Man: Woman offered sex for life to kill husband
By MICHELLE MILLHOLLON
mmill...@theadvocate.com
Advocate staff writer
A man on trial for murder told police in a videotaped statement that a
neighbor offered to become his sex slave if he would kill her estranged
husband.
"She said it was a standing offer, you know, about the slavery," Jeffrey
Maggio tells police detectives on the tape that was played for a jury
Wednesday.
Maggio, 32, is charged with second-degree murder in the death of Frederick
Lane Fontana.
Second-degree murder is punishable by life in prison.
Maggio has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity.
Fontana's body was found in his Plymouth Grand Fury in the 600 block of East
Roosevelt Street in April 2001. The car had been set on fire.
Autopsy results showed the victim died from manual asphyxiation, or
strangulation.
Police said Fontana's estranged wife, Hattie Rennolds, promised Maggio sex
for life in exchange for killing Fontana.
Rennolds also is charged with second-degree murder in Fontana's death. She
is awaiting trial.
At the time of the killing, Fontana and Rennolds were embroiled in a custody
dispute over their son.
Fontana filed for primary custody of the boy weeks before the killing.
Prosecutor Chris Nevils told jurors in opening statements that Fontana and
Maggio were roommates.
Rennolds lived in the same apartment complex, he said.
Maggio had multiple motives for killing Fontana, Nevils said.
The most important motive was Rennolds' sex-for-life offer, he said.
"This was a clear case of pre-meditated, deliberate murder," Nevils said.
"It was a needless murder."
Maggio's attorney, Edward Partin, said he would give his opening statements
at the end of the prosecution's case.
Maggio was arrested within days of Fontana's death.
In a videotaped statement, he told police about his bumbled attempts to kill
Fontana as they sat inside Fontana's car on the levee near the Mississippi
River.
Maggio said he first tried to stab Fontana with a steak knife but the blade
broke off the handle.
He said he didn't have any better luck with a telephone cord.
Maggio said he wrapped the cord around Fontana's neck but the cord kept
breaking.
He said he finally grabbed a heavy cord from the back seat and pulled it
around Fontana's neck until Fontana was dead.
Maggio said he drove around with the body in the car before setting the car
on fire.
He said Fontana was dead before the fire.
"I checked his pulse in his right hand," Maggio says on the tape. "I felt no
pulse."
Maggio said a friend later asked him what it felt like to kill a man.
"I told her, 'I felt like God,' " Maggio said.
Testimony resumes today in state District Judge Richard Anderson's court