Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

iRe: Rodman suspension vs. Jordan's suspension

2 views
Skip to first unread message

Reginald Patton

unread,
Mar 28, 1996, 3:00:00 AM3/28/96
to
On Wed, 27 Mar 1996, jespey wrote:

> In article <4j58r7$h...@news.cais.com>,
> p p...@cais.com (Darnell & Heather M. Brown) wrote:
> >bu...@ix.netcom.com(SUX 2 BU ) wrote:

SNIP--


> >>What these babies have to learn is that they are paid millions even
> >>though they have no marketable skills. If it weren't for their ability
> >>to jump, they would be working at the local McDonald's sweeping the
> >>floor and cleaning the microwave.
> >
> >>In the words of Billy Packard, Jordan, Rodman, and the rest of them are
> >>"Lucky monkeys".
> >
> >What a RACIST thing to say !
> >
> Where is the RACISM in this statement??? Are we not all glorified monkeys
> (apes really) some of whom are luckier then others?
>
> Just a thought


You are either very naive or you do not understand the commotion that
the original "... tough little monkey.." statement caused after it was
spoken. However, the poster who made the first reference to this
statement knew exactly what the implications of the statement were.


___________________________________________
Reginald N Patton rpa...@cs.uah.edu
You can make it through life with bad
manners, but it's easier with good manners.

aw...@sn.no

unread,
Apr 1, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/1/96
to rpatton@pluto
rodman is a nazi


FireStorm

unread,
Apr 2, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/2/96
to
In article <4jp4fi$9...@hasle.sn.no>, aw...@sn.no says...
>
>rodman is a nazi

shaddap ya freakin' dingleberry

@ Firestorm @


Reuben Rubio

unread,
Apr 2, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/2/96
to
In article <4jp4fi$9...@hasle.sn.no>, "arne...@sn.no" <aw...@sn.no> wrote:

> rodman is a nazi

rodman is a communist

;)
--
Reub (rar...@umich.edu)
http://www.umich.edu/~rarubio

cjs...@acs.ucalgary.ca

unread,
Apr 2, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/2/96
to

On 1 Apr 1996, arne...@sn.no wrote:

> rodman is a nazi
>
Would you care to back up your staement with facts, oh
rocket-scientist-like one?
R. Gragg

Thomas Morgan

unread,
Apr 4, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/4/96
to
sports.basketball.nba.det-pistons,
alt.sports.basketball.nba.gs-warriors,alt.sports.basketball.nba.hou-rockets,
alt.sports.basketball.nba.ind-pacers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.la-lakers,
alt.sports.basketball.nba.miami-heat,alt.sports.basketball.nba.mil-bucks:

,alt.sports.basketball.nba.mn-wolves,alt.sports.basketball.nba.nj-nets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.orlando-magic,alt.sports.basketball.nba.phila-76ers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.phx-suns,alt.sports.basketball.nba.sa-spurs,alt.sports.basketball.nba.sac-kings,:

alt.sports.basketball.nba.seattle-sonics,alt.sports.basketball.nba.utah-jazz,alt.sports.basketball.nba.wash-bullets,alt.sports.basketball.pro.ny-knicks:
Followup-To: alt.sports.basketball.nba.atlanta-hawks,alt.sports.basketball.nba.boston-celtics,alt.sports.basketball.nba.char-hornets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.chicago-bulls,alt.sports.basketball.nba.dallas-mavs,alt.sports.basketball.nba.denver-nuggets,alt:
.sports.basketball.nba.det-pistons,alt.sports.basketball.nba.gs-warriors,alt.sports.basketball.nba.hou-rockets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.ind-pacers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.la-lakers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.miami-heat,alt.sports.basketball.nba.mil-buck:
s,alt.sports.basketball.nba.mn-wolves,alt.sports.basketball.nba.nj-nets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.orlando-magic,alt.sports.basketball.nba.phila-76ers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.phx-suns,alt.sports.basketball.nba.sa-spurs,alt.sports.basketball.nba.sac-kings:
,alt.sports.basketball.nba.seattle-sonics,alt.sports.basketball.nba.utah-jazz,alt.sports.basketball.nba.wash-bullets,alt.sports.basketball.pro.ny-knicks
References: <Pine.SOL.3.91.960328133648.24844B-100000-100000@pluto> <4jp4fi$9...@hasle.sn.no> <rarubio-0204...@science2.soe.umich.edu>
Distribution:

Reuben Rubio (rar...@umich.edu) wrote:


: In article <4jp4fi$9...@hasle.sn.no>, "arne...@sn.no" <aw...@sn.no> wrote:

: > rodman is a nazi

: rodman is a communist

What's wrong with communism?
--
Thomas Morgan
tmo...@grfn.org
The 4th Dimension
http://www.grfn.org/~tmorgan/

it's getting kinda quiet in my city's head,
it takes a teenage riot to get me out of bed,
right now

Tim Blake

unread,
Apr 4, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/4/96
to
In article <rarubio-0204...@science2.soe.umich.edu>,

rar...@umich.edu (Reuben Rubio) wrote:
>In article <4jp4fi$9...@hasle.sn.no>, "arne...@sn.no" <aw...@sn.no> wrote:
>
>> rodman is a nazi
>
>rodman is a communist
>
>;)

And here I thought he was your run of the mill anarcho-syndicalist.

Milton R Shook

unread,
Apr 5, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/5/96
to
On Tue, 2 Apr 1996 cjs...@acs.ucalgary.ca wrote:

>
> On 1 Apr 1996, arne...@sn.no wrote:
>
> > rodman is a nazi
> >

> Would you care to back up your staement with facts, oh
> rocket-scientist-like one?
> R. Gragg
>
>

It is impossible for Rodman, by definition, to be a Nazi. Think about it.

Aaron E. Chang

unread,
Apr 9, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/9/96
to
>Does anyone think Van Exel's suspension will be longer than Rodman's
>after that stupid stunt tonight.I liked our chances before tonight but
>who knows if NVE will be available for the playoff.Smooth move
>Nick,always looking out for the team.

Van Exel will probably be suspended for the remainder of the regular
season. He will most likely be available for the playoffs.

Bob

unread,
Apr 10, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/10/96
to


Rodamn does play dirty. But he is no worse than Malone or Barkely.

In article <Pine.A32.3.91.960405...@nevis.u.arizona.edu>,

Allen C. Dimick

unread,
Apr 10, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/10/96
to
In <Pine.A32.3.91.960405...@nevis.u.arizona.edu>

Milton R Shook <msh...@U.Arizona.EDU> writes:
>
>On Tue, 2 Apr 1996 cjs...@acs.ucalgary.ca wrote:
>
>>
>> On 1 Apr 1996, arne...@sn.no wrote:
>>
>> > rodman is a nazi
>> >
>> Would you care to back up your staement with facts, oh
>> rocket-scientist-like one?
>> R. Gragg
>>
>>
>It is impossible for Rodman, by definition, to be a Nazi. Think about
it.

Charles Held

unread,
Apr 10, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/10/96
to
In article <4kfjg9$k...@dfw-ixnews1.ix.netcom.com>,
big...@ix.netcom.com(Allen C. Dimick) wrote:
=Does anyone think Van Exel's suspension will be longer than Rodman's
=after that stupid stunt tonight.

I suspect it will be the same as Rodman's; MAYBE one game less.

Aggravating circumstance:

Happened after Thorn "sent a message" with the Rodman suspension.

Mitigating circumstances:

Appeared to be less violent contact than Rodman's.
He's not Rodman <g>.

Eric Erickson

unread,
Apr 10, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/10/96
to
sports.basketball.nba.det-pistons,alt.sports.basketball.nba.gs-warriors,alt.sports.basketball.nba.hou-rockets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.ind-pacers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.la-lakers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.miami-heat,alt.sports.basketball.nba.mil-bucks


alt.sports.basketball.nba.seattle-sonics,alt.sports.basketball.nba.utah-jazz,alt.sports.basketball.nba.wash-bullets,alt.sports.basketball.pro.ny-knicks
Followup-To: alt.sports.basketball.nba.atlanta-hawks,alt.sports.basketball.nba.boston-celtics,alt.sports.basketball.nba.char-hornets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.chicago-bulls,alt.sports.basketball.nba.dallas-mavs,alt.sports.basketball.nba.denver-nuggets,alt

.sports.basketball.nba.det-pistons,alt.sports.basketball.nba.gs-warriors,alt.sports.basketball.nba.hou-rockets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.ind-pacers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.la-lakers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.miami-heat,alt.sports.basketball.nba.mil-buck

s,alt.sports.basketball.nba.mn-wolves,alt.sports.basketball.nba.nj-nets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.orlando-magic,alt.sports.basketball.nba.phila-76ers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.phx-suns,alt.sports.basketball.nba.sa-spurs,alt.sports.basketball.nba.sac-kings

,alt.sports.basketball.nba.seattle-sonics,alt.sports.basketball.nba.utah-jazz,alt.sports.basketball.nba.wash-bullets,alt.sports.basketball.pro.ny-knicks
References: <Pine.SOL.3.91.960328133648.24844B-100000-100000@pluto> <4jp4fi$9...@hasle.sn.no> <Pine.A32.3.91.960402...@acs3.acs.ucalgary.ca> <Pine.A32.3.91.960405...@nevis.u.arizona.edu> <4kfjg9$k...@dfw-ixnews1.ix.netcom.c

om>
Distribution:

Allen C. Dimick (big...@ix.netcom.com) wrote:
: In <Pine.A32.3.91.960405...@nevis.u.arizona.edu>


: Milton R Shook <msh...@U.Arizona.EDU> writes:
: >
: >On Tue, 2 Apr 1996 cjs...@acs.ucalgary.ca wrote:
: >
: >>
: >> On 1 Apr 1996, arne...@sn.no wrote:
: >>
: >> > rodman is a nazi
: >> >
: >> Would you care to back up your staement with facts, oh
: >> rocket-scientist-like one?
: >> R. Gragg
: >>
: >>
: >It is impossible for Rodman, by definition, to be a Nazi. Think about
: it.

: Does anyone think Van Exel's suspension will be longer than Rodman's
: after that stupid stunt tonight.I liked our chances before tonight but


: who knows if NVE will be available for the playoff.Smooth move
: Nick,always looking out for the team.

Well, since the refs father is the head of the rules committee (or
something to that effect), he picked on the wrong ref to push around.
His push seemed a lot more violent and intentional than Rodman's
headbutt. Van Exel should be out for the rest of the season, at the very
least. I thought that Rodman's suspension was fairly light. The NBA
should crack down hard on violence against the refs. If players can
intimidate the refs, the game becomes little more than jungle ball.

-- Ciao!

