Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Best/Worst Hosts of All Time...

42 views
Skip to first unread message

Richard Berger

unread,
Aug 17, 2001, 8:36:40 PM8/17/01
to
I'd be very interested in who the esteemed members of
this ng consider to be among the best game show hosts.
I can easily imagine the charming and witty Bill Cullen
(especially in his younger days) would be high on the list.
I'd also expect Gene Rayburn to be right up there for the
same reasons.

Both of these emcees had the ability to indulge in comedic
repartee while not losing control of the game situation. In
other words, they each possessed likeability and a good
sense of humor, along with a sense of pacing that didn't
permit the goofiness to run roughshod over the game
itself. At least, that's how I've always viewed them.

On the flip side of the coin, there are hosts that turn off
the viewer through the sheer force of personality (or lack
thereof). I've had conversations with folks who swear that
Allen Ludden was as bland and uninteresting as a shoelace.
I don't agree with that assessment, although I can under-
stand their viewpoint. (Besides, anybody married to the
lovely and talented Betty White HAS to have something
going for him in the personality department. I know he
wasn't all THAT rich).

As far as I'm concerned, the poster boy of bad hosts
would be someone like Wink Martindale. Not only did
he have a very insincere smile (again, in my opinion),
but I found him to be exceedingly slow-witted. (Some
would say stoopid, but not I). Yes, old Wink is likely a
nice guy and all, but any time I saw him on a game
show, I'd inevitably find myself becoming irritated
with his clueless style. Anybody else concur with
this? Who would be your candidates for best and
worst hosts and why?

= R =

Adam Michaels

unread,
Aug 17, 2001, 9:20:53 PM8/17/01
to
>Who would be your candidates for best and
>worst hosts and why?

This one is easy!!! These are people from Nickelodeon game shows that have
been the worst hosts ever!

Wesley Eure-Finders Keepers-He always seems like he has no idea how to play the
game, he tells the worst kiddie jokes in the book, and you can always tell he
is thinking of what to say next

Skip Lackey-Think Fast-Umm ahh emmm BLUE TEAM GETS THE POINTS!!! (Everyone
screams). He was a great host for a kids show, but he everything he said was
not left without a "ummm ahh, stutter, stutter" Also, he always forgot they
played for dollars, not points! GEEZ!

Robb Edward Morris-Make The Grade-He is the most blaaa host I have ever seen
for a kids game show. Lew Schneider quit, and they got a guy who tried to act
like him, DIDN'T WORK!!

Michael Carrington-Think Fast-Much better than Skip, but he still wasn't fit
for that job.
*FACT-Carrington announced on the CBS late night game show A Perfect Score.

GOOD NICKELODEON HOSTS:
Mike O'Malley
Lew Schneider
MARC SUMMERS-Best of the best
Larry Toffler
Phil Moore


Send Me Some E-mail At-gs...@yahoo.com
Check Out Adam's Game Show Bazaar!
http://www.geocities.com/amwbeatle/

John Sergent

unread,
Aug 19, 2001, 6:34:22 AM8/19/01
to
I certainly can't agree to Wink Martindale being one of the worst! Look
no further than BOTH versions of Tic Tac Dough after his. My least
favorite? Mike Reilly, though it's possible he wouldn't have been so bad
if he hadn't had to explain rules in detail after and during each
question.

SpeedyG242

unread,
Aug 19, 2001, 8:53:22 AM8/19/01
to
>This one is easy!!! These are people from Nickelodeon game shows that have
>been the worst hosts ever!

You forgot one big one. Kirk Fogg, from Legends of the Hidden Temple. He
couldn't even read the teleprompter well. And even the worst game show hosts
abandon SOME of a show's gimmicks if there are plenty of them. He didn't.


Shirliee

unread,
Aug 19, 2001, 11:02:00 AM8/19/01
to
The best, IMHO, is Richard Dawson, without a doubt. He's warm, witty,
charming, and an absolute master at putting people at ease and making
them feel comfortable. Very few game show hosts make the home viewers
feel a strong connection to them, but Richard had that gift in spades
- you could feel his warmth coming through the television...The worst,
in my mind, will always be Chuck Barris : )

Jim Maxwell

unread,
Aug 19, 2001, 12:16:23 PM8/19/01
to
John Sergent <feu...@ix.netcom.com> wrote in message news:<feudfan-BA95E0...@nntp.ix.netcom.com>...

