On 2018-05-14 5:44 PM, anim8rfsk wrote:
> In article <pdcp2c$u56$
1...@dont-email.me>,
> Rhino <
no_offlin...@example.com> wrote:
>
>> On 2018-05-14 1:35 PM, Ubiquitous wrote:
>>> WE might accept as axiomatic the belief that patience is a virtue.
>>> However, over the decades, several notable and even celebrated
>>> science fiction TV series have failed to live up to this ideal.
>>>
>>> Instead of demonstrating patience and prudence, their makers have
>>> instead demonstrated radical impatience, and — after promising first
>>> season sorties — instituted sweeping changes that, in some cases,
>>> threw away the baby with the bath water.
>>>
>>> Below is a list of five science fiction programs that — had they
>>> adhered more closely to their original format — might have survived
>>> the turbulent air-waves for several additional seasons.
>>>
>>> In other words, these science fiction TV series were not broke, and
>>> simply didn’t require the kind of dramatic format “fixing†they
>>> endured.
>>>
>>> Space: 1999 (1975 – 1977)
>>>
>>> During its first season on the air, Gerry and Sylvia Anderson’s
>>> 1970s-era space adventure drew “amazing ratings†in the U.S
>>> according to Dick Adler at The Los Angeles Times (January 7, 1976).
>>> Although prominent critics such as Isaac Asimov complained about the
>>> series’ scientifically-challenged premise, which involved the moon
>>> blasted out of Earth’s orbit and visiting other worlds, the series
>>> was nonetheless incredibly impressive in terms of production design,
>>> miniature effects, and philosophical storylines.
>>>
>>> The Wall Street Journal termed Space:1999 “the most flashy,
>>> gorgeous sci-fi trip ever to appear on TV,†(“Sailing Along on a
>>> Moonbase Way,†Fall 1975) while Newsweek’s Harry Waters enthused
>>> that not since Stanley Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968) had “
>>> sci-fi freaks had the chance to trip out on so much surrealistic
>>> gimmickry†(“Spaced Out,†October 1975).
>>>
>>> Meanwhile, the same paper that had printed Asimov’s negative review
>>> — The New York Times — suggested that Space: 1999 featured “what no
>>> other TV science-fiction program except Star Trek had – good stories
>>> and good special effects.†(October 19, 1975).
>>>
>>> But at the end of Space:1999’s first year, however, the series stood
>>> on the chopping block of cancellation and American producer Fred
>>> Freiberger replaced Sylvia Anderson. In an effort to save the
>>> series, Mr. Freiberger “Americanized†Space:1999 to a substantial
>>> degree.
>>>
>>> One major change was largely successful. Space:1999 Year Two
>>> introduced the shape-shifting metamorph named Maya, played by the
>>> charming and lovely Catherine Schell. Although Maya was a
>>> delightful alien character, the series simultaneously jettisoned
>>> familiar old hands such as Barry Morse’s Victor Bergman and Prentis
>>> Hancock’s controller, Paul Morrow.
>>>
>>> Just as troubling, perhaps, Space: 1999’s singular sense of
>>> atmospheric, philosophical terror — in which all of space was an
>>> unsolvable mystery that the Alphans were psychologically unprepared
>>> to contend with — was overturned. That vision of the universe was
>>> replaced with a one more consistent with the tenets of the then-
>>> popular Star Trek. In other words, the marooned denizens of
>>> Moonbase Alpha suddenly found themselves battling sentient plants,
>>> silicon life-forms, and amazon women in cat-suits, as well as a
>>> Harry Mudd like trader/rogue called “The Taybor.†Space:1999 Year
>>> Two featured a lot of action, but much of it involved bad monster
>>> suits too, a far cry from the terrifying monster of the first season
>>> triumph, “Dragon’s Domain.â€
>>>
>>> In an effort to rival the popular Star Trek, the makers of
>>> Space:1999 thus made their series more like its competitor, a
>>> change which ultimately doomed the series. Instead of growing an
>>> audience based on their notable first season successes, the series
>>> producers fixed the things that, simply, weren’t broken.
>>>
>>> Perhaps series star Martin Landau said it best. He told Starlog in
>>> July of 1986 (Lee Goldberg: “Martin Landau: Space Age Hero,†page
>>> 45.): “They changed it because a bunch of American minds got into
>>> the act and they decided to do many thing they felt were more
>>> commercial. I think the show’s beauty was that it wasn’t commercial,
>>> it had its own rhythm. I felt the episodes we started with in the
>>> first season were much more along the lines I wanted to go. To some
>>> extent, that was corrupted.â€
>>>
>>> Buck Rogers in the 25th Century (1979 – 1981)
>>>
>>> Like Space:1999 before it, NBC’s post-Star Wars outer space series
>>> Buck Rogers in the 25th Century(1979 – 1981) endured a dramatic
>>> change from first season to second.