******************************************************************************
Eric C. Erickson * **DALLAS COWBOYS**
Elliott School of International Affairs * Super Bowl Champions
The George Washington University * VI, XII, XXVII, XXVIII & XXX
******************************************************************************

Randy Rodman

unread,
Apr 10, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/10/96
to
In article <4k0p4b$e...@maple.enet.net>, tbl...@enet.net (Tim Blake) wrote:

> In article <rarubio-0204...@science2.soe.umich.edu>,
> rar...@umich.edu (Reuben Rubio) wrote:

> >In article <4jp4fi$9...@hasle.sn.no>, "arne...@sn.no" <aw...@sn.no> wrote:
> >
> >> rodman is a nazi
> >

> >rodman is a communist
> >
> >;)
>
> And here I thought he was your run of the mill anarcho-syndicalist.

rodman is god
RODMAN RULES THE NBA AND THE WORLD

trung p nguyen

unread,
Apr 11, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/11/96
to
Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
difficult 16 footer.

mha...@iastate.edu

unread,
Apr 11, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/11/96
to
In article <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu>,


We could also make a few more changes based on difficulty:

- layups should be worth 1.5pts - you must release the ball
- open shots receive a 1/3 or 0.33 value
- shots made w/defense receive 1.5 value with a 0.25pt adjusment for every
inch difference in height

Say the Wolves are down by 4 in the final seconds against the Knicks...
Spud Web has the ball and a choice between:

Options:
a) pulling up for the open J... or
b) driving baseline and dunking over Ewing

Calculations:
a) 2 * 0.33 = 0.66pts
b) [1 * 1.5] + [(84"- 67")*0.25] = 1.5 + 4.25 = 5.75pts

Obviously Webb will calculate the difference (5.09 pts) and go for option b
to overcome the deficit.

T-wolves win 114.50 - 112.75!

Now basketball will be truly be based on skill.

Yes, I'm being a bit sarcastic. I don't think we need to change anything...
although this could be interesting.

Mike
--
mha...@iastate.edu

Andrew Guerrera

unread,
Apr 11, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/11/96
to
great make a layup for two and that will make the game SO MUCH more
exciting.

good point.

neal

Kevin M. Hebert

unread,
Apr 11, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/11/96
to
In article <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu>,
trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:
>Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
>dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
>be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
>difficult 16 footer.

Absolutely not! If that's the case, then no one will dunk, and the game
loses its most exciting aspect. With the dunk, the difficulty is either
in getting close enough to the rim by faking out your opponent or by
capitalizing on turnovers.

-- KMH

--
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Kevin M. Hebert kmhe...@seas.gwu.edu http://www.seas.gwu.edu/student/kmhebert
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

peeler

unread,
Apr 11, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/11/96
to
Suppose you were a referee; would you rather receive a:

1) Forearm bump by Nick, or

2) Head-butt by Dennis Rodman?

I would feel less threatened by option 1.

Pete Waack

unread,
Apr 11, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/11/96
to
In article <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu>,
trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:

> Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
> dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> difficult 16 footer.

No. The dunk or layup should get three points cuz it is usually the
result of a great offensive play or a steal. It is much more difficult to
get open for a dunk than a three pointer.

By the way, does this have anything to do with vertical leap envy?

rocky

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to
In article <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu>,
trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:

> Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
> dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> difficult 16 footer.


Be careful what you say about the dunk. It's not as easy as it looks and
not EVERYONE can do it. Ron Harper missed a dunk point-blank once I mean
that quite litterally, he went to throw it down and missed the rim.
Besides, if it ain't broke, don't fix it.

P. Annamalai

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to
In article mha...@iastate.edu () writes:
>Subject: Re: The dunk!
>Organization: Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa USA

>
>In article <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu>,
>trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:
>>Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
>>dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
>>be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
>>difficult 16 footer.
>
>
>We could also make a few more changes based on difficulty:
>
>- layups should be worth 1.5pts - you must release the ball
>- open shots receive a 1/3 or 0.33 value
>- shots made w/defense receive 1.5 value with a 0.25pt adjusment for every
> inch difference in height
>
>Say the Wolves are down by 4 in the final seconds against the Knicks...
>Spud Web has the ball and a choice between:
>
>Options:
>a) pulling up for the open J... or
>b) driving baseline and dunking over Ewing
>
>Calculations:
>a) 2 * 0.33 = 0.66pts
>b) [1 * 1.5] + [(84"- 67")*0.25] = 1.5 + 4.25 = 5.75pts
>
>Obviously Webb will calculate the difference (5.09 pts) and go for option b
>to overcome the deficit.
>
>T-wolves win 114.50 - 112.75!
>
>Now basketball will be truly be based on skill.
>
>
>Mike
>--
>mha...@iastate.edu

The flaw in the above is that Ewing would have to be a total dumb-ass to
even contest the shot in the above scenario. So while Webb is calculating the
point differences in the scenario, Ewing would be hard at work and arrive at
the same conclusion. So ideally, Ewing would stand near the basket, pretending
to play defense, but at the last second move out the way giving Webb
an uncontested dunk or layup which would be less than two points giving the
Knicks the win.
--
Thanx for the comeback, MJ "Men will lie on their backs, talking about the
P. Annamalai, aka Pman fall of man, and never make an effort to get up"
anna...@uiuc.edu - Henry David Thoreau

WoodStock

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to

On Tue, 9 Apr 1996, Aaron E. Chang wrote:
> >Does anyone think Van Exel's suspension will be longer than Rodman's
> >after that stupid stunt tonight.I liked our chances before tonight but
> >who knows if NVE will be available for the playoff.Smooth move
> >Nick,always looking out for the team.
>
> Van Exel will probably be suspended for the remainder of the regular
> season. He will most likely be available for the playoffs.
>

Van "Baby" Excel will be suspended for seven games (one more than Rodman)
and fine a NBA record $25,000 (like those NBA stars really care). I say
that is too light of a punishment to sent a message. If they really want
to sent a message, it should be $50,000 fine and suspended for the WHOLE
NBA SEASON INCLUDING PLAYOFFS!!!!!!!!!!!! Of course they are too wimpy
to do that so look for refs to get into a more serious situation. Future
predictions -- Barkley spits into the face of a ref, and Mad Max turn a
sucker punch to a ref.


>
>
>
>
>
>

WoodStock

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to

On Thu, 11 Apr 1996, trung p nguyen wrote:

> Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
> dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> difficult 16 footer.

No it shouldn't. If you are talking a wide open dunk than sure it is
easy, but so are wide open layups, and jump shots. To dunk with
defensive players around you is really harder than you see on TV (I know).

WoodStock

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to

> rodman is god
> RODMAN RULES THE NBA AND THE WORLD

Rodman = overrated, worthless bastard (besides rebounds of course).
You = hopeless subject of Rodman that he probably won't even give you a
damn penny for your blind loyalty to his ass.

Bye

Del Brown

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to trung p nguyen
Here's a question for you. Do you play basketball? And if so, I wonder
if your skill level is so low that you cannot see the art in "THE DUNK".
Just in case you didn't know, these are the tools that are necessary in
making a DUNK. 1)Vertical jump or leap. 2)Timing 3)Vision 4)Coordination
if you're on a break. If you think I'm wrong, I suggest you go to a
"KIDDIE" court and try to do a breakaway dunk and see if you think it's
worth one point after that. Also if you get a chance to see some of the
former players dunk, Connie Hawkins, David Thompson, and DR.J you'll see
the grace that was involved especially with DR.J. Besides sometimes a
"DUNK" sparks an entire team to turn a game situation around. No
disrespect to you, but you're either not a big B-Ball fan or you don't
know skill when you see it.

Peace,
Del

It is better to be thought of as a fool for being quiet, than it is to
open your mouth and remove all doubt.

andrew m saari

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to
In article <Pine.A32.3.92a.960412...@homer16.u.washington.edu>,


Okay, I never wrote the first post in the first place, and don't get me
wrong, I'm not trying to change the worth of lay-ups or dunks. But why
is dunking conisered so hard for 6-7 guys and 6-5 guys. If I were 6-5, I
could easily dunk. Shit I can dunk a volleyball at 6-1, and I'm not the
best athlete in the world. So, why do you conider it so skillful to
dunk. For Dee Brown, it is truly remarkable, but for Shaq or Rik Smits
to do it, that's nothing. I'd much rather watch John Stockton or Reggie
Miller sink a game-winning 3-pointer at the buzzer. Now that takes some
talent...and many times some luck...that's why it's worth more. I wish
they'd move the line back though.
--

-- Native Son

Reuben Rubio

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to
In article <Pine.ULT.3.91.960412...@rac6.wam.umd.edu>,
WoodStock <da...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:

> No it shouldn't. If you are talking a wide open dunk than sure it is
> easy, but so are wide open layups, and jump shots. To dunk with
> defensive players around you is really harder than you see on TV (I know).

He's right - he defends people who dunk on him all the time, and they
always sweat all over him . . . ;)

Seriously, he is right in that dunking in the middle of congestion is
tough (yeah, I do make it to those kiddie baskets from time-to-time).
Maybe the guy who started this thread doesn't understand that the "dunker"
and the "dunkee" are able to occupy the same general area, so that a dunk
is hardly some simple uncontested thing. A dunk in traffic or off a
rebound is the penultimate power move, and definitely a great part of the
game for players and spectators.
--
Reub (rar...@umich.edu)
http://www-personal.umich.edu/~rarubio

Brian Simpson

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to
In article <4kkvq6$c...@vixen.cso.uiuc.edu>,

P. Annamalai <anna...@ux7.cso.uiuc.edu> wrote:
>In article mha...@iastate.edu () writes:
>>Subject: Re: The dunk!
>>Organization: Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa USA
>>
>>In article <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu>,
>>trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:
>>>Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
>>>dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
>>>be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
>>>difficult 16 footer.
>>
>>
>>We could also make a few more changes based on difficulty:
>>
>>- layups should be worth 1.5pts - you must release the ball
>>- open shots receive a 1/3 or 0.33 value
>>- shots made w/defense receive 1.5 value with a 0.25pt adjusment for every
>> inch difference in height
>>
>>Say the Wolves are down by 4 in the final seconds against the Knicks...
>>Spud Web has the ball and a choice between:
>>
>>Options:
>>a) pulling up for the open J... or
>>b) driving baseline and dunking over Ewing
>>
>>Calculations:
>>a) 2 * 0.33 = 0.66pts
>>b) [1 * 1.5] + [(84"- 67")*0.25] = 1.5 + 4.25 = 5.75pts
>>

So if Muresan dunks over mugsy bouges, that would be

[1 * 1.5] + [(63"- 91")*0.25] = 1.5 + -7 = -5.5 points


This would open up a whole new field of work for midgets. Never again
would they have to work in the circus or do a weird al video, they could
all be multi-millionares in basketball.

terrewhitemon

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to
>In article <Pine.A32.3.92a.960412...@homer16.u.washington.edu>,
>Del Brown <del...@u.washington.edu> wrote:
>>Here's a question for you. Do you play basketball? And if so, I wonder
>>if your skill level is so low that you cannot see the art in "THE DUNK".
>>Just in case you didn't know, these are the tools that are necessary in
>>making a DUNK. 1)Vertical jump or leap. 2)Timing 3)Vision 4)Coordination
>>if you're on a break. If you think I'm wrong, I suggest you go to a
>>"KIDDIE" court and try to do a breakaway dunk and see if you think it's
>>worth one point after that. Also if you get a chance to see some of the
>>former players dunk, Connie Hawkins, David Thompson, and DR.J you'll see
>>the grace that was involved especially with DR.J. Besides sometimes a
>>"DUNK" sparks an entire team to turn a game situation around. No
>>disrespect to you,

Kiddie court? Sounds like disrespect to me. And I don't know what skill level
has to do with the ability to see the art in anything.

