3 - Anyone else think they didn't have sex?
Nancy Black
I have a feeling I'm in the minority here, but I just watched "3" and
refuse to believe that Mulder and Kristen did "the deed". Sure, they're
doing some pretty passionate kissing in the bathroom, but we then see him
asleep in a chair and dressed. (If you recall, he also slept in the
chair in Scully's hotel room in "Jose Chung", but only those with really
active imaginations will think that anything sexual happened there). If
he had been in Kristen's bed, I would believe it, but when I saw he was
in the chair, I exclaimed to my husband "they didn't do it!". Then I
read the posts here and everyone writes as though it's a confirmed fact
that they did have sex. Just put me in the group that thinks that Mulder
and Scully shouldn't sleep together (except possibly in the final
episode), but they also shouldn't be with anyone else either.
Anyone else out there believe (or want to believe) it didn't happen?
Nancy B.
Jackie
On Apr 27, 1996 12:41:48 in article <3 - Anyone else think they didn't have
sex?>, 'XZH...@prodigy.com (Nancy Black)' wrote:
>Just put me in the group that thinks that Mulder
>and Scully shouldn't sleep together (except possibly in the final
>episode), but they also shouldn't be with anyone else either.
nasty...would ruin the wonderful friendship and partnership they now
exhibit. But to say that they should not be with ANYONE else
either....geesh. What do you have against sexual satisfication?
--
Jackie
Sujjavanich@internetmci.com S. Sujjavanich
Now that you say it, I think you're right. I've been in denial that Mulder and Kristen slept
together - Chris Carter wanted us viewers to see that Mulder wasn't a priest, and I figured that
meant that he had meant that they had slept together.
Whatever the case, "3" is very depressing for me! The whole way through I missed Scully a lot!
Sujjavanich
Sawnotes
I never believed it and have said so all along. Unless they did it in the
bathroom, standing up against the sink and removing very little, I can't
believe he'd get out of bed, get dressed, and then go to sleep in a chair.
Unless he just is incapable of sleeping in a bed?
I don't know. At least over this issue, I DO NOT Want To Believe!
just della
On 27 Apr 1996 12:41:48 GMT, XZH...@prodigy.com (Nancy Black) was urged to share:
>I have a feeling I'm in the minority here, but I just watched "3" and
>refuse to believe that Mulder and Kristen did "the deed". Sure, they're
>doing some pretty passionate kissing in the bathroom, but we then see him
>asleep in a chair and dressed. (If you recall, he also slept in the
>chair in Scully's hotel room in "Jose Chung", but only those with really
>active imaginations will think that anything sexual happened there). If
>he had been in Kristen's bed, I would believe it, but when I saw he was
>in the chair, I exclaimed to my husband "they didn't do it!". Then I
>read the posts here and everyone writes as though it's a confirmed fact
>that they did have sex.
>Just put me in the group that thinks that Mulder and Scully shouldn't sleep
>together (except possibly in the final episode), but they also shouldn't
>be with anyone else either.
geeze . . . what're they 'sposed to do? you don't leave
them with much. :-/
>Anyone else out there believe (or want to believe) it didn't happen?
>
>Nancy B.
>
>
>
>
________________________________________________________________
"Sin is a dangerous toy in the hands of the virtuous. It should
be left to the congenitlly sinful, who know when to play with it
and when to let it alone." --H.L. Mencken
------------...@ix.netcom.com-------------------------
Pandora Box
Sawnotes wrote:
>
> I never believed it and have said so all along. Unless they did it in the
> bathroom, standing up against the sink and removing very little, I can't
> believe he'd get out of bed, get dressed, and then go to sleep in a chair.
> Unless he just is incapable of sleeping in a bed?