I would have to say my favorite gameshows host of all time is Bob
Eubanks, because of how he did the 25 point bonus question. I do like
Wink Martindale. I heard a clip of an episode of Joker's Wild with
Jack Barry, and I didn't like him too well. He sounded dperessed.
Did Jack Barry sound so depressed? I would nominate him as the worst
host of all time.

CoolBritguy82

unread,
Aug 19, 2001, 12:48:19 PM8/19/01
to
Although it was highly forgettable, Paul Reubens couldn't host worth anything.
A guy who freezes up when a cue isn't given has got to be hands down the worst.
At least ones like Patrick Wayne and Rolf Benerschke TRIED.

$600 or what's behind Door #3

unread,
Aug 19, 2001, 1:11:47 PM8/19/01
to
Richard Berger <rbe...@fastmdu.com> wrote in message news:<9hcrnt8vrk8alg82l...@4ax.com>...

Of course, the good ones are people like Bill Cullen, Tom Kennedy, Bob
Barker, and Gene RAyburn...

I'm surprised no one's mentioned the ABSOLUTE worst host yet, and this
topic already well underway.

Jim Caldwell...

(shudders)

Sherman Potter

unread,
Aug 19, 2001, 7:38:16 PM8/19/01
to
"Richard Berger" <rbe...@fastmdu.com> wrote in message
news:9hcrnt8vrk8alg82l...@4ax.com...
> Who would be your candidates for best and
> worst hosts and why?

Not long ago there was a discussion of game show hosts and there was
established a "Convy Line," similar to the baseball Mendoza Line, for game
show hosts. The Convy Line separates the good hosts from the bad hosts;
Bert Convy was the Mario Mendoza of the genre -- nobody less talented than
Bert Convy should ever have been given the keys to a game show.

It was also agreed that while Bert Convy was the Mario Mendoza, Bill
Cullen was the Babe Ruth and Jack Barry was the Pete Rose.


Fight The Power

unread,
Aug 19, 2001, 8:16:33 PM8/19/01
to
coolbr...@aol.com (CoolBritguy82) scribbled in message
news:<20010819124819...@mb-fp.aol.com>...

> Although it was highly forgettable, Paul Reubens couldn't host worth anything.
> A guy who freezes up when a cue isn't given has got to be hands down the worst.
> At least ones like Patrick Wayne and Rolf Benerschke TRIED.

Uh, maybe cuz it wasn't Paul Reubens...it was Troy Stevens!!!

Paul Reubens hosting as himself would totally kick ass.

CoolBritguy82

unread,
Aug 19, 2001, 9:26:31 PM8/19/01
to
>Uh, maybe cuz it wasn't Paul Reubens...it was Troy Stevens!!!
>Paul Reubens hosting as himself would totally kick ass.

Jamie (what a coincidence), Paul Reuben did an amusing job (at least on the
first show) of playing Troy Stevens. However, when it came to actually carrying
the show, he couldn't do jack. (horrible pun was intended.) I shudder at the
though at Paul Reubens hosting as himself...but that's just me.


deepmilk

unread,
Aug 19, 2001, 11:20:06 PM8/19/01
to

> Barker, and Gene RAyburn...
>
> I'm surprised no one's mentioned the ABSOLUTE worst host yet, and this
> topic already well underway.
>
> Jim Caldwell...
>
> (shudders)

How about Chris Harrison?


BudMann9

unread,
Aug 19, 2001, 11:34:03 PM8/19/01
to
Is Dick Clark the Ted Williams?

Is Bob Barker the Joe DiMaggio?

Is Alex Trebek the Ty Cobb?

Is Pat Sajak the Roger Maris?

Is Betty White the Jackie Robinson?

One of the GOOD AOL users

unread,
Aug 20, 2001, 1:24:51 AM8/20/01
to
> It was also agreed that while Bert Convy was the Mario Mendoza, Bill
>Cullen was the Babe Ruth and Jack Barry was the Pete Rose.
>

Being Bill has also hosted the most shows, could it be said he was also the
Mark McGwire*?

*or will it be Barry Bonds?