As for the dunk...it's awesome. But, aside from its crowd appeal, it's had its
negative effects on the league, in my opinion. Namely...

~ Deterioration of shooting skills.
~ Traveling (hardly anyone gets called for steps on a dunk)
~ Allows One Trick Ponies to be so called Superstars (Kemp, O'Neal, among others)
~ Further shifts the emphasis of the game in favor of the big men
~ Poor sportsmanship (who ever gets called for Taunting after a killer pass or a
Jordanesque reverse layup?)

But you can't get rid of it, and limiting dunking to less than two points seems
silly. The only realistic limitation I can see that could be placed on the dunk
would be to limit it to transition: fast break dunks only. Then you'd still have
the more exciting dunks for entertainment, and players like Mourning and Bradley
would have to improve their finesse skills. But don't count on any dunking rules
being implemented.

Then again, if Brent Barry was able to win the Dunk Contest, maybe that means
dunking IS too easy and should be banned!

THE GENIUS

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to
On Thu, 11 Apr 1996, trung p nguyen wrote:

> Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
> dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> difficult 16 footer.
>
>

Not really. Saying this is like saying you should outlaw leaping,
one-handed touchdown catches in football or that home runs should not
count. It's a more spectacular way of scoring,
and if you worry too much about doing it right instead of just scoring at
all, you will have problems executing. I don't think people try to dunk
too much; I konw if I could do it I'd try it every time. The bad thing
is that people don't learn that a 16-foot jumper is also worth two
points, and that being to hit that consistently is damn important if you
want your team to win. Let the dunkers dunk away; if that's all you can
do we won't be seeing too much of you anyway. (see Miner, Harold).

Robert Bonnette

T-Rock

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to
trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:

>Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
>dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
>be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
>difficult 16 footer.

No Trung, no!!! Please don't do this - the NBA's tried it before, and
the whole thing backfired. After the dunking stopped, more and more
people stopped coming out to see games. Of course I'm referring to the
"old-school" of basketball here, but I know I wouldn't come out to as
many games either. Trust me, it takes skill. I'm 6'0 1/2 feet tall,
and because of my small hands, I haven't slammed a 10 ft goal yet. 9.5
isn't hard to do, but 10 is. Dunking takes a lot of things to do for
anyone shorter than about 6'3.

It takes:
1) Jumping ability- If the legs don't have "springs" in 'em, you won't
get those ups you need.

2) Just ask Spud Webb how he won the Slam Dunk Championships. It was
mostly speed, as well as jumping ability. If you can't run, you won't
be able to elevate with your jump. Look at the physics, man.

3) Determination and Synchronization - Dunking is not something that's
done by doubt. If you're going to "punch", then it has to go through
your mind. It's not as easy as, I think I'll try dunking. No. Forget
it. You have to be in sync with yourself and the ball, or else you'll
get "hung" on the basket, which is very embarrasing. Synchronization
is ESPECIALLY important in Shaq's alley-oops, and Jordan's "Air
Reverse" slam, as well as other specialty, fancy, designer slams.

I myself play the position of small forward. Though I can shoot pretty
well from the outside, BELIEVE me that I like to be as close to the
goal as possible. I've got ups, and I have rejected dunks before. As a
matter of fact, shot blocking is one of the things I do best.

Don't take away the slam. It's fun, it's intimidating, and it DOES
take skill.

PEACE!!!
T-Rock

"You're Welcome!" -Derrick Coleman

Go Magic! Hardaway for President!

trung p nguyen

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to

On Fri, 12 Apr 1996, Del Brown wrote:

> Here's a question for you. Do you play basketball? And if so, I wonder
> if your skill level is so low that you cannot see the art in "THE DUNK".
> Just in case you didn't know, these are the tools that are necessary in
> making a DUNK. 1)Vertical jump or leap. 2)Timing 3)Vision 4)Coordination
> if you're on a break. If you think I'm wrong, I suggest you go to a
> "KIDDIE" court and try to do a breakaway dunk and see if you think it's
> worth one point after that. Also if you get a chance to see some of the
> former players dunk, Connie Hawkins, David Thompson, and DR.J you'll see
> the grace that was involved especially with DR.J. Besides sometimes a
> "DUNK" sparks an entire team to turn a game situation around. No

> disrespect to you, but you're either not a big B-Ball fan or you don't
> know skill when you see it.

My criticism of the dunk arises from the observation that too many
basketball players today choose to focus on their ability to dunk rather
than to take and make a jumpshot. As a result of this focus, the
percentage of jumpshots has experienced a dip in comparison to those of
yesteryear. Apparently, newer NBA players are no longer familiar with the
jumpshot because of their overwhelming concern on developing a "good"
dunk. I don't mind an occasional dunk from a small player, but
seeing 7-footers stuffing the ball without leaving their feet is no fun.
I'd rather see Hakeem making beautiful fade-aways than witness Shaq slamming
the ball into the basket yet again, especially when it doesn't require much
skill to do so. The dunk was interesting when Dr. J did it because it was
new at the time and considered a rarity because few could do it. How
interesting can it be when almost everybody in the NBA could do it today?
Would the three-point shot be considered such a deadly weapon and worth so
much if everybody could do it? Somehow I doubt it.

>
> Peace,
> Del
>
> It is better to be thought of as a fool for being quiet, than it is to
> open your mouth and remove all doubt.
>

Hmm, maybe you should take your own advice.

jacko

unread,
Apr 12, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/12/96
to

A basket, is a basket is a basket.....a dunk or field goal should both
be 2 pts, its part of the game. The 3 pt line is WAY too close right
now though....

On 12 Apr 1996 05:52:02 GMT, em...@nwu.edu (rocky) wrote:

>In article <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu>,


>trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:
>
>> Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
>> dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
>> be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
>> difficult 16 footer.
>
>
>
>

nor...@earthlink.net

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to
On Thu, 11 Apr 1996 10:10:35 -0400, trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu>
wrote:

>Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
>dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
>be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
>difficult 16 footer.

Then Shaq would be the lowest scoring player in the league!!
Michael Nordwick
A True Rocket Fan to the end
Stuck in the LA area


J. Krokus

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to
trung p nguyen wrote:
>
> Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
> dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> difficult 16 footer.

You make a good point but its the defense that allows a player to get
inside to make that dunk. If the team's defense is tight it just won't
happen.

Jeanette

Matt Propes

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to
In article <4kfjg9$k...@dfw-ixnews1.ix.netcom.com>,
big...@ix.netcom.com(Allen C. Dimick) wrote:

> In <Pine.A32.3.91.960405...@nevis.u.arizona.edu>
> Milton R Shook <msh...@U.Arizona.EDU> writes:
> >
> >On Tue, 2 Apr 1996 cjs...@acs.ucalgary.ca wrote:
> >
> >>

> >> On 1 Apr 1996, arne...@sn.no wrote:
> >>
> >> > rodman is a nazi
> >> >

> >> Would you care to back up your staement with facts, oh
> >> rocket-scientist-like one?
> >> R. Gragg
> >>
> >>
> >It is impossible for Rodman, by definition, to be a Nazi. Think about
> it.

> Does anyone think Van Exel's suspension will be longer than Rodman's
> after that stupid stunt tonight.I liked our chances before tonight but
> who knows if NVE will be available for the playoff.Smooth move
> Nick,always looking out for the team.

I can't believe Rodman didn't receive a longer suspension. I'm not
condoning either Van Exel or Rodman, but I think headbutting is worse than
throwing a punch.

so...@inforamp.net

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to

Why do you need to put who did the threat?
Now that is discrimination.

so...@inforamp.ca


so...@inforamp.net

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to
>>
>>Calculations:
>>a) 2 * 0.33 = 0.66pts
>>b) [1 * 1.5] + [(84"- 67")*0.25] = 1.5 + 4.25 = 5.75pts
>>
>>Obviously Webb will calculate the difference (5.09 pts) and go for option b
>>to overcome the deficit.

Let's play midget b-ball.


>>T-wolves win 114.50 - 112.75!
>>
>>Now basketball will be truly be based on skill.
>>
>>
>>Mike
>>--
>>mha...@iastate.edu

so...@inforamp.ca


T-Rock

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to
Del Brown <del...@u.washington.edu> wrote:

>Here's a question for you. Do you play basketball? And if so, I wonder
>if your skill level is so low that you cannot see the art in "THE DUNK".
>Just in case you didn't know, these are the tools that are necessary in
>making a DUNK. 1)Vertical jump or leap. 2)Timing 3)Vision 4)Coordination
>if you're on a break. If you think I'm wrong, I suggest you go to a
>"KIDDIE" court and try to do a breakaway dunk and see if you think it's
>worth one point after that. Also if you get a chance to see some of the
>former players dunk, Connie Hawkins, David Thompson, and DR.J you'll see
>the grace that was involved especially with DR.J. Besides sometimes a
>"DUNK" sparks an entire team to turn a game situation around. No
>disrespect to you, but you're either not a big B-Ball fan or you don't
>know skill when you see it.

Del, I only told him the basics. THANK YOU FOR YOUR REPLY!!!
I tried to tell the guy the same thing. I know that dunking takes a
lot of skill. Do you know how upset I got when that guy said nearly
anyone can do it! GOODNESS mannn! Unlike that guy, I DO play b-ball.
Been playin' at it for over 11 years. So I can respect your reply.
Keep it up Del.

>Peace,
>Del

>It is better to be thought of as a fool for being quiet, than it is to
>open your mouth and remove all doubt.

PEACE!!!
T-Rock

Go Magic! Hardaway for President!

so...@inforamp.net

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to
>trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:
>>Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
>>dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
>>be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
>>difficult 16 footer.
>
>
>We could also make a few more changes based on difficulty:
>
>- layups should be worth 1.5pts - you must release the ball
>- open shots receive a 1/3 or 0.33 value

In this case, forget about D. Just let them take open shots.

