I agree with everything you said. Deshawn was one of my favorites from the start.
Caleb is a joke. It won't surprise me if Arthur Gunn wins. Then his career won't
progress any farther than it did when he was runnerup last season. He totally ruined
"Remember Me" last night. The "melody" he sang sounded nothing like the song.
If Idol can't produce a better show, then I'd prefer ABC to just hang it up. Ratings
set a low record the last Monday night they were on, so Monday nights are gone now.
Maybe some (like me) were unhappy about seeing contestants from last season show up
to throw a monkey wrench into this season.
Larc