Steve
Lets hear what this guy ("Jayco" a.k.a. Bill) has to say....... we're
listening.........
I want to become an amputee because:
I cost my soccer team the championship?
Steve
Chuck wrote in message <01be61ff$fd227080$dbc47ad1@win95client>...
Dave
David Sullivan heeft geschreven in bericht
<36FBB7F7...@buckmasters.com>...
If anyone understands, please explain.
An interested coward.
Chuck wrote in message <01be74e4$1a569540$79c47ad1@win95client>...
John
Nice of you to introduce yourself. How about telling us what the
fascination is. It seems you wannabes and devotees have a bad name.
Why not take this opportunity to give us a bit of insight into your
reasons.
In article <7dh1n2$qfo$1...@news.planetinternet.be>, Alexis MENSAERT
<ampu...@planetinternet.be> writes
--
Mark Eustace
I am an amputee fan (or a devotee - as we prefere to call ourselves). I have
- while searching for more info on amputees - found out about this newsgroup,
which is "perfectly straight" and is aimed towards helping people with
amputated limbs. Since I consider myself quite normal in every respect - I'd
like to know what exactly IS wrong with people attracted to amputees? I have
seen even more agressive posts following yours and I fail to see, what is
really wrong...
I agree, posting people on the net against their will might be immoral, but
for all I know my picture might be in a alt.sex.fetish.hair group. If one
finds him/herself on a cover of a newspaper or a magazine, one is proud, If
one finds himself in a fetish group (probbably far more admired and liked
than on a cover of a newspaper) one is disgusted. Go figure...
If anyone wants to know more, just post to this group, because my email is
invalid (spam protection)
__
BP Toni
-----------== Posted via Deja News, The Discussion Network ==----------
http://www.dejanews.com/ Search, Read, Discuss, or Start Your Own
Steve
toni_a...@my-dejanews.com wrote:
> I am an amputee fan (or a devotee - as we prefere to call ourselves). I have
> - while searching for more info on amputees - found out about this newsgroup,
> which is "perfectly straight" and is aimed towards helping people with
> amputated limbs. Since I consider myself quite normal in every respect - I'd
> like to know what exactly IS wrong with people attracted to amputees? I have
> seen even more agressive posts following yours and I fail to see, what is
> really wrong...
>
> I agree, posting people on the net against their will might be immoral, but
> for all I know my picture might be in a alt.sex.fetish.hair group. If one
> finds him/herself on a cover of a newspaper or a magazine, one is proud, If
> one finds himself in a fetish group (probbably far more admired and liked
> than on a cover of a newspaper) one is disgusted. Go figure...
>
> If anyone wants to know more, just post to this group, because my email is
> invalid (spam protection)
>
> __
> BP Toni
>
> -----------== Posted via Deja News, The Discussion Network ==----------
> http://www.dejanews.com/ Search, Read, Discuss, or Start Your Own
--
Dorothy
Well, how can you talk if you haven't got a brain?
Scarecrow
I don't know. But some people without brains do an awful lot of talking, don't
they?
I am one of the devotees (people fascinated and attracted to amputees). If
there is anything concerning my (our) fascination feel free to ask.
I would like to point out, that i think of myself as a perfectly normal human
being and that there is nothing very deviated in my fascination. Just like
some people are attracted to hairy, some to blond, some to short people - we
are attracted to amputees.
Have a nice day!
It is certainly not a routine practice among the populations in the world.
Nevertheless, there are people who seem to want to be amputated that have no
medical reason to do so - they have a desire to have one part or another
amputated.
And I think it is a letigimate question to ask why that is so.
> It is certainly not a routine practice among the populations in the world.
> Nevertheless, there are people who seem to want to be amputated that have no
> medical reason to do so - they have a desire to have one part or another
> amputated.
> And I think it is a letigimate question to ask why that is so.
To take a wild shot, I'd say that the reasons are quite similar to those
of transsexuals who feel they were born 'the wrong gender', only, in
this case, it's a matter of being born with more limbs than they feel
'right' having.
b@|+/-\1
--
We have to spread this around!
Great! Let's put it on the InterNet!
No. We have to reach people who's opinions actually matter.
-the Simpsons
And, i agree with the general sentiment here. A person who admires amputees
is completely different from someone who wants to be an amputee. And,
although I've heard wannabeeism compared with someone who wants to change
their sex; this also isn't comaparable. Wanting to become a woman isn't the
same as wanting an amputation.
There isn't really a good reason why anyone is attracted to anyone. Trying
to explain it isn't going to get you anywhere. How you act toward those you
are interested in is what matters. For instance, telling me that you are
attracted to me the same way someone else is attracted to blonde hair,
doesn't do anything for me. But, telling me that you find my inner strength
attractive, or that you find me more beautiful because i'm unique, or that
you find my confidence sexy; might get my attention.
Vera Little
for personal email remove 'no spam' from my address.
Vera Little wrote:
>
> Hello,
> Although I don't have any problems with someone being attracted to me
> because I'm an amputee; the 'some are attracted to (fill in the blank)- we
> are attracted to stumps' doesn't hold any water. I will tell you why: Hair,
> height, or bust size is not comparable to a disability. The difference is
> that you are attracted to a physical trait that is, at the very least, an
> inconvenience, to the people who have them.