>- shots made w/defense receive 1.5 value with a 0.25pt adjusment for every
> inch difference in height
>
>Say the Wolves are down by 4 in the final seconds against the Knicks...
>Spud Web has the ball and a choice between:
>
>Options:
>a) pulling up for the open J... or
>b) driving baseline and dunking over Ewing
>

>Calculations:
>a) 2 * 0.33 = 0.66pts
>b) [1 * 1.5] + [(84"- 67")*0.25] = 1.5 + 4.25 = 5.75pts
>
>Obviously Webb will calculate the difference (5.09 pts) and go for option b
>to overcome the deficit.
>

>T-wolves win 114.50 - 112.75!
>
>Now basketball will be truly be based on skill.
>

>Yes, I'm being a bit sarcastic. I don't think we need to change anything...
>although this could be interesting.
>
>Mike
>--
>mha...@iastate.edu


so...@inforamp.ca


so...@inforamp.net

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to
In <4kjvgu$k...@felix.seas.gwu.edu>, kmhe...@seas.gwu.edu (Kevin M. Hebert) writes:
>In article <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu>,
>trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:
>>Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
>>dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
>>be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
>>difficult 16 footer.
>
>Absolutely not! If that's the case, then no one will dunk, and the game
>loses its most exciting aspect. With the dunk, the difficulty is either
>in getting close enough to the rim by faking out your opponent or by
>capitalizing on turnovers.

Or by 2 feet taller then the center of the other team.

>-- KMH
>
>
>
>--
>~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
>Kevin M. Hebert kmhe...@seas.gwu.edu http://www.seas.gwu.edu/student/kmhebert
>~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


so...@inforamp.ca


Charles Held

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to
In article <4kon68$a...@sam.inforamp.net>, so...@inforamp.ca wrote:
=In <peeler.97...@aol.com>, pee...@aol.com (peeler) writes:
=>Suppose you were a referee; would you rather receive a:
=>
=>1) Forearm bump by Nick, or
=>
=>2) Head-butt by Dennis Rodman?
=>
=>I would feel less threatened by option 1.
=
=Why do you need to put who did the threat?
=Now that is discrimination.

When did NVE become white, er, excuse me, EUROPEAN-AMERICAN?


Gareth Howell

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to

> Here's a question for you. Do you play basketball? And if so, I wonder
> if your skill level is so low that you cannot see the art in "THE DUNK".
Yeah less than zero !!

> Just in case you didn't know, these are the tools that are necessary in
> making a DUNK. 1)Vertical jump or leap. 2)Timing 3)Vision 4)Coordination
> if you're on a break.

PLEEEEZE...
More like height and leg strength !!!

> If you think I'm wrong, I suggest you go to a
> "KIDDIE" court and try to do a breakaway dunk and see if you think it's
> worth one point after that.

Well, for your information, not all of us are 7 feet tall !!

> Also if you get a chance to see some of the
> former players dunk, Connie Hawkins, David Thompson, and DR.J you'll see
> the grace that was involved especially with DR.J. Besides sometimes a
> "DUNK" sparks an entire team to turn a game situation around.

Yeah, so can a three point shot...

> No
> disrespect to you, but you're either not a big B-Ball fan or you don't
> know skill when you see it.

Yep, when Grant Hill weaves through the opponents THATS skill, but when he
dunks the ball, thats just matter of course !!


On Thu, 11 Apr 1996, trung p nguyen wrote:
>
> > Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
> > dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> > be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> > difficult 16 footer.
> >
> >
>

----
Utah Jazz 1996-'97 Defending Champions
Game 7, Finals
Utah Jazz 132 Chicago Bulls 100

email: Ca...@iafrica.com
voice: +27-11-616-6336


Justin G Kappel

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to
sports.basketball.nba.det-pistons,alt.sports.basketball.nba.gs-warriors,alt.sports.basketball.nba.hou-rockets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.ind-pacers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.la-lakers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.miami-heat,alt.sports.basketball.nba.mil-bucks

,alt.sports.basketball.nba.mn-wolves,alt.sports.basketball.nba.nj-nets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.orlando-magic,alt.sports.basketball.nba.phila-76ers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.phx-suns,alt.sports.basketball.nba.sa-spurs,alt.sports.basketball.nba.sac-kings,

alt.sports.basketball.nba.seattle-sonics,alt.sports.basketball.nba.utah-jazz,alt.sports.basketball.nba.wash-bullets,alt.sports.basketball.pro.ny-knicks
Followup-To: alt.sports.basketball.nba.atlanta-hawks,alt.sports.basketball.nba.boston-celtics,alt.sports.basketball.nba.char-hornets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.chicago-bulls,alt.sports.basketball.nba.dallas-mavs,alt.sports.basketball.nba.denver-nuggets,alt

.sports.basketball.nba.det-pistons,alt.sports.basketball.nba.gs-warriors,alt.sports.basketball.nba.hou-rockets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.ind-pacers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.la-lakers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.miami-heat,alt.sports.basketball.nba.mil-buck

s,alt.sports.basketball.nba.mn-wolves,alt.sports.basketball.nba.nj-nets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.orlando-magic,alt.sports.basketball.nba.phila-76ers,alt.sports.basketball.nba.phx-suns,alt.sports.basketball.nba.sa-spurs,alt.sports.basketball.nba.sac-kings

,alt.sports.basketball.nba.seattle-sonics,alt.sports.basketball.nba.utah-jazz,alt.sports.basketball.nba.wash-bullets,alt.sports.basketball.pro.ny-knicks
References: <Pine.SOL.3.91.960328133648.24844B-100000-100000@pluto> <4jp4fi$9...@hasle.sn.no> <Pine.A32.3.91.960402...@acs3.acs.ucalgary.ca> <Pine.A32.3.91.960405...@nevis.u.arizona.edu> <4kfjg9$k...@dfw-ixnews1.ix.netcom.c

om> <4kh1d7$21...@mule1.mindspring.com> <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu>
Organization: North Dakota Higher Education Computing Network (NDHECN)
Distribution:
:
Hey, I think there is too much dunking going on in the league too. But,
would you rather have fast breaks climaxing with a lay up, or a guy
dunking except not touching the rim(a slam lay-up?). The fact is, it is an
exciting part of the game and a basket is a basket. If it were a
perfect world, guys who can't shoot 60% free throws, like many junior
high kids, wouldn't be in the league. But you can't have it all, can
you? Also, would your next move be to set a standard shooting form or
batting stance in baseball? So that would mean a fade away jumper
wouldn't count because in grade school they taught you to jump straight
up when you shot. The object is to get the ball through the hoop anyway
you can.

Jason Gorgia

unread,
Apr 13, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/13/96
to
> >On Thu, 11 Apr 1996, trung p nguyen wrote:
>
> >> Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
> >> dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> >> be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> >> difficult 16 footer.
> >>
The easy shot is to stand around the perimeter where someone will give up
the jump shot and drain the wide-open shot. If you can't consistently
make a wide-open jumper, you just don't practice, and maybe a point
should be taken away! Ok, I'm kidding there, but we already have a
system that rewards perimeter shooting over inside play. Ladies and
gentlemen, please let me reintroduce you to the three-point shot. You
*already* get more points for outside play as it is. It doesn't take
"skill" to get to the rim consistently?? Wow! It takes much more skill
to weave through a sea of defenders and go over/around/through defenders
trying to stuff your shot, and dunk it down. And in the NBA, if you're 7
feet tall, you probably have a 7-feet tall defender on your back. Other
than occasional lazy defenders, "easy" shots are generated by hard work.
This reminds me of suggestions to ban the dunk (which didn't work) and
raise the rim (which furthers punishes smaller guys). If you take a
two-pointer, the hardest shot to take is the dunk shot, as a matter of
breaking down the defense.

Whoever wrote the comment about "vertical leap envy" got me ROTFL!!

Jason

Christopher M. Becker

unread,
Apr 14, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/14/96
to

> trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:
>
> >Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
> >dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> >be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> >difficult 16 footer.


Ummm... I think your missing a BIG point here:

The actual act of putting the ball in the hoop is not the point of the game.
Rather its only a part of a big picture. Its the D that turns the ball over,
its the pass that set up the play -- you can't just pick out one thing.

Under the scheme you present, the Magic Johnson no-look pass that results in an
wide open dunk gets less value than a jump shot the foul line? Makes no sense.


-- Chris

P.S. You dunk with a 7' man in your way and tell me how easy it is....

Georg Huber

unread,
Apr 14, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/14/96
to
In message <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu> - trung
p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> writes:
:>
:>Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
:>dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
:>be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
:>difficult 16 footer.

Not a good idea, I guess. Dunks are what the crowd (ME!) wanna see. Besides it
takes a lot of skill to dunk OVER the Admiral just like Finnley (Suns) did in
their recent matchup. For the same reason (skill) you could demand that a ball
thrown in from half-court counts 6 or a buzzer beater gives you a bonus
point....

JMHO.

#######################
#LIVE FAST, DIE YOUNG!#
#######################
___________________________________________________________________
Georg J. Huber

Internet: ghu...@ibm.net

European Contact of Computerist Online Magazine

Check out http://www.deepcove.com/computerist
___________________________________________________________________


noodle

unread,
Apr 14, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/14/96
to
All I have to say is taking away the dunk (or lessening its value) is
crazy. Dunking is difficult. I am 6'3" (19 years old) and have only
been able to dunk for about 2 years. At first it was only the real easy
stuff but that was after trying, unsuccessfully for one whole year. Now
that I can dunk I have started trying more difficult dunks and these take
a great deal of timing and practice. To this day I have only "dunked on
someone" once in a game and I will tell you that it is difficult. It
requires total concentration and NO FEAR (like being undercut or getting
hung on the rim and landing on your, which hurts!). Leave the dunk the
way it is, either that, or make it worth more points!

Noodle

Matt Propes

unread,
Apr 14, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/14/96
to
In article <Pine.SGI.3.91.96041...@umbc8.umbc.edu>, THE
GENIUS <rbo...@gl.umbc.edu> wrote:

> On Thu, 11 Apr 1996, trung p nguyen wrote:
>

> > Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
> > dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> > be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> > difficult 16 footer.
> >
> >

> Not really. Saying this is like saying you should outlaw leaping,
> one-handed touchdown catches in football or that home runs should not
> count. It's a more spectacular way of scoring,

But the one-handed catch in football or the home run is not soemthing
that's done strictly for intimidation and showyness.

> and if you worry too much about doing it right instead of just scoring at
> all, you will have problems executing. I don't think people try to dunk
> too much; I konw if I could do it I'd try it every time. The bad thing
> is that people don't learn that a 16-foot jumper is also worth two
> points, and that being to hit that consistently is damn important if you
> want your team to win. Let the dunkers dunk away; if that's all you can
> do we won't be seeing too much of you anyway. (see Miner, Harold).
>
> Robert Bonnette

Look at Shaquille O'Neal (Ptooey!) and try to tell me again that some
people don't try to dunk that much.(And Sottie Pippen and Michael Jordan
for that matter...Just to name a few....)

