Public housing slated for demolition
Donna Cornist stands outside the Stanley Rowe Towers, where she lives.
The Cincinnati Metropolitan Housing Authority is considering
demolishing the West End housing project and giving residents Section 8
vouchers. Cornist said the towers are "a mess" and that CMHA is not
maintaining them. "Old people are scared," she said.
A resident of the Stanley Row Towers crosses Linn
Street in the West End. Cincinnati Metropolitan Housing Authority is
considering following a national trend and getting rid of public
housing over the next 5-10 years.
Friday, May 23, 2014 A resident of the Stanley Row Towers crosses Linn
Street in the West End. Cincinnati Metropolitan Housing Authority is
considering following a national trend and getting rid of public
housing over the next 5-10 years.
Domonique Washington, 20, has been a resident of
Findlater Gardens most of his life. He was raised in foster care. He's
now four credits away from his GED at Cincinnati State and hopes for
better things. Washington said if they were to tear down the complex,
it wouldn't be a bad thing. He added, "It (housing) should be a
stepping stone to get your stuff in order. You shouldn't live here your
whole life. There's too too much drama."
Domonique Washington, 20, has been a resident of
Findlater Gardens most of his life. He was raised in foster care. He's
now four credits away from his GED at Cincinnati State and hopes for
better things. Washington said if they were to tear down the complex,
it wouldn't be a bad thing. He added, "It (housing) should be a
stepping stone to get your stuff in order. You shouldn't live here your
whole life. There's too too much drama."
Donna Cornist, talks about the Stanley Row Towers, behind her. She said
they're a mess. "They (CMHA) are not taking care of them. Old people
are scared." She added, "You can smell the bed bugs." Cincinnati
Metropolitan Housing Authority is considering following a national
trend and getting rid of public housing over the next 5-10 years.
Residents of Stanley Row Towers in the West End, enjoy the morning sun.
Bobby Palmer (from left), 74, Coneal Miller (he was visiting), Lige
Williams, 81, and Willie Watson, 65. The Cincinnati Metropolitan
Housing Authority is considering following a national trend and getting
rid of public housing over the next 5-10 years. Lige, a retired steel
mill worker who lives off disability and social security said he
doesn't know where he would go if the complex was torn down. He's lived
in the towers for about five years.
These 4-year-old friends were heading off to school from their Winton
Terrace apartments. Zaniyah Williams (from left), Emmanuel Giles and
his twin brother Eli. Cincinnati Metropolitan Housing Authority is
considering following a national trend and getting rid of public
housing over the next 5-10 years.
A view of apartments in Winton Terrace. Winton
Terrace was started in 1939. Cincinnati Metropolitan Housing Authority
is considering following a national trend and getting rid of public
housing over the next 5-10 years.
Some of Cincinnati's largest public housing complexes are slated for
demolition - a prospect that could transform neighborhoods but has both
tenants and West Side leaders on edge.
Roughly 1,400 housing units could disappear as Findlater Gardens and
Winton Terrace in Winton Hills and Stanley Rowe Towers in the West End
be turned to rubble, according to a plan posted on the Cincinnati
Metropolitan Housing Authority's website. The land will become "green
space," according to the plan.
And the people who live there now? They'll be given Section 8 vouchers
and sent to find housing in the community.
Right now, though, there is a waiting list for Section 8 vouchers, as
well as a waiting list to get into public housing units.
CMHA leaders were reluctant to discuss the plan with The Enquirer until
they roll out the plan to employees Tuesday morning and to the public
during a Tuesday night meeting. The plan didn't detail costs of the
demolition; officials told The Enquirer nothing would be definite until
they figure out how to pay for the changes.
"We did a total look at our portfolio and how we could provide the best
housing," said CMHA Executive Director Gregory Johnson. "We're trying
to make sure our housing is sustainable."
Community leaders are paying attention, fearful that an influx of
low-income families will weaken already struggling neighborhoods.
West Side activist Pete Witte, a former CMHA board member, said this
action will cause many to worry about what CMHA is doing. "CMHA seems
to indicate a plan for melding into existing housing the displaced
units," he said, "but time will tell if that is a practical approach."
Witte is not alone. West Siders in particular believe that the closure
of West End Public Housing (Lincoln Court and Laurel Homes) and the
gentrification of Over-the-Rhine led to significant increases in
subsidized housing in West Side neighborhoods.
It's all part of a larger plan by the Department of Housing and Urban
Development to eradicate public-housing complexes. It's a strategy that
reflects a trend across the county to turn public housing into
mixed-income developments that are family-friendly.
Advocates for the complexes' low-income residents worry the system of
vouchers is difficult to navigate and say many of the residents stay in
the same poor areas. HUD officials say the new model has been popular,
helping them move out of poverty.
Domonique Washington, 20, lives in Findlater - where he has lived on
and off through his life - while he works to get his GED. He described
life there as "rough, the survival of the fittest," because there's
drug activity and other crime.
"I can't afford to live anywhere else," Washington said. "That's a fact
for everyone here."
He supports the voucher program. "That lets people who want to succeed
get away if they want to," he said.
Resident Donna Cornist described Stanley Rowe Towers as a mess. "They
(CMHA) are not taking care of them. Elevators are broken, old people
are scared.
"You can smell the bed bugs," she added.
Elizabeth Brown, executive director of Housing Opportunities Made
Equal, said she was "very concerned" when she saw demolitions in CMHA's
annual plan, but she has been told it's more about general direction
than a set-in-stone plan. "It was very upsetting to residents," said
Brown, whose agency is the private fair-housing agency that serves
Greater Cincinnati. Among its services is a tenant advocacy program.
Brown, who typically reviews the annual plan, said there is no question
Washington is squeezing CMHA's funding. The properties are aging, but
Brown said their condition is "still a whole lot better than some of
the housing out there."
"That doesn't mean some of it is not old and at the point it needs
rehabilitation, but I wouldn't consider any of it substandard," Brown
said. "(CMHA) is a good landlord that maintains their properties."
As CMHA formulated the five-year plan, its first under Johnson, it
faced two hurdles.
o Maintaining large public-housing developments is financially
draining. It has to maintain the standard of livability in the large
complexes while running a voucher program that puts people in community
housing.
o It has to operate as the federal government continues to slash money
for public housing.
"These factors create the double whammy that has made many housing
authorities really accelerate ... closing of public housing around the
country," Witte said.
Staff photographer Liz Dufour contributed.
Hear the plan
The Cincinnati Metropolitan Housing Authority will unveil its 5-year
strategic plan at a community meeting.
When: 6 p.m. Tuesday
Where: Cintas Center at Xavier University, Schiff Family Conference
Center, 1624 Herald Ave., Evanston.
CMHA's budget
o Total budget: $121 million.
o About $40 million is spent on public housing - rent, upkeep and
capital projects.
o $71 million goes to private landlords for rent subsidies.
258 CONNECT[50]TWEET[51]LINKEDIN 11 COMMENTEMAILMORE
Read or Share this story:
http://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/politics/2014/05/26/public-housing
-slated-demolition/9602943/
http://www.cincinnati.com/picture-gallery/news/2014/05/27/housing-projects-slated-for-demolition/9619695/