Hi Fellow X-philes,
I have been lurking for a couple of weeks now it is
time for me to put in my 2 cents. THEY DID THE NASTY. David Duchovny
confirmed in this month's Rolling Stone. Mulder did sleep with Kristin on
that episode. I found their scenes together really erotic since they were
lovers in real life at that time. So if they didn't do the deed , I bet
they sure as hell did it when they got home that night. God, that man can
kiss!
Pandora Box
Lisa DaFoe
Nancy Black wrote:
>
> I have a feeling I'm in the minority here, but I just watched "3" and
> refuse to believe that Mulder and Kristen did "the deed". Sure, they're
> doing some pretty passionate kissing in the bathroom, but we then see him
> asleep in a chair and dressed. (If you recall, he also slept in the
> chair in Scully's hotel room in "Jose Chung", but only those with really
> active imaginations will think that anything sexual happened there). If
> he had been in Kristen's bed, I would believe it, but when I saw he was
> in the chair, I exclaimed to my husband "they didn't do it!". Then I
> read the posts here and everyone writes as though it's a confirmed fact
> that they did have sex. Just put me in the group that thinks that Mulder
> and Scully shouldn't sleep together (except possibly in the final
> episode), but they also shouldn't be with anyone else either.
>
>
> Nancy B.
Nancy, honey, don't kid yourself. When John grabbed Kristen in the
living room, he said "I had to wait until you were finished." If they
weren't having sex, what was he waiting for? They did it! Please don't
begrudge Mulder having sex once in three years.
--
Lisa lda...@ix.netcom.com
DFW Reserve Corps Mulder/Scully 96
X-Angst Anonymous Trust No One But Them!
Another Bleepin' X-Phile
Bennetta Schmidt
In <4lt4mc$1j...@useneta1.news.prodigy.com> XZH...@prodigy.com (Nancy
Black) writes:
>
>I have a feeling I'm in the minority here, but I just watched "3" and
>refuse to believe that Mulder and Kristen did "the deed". Sure,
they're
>doing some pretty passionate kissing in the bathroom, but we then see
him
>asleep in a chair and dressed.
Except he wasn't wearing his shoes, and I doubt he took them off to
shave! ;)
If
>he had been in Kristen's bed, I would believe it, but when I saw he
was
>in the chair, I exclaimed to my husband "they didn't do it!".
If you looked, you would have seen the bed was messed up and Kristen
was wearing only a sweat shirt. Sorry, but they did it while John
watched, then they got up to get dressed. Mulder fell asleep in the
chair when he was getting ready to put on his shoes, while Kristen was
talking to John in the kitchen.
>
>Anyone else out there believe (or want to believe) it didn't happen?
>
>Nancy B.
>
In a word, NO.
Bennetta
Champey
In article <4lu1f3$7...@newsbf02.news.aol.com>, sawn...@aol.com (Sawnotes)
writes:
>I never believed it and have said so all along. Unless they did it in the
>bathroom, standing up against the sink and removing very little, I can't
>believe he'd get out of bed, get dressed, and then go to sleep in a
chair.
>Unless he just is incapable of sleeping in a bed?
I tend not to believe it either HOWEVER . . .where does it say you have to
remove ANY clothes to have sex. Last I checked all you need is a few
minor readjustments. . .
Barbara
Phenex Tiffany
Ok..they DID have sex. Carter even said that that was why the show bombed was
because he had 2 that were normally intimate being intimate on tv. he said that
that was why it didn't work. Anyway..for all you NONbelievers..BELIEVE..there
is PROOF! the man s
aid it himself..later all!
TNW7
XZH...@prodigy.com (Nancy Black) wrote:
> I have a feeling I'm in the minority here, but I just
> watched "3" and refuse to believe that Mulder and Kristen
> did "the deed". Sure, they're doing some pretty passionate
> kissing in the bathroom, but we then see him asleep in a
> chair and dressed. (If you recall, he also slept in the
> chair in Scully's hotel room in "Jose Chung", but only
> those with really active imaginations will think that
> anything sexual happened there). If he had been in
> Kristen's bed, I would believe it, but when I saw he was in
> the chair, I exclaimed to my husband "they didn't do it!".