Andy

unread,
Apr 14, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/14/96
to

>In article <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu>,

>trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:
>Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody
can
>dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you
should
>be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
>difficult 16 footer.

I don't think so. While we are at it, why not add a 23 ft 4-pointer, a
25 ft 5-pointer, and a full court 10-pointer (gasp) Just because it is
a more "difficult" shot doesn't mean it should be worth more. Hmmmmm,
have you ever tried dunking before? It is actually much harder than it
looks. Ok, so I can do it. (alright, so its only a 9 1/2 feet rim)
Yeah, I got a 38 in verticle leap, but you know what? Its not just
about jumping up and putting the ball down. While it takes almost no
skill to dunk, it does take some skills to dunk on somebody else. If
you can do it, then you'll know what I mean.


Michael Stephen Connelly (PHY)

unread,
Apr 15, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/15/96
to

On Sat, 13 Apr 1996, J. Krokus wrote:

> trung p nguyen wrote:
> >
> > Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
> > dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> > be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> > difficult 16 footer.
>

> You make a good point but its the defense that allows a player to get
> inside to make that dunk. If the team's defense is tight it just won't
> happen.
>
> Jeanette
>
>

On April 15th Michael Connelly wrote,

A good point here, a good point there, but this illustrates why i no
longer care about the pre allstar game, namely the dunk contest. It is
usually won by some young "star" who is probably riding the pine on his
current team, or playing in Yugoslavia. either outlaw the dunk, which
would be ridiculous, or score one point. If you don't like either of
those selections, play some "D". The NBA has been accused in the past
that it did not. NOT scrappy Knick "d", bring back the zone .

Rick

unread,
Apr 15, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/15/96
to
Georg Huber wrote:
>
> In message <Pine.ULT.3.91.96041...@rac6.wam.umd.edu> - trung
> p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> writes:
> :>
> :>Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can

> :>dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> :>be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> :>difficult 16 footer.
>
> Not a good idea, I guess. Dunks are what the crowd (ME!) wanna see. Besides it
> takes a lot of skill to dunk OVER the Admiral just like Finnley (Suns) did in
> their recent matchup. For the same reason (skill) you could demand that a ball
> thrown in from half-court counts 6 or a buzzer beater gives you a bonus
> point....
>
> JMHO.
>
> #######################
> #LIVE FAST, DIE YOUNG!#
> #######################
> ___________________________________________________________________
> Georg J. Huber
>
> Internet: ghu...@ibm.net
>
> European Contact of Computerist Online Magazine
>
> Check out http://www.deepcove.com/computerist
> ___________________________________________________________________You can't start meesing around with the game like that...pretty soon it would look
like an NBA Jam TII video game where special bonuses pop up. I can see Mitch popping
for a nine pointer from the opposite key, or a "fast" spot lighting up enabling
Causwell to run all the weay from baseline to baseline without stopping. It would
bastardize the game.
- Mark Billingsley, newbie web surfer.

Aaron E. Chang

unread,
Apr 15, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/15/96
to
>would be ridiculous, or score one point. If you don't like either of
>those selections, play some "D". The NBA has been accused in the past
>that it did not. NOT scrappy Knick "d", bring back the zone .

You've got to be kidding. Watching NBA teams play zone defense must
be the most boring thing in the world.

Greg Lentz

unread,
Apr 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/16/96
to

And watching the pass inside kick it out to the 3 point
shooter/isolation game where 4 guys stand around while 2 guys play one
on one is a thrill?

I agree. Bring back the zone. The zone is far from a perfect defense
and competent NBA players/coaches/offenses can break it down. Zones
only work when a team has no capable outside shooting and most NBA
teams have at least 1/2 capable shooters (Warriors excepted). The
best defense is still man to man, if you have five guys committed to
playing it. The best part about reinstating the zone is that then the
defense will improve since you don't have to worry about the bogus
illegal defense calls and you can sag off of chumps like Bimbo Coles.
However, to offset that, start calling all the B.S. rough stuff inside
that goes on both offensively and defensively to maintain position.
With the ability to double good players, that shouldn't be necessary.

--

Greg Lentz

Top of the Key - Internet Sports Newsletter
(e-mail KWe...@aol.com for details)

"When you are courting a nice girl, an hour seems like a second. When you sit on a red-hot cinder, a second seems like an hour. That's relativity."

-- Albert Einstein


Josh Rice

unread,
Apr 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/16/96
to
In article <4kvfqg$9...@ultra.sonic.net>, spac...@sonic.net says...

>I agree. Bring back the zone.

At last we're making some sense in here! Bring back the zone and eliminate the
3-point shot, and we'd start to see some interesting hoops. This would change
the game back to passing, cutting offenses. Most dunks would be eliminated due
to big shot-blockers hanging under the rim. I like it.

josh


Del Brown

unread,
Apr 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/16/96
to trung p nguyen
I just know you're not trying to flame me. Your original question was
about the dunk being worth 1 point. I merely pointed out to you why it
should not be. I too am not at the edge of my seat everytime someone
dunks in the NBA or College or the park or the gym. And when DR.J was
dunking it was a rare sight for alot of NBA watchers. But many people did
great dunks before him with flair, grace and skill. (See the Holcombe
Rucker Memorial Tournament NYC) My eldest brother was dunking back in the
60's in the park as well as in high school and Elmcor, AAU Tournaments.
So it is not some NEW phenomenon that alot of people can do it. Back in
the day it was not allowed in college and the pros. And I just wonder why
that was the case. The game also did not enjoy the same success and
excitement that it does now. I wonder if the DUNK had anything to do with
that. I'm not taking anything away from the jumper or even the layup. I
knew of people that would run to the corner on a fast break all alone and
stroke a "J" and that is exciting to watch too. But once again to suggest
that it be worth one point because its easy for Shaq, Hakeem etc is
ridiculous! ENOUGH SAID, FIND ANOTHER SUBJECT!

On Fri, 12 Apr 1996, trung p nguyen wrote:

>
>
> On Fri, 12 Apr 1996, Del Brown wrote:
>

> > Here's a question for you. Do you play basketball? And if so, I wonder
> > if your skill level is so low that you cannot see the art in "THE DUNK".

> > Just in case you didn't know, these are the tools that are necessary in
> > making a DUNK. 1)Vertical jump or leap. 2)Timing 3)Vision 4)Coordination

> > if you're on a break. If you think I'm wrong, I suggest you go to a


> > "KIDDIE" court and try to do a breakaway dunk and see if you think it's

> > worth one point after that. Also if you get a chance to see some of the


> > former players dunk, Connie Hawkins, David Thompson, and DR.J you'll see
> > the grace that was involved especially with DR.J. Besides sometimes a

> > "DUNK" sparks an entire team to turn a game situation around. No


> > disrespect to you, but you're either not a big B-Ball fan or you don't
> > know skill when you see it.
>

> My criticism of the dunk arises from the observation that too many
> basketball players today choose to focus on their ability to dunk rather
> than to take and make a jumpshot. As a result of this focus, the
> percentage of jumpshots has experienced a dip in comparison to those of
> yesteryear. Apparently, newer NBA players are no longer familiar with the
> jumpshot because of their overwhelming concern on developing a "good"
> dunk. I don't mind an occasional dunk from a small player, but
> seeing 7-footers stuffing the ball without leaving their feet is no fun.
> I'd rather see Hakeem making beautiful fade-aways than witness Shaq slamming
> the ball into the basket yet again, especially when it doesn't require much
> skill to do so. The dunk was interesting when Dr. J did it because it was
> new at the time and considered a rarity because few could do it. How
> interesting can it be when almost everybody in the NBA could do it today?
> Would the three-point shot be considered such a deadly weapon and worth so
> much if everybody could do it? Somehow I doubt it.
>
> >

> > Peace,
> > Del
> >
> > It is better to be thought of as a fool for being quiet, than it is to
> > open your mouth and remove all doubt.
> >

andrew m saari

unread,
Apr 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/16/96
to
In article <4kv2tq$d...@geraldo.cc.utexas.edu>,

Aaron E. Chang <newo...@mail.utexas.edu> wrote:
>>would be ridiculous, or score one point. If you don't like either of
>>those selections, play some "D". The NBA has been accused in the past
>>that it did not. NOT scrappy Knick "d", bring back the zone .
>
>You've got to be kidding. Watching NBA teams play zone defense must
>be the most boring thing in the world.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>


Okay, this dunk shit's getting old. The dunk will never be worth just
one point, so forget it. Enough said. Thank You.

Andrew
--

-- Native Son

Grizz

unread,
Apr 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/16/96
to
Aaron E. Chang wrote:
>
> >Does anyone think Van Exel's suspension will be longer than Rodman's
> >after that stupid stunt tonight.I liked our chances before tonight but
> >who knows if NVE will be available for the playoff.Smooth move
> >Nick,always looking out for the team.
>
> Van Exel will probably be suspended for the remainder of the regular
> season. He will most likely be available for the playoffs.

How bout that Magic. That's showin' those youngsters how its done.
--
Grizz
* Children don't hate. They are taught to.

Grizz

unread,
Apr 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/16/96
to
Matt Propes wrote:
>
> In article <Pine.SGI.3.91.96041...@umbc8.umbc.edu>, THE
> GENIUS <rbo...@gl.umbc.edu> wrote:
>
> > On Thu, 11 Apr 1996, trung p nguyen wrote:
> >
> > > Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
> > > dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
> > > be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
> > > difficult 16 footer.
> > >
> Look at Shaquille O'Neal (Ptooey!) and try to tell me again that some
> people don't try to dunk that much.(And Sottie Pippen and Michael Jordan
> for that matter...Just to name a few....)

Shaq is the perfect reason why the rim should be raised. You have someone
that has trouble hitting the basket from 6 feet away and gets lots of
points because he can dunk the ball. Dunking is about like shooting fish
in a bucket. And about as exciting. It takes about as much skill. That's
why they have the paint, that Shaq seems to spend a lot of time in because
he is worthless outside of it. The paint is there to keep the game more
challenging and fun to watch. Since the paint gets ignored it is time to
raise the rim.

Aaron E. Chang

unread,
Apr 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/16/96
to

Yeah eliminate the 3-point shot and eliminate the little man from the
game.

Brent Singers

unread,
Apr 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/17/96
to
>>>Calculations:
>>>a) 2 * 0.33 = 0.66pts
>>>b) [1 * 1.5] + [(84"- 67")*0.25] = 1.5 + 4.25 = 5.75pts
>>>
>>>Obviously Webb will calculate the difference (5.09 pts) and go for option b
>>>to overcome the deficit.

I can see it now.....

Spud: Excuse me...do you mind stopping the game while I do a few calculations
to figure out which is more beneficial please?