The ONE and ONLY, Brandon Foster-Gray

CAPT. TENNILLE: Simpson, you're like the son I never had.
HOMER: And you're like the father I never visit.
---"Simpson Tide" episode, "The Simpsons," 1998

Randy Amasia

unread,
Aug 20, 2001, 2:53:24 AM8/20/01
to

"Fight The Power" <jamie...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:a7f53901.0108...@posting.google.com...

Having attended the first taping of YDKJ, Paul Reubens hosting as
himself was tolerable, at best.


James R. Owen

unread,
Aug 20, 2001, 8:21:17 AM8/20/01
to
Is Joe Garagiola the Joe Garagiola?

BudMann9

unread,
Aug 20, 2001, 10:56:03 AM8/20/01
to
of course

Lynn Swann is also the Fred Lynn.

BudMann9

unread,
Aug 20, 2001, 11:02:03 AM8/20/01
to
Having hosted the most shows could make Bill Cullen the Gaylord Perry, since
Perry is a hall of famer that played for at least eight different teams.

Pete Rose played in the most baseball games, but Cullen can't be the Rose.

Berry has to be the Rose, since Rose was accused of rigging games and Berry was
involved in a rigged show.

I also think Barker and DiMaggio is a perfect fit, with one example both
having, or somewhat having, ladies-man reputations.

Maybe Alex Trebek can be the Mickey Mantle, since Mantle was known for drinking
and Trebek is rumored to be a drinker (in at least one oft-told High Rollers
finale tale).

Then again, Cobb was known for being surly and arrogant, and Trebek is
sometimes described as arrogant.

David Rigsby

unread,
Aug 20, 2001, 2:41:16 PM8/20/01
to
BudMann9 wrote...

> Is Betty White the Jackie Robinson?

No, Adam Wade was.

David Rigsby
rigsby23[at]excite[dot]com
http://go.to/rigsby4


Chris Lambert!

unread,
Aug 21, 2001, 12:01:38 PM8/21/01
to

"deepmilk" <deep...@worldnet.att.net> wrote in message
news:Gl%f7.53026$gj1.4...@bgtnsc05-news.ops.worldnet.att.net...

> > I'm surprised no one's mentioned the ABSOLUTE worst host yet, and this
> > topic already well underway.
> > Jim Caldwell...

> How about Chris Harrison?

Bob Hastings.

-C

--
Chris Lambert * Indianapolis's Own * IU '97
---------------------------------------------------
Visit the Original Game Show Page!
at http://gameshowpage.com
(There's Reality Show stuff there, too.)


Matt Ottinger

unread,
Aug 21, 2001, 2:44:59 PM8/21/01
to

"Chris Lambert!" <djc...@kiva.net> wrote ...

>
> > > I'm surprised no one's mentioned the ABSOLUTE worst host yet, and this
> > > topic already well underway.
> > > Jim Caldwell...
> > How about Chris Harrison?
>
> Bob Hastings.

I would never have thought of him, but I agree with Chris. Great choice.

--Matt
otti...@acd.net


AFIKCHUCK

unread,
Aug 22, 2001, 4:25:52 PM8/22/01
to

"Chris Lambert!" <djc...@kiva.net> wrote in message
news:9lu0lc$jhn$1...@topsy.kiva.net...
> Bob Hastings.

Amen to that...he was extremely hyper and a notorious example of why most
actors (save for Blyden, Convy, and maybe a few others) make bad GS hosts.

Chuck Donegan (The Illustrious "Chuckie Baby")

Fred McKinney

unread,
Aug 22, 2001, 11:19:17 PM8/22/01
to
Quite possibly, but I don't think Richard "kissy-face" Dawson could get
away with smoochin' on all the female contestants these days, because if he
tried it, that would be just asking for a sexual harassment suit.

Let's see, who would be my picks for best hosts of all-time? I'd probably
have to say Bill Cullen, Allen Ludden, oh, and Bob Barker has a unique way
of making people funny, of course, that will never be duplicated!

All-time worst hosts? EASY! Two words: Patrick Wayne! GEEZ, I couldn't
stand him! Oh, and another one I can't stand is Anne Robinson...I've
already had my fill of The Weakest Link, thank you very much. Another one
who, while he certainly tried, proved that he was just not quite with it
enough to be a game show host was Jim Caldwell. I like him as a host, but
sometimes I have to laugh at some of his gaffes!

Fred

shirlie...@hotmail.com (Shirliee) wrote in
<186dc404.01081...@posting.google.com>:

0 new messages