceptible to the arbitrariness of images. This is similar to the
> criticisms often applied to the Pioneer plaque that Frank Drake and
> Carl Sagan placed on board the Pioneer 10 spacecraft. The diagram
> in the story, much like the diagrams on the Pioneer plaque, can be
> easily misunderstood by any nonhuman life form that comes across
> it. In short, the strategy of using images to communicate with
> aliens in science fiction is not linguistically robust.
>
> <
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistics_in_science_fiction#Alien_communication>
Interesting indeed.