Everyone else: Sure, go ahead......

Yeah right!!!!! Basketball is a fast moving game where you have to make some
decisions in a split second. By the time Spud (or anyone else bar a
mathmatical genius) has made the 'c' the other team has gone and stole the
ball and scored at the other end!

Brent

tr...@imap1.asu.edu

unread,
Apr 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/17/96
to

Raising the rim?!?!?! That would be chaos for a player's shot
form. The whole idea of the dunk is that it is a high percentage shot.
If people play good defense. They reduce that percentage. I've seen
guys in the NBA blow layups. Not often, but it happens. And what about
all the guys who don't HAVE the size or ups to dunk but have excellent
outside shots? If you raise the rim to make it harder to dunk, doesn't
it favor those players who have excellent marksmanship? It's the same as
bringing in the three point line. Now EVERYBODY wants to shoot the
three. Yes, it amounts to more points and yes, it means a more offensive
game, but it also means that the defense has to cover less ground.
Not getting too far off the subject. Raising the rim would only
defeat the whole goal of the NBA's top executives. They are trying to
make it a much more entertaining game to watch by making it more up tempo
and offensive minded. Raising the rim would eliminate that high
percentage shot we call the dunk and people like Shaq will have to resort
to shooting the three. And we all know THAT would be ugly!

Joe Theriault

unread,
Apr 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/17/96
to

...But did they DUNK !?!?!? ;-)

|>
|> Brent

lawrence kuiper

unread,
Apr 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/17/96
to
On the subject ot the paint, I thought Chuck Daly had a good idea once
whne he suggested changing the paint to be like in international rules
(widening towards the basket). I think this would be of some help,
because at least it would make it a little harder for big goons to set up
so close to the hoop.

My .02


JLK

unread,
Apr 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/17/96
to
trung p nguyen <wh...@wam.umd.edu> wrote:

>Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth? Everybody can
>dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think you should
>be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a more
>difficult 16 footer.


Its true that dunking is something most NBA players can do, but I
don't think you have the right idea. Point blank dunks occur when? I
can think of maybe after a steal or on a breakaway, but it takes skill
to get into those situations in the first place. Other dunks would
have to be over someone or after cutting through the lane, which also
takes skill. And, even more importantly, spectacular dunks at the
right time can get a team (and the fans, of course,) charged up!
Besides, I dont know about you, but I sure wish I could dunk!

>My criticism of the dunk arises from the observation that too many
>basketball players today choose to focus on their ability to dunk rather
>than to take and make a jumpshot.

That's a good point, I mean look at the current argument over free
throws. But I think that a player who wants to be a great NBA player
has to realize that all aspects of his game have to be
feared/respected. Its important to be an all around player.

>I'd rather see Hakeem making beautiful fade-aways than witness Shaq slamming
>the ball into the basket yet again

Of course I'd have to agree with you there! :) But, I think that has
a lot to do with a person's role/game. Olajuwon just isn't a power
slam player. He's got a different game than Shaq.

Just my opinion,

JLK


Lance Goodthrust

unread,
Apr 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/18/96
to
In article <317480...@pacific.telebyte.net>,

Grizz <glen...@pacific.telebyte.net> wrote:
>Matt Propes wrote:
>>
>> In article <Pine.SGI.3.91.96041...@umbc8.umbc.edu>, THE
>> GENIUS <rbo...@gl.umbc.edu> wrote:
>>

[snip]

>
>Shaq is the perfect reason why the rim should be raised. You have someone
>that has trouble hitting the basket from 6 feet away and gets lots of
>points because he can dunk the ball. Dunking is about like shooting fish
>in a bucket. And about as exciting. It takes about as much skill. That's
>why they have the paint, that Shaq seems to spend a lot of time in because
>he is worthless outside of it. The paint is there to keep the game more
>challenging and fun to watch. Since the paint gets ignored it is time to
>raise the rim.

are you serious? what do you plan on raising it to? 11 ft? no... i don't
think sahq could jump that additional foot... NOT! how about 12? i think
he could make that too... most of his dunks are from right below the rim.
keep him out of the paint and get him into foul troubles is the easiest way
to silence chumps like him...

>
>--
>Grizz
>* Children don't hate. They are taught to.

><**************************><**************************************><
>< This quality message was >< Instead of giving a politician the ><
>< brought to you by: >< keys to the city, it might be better ><
>< Matthew A. Grosschedl >< to change the locks. ><
>< magr...@mailbox.syr.edu >< - Doug Larson ><
>< mudhen@IRC ><**************************************><
><**************************>< http://web.syr.edu/~magrossc

BSM

unread,
Apr 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/18/96
to
spac...@sonic.net (Greg Lentz) wrote:

>However, to offset that, start calling all the B.S. rough stuff inside
>that goes on both offensively and defensively to maintain position.
>With the ability to double good players, that shouldn't be necessary.

Oh, gimme a break...You can't take that away. It was enough that
they took away hand checking; you take away that, and teams will be
*forced* to become finesse teams. I'll take Anthony Mason pushing the
opposing team's center off the blocks over a fancy layup anyday...

>--

>Greg Lentz

>Top of the Key - Internet Sports Newsletter
>(e-mail KWe...@aol.com for details)

>"When you are courting a nice girl, an hour seems like a second. When you sit on a red-hot cinder, a second seems like an hour. That's relativity."

> -- Albert Einstein



: -*-*-*-*-
*\\-=BSM=-//* : "I Miss Her Sometimes"
: by Jeff Ross
:
Cha...@escape.com : Yesterday I ran into my old girlfriend.
: Then I backed up and ran into her again.
: I miss her sometimes.
: -*-*-*-*-
Reach me on IRC - #FFrpg on irc.dragonfire.net, port 7000
BSM, AKA Unicron


Peter Schurr

unread,
Apr 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/18/96
to
mjpr...@bitstream.net (Matt Propes) wrote:

>I can't believe Rodman didn't receive a longer suspension. I'm not
>condoning either Van Exel or Rodman, but I think headbutting is worse than
>throwing a punch.

Obviously you didn't SEE the incident. Hardly a headbutt!!!!


Peter Schurr
Melbourne Australia Earth


Sgt. Stadanko

unread,
Apr 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/19/96
to

Dunks are a great way to keep the 'd' honest. It's an easy,
high-percentage shot, and if your opponent gets one, then you need to
readjust. It can also be a powerful was to exclamate a great move.
Plus, when in doubt, throw the rock down.

Raise the rim? You must be nuts....


Matt Propes

unread,
Apr 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/20/96
to
In article <4l6n0o$aeh@cdn_news.telecom.com.au>,
Peter.N...@corpmail.telstra.com.au (Peter Schurr) wrote:

I did see it. It was a headbutt.(Head willingly bumping referee's
head.What else could it be?)

Pippen WWW Page

unread,
Apr 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/20/96
to
Web watchers, if you're a fan of Scottie Pippen. Check out:
http://www.clark.net/pub/cardman/pippen/ This site is dedicated to Scottie
Pippen's career. If you have not seen it yet. Check it out atleast once. You may
be surprised with the content on Scottie.

Give it a try!
Jb
http://www.clark.net/pub/cardman/pippen/

s...@wingsbbs.com

unread,
Apr 21, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/21/96
to
tr...@utdallas.edu (T-Rock) wrote:

I think the dunk should be worth three points if
it is good. Steph

>Del Brown <del...@u.washington.edu> wrote:

>>Here's a question for you. Do you play basketball? And if so, I wonder
>>if your skill level is so low that you cannot see the art in "THE DUNK".
>>Just in case you didn't know, these are the tools that are necessary in
>>making a DUNK. 1)Vertical jump or leap. 2)Timing 3)Vision 4)Coordination
>>if you're on a break. If you think I'm wrong, I suggest you go to a
>>"KIDDIE" court and try to do a breakaway dunk and see if you think it's
>>worth one point after that. Also if you get a chance to see some of the
>>former players dunk, Connie Hawkins, David Thompson, and DR.J you'll see
>>the grace that was involved especially with DR.J. Besides sometimes a
>>"DUNK" sparks an entire team to turn a game situation around. No
>>disrespect to you, but you're either not a big B-Ball fan or you don't
>>know skill when you see it.

>Del, I only told him the basics. THANK YOU FOR YOUR REPLY!!!
>I tried to tell the guy the same thing. I know that dunking takes a
>lot of skill. Do you know how upset I got when that guy said nearly
>anyone can do it! GOODNESS mannn! Unlike that guy, I DO play b-ball.
>Been playin' at it for over 11 years. So I can respect your reply.
>Keep it up Del.

>>Peace,
>>Del

>>It is better to be thought of as a fool for being quiet, than it is to
>>open your mouth and remove all doubt.

>PEACE!!!
>T-Rock

>Go Magic! Hardaway for President!

PAUL GAMBLE

unread,
Apr 22, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/22/96
to
MSGID: 1:106/4...@hsn.fg.score1.com 97a5d744
-> Subject: Re: The dunk!
-> Date: Sat, 13 Apr 1996 01:14:11 -0700

The dunk has always been underestimated.
How many B-ballers DUNK on K.Malone,O.Thorpe....ETC........

--- QScan/PCB v1.19b / 01-0525
* Origin: Houston Sports Network * USR 33.6K * 713-988-8411 (1:106/45)

slarratt

unread,
Apr 23, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/23/96
to
A dunk is an artform all of it's own. It allows players to
express their energy, even if it's Shawn Kemp screaming like a madman.
To remove it from the game or to only give 1 point would be a tragic
mistake. It gives Basketball an aura that is uncommon in other sports.
The skill involved in a dunk by it's creator is as impressive as the
grace it appears to the beholder... if you don't enjoy or at the very
least respect the grace of a Micheal Jordan or a Dr. J, maybe this
game's not for you.


Matt Propes

unread,
Apr 24, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/24/96
to
In article <4lj9g3$8...@news-2.ccinet.ab.ca>, slarratt
<slar...@ccinet.ab.ca> wrote:

I'd hardly call it an artform. It only allows players to get reaction
from the crowd. Obviously it doesn't involve too much skill because most
everyone does it nowadays. I remember when Harold Miner was being touted
as "Baby Jordan" and now people are saying he's better at dunking than at
the game of basketball.

Jerold Day

unread,
Apr 24, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/24/96
to
In article <317480...@pacific.telebyte.net>, Grizz
<glen...@pacific.telebyte.net> wrote:

> Shaq is the perfect reason why the rim should be raised. You have someone
> that has trouble hitting the basket from 6 feet away and gets lots of
> points because he can dunk the ball. Dunking is about like shooting fish
> in a bucket. And about as exciting. It takes about as much skill. That's
> why they have the paint, that Shaq seems to spend a lot of time in because
> he is worthless outside of it. The paint is there to keep the game more
> challenging and fun to watch. Since the paint gets ignored it is time to
> raise the rim.