> Then I read the posts here and everyone writes as though
> it's a confirmed fact that they did have sex. Just put me
> in the group that thinks that Mulder and Scully shouldn't
> sleep together (except possibly in the final episode), but
> they also shouldn't be with anyone else either.
>
> Anyone else out there believe (or want to believe) it
> didn't happen?
Earlier in "3", Mulder mentioned that he didn't get a motel room because
(since Scully's abduction) he didn't sleep anymore. One would assume that
at night he sat somewhere and occasionally dozed, as it would be
impossible for any human to go weeks without sleep. In "3", the
implication was that he had sex with Kristen (perhaps on the bathroom
floor or perhaps in bed) and then got dressed and sat in the chair because
he thought he wasn't going to fall sleep. He then dozed-off. [People who
have trouble sleeping often dread getting into bed, but will fall asleep
on a couch, etc.]
TNW
Tony R. Boies
In article <4lt4mc$1j...@useneta1.news.prodigy.com>, XZH...@prodigy.com
(Nancy Black) wrote:
> I have a feeling I'm in the minority here, but I just watched "3" and
> refuse to believe that Mulder and Kristen did "the deed". Sure, they're
> doing some pretty passionate kissing in the bathroom, but we then see him
> asleep in a chair and dressed. (If you recall, he also slept in the
> chair in Scully's hotel room in "Jose Chung", but only those with really
> active imaginations will think that anything sexual happened there). If
> he had been in Kristen's bed, I would believe it, but when I saw he was
> in the chair, I exclaimed to my husband "they didn't do it!". Then I
> read the posts here and everyone writes as though it's a confirmed fact
> that they did have sex. Just put me in the group that thinks that Mulder
> and Scully shouldn't sleep together (except possibly in the final
> episode), but they also shouldn't be with anyone else either.
>
> Anyone else out there believe (or want to believe) it didn't happen?
>
> Nancy B.
Okay, but then why does the guy who breaks in after the supposed "deed"
say to Kristen "I had to wait until the two of you were finished." (or
something to that effect). What else would they be finishing at that point
in the plot?
Tony R. Boies
--
Check this out!!
http://www.shentel.net/nutmusic/nutmain.html
CEKendall
>Unless he just is incapable of sleeping in a bed?
THAT'S IT!!! =D Mulder *can't* sleep in a bed--that's why he doesn't
ahve one. The bed we see in JCFOS is simply Chung's speculation of
Mulder's activities, and Chung doesn't know about Mulder's
bed-o-phobia!!!!
----------------------------------------------------
tarvin14 masquerading as cekendall
CEKendall
> [People who
>have trouble sleeping often dread getting into bed, but will fall asleep
>on a couch, etc.]
A possible explanation for why we never see Mulder's bed?
Parisa Ahmadi
TNW7 (tn...@aol.com) wrote:
: XZH...@prodigy.com (Nancy Black) wrote:
: > I have a feeling I'm in the minority here, but I just
: > watched "3" and refuse to believe that Mulder and Kristen
: > did "the deed". Sure, they're doing some pretty passionate
you're in denial, baby.. the entire episode was basically working up to
that one point (sad, but true), it was supposed to add some credibility for
the emotional link.. there's plenty of "evidence" pointing to this, such as
(god help me for knowing this): (1) the quote "i had to wait until you were
done," (2) the change of clothes on her part (didn't she go from night
gown to tee and shorts?), etc
parisa
**
Jeff Stehman
S. Sujjavanich (S.Sujj...@internetMCI.com) wrote:
: Whatever the case, "3" is very depressing for me! The whole way through I missed Scully a lot!
Good. Then perhaps you can understand how far gone Mulder was in that
episode and why he behaved like that.
