On Monday, April 23, 2018 at 2:47:52 PM UTC-4, jack wrote:
> OTOH, I remember seeing a long time ago the Spencer Tracy flick Northwest Passage ( which had nothing to do with it), about the French and Indian War (I may have posted this before), where in a verisimilitude rare for even 1940s Hollywood, the colonials openly and favorably-presented, conducted a genocidal raid on an Indian village, killing all in it.
I'm not sure I'd characterize the actual raid as being genocidal since the orders for the raid included "Amherst's orders to Rogers on September 13 included the following: "Remember the barbarities that have been committed by the enemy's Indian scoundrels on every occasion, where they had an opportunity of showing their infamous cruelties on the King's subjects, which they have done without mercy. Take your revenge, but don't forget ... it is my orders that no women or children are killed or hurt."" However, when the attack occurred, "Amherst's order to avoid killing women and children was lost in the frenzy."
They also took prisoners although I'm not sure for what reason. However, "Robert Kirkwood, in a relatively unadorned account, tells how Rogers killed one of their prisoners, an Indian woman, butchered the remains, and divided them among his men."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Francis_Raid
Also, this raid took place during the French and Indian War and St. Francis was regarded as a staging ground for many attacks upon the British. There weren't many men in the town at the time of the attack because they had gone to fight for the French.
In the search for realism where do you come down on keeping the dog's name or changing it for the proposed remake of Dam Busters?