First of all, the dunk is the most exiting play in basketball for most of
the paying public. Eliminating it would be a tremendously bad for the
popularity of the sport.
Sorry if you don't like it, but basketball was a minor sport before the dunk.

Secondly (and more importantly), raising the rim is an incredibly poor
idea, unless you propose to raise the rim in every playground in the
country. Great shooters get that way because they shoot 100s of jump
shots a day since grade school. So you want them to shoot at a ten foot
hoop for fifteen years and then adjust to an 11ft foot hoop when they turn
pro? Do you realize what kind of shooting percentages they'd have? And no,
it wouldn't change after a couple years. The game would be a sloppy mess
that no one would pay to see.

Third, Shaq's game wouldn't be half as good if his team didn't have great
outside shooting to balance him. And because he can't shoot free throws,
he ain't that great.

Your point about the paint, however, is well taken. There's always a need
for more three-second calls.

Basketball ain't broke. It's more popular than ever. Why do you want to
screw with it?

Jerry

--
Whoever knows he is deep, strives for clarity; whoever would like to appear deep to the crowd, strives for obscurity. For the crowd considers anything deep if only it cannot see to the bottom: the crowd is so timid and afraid of going into the water.---Nietzsche

Charles Held

unread,
Apr 24, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/24/96
to
In article <jerry-24049...@ppp109-sf2.sirius.com>,
je...@sirius.com (Jerold Day) wrote:
=Sorry if you don't like it, but basketball was a minor sport before the dunk.

Yeah, the '57 UNC-KU game sucked. So did all those Alcindor UCLA teams.
Adolph Rupp, Everett Case, Frank McGuire: "minor sport" coaches.

samantha

unread,
Apr 25, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/25/96
to

In <317480...@pacific.telebyte.net> Grizz

<glen...@pacific.telebyte.net> writes:
>
>Matt Propes wrote:
>>
>> In article <Pine.SGI.3.91.96041...@umbc8.umbc.edu>,
THE
>> GENIUS <rbo...@gl.umbc.edu> wrote:
>>
>> > On Thu, 11 Apr 1996, trung p nguyen wrote:
>> >
>> > > Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth?
Everybody can
>> > > dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so. I think
you should
>> > > be rewarded less for making a point-blank dunk than for making a
more
>> > > difficult 16 footer.
>> > >
>> Look at Shaquille O'Neal (Ptooey!) and try to tell me again that
some
>> people don't try to dunk that much.(And Sottie Pippen and Michael
Jordan
>> for that matter...Just to name a few....)
>
>Shaq is the perfect reason why the rim should be raised. You have
someone
>that has trouble hitting the basket from 6 feet away and gets lots of
>points because he can dunk the ball. Dunking is about like shooting
fish
>in a bucket. And about as exciting. It takes about as much skill.
That's
>why they have the paint, that Shaq seems to spend a lot of time in
because
>he is worthless outside of it. The paint is there to keep the game
more
>challenging and fun to watch. Since the paint gets ignored it is time
to
>raise the rim.
>
>--
>Grizz
>* Children don't hate. They are taught to.

Fine, but why on earth should everyone else in the league be penalized
just because Shaq, and Muresan and Bradley, for that matter, happen to
be freaks of nature? Raising the rim won't only hurt Shaq, it'll hurt
everyone. If everyone knows he can't hit from 6 ft., they should be
smart enough to exploit that. For all the talk of the "three headed
center", and the "18 fouls" that Chicago had, they weren't really good
enough last year to expose that weakness... Shaq hit his fouls, for one
thing...

Why is it so irksome to have some people who are just naturally good at
something? You have people like that in every profession... people who
have a knack for something, for whatever the reason, physical or mental
advantages... should boxing force Tyson to tie a hand behind his back?

Besides, some people actually *like* all the athleticism that has
cropped up in Basketball, despite all the bad press it's receiving from
sticklers.. why not give people what they want? It's such a great
shot...

And if it's so easy to dunk, then why arent more seven footers
effective? Ever see the great Koncak? What a pitful sight in the
paint. Kevin Willis, Rony Seikaly, Shawn Bradley... these guys
actually make height look like a *chore*! I suspect that there's a bit
more to Shaq's game than height. Yes, he has incredible power (which
in most other sports would be considered a blessing, in Basketball it
earns you derisive comments), but he also has a pair of the quickest,
surest hands in basketball. I suspect that he works very hard on the
stupid foul shot, he just can't seem to get his pea-brain around the
concept of actually *rolling* his wrist to get a spin on the shot.

For that matter, we all know that Dennis wouldn't be *half* as good a
rebounder if he actually had to score, say, between 12-15 pts PER
NIGHT. I actually see Barkley as a better rebounder, but a guy who
doesn't have the luxury of being one-dimensional. So should it be
illegal to score over 15 rebounds without also scoring a pre-determined
number of points?

No.

The beauty of basketball (a beauty that is being lost with all these
new rules and reformations) is that it is free-form, open, flowing...
it is open to interpretation... you can assemble any kind of team you
want. Set a minimum number of rules, and watch people's creativity
figure out how to beat your rules. Which is pretty much my final
argument: if you change the rules, or the height of the rim, or
anything, the coaches and players will just find newer ways to get
around it, and then you'll just be mad at them for making *that* look
to easy... you will not hurt the players or coaches... the only ones
you risk alienating are the FANS... who may not cotton to a game that
claims to be "basketball" but isn't really any more...

Frankly, I think that is beginning to happen with these new "NBA rules"
rules that seem to have nothing whatsoever with basketball... people
are getting pissed and bored with the hand-checkless NBA, an NBA where
*everything* is a foul, where stepping 2 inches out of position is an
illegal defense, tech foul... I guess zone d was getting a little
boring, but was it worth it? Now everyone's just bored of the
overly-offensive, dunk crazy NBA. I say, go back to how it was.

Although maybe moving the line in was a good idea... I guess that
could stay...

But let's not be mad just because players make something *look* easy...
it may not necessarily *be* that easy... look at poor Sir Charles,
facing retirement every year because he's walking on splints. Ditto
Ewing. Ditto Pippen. Dunking takes it's tolls... which means it's
probably not all *that* easy to do...

oh well...


Brett M. Carlisle

unread,
Apr 26, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/26/96
to

In article <4losbf$1...@dfw-ixnews2.ix.netcom.com>, wi...@ix.netcom.com(samantha) wrote:
>
>Why is it so irksome to have some people who are just naturally good at
>something? You have people like that in every profession... people who
>have a knack for something, for whatever the reason, physical or mental
>advantages... should boxing force Tyson to tie a hand behind his back?
>
>The beauty of basketball (a beauty that is being lost with all these
>new rules and reformations) is that it is free-form, open, flowing...
>it is open to interpretation... you can assemble any kind of team you
>want. Set a minimum number of rules, and watch people's creativity
>figure out how to beat your rules. Which is pretty much my final
>argument: if you change the rules, or the height of the rim, or
>anything, the coaches and players will just find newer ways to get
>around it, and then you'll just be mad at them for making *that* look
>to easy... you will not hurt the players or coaches... the only ones
>you risk alienating are the FANS... who may not cotton to a game that
>claims to be "basketball" but isn't really any more...
>
>But let's not be mad just because players make something *look* easy...
>it may not necessarily *be* that easy... look at poor Sir Charles,
>facing retirement every year because he's walking on splints. Ditto
>Ewing. Ditto Pippen. Dunking takes it's tolls... which means it's
>probably not all *that* easy to do...


I hate to quote such a large portion of your message, but my comments would be
moot without the essence of your post to accompany them.

I agree wholeheartedly. I think too many people concentrate on the
deficiencies of the sport rather than the beauty. The action, the
pulse-pounding excitement (my wife and I have taken to calling the Magic the
Cardiac Kids this season due to so many last second nail-biters), and, as you
so eloquently put it, the free flowing nature of the game is why we all watch.
Sure, dunking *seems* easy for those who can do it (another issue entirely),
but we all know that things that seem easy often aren't. And besides, quite a
good percentage of the time, Dennis Scott makes the three-pointer seem easy.
Perhaps we should outlaw the tre. NOT.

Let the players utilize their particular strengths and skills. Would you make
Brooks Thompson become a dunker, or a post-up player, and have Shaquille
O'Neal be mandated to take a certain number from beyond the arc? I think
not...what kind of game would we have then? I can hear Chip Carey now "OK
Goose, there's our final: Magic 12, Hornets 8 (even Brooks can dunk better
than Mugsy <laugh>). Is that what you all want?

Let 'em play.

Jerold Day

unread,
Apr 27, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/27/96
to

In article <4lm10f$21...@mule2.mindspring.com>, ch...@clt.mindspring.com
(Charles Held) wrote:

I'm not saying the game wasn't good. But from a monetary standpoint (which
was the point of my entire post), PRO Basketball (again, which was what I
was posting about. These are pro basketball newsgroups) lagged far behind
other sports in popularity. Now hoop is king.

Greg Lentz

unread,
Apr 28, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/28/96
to

wi...@ix.netcom.com(samantha) wrote:

>The beauty of basketball (a beauty that is being lost with all these
>new rules and reformations) is that it is free-form, open, flowing...
>it is open to interpretation... you can assemble any kind of team you
>want. Set a minimum number of rules, and watch people's creativity
>figure out how to beat your rules. Which is pretty much my final
>argument: if you change the rules, or the height of the rim, or
>anything, the coaches and players will just find newer ways to get
>around it, and then you'll just be mad at them for making *that* look

>too easy... you will not hurt the players or coaches... the only ones


>you risk alienating are the FANS... who may not cotton to a game that
>claims to be "basketball" but isn't really any more...

>Frankly, I think that is beginning to happen with these new "NBA rules"
>rules that seem to have nothing whatsoever with basketball... people
>are getting pissed and bored with the hand-checkless NBA, an NBA where
>*everything* is a foul, where stepping 2 inches out of position is an
>illegal defense, tech foul... I guess zone d was getting a little
>boring, but was it worth it? Now everyone's just bored of the
>overly-offensive, dunk crazy NBA. I say, go back to how it was.

Agreed. Move the line back where it was and get rid of the illegal
defense. If zones were such great defenses, all the college teams
would play them - most play man. A professional team should be able
to dissect a zone if they have a post scorer and 1-2 reliable outside
shooters. A 100% effort man to man defense is still the best defense
there is.

If the zone came back, many of the things which make basketball so
unwatchable would go away. The isolation play would go away, the down
to the post back out for the easy three pointer play, etc. Teams
would actually have to start running plays, passing, and learning how
to shoot. The game is so much worse than it was when the Bird
Celtics, "J" Sixers, and Magic Lakers dominated, it isn't even funny.
The skill level was much higher, even though the athleticism wasn't as
high. Any of those teams would smoke the last 7 champs, including all
3 Bulls teams, both Piston teams, and both Rocket teams.