>
> And, i agree with the general sentiment here. A person who admires amputees
> is completely different from someone who wants to be an amputee. And,
> although I've heard wannabeeism compared with someone who wants to change
> their sex; this also isn't comaparable. Wanting to become a woman isn't the
> same as wanting an amputation.
>
> There isn't really a good reason why anyone is attracted to anyone. Trying
> to explain it isn't going to get you anywhere. How you act toward those you
> are interested in is what matters. For instance, telling me that you are
> attracted to me the same way someone else is attracted to blonde hair,
> doesn't do anything for me. But, telling me that you find my inner strength
> attractive, or that you find me more beautiful because i'm unique, or that
> you find my confidence sexy; might get my attention.
>
> Vera Little
> for personal email remove 'no spam' from my address.
Vera,
there is a similarity ti TG people. I know two successful wana´s who
just
describe the same symptoms, i.e. feeling to live in the "wrong" body an
now feel
very well and "normal".
Most people do not have access to amputees unless they work in medicine
or are amputees themselves. In Britain the population of amputees is
only around .2% of the total so it is very rare. Because of this I find
it hard to believe that being around an amputee at an early age is the
reason for the attraction.
Rather than being a fetish in the traditional sense, I feel amputee
devotees are a bit cult like and enjoy being part of a 'club'. Perhaps
this is a compulsion which is more difficult to explain. The fact that
they have no consideration for the amputees they write to
indiscriminately or whose photographs they display without permission
suggests a selfishness that goes beyond normal justification. Whatever
the reason behind the attraction or the urge to be an amputee and in the
absence of any evidence to the contrary, I do not believe the people
concerned are normal in any way.
Mark.
In article <7elta2$oh3$1...@eve.enteract.com>, b@|+/-.? writes
For those who understand, no explanation is necessary; for those who don't, no
explanation is possible.
> For those who understand, no explanation is necessary; for those who don't, no
> explanation is possible.
Wonderfully put.
Attempting to justify something like this to someone who has already
decided in their own mind that it is 'wrong' is futile. It is very
confusing to me why so many people bother to ask 'Why' when they have
already come to their own conclusions.
Very true, although I remember being attracted to all sorts of disabled
people from ever since I can remember. Even when I was just a child of 4 or 5
I would experience the exact same feeling as I feel now (and it has nothing
to do with sex then). I suspect it is not (only) a sexual thing, because a
child at 4 can hardly be drawn by sexual desire. I had periods of "wanabee"
experiences myself, and I still do, but common sense prevails over my desires
and I am quite sure about myself NOT wanting to become an amputee.
Nevertheless, I am still fascinated (even after so many years) by the desire
of wanting to become an amputee or even only seeing or meeting one.
> Rather than being a fetish in the traditional sense, I feel amputee
> devotees are a bit cult like and enjoy being part of a 'club'.
I would disagree, because this is something most of us were ashamed of prior
to finding each other on the net. It is not everyday, that you find out that
you are a misfit and have deviant desires (by normal standards). This
fascination (in my opinion) has grown in individuals for a very long time,
and most of us are not really thinking of ourselves as "part of a club".
> this is a compulsion which is more difficult to explain. The fact that
> they have no consideration for the amputees they write to
> indiscriminately or whose photographs they display without permission
> suggests a selfishness that goes beyond normal justification. Whatever
> the reason behind the attraction or the urge to be an amputee and in the
> absence of any evidence to the contrary, I do not believe the people
> concerned are normal in any way.
Hmm...
__
BP Toni
> Although I don't have any problems with someone being attracted to me
> because I'm an amputee; the 'some are attracted to (fill in the blank)- we
> are attracted to stumps' doesn't hold any water. I will tell you why: Hair,
> height, or bust size is not comparable to a disability. The difference is
> that you are attracted to a physical trait that is, at the very least, an
> inconvenience, to the people who have them.
Hmm good point. And I can not really match any "inconvenience" that would even
remotely come close to an amputation (hairy legs or flat chest for girls,
braces etc...). Still I feel that attraction to a physical feature can be
looked at from the same viewpoint.
> There isn't really a good reason why anyone is attracted to anyone. Trying
> to explain it isn't going to get you anywhere. How you act toward those you
> are interested in is what matters. For instance, telling me that you are
> attracted to me the same way someone else is attracted to blonde hair,
> doesn't do anything for me. But, telling me that you find my inner strength
> attractive, or that you find me more beautiful because i'm unique, or that
> you find my confidence sexy; might get my attention.
I found myself in a probbably once-in-a-lifetime situation of meeting a quad
amputee girl in a street. I think an institution for disabled youth had a day
out and went to see the same movie.
My attraction to the physical state of the person (I do not know who she is)
literally prevented me to make any contact with her, since I feel I could not
get beyond the physical point. It is so plain and simple inside my head - like
it was hardcoded into my brainwaves, that Amputees Are Beautifull.
I suspect it is very hard for other devotees or wanabees to go about saying,
that inner strenghth, uniqueness or confidence is sexy, while the first
atraction is really the disability itself.
__
BP Tony
PLEASE DO NOT POST OR DISTRIBUTE PHOTOS WITHOUT PERMISSION OF THE PHOTOGRAPHEE!
And please treat us with respect and dignity. We are people first. Mothers,
fathers, employers, athletes and so on. Most of us try to push being an "amputee"
as far away from the top of our "who we are" list as we possibly can. Please
remember that.