>>>
>>> The first year of the Glen Larson series had been a swashbuckling,
>>> tongue-in-cheek adventure that featured Buck Rogers (Gil Gerard) and
>>> Wilma Deering (Erin Gray) essentially acting as secret agents in the
>>> far-flung 25th century. In this capacity, they subverted space
>>> dictators, battled despots like the Draconians and vanquished cult-
>>> leaders such as Kaleel (Jack Palance). They even rescued a
>>> “defector†from a communist-styled planet during the “space
>>> Olympics†episode, “Olympiad.â€
>>>
>>> Accordingly, the first season of Buck Rogers felt a lot like an
>>> outer-space variation on Mission: Impossible, only cheekier, and
>>> with less information to keep track of.
>>>
>>> Although expensive to produce, Buck Rogers had found a distinctive
>>> groove, and proved popular with viewers. It even made the Nielson
>>> Ratings top forty, all while battling the Robin Williams juggernaut
>>> on ABC: Mork and Mindy.
>>>
>>> At the end of the first season, producer Bruce Lansbury departed and
>>> was replaced by Gunsmoke’s John Mantley, a talent who enacted major
>>> alterations.
>>>
>>> Dr. Huer (Tim O’Connor), Dr. Theopolis, the Earth Defense
>>> Directorate, and the Draconians were dropped from the format
>>> entirely, and Buck became a crew member aboard a starship called the
>>> Searcher, instead. The Searcher had been assigned to find the “lost
>>> tribes†of Earth; people who had departed their home planet after
>>> the nuclear holocaust of the 1980s.
>>>
>>> And yes, that description sounds an awful lot like the premise of
>>> Battlestar Galactica (1978-1979).
>>>
>>> Buck’s second season introduced a new resident alien, a bird-man
>>> called Hawk (Thom Christopher), while Wilma Deering became less
>>> assertive and much less central to the action. The second season
>>> also the introduction of an irritating new robot called Crichton,
>>> and saw Mel Blanc leave the series as the voice of Twiki.
>>>
>>> Although Thom Christopher was always impressive as Hawk, and made
>>> the alien a compelling character (much as Catherine Schell had done
>>> with Maya on Space:1999), the shift in story-telling and tenor was
>>> the real problem. The stories on the new Buck Rogers became wannabe
>>> Star Trek episodes about new “civilizations of the week.†One
>>> especially dire episode saw Buck and Wilma dealing with a golden
>>> alien who aged backwards (like Jonathan Winters’ Mearth on Mork and
>>> Mindy), while another involved mischievous dwarves run amok on the
>>> Searcher.
>>>
>>> Series star Gil Gerard was not pleased, and reportedly felt that the
>>> season was a rip off of both Star Trek and Battlestar Galactica.
>>>
>>> The re-vamped Buck Rogers was canceled after half-a-season.
>>>
>>> War of the Worlds (1988 – 1990)
>>>
>>> The premise of this late-1980s syndicated series was that Martian
>>> invaders had attempted to invade Mother Earth in 1953, in the events
>>> depicted by the George Pal movie. However, “common bacteriaâ€
>>> stopped the alien assault. But when scientists discovered later that
>>> the aliens were hibernating, not dead, the U.S. government
>>> suppressed the news, fearing a panic.
>>>
>>> Instead, the U.S. army sealed up the alien bodies in black drums and
>>> stored them at remote military installation called “Jericho.â€
>>> Meanwhile, the world at large seemed to forget entirely about the
>>> alien invasion.
>>>
>>> By the year 1988, however, armed terrorists found the barrels, and
>>> the aliens awoke, stealing human form and launching a new, stealth
>>> war (of the worlds) against humanity.
>>>
>>> Dr. Harrison Blackwood (Jared Martin) led a team against the Martian
>>> sleeper cell, known as “The Advocacy.†And protecting the team from
>>> danger was the series’ most popular character, Lt. Colonel Ironhorse
>>> (Richard Chaves), formerly a member of “Delta Squad.â€
>>>
>>> Shot in Canada and produced on the cheap, War of the Worlds
>>> nonetheless drew a large and supportive fan base throughout its
>>> first season, in part due to the fact that series often highlighted
>>> over-the-top gore, and showcased some quirky humor.
