https://screenrant.com/buffy-the-vampire-slayer-fans-questions-the-initiative/
Buffy The Vampire Slayer: 10 Questions Fans Still Have About The Initiative
The Initiative had a major impact on the fourth season of Buffy The Vampire
Slayer. However, fans still have lingering questions about the group.
BY JONATHAN THOMPSON
After the fan-favorite season 3 finale, Buffy the Vampire Slayer set its
sights on the college experience, which resulted in the love-it-or-hate-it
fourth season. There were aspects of the season that were refreshing, with
new characters and engaging storylines involved. However, one thing that did
confuse fans was the introduction of the Initiative. As the Scoobies would
learn, the Initiative was a secret government effort to study and harness
the power of the supernatural for military purposes.
In season 4, viewers and Buffy were guided into the Initiative by Buffy’s
love interest, Riley Finn, who was a secret Initiative operative. The idea
that after three seasons of supernatural activity and near-apocalypses,
there was a government monster squad lurking in Sunnydale the whole time
mystified fans. It also raised a lot of questions, many of which have gone
unanswered but persist with each new Buffy binge watch.
10
How Was The Initiative Allowed In Sunnydale?
Considering what the Initiative’s agenda was, it is puzzling to determine
how the government operation ever came to open its doors in Sunnydale. In
season 3, fans discovered that Sunnydale was founded on the Hellmouth by one
of Buffy the Vampire Slayer's major villains, Mayor Richard Wilkins III.
Wilkins himself was not only evil, but he was strategic. He founded
Sunnydale as part of his plan to become a pure demon and feast on the town
in the process. However, this has led fans to question why did he not do
anything about the Initiative establishing itself in his sleep demon town?
It also begs the question of why the Initiative did absolutely nothing to
stop the Mayor’s ascension.
9
Why Did The Initiative Set Up Under A College?
Whatever the reason, the U.S. government was able to set up shop in
Sunnydale. Some fans wonder, though, why the organization chose to insert
itself below a college campus and integrate some of its key leaders and
operatives into the academic population. Other than the fact that UC
Sunnydale was an important new location in Buffy, it does not add up.
The extra lengths that the organization must have gone through to make this
happen seem ridiculous, as was their risk of exposure. Narratively, the
campus made sense because Buffy was starting school there. The setting also
allowed for Buffy and Riley, a teaching assistant, to meet and fall in love.
Logically, however, the location makes little sense on its face.
8
How Did The Government Convince Anyone To Join The Initiative?
During or after establishing itself under UC Sunnydale, the Initiative
needed to recruit operatives. Riley mentioned to Buffy that he was trained
in special operations with the U.S. Air Force before he was selected for the
Initiative. While it is unclear what Riley saw while in Special Ops, the
larger question is how the government convinced him or anyone else to join
the Initiative?
How did they introduce these candidates to the idea of the supernatural? How
did they all respond to learning that monsters are real? What happened to
recruits who could not handle it? Even for members of the military, this is
a big leap, but somehow they staffed the Initiative well.
7
Was There A Relationship Between The Initiative And The Sunnydale Military
Base?
In the season 2 episode “Innocence,” viewers learned of a very public and
visible military base in Sunnydale. In fact, the Scoobies managed to steal a
rocket launcher from the facility to destroy the Judge. So, when the
Initiative appeared in season 4, many fans wondered if there was a
relationship between the two military organizations.
That question lingers today. Sunnydale was a one-Starbucks town, so it was
unlikely it was a two-military complex town. Since viewers were meant to
suddenly believe the Initiative had been there all along, connecting it to
the known base would have made the concept more believable and less jarring.
6
Where Were The Initiative's Fraternity Commandos In Reptile Boy?
When season 4 revealed that numerous UC Sunnydale fraternity members were
secret monster hunters, many fans thought back to Buffy’s frat-demon
experience in season 2’s “Reptile Boy.” Some then wondered how the
Initiative missed the Delta Zeta Kappa annual human sacrifices to the demon
Machida.
Riley mentioned he had been living in Sunnydale for a few years, so it
stands to reason that the Initiative had been around in season 2. Would that
annual demonic event not have been something the military frat members would
have heard of? It is hard to believe, given their fraternity cover along
with the Initiative’s mission.
5
How Did The Initiative Not Know About Buffy?
One of the most bizarre moments in the introduction of the government
monster hunting squad and the research facility in Sunnydale was that said
organization had no idea Buffy was the Slayer (or the fact that she was the
latest in a long line of known Slayers in Buffy canon). In fact, Maggie
Walsh stated that they thought the Slayer was a myth.
Given every supernatural event that occurred in Sunnydale over the previous
three years and Buffy’s role in them, it seems truly unbelievable that the
Initiative did not know about her. Big Brother Walsh had security cameras in
Riley’s bedroom, but she had no idea one of her students was the Chosen One,
feared throughout the supernatural world she herself was studying. This made
the Initiative look worse than the time Spike escaped.
4
Was The Initiative Going To Do Anything About Pre-Season 4 Big Bads?
Revealing the Initiative not only begged the question of where were these
commandos during the college-related demonic events in “Reptile Boy,” but it
also caused viewers to question where they had been during the last three
seasons at all. Prior to season 4, the Scoobies averted at least four
apocalypses.
Any of those villainous Big Bads could have overpowered Buffy and destroyed
the world and the Initiative was right there all along. Did the organization
have any plans to intervene if they got too close to an apocalypse? Since
they did not know about Buffy, they had to assume no one else was going to
stop them. Perhaps they had no idea of anything outside the UC Sunnydale
sphere, but that is just silly.
3
Where Was The Initiative During The Apocalypses After Season 4?
Season 4 started and also essentially concluded the Initiative story arc.
The U.S. government determined the experiment was a failure and walked away.
After Buffy and Riley's painful breakup in season 5, Riley also walked away.
However, in season 6, he returned with an Initiative-adjacent group and in
season 7 the government returned to the old Initiative base to assist Buffy.
So, the government continued dabbling with and responding to the
supernatural, which leaves fans wondering why they never came to Buffy’s aid
during any of the apocalyptic events occurring before season 4. Narratively,
this would not have worked for Buffy’s story, but logistically it is hard to
believe that the government relied on one Slayer to repeatedly save the
world, even if it was Buffy.
2
How Did The Scoobies Never Encounter The Initiative Prior To Season 4?
As much as fans wondered how the Initiative could not have known the Slayer
was real, many also question how the Scooby gang never encountered the
commandos before season 4. Once the Initiative plot began, it was not long
before Buffy figured out what was going on.
Episodes like “Hush” even directly showed Initiative soldiers patrolling
downtown Sunnydale, which is often frequented by the Scoobies. Yes, the
Initiative was tucked away under UC Sunnydale, which the show treats almost
like a separate community from the town. Still, it seems highly unlikely
that the Scoobies never saw the Initiative in action earlier.
1
Were There Other Initiative Bases At The Other Hellmouths?
Throughout Buffy’s seven seasons, there have been multiple mentions of at
least one other Hellmouth in Cleveland. Giles even stated this again in the
series finale after the Sunnydale Hellmouth closed, and the season 7 episode
“Never Leave Me,” also showed a map that had all the other Hellmouths around
the world.
Given the Initiative’s overall mission, there is reason to question if they
had facilities at any of these other locations. The end of season 4 appeared
to fully sever government involvement with the supernatural, but seasons 5,
6, and 7 proved that to be untrue, so the question remains.
[[MY question -- how was the Initiative able to excavate such a huge
underground facility without anyone attending the college knowing about
it?]]
David