--
Jeff Stehman Senior Systems Administrator
ste...@southwind.net SouthWind Internet Access, Inc.
voice: (316)263-7963 Wichita, KS
URL for Wichita Area Chamber of Commerce: http://www.southwind.net/ict/
Bennetta Schmidt
In <4m3785$b...@mark.ucdavis.edu> ez04...@rocky.ucdavis.edu (Parisa
I think the clincher is that in the Rolling Stone interview, DD says
Mulder had sex with Kristen. If he doesn't know, nobody does!
Bennetta
Renaud LAFFONT
In article <3182B3...@ix.netcom.com>, lda...@ix.netcom.com says...
>
>Nancy Black wrote:
Just put me in the group that thinks that Mulder
>> and Scully shouldn't sleep together (except possibly in the final
>> episode), but they also shouldn't be with anyone else either.
>>
>> Anyone else out there believe (or want to believe) it didn't happen?
>>
>> Nancy B.
>
>living room, he said "I had to wait until you were finished." If they
>weren't having sex, what was he waiting for? They did it! Please don't
>begrudge Mulder having sex once in three years.
>
>--
>Lisa lda...@ix.netcom.com
>DFW Reserve Corps Mulder/Scully 96
>X-Angst Anonymous Trust No One But Them!
>Another Bleepin' X-Phile
In the Vampire's episode in the second series, I thought Mulder did it with
the vampire female (She's his real life girlfriend or wife).
Anyway, if Mulder has sex once in three years, then what Scully hadn't had sex
as well?
Renaud
Lucas
> I never believed it and have said so all along. Unless they did it in the
> bathroom, standing up against the sink and removing very little, I can't
> believe he'd get out of bed, get dressed, and then go to sleep in a chair.
> Unless he just is incapable of sleeping in a bed?
> I don't know. At least over this issue, I DO NOT Want To Believe!
I'm sorry I hate to be bitchy and burst your bubble, but yes they did do
it in three (let's hope not in three minutes, however). There is a time
lapse between the bathroom and Mulder waking up in a state of deshabille
in the bedroom. The poor man is celibate most of the time, can't he get
lucky just once in three years? The woman did die after all, and he did
break it off with her in real life. Take heart, he's been good since then
and kept his dalliances to the celluloid type a la home video. Bambi did
choose the old fart in the wheel chair and detective White did get the
brush off. There has been a slight return of UST so be brave and try to
forgive.
Becky Lucas, borrowing the e-mail of the sibling
--
101-ism:
The tendency to pick apart, often in minute detail, all aspects of life using half understood pop psychology as a tool.
Douglas Coupland-GENERATION X
Jessica Lucas-pretending to be:
osgo...@mailo.starnetinc.com
Michael Angelo Interbartolo
S. Sujjavanich (S.Sujj...@internetMCI.com) wrote:
: Now that you say it, I think you're right. I've been in denial that Mulder
: together - Chris Carter wanted us viewers to see that Mulder wasn't a priest
: Whatever the case, "3" is very depressing for me! The whole way through I
: missed Scully a lot!
: Sujjavanich
In the recent issue of Rolling Stones with DD and GA on the cover in bed,
in the article it discusses who if anyone Mulder has slept with and DD
says that Mulder only slept with the woman in "3". So I guess that
settles it. I think in the article Chris Carter also says that is the
only person Mulder has slept with.
Mike I 3
Nancy Black
OK, enough replies folks. I concede, Mulder and Kristen *DID* have sex
in "3". In my defense, I posted the original note before the US Rolling
Stone article came out. I have since read the article and if DD says
they did it, then it must be true. I also originally missed (in the
episode) John saying he was waiting for them to finish, but have since
heard it upon watching the episode again on tape. I know the intention
was for the audience to think they had sex, but I thought, since the
actual act wasn't shown (unlike Skinner and the
prostitute in "Avatar"), there was some room for doubt. I don't have to
like it, and I don't (both the fact it happened and the episode in
general), but I'll admit I was wrong.
Nancy B.