>>>
>>> But you know where this is headed, right? Everything changed for
>>> the second season. In the re-booted War of the Worlds, Earth was no
>>> longer the planet we know, but a post-apocalyptic wasteland. Now,
>>> the heroes of the series were suddenly on the run from the aliens,
>>> and without a home base.
>>>
>>> The bad guys — The Advocacy — were also dispatched and new aliens,
>>> the Morthren, replaced them.
>>>
>>> The greatest offense, however, was that the series’ most beloved
>>> character, Ironhorse, was killed off during the first episode of
>>> season two and replaced with Adrian Paul’s John Kincaid. Paul was
>>> absolutely fine in the role, but it made zero sense to replace a
>>> popular character with a new character of similar type.
>>>
>>> In short, the second season of War of the Worlds completely
>>> destroyed the world of the first season, killed the most popular
>>> character, and replaced one alien invasion with another. The
>>> changes were so radical and sweeping that the series was virtually
>>> unrecognizable, and it was canceled by the end of its sophomore
>>> season.
>>>
>>> SeaQuest DSV (1993 – 1995)
>>>
>>> This Steven Spielberg –produced series from the mid-1990s began its
>>> TV life as a serious, scientific, and futuristic exploration of the
>>> Earth’s sea. The meme was displayed ably in SeaQuest’s opening
>>> voice-over narration: “The 21st century: mankind has colonized the
>>> last unexplored region on Earth; the ocean. As captain of the
>>> seaQuest and its crew, we are its guardians, for beneath the surface
>>> lies the future…â€
>>>
>>> The series involved the voyages of a state of the art sub, SeaQuest,
>>> which operated under the aegis of the UEO (United Earth Oceans).
>>> SeaQuest was “the largest deep sea exploration vehicle ever,†and
>>> outfitted with a crew of 124 scientists and 88 military personnel.
>>> Playing the captain, Bridger, was the late Roy Scheider.
>>>
>>> Among the other crew members on SeaQuest were the headstrong
>>> executive officer, Jonathan Ford (Don Franklin), head of science and
>>> medicine, Dr. Kristin Westphalen (Stephanie Beacham), Chief Engineer
>>> Katherine Hitchcock (Stacy Haiduk) and communications officer Tim
>>> O’Neill (Ted Raimi).
>>>
>>> Other notable crew members and passengers on the first season of
>>> SeaQuest DSV included the teenage genius and computer whiz, Lucas
>>> Wolenczak (Jonathan Brandis) and Darwin, a dolphin who could
>>> communicate verbally with Bridger and the others using an instrument
>>> called a “vocorder.â€
>>>
>>> During the first season there was a dedicated attempt every week on
>>> SeaQuest to marry a hard-science concept or mission with some small
>>> but fantastical aspect of the sci-fi genre. In “Treasure of the
>>> Mind,†for instance, the SeaQuest discovered the lost Great Library
>>> of Alexandria intact at the bottom of the Mediterranean Sea. Another
>>> story (“Games†) saw the sub exploring the polar ice caps.
>>>
>>> Finally, each episode of the first season ended with a brief
>>> epilogue featuring the series’ science adviser, oceanographer Dr.
>>> Robert Ballard. His monologues would always point out how specific
>>> aspects of the episode were based on fact; and then encourage
>>> viewers to learn more about the subject.
>>>
>>> But reality and science went out the window in the dramatically re-
>>> vamped second season.
>>>
>>> Fully half the cast was axed from the show, including Stacy Haiduk,
>>> John D’Aquino, Stephanie Beacham. Worse, their replacement
>>> characters were obvious rejects from the Star Trek universe. The
>>> new doctor had Counselor Troi-like empathic powers, for instance,
>>> and other characters were genetically-engineered “resident†aliens
>>> called “Daggers.â€
>>>
>>> Once more, the real problem, however, was not the cast-changes, but
>>> the shift in storytelling style. The second season found the
>>> SeaQuest encountering giant sea monsters and on one wretched
>>> occasion, the Greek God, Poseidon/Neptune.
>>>
>>> In a notorious with the Orlando Sentinel on September 13, 1994 star
>>> Roy Scheider lambasted the new direction of Sea Quest. He said he
>>> was “ashamed†of the series, and noted that the new stories were
>>> “junk.†He also said that the series was “not even good fantasy. I
>>> mean Star Trek does this stuff much better than we can do it. To me
>>> the show is now 21 Jump Street meets Star Dreck.â€
>>>
>>> Dark Angel (2000 – 2002)
>>>
>>> Long before Avatar, James Cameron produced this sci-fi series with
>>> writing partner Charles Eglee, and Jessica Alba starred as “Max,†a
>>> genetically-enhanced woman born of Project Manticore.†Max, a
>>> “transgen†lived in an economically depressed and EMG-ravaged
>>> Seattle of the year 2020.