>Although maybe moving the line in was a good idea... I guess that
>could stay...

Move it back. Too many bad shooters are taking the shot because even
if you only shoot 30%, it's better than shooting 50% from 2 point
land. Make it so that only the real shooters (Reggie, Scott) are
taking them.

>But let's not be mad just because players make something *look* easy...
>it may not necessarily *be* that easy... look at poor Sir Charles,
>facing retirement every year because he's walking on splints. Ditto
>Ewing. Ditto Pippen. Dunking takes it's tolls... which means it's
>probably not all *that* easy to do...

I think things other than dunking are taking its toll, like all the
rough stuff that doesn't get called underneath the basket.

a01...@academic.csubak.edu

unread,
Apr 29, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/29/96
to

Hey, next lets have no three pointer, take away the shot clock, and go back to
the old days when 30-20 was a high scoring game. ok, I'm being sarcastic. You
really defend with your foot work if a person gets that close deserves two
points. Also, remember not all players can't dunk, but a 11-12 foot rim would
give shooters trouble. I think you can't just change the rim height everytime a
player is dominant. Also in case of Shaq, everypoint for him is not a dunk, he
ussually uses a jump hook, a fade, or *gasp* freethrows.

I also read a post on reducing point value of the dunk. If you think its so
easy, first try it, and if you can, try to get around an NBA defense, and if
you're a michael jordan, try and ask Spudd webb how easy it is for those who
aren't 6'6"+.....


Later,


Joe


Rick Lopez

unread,
Apr 30, 1996, 3:00:00 AM4/30/96
to

Jerold Day wrote:
>
> In article <317480...@pacific.telebyte.net>, Grizz
> <glen...@pacific.telebyte.net> wrote:
>
> > Shaq is the perfect reason why the rim should be raised. You have someone
> > that has trouble hitting the basket from 6 feet away and gets lots of
> > points because he can dunk the ball. Dunking is about like shooting fish
> > in a bucket. And about as exciting. It takes about as much skill. That's
> > why they have the paint, that Shaq seems to spend a lot of time in because
> > he is worthless outside of it. The paint is there to keep the game more
> > challenging and fun to watch. Since the paint gets ignored it is time to
> > raise the rim.
>
> First of all, the dunk is the most exiting play in basketball for most of
> the paying public. Eliminating it would be a tremendously bad for the
> popularity of the sport.
> Sorry if you don't like it, but basketball was a minor sport before the dunk.
>

It doesn't sound to me if he is proposing the elimination of dunks. He merely
stated his opinion on the subject.


> Secondly (and more importantly), raising the rim is an incredibly poor
> idea, unless you propose to raise the rim in every playground in the
> country. Great shooters get that way because they shoot 100s of jump
> shots a day since grade school. So you want them to shoot at a ten foot
> hoop for fifteen years and then adjust to an 11ft foot hoop when they turn
> pro? Do you realize what kind of shooting percentages they'd have? And no,
> it wouldn't change after a couple years. The game would be a sloppy mess
> that no one would pay to see.
>


Agreed. The game would be a mess. Then teams would rely on dunks and lay-ups
more. If an adjustment is to be made, chances are it will be to reduce the
diameter of the rim. Right now it lies at two times the diameter of a regulation
ball. Shorten that diameter be a couple of inches, and you have people blowing
dunks like Kemp all over, unless they concentrate!

>
> Your point about the paint, however, is well taken. There's always a need
> for more three-second calls.
>

Agreed.


> Basketball ain't broke. It's more popular than ever. Why do you want to
> screw with it?
>
> Jerry
>
> --

There's a lot of things wrong with basketball. But it is mostly off the court
stuff. (salaries, dissention, griping, egos, etc.)

Greg Lentz

unread,
May 2, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/2/96
to

r...@planetaip.com (R Muncada) wrote:

>In article <4lv46d$d...@ultra.sonic.net>, spac...@sonic.net (Greg Lentz) wrote:

>> wi...@ix.netcom.com(samantha) wrote:

>> Agreed. Move the line back where it was and get rid of the illegal
>> defense. If zones were such great defenses, all the college teams
>> would play them - most play man. A professional team should be able
>> to dissect a zone if they have a post scorer and 1-2 reliable outside
>> shooters. A 100% effort man to man defense is still the best defense
>> there is.

>The elite college teams play man because they CAN. To play man, a team
>has to have good, nearly tireless defenders, who are well disciplined.
>Also, most man-to-man teams have some sort of depth to handle the
>increase of energy and intensity that the defense requires. Often, others
>play zone simply because they don't have the talent to play man. That
>means either not having guys that are skilled enough, or maybe not
>disciplined enough, though it takes discipline to play good zone as
>well.

Even most of the non-elite teams play man. That doesn't mean they all
play it well, but they play it. When a team plays a zone, it's
usually because they don't respect the other team's ability to shoot
the 3. Lack of talent is not usually a problem at the college level,
it's more of a high school reason.

>> If the zone came back, many of the things which make basketball so
>> unwatchable would go away. The isolation play would go away, the down
>> to the post back out for the easy three pointer play, etc. Teams
>> would actually have to start running plays, passing, and learning how
>> to shoot. The game is so much worse than it was when the Bird
>> Celtics, "J" Sixers, and Magic Lakers dominated, it isn't even funny.
>> The skill level was much higher, even though the athleticism wasn't as
>> high. Any of those teams would smoke the last 7 champs, including all
>> 3 Bulls teams, both Piston teams, and both Rocket teams.

>That's not gonna happen. The NBA is being marketed as an individual
>game. Besides, what you're saying assumes that all players are pretty
>much selfless and not stat-oriented, which seems all but impossible
>today. The consensus is that zones would make the game boring. Look
>at Seattle. They play something close to a zone. All of their players
>are 6'4" or over. They don't mind switching. It's horrible to watch.
>It's not visually appealing, especially considering that the average
>fan has very little clue about what is happening away from the ball.
>Next time you see an illegal defense, and there are others watching
>the game with you, ask them why it was an illegal d. Chances are
>that they can't tell you. They would say, "They're playing zone,
>right?" Wrong. Usually it's a guy trapped deciding between following
>his man and a double team.

I know it won't happen. I just said it should happen. I don't
consider Seattle a great team to watch, but no more boring than
everyone else. At least they play defense.

>> Move it back. Too many bad shooters are taking the shot because even
>> if you only shoot 30%, it's better than shooting 50% from 2 point
>> land. Make it so that only the real shooters (Reggie, Scott) are
>> taking them.

>Yes, move it back. Too many power forwards are taking them, when they
>have no business doing so.

>--
>Rhamesis Muncada
>r...@planetaip.com

Jon Wondrack

unread,
May 2, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/2/96
to

> > In article <317480...@pacific.telebyte.net>, Grizz
> > <glen...@pacific.telebyte.net> wrote:
> >
> > > Shaq is the perfect reason why the rim should be raised. You have someone
> > > that has trouble hitting the basket from 6 feet away and gets lots of
> > > points because he can dunk the ball. Dunking is about like shooting fish
> > > in a bucket. And about as exciting. It takes about as much skill. That's
> > > why they have the paint, that Shaq seems to spend a lot of time in because
> > > he is worthless outside of it. The paint is there to keep the game more
> > > challenging and fun to watch. Since the paint gets ignored it is time to
> > > raise the rim.

What needs to happen is more backing in calls. Barkley has gotten away
with it his entire career and now Shaq is the new poster boy for throwing
your a$$ into the defender and slowly backing him under the basket and
then dunking on him. This takes no skill and pretty soon we'll have a
lot of 300 pound centers in the league doing the same thing. If of
course there are any more 300 lb. 7 feet tall basketball players out
there. My point is Hakeem, Robinson, and Ewing have finesse moves and
actually shoot the ball. Even Barkley has more of a game than bruising
on the blocks. I say make Shaq develop a real game instead of his the
crap he does now. Call the foul every time he moves a player more than
2-3 feet towards the basket by throwing his bulk at them.

Jon

Lance Goodthrust

unread,
May 2, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/2/96
to

In article <3188E4...@uclink4.berkeley.edu>,

uhhh.... don't worry about shaq. how many rings does he have? none.
and he won't get any until he learns how to shoot. Hakeem has the moves,
and he ripped Shaq in the championship last year. people will continue
to haq Shaq until he learns how to shoot. Barkley can hit his shots,
that is why people don't haq him as much. don't raise the rim. you will
ruin the game. raising the rim will only lead to more missed shots, and
sloopy play. more banging and bruising on the inside where people are
trying to get position for the rebounds. talk about boring.

Gabriel Ba'<gabtwins@usp.br>

unread,
May 3, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/3/96
to

> >Matt Propes wrote:
> >>
> >> > > Should the dunk in basketball be reduced to 1 pt in worth?
> Everybody can
> >> > > dunk these days, and it takes almost no skill to do so.

On 25 Apr 1996, samantha wrote:
> >
> >Shaq is the perfect reason why the rim should be raised. You have
> someone
> >that has trouble hitting the basket from 6 feet away and gets lots of

> >points because he can dunk the ball. And about as exciting. It takes
> >about as much skill.

> > Since the paint gets ignored it is time
> to
> >raise the rim.
>

> Fine, but why on earth should everyone else in the league be penalized
> just because Shaq, and Muresan and Bradley, for that matter, happen to
> be freaks of nature? Raising the rim won't only hurt Shaq, it'll hurt
> everyone.


It won't hurt Michael "Air" Jordan, that's for sure!


> Why is it so irksome to have some people who are just naturally good at
> something? You have people like that in every profession... people who
> have a knack for something, for whatever the reason, physical or mental
> advantages... should boxing force Tyson to tie a hand behind his back?


Should all players give up because of what Michael can do and they
don't???Courser not. They have to catch up to him, to that point.

> Besides, some people actually *like* all the athleticism that has
> cropped up in Basketball, despite all the bad press it's receiving from
> sticklers.. why not give people what they want? It's such a great
> shot...

>Everyone's just bored of the overly-offensive, dunk crazy NBA.


> I say, go back to how it was.

> Although maybe moving the line in was a good idea... I guess that
> could stay...

Well, that rules thing is realy upseting n borung. No one likes it, but I
hope Basketball won't reach that "NFL" crazy montain of rules.

Gabriel Ba
<gabt...@usp.br>
Brazil


GO Bulls!!!!!


SUX 2 BU

unread,
May 3, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/3/96
to

If it weren't for basketball, the dead Reggie Lewis and his ghetto born
wife would be selling the drugs that killed Reggie Lewis on a street
corner.

Why won't Donna Lewis let it rest? Does she want to bring shame to the
great Celtics organization that did its best to keep Reggie's drug use
within the organization. When the Wall