>>>
>>> In this dystopian future, the United States had become a third-world
>>> country with its treasures sold off to the highest bidders. The
>>> series also anticipated the use of automated military drones in
>>> combat, and featured a Seattle run by a “protectorate†of corrupt
>>> agencies.
>>>
>>> The first season of Dark Angel was extremely grounded in gritty
>>> reality, and saw Max working with a resourceful journalist/crusader,
>>> Logan Cale (Michael Weatherly) known as “Eyes Only.†He called
>>> himself “the only free voice left in†Seattle, and made it his
>>> business to expose the corrupt. Cale ran a version of WikiLeaks
>>> before such a thing existed.
>>>
>>> Although initial ratings were strong — in the realm of 17 million
>>> viewers for the premiere episode — Dark Angel was barely renewed by
>>> Fox for a second season. And that second season was quite different
>>> in style and feel from the first, a veritable dumbing down or
>>> lobotomy of the premise.
>>>
>>> Suddenly, Max became surrounded by other genetic mutations — the
>>> equivalent of “resident aliens†– and had to care for a chimera
>>> creature called Joshua (Kevin Durand), a dog-boy of sorts. This
>>> dreadful character offered lame comic relief and in one terrible
>>> episode (“Medium is the Message†) ate a tube of paint.
>>>
>>> In just one season, the show went from being a smart exploration of
>>> dystopia, military rule, and economic depression to a partially-
>>> comedic effort that ramped up the romantic angles, and featured a
>>> love triangle between Logan, Max, and future Supernatural star
>>> Jensen Ackles, as a transgen named Alec. Similarly, many supporting
>>> cast members from the first season were either axed or given
>>> substantially less screen-time than before.
>>>
>>> Today, history might remember Space:1999, Buck Rogers in the 25th
>>> Century, War of the Worlds, SeaQuest DSV, and Dark Angel quite
>>> differently if their second season re-vamps had not so radically
>>> altered the very qualities that made the programs successes in the
>>> first place.
>>>
>>> These series — trees cut down in winter, as it were — weren’t broken
>>> to begin with, and history now records that many of these efforts to
>>> “fix them†were misguided…or worse, the very reason they were
>>> cancelled.
>>>
>> I think I can offer an example of a show that got BETTER after a revamp.
>>
>> I have only dim recollections at this point but Lost in Space had a
>> major revamp too in Season 2. As I recall, Season 1 found them on the
>> planet they had landed in the pilot (or second episode) for the entire
>> season. I remember being disappointed that they weren't seeing any other
>> planets. But then, in Season 2, starting very early on, they started
>> travelling to other stars and planets and hardly ever spent more than
>> one episode on a given planet. At the time, I thought that was a big
>> improvement. Lost in Space ran three seasons didn't it? If so, that is
>> one longer than the other examples listed.
>>
>> Mind you, I was only a kid when all this took place and had different
>> sensibilities than I do today. If I were watching the show for the first
>> time as an adult, I might be more distressed than pleased that they'd
>> started gallivanting around the universe instead of staying put on tthe
>> original planet. Or not.
>
> OMG, Rhino, not to be unkind, but you're as 'wrong as Ian' here.
>
Uh oh. I was prepared to be wrong - I can't remember what I had for
lunch yesterday so remembering TV shows from 50 years ago is a dicey
proposition at best - but I hadn't expected to be *that* wrong....
> LOST IN SPACE is one of the very few examples of a show that cratered in
> and then got better. Season 2 is universally considered the low point,
> what with the space vikings and god help us the Questing Beast and such.
>
> While it's true they have a much welcome lift off in season 2 (leaving
> all their friends on the planet to die horribly), by the 4th (IIRC) ep
> they're settled back in on a planet that looks suspiciously like their
> old one.
>
> Now, in season 3, they lift off again, and actually have several
> episodes with space adventures and a lack of silliness until they
> finally settle down and let Smith ruin the show again with space hippies
> and the like.
>
You either have a much better memory than me or you've seen it more
recently, perhaps in syndication somewhere or maybe it's out on DVD. I
bow to your obviously superior recollection of the show :-)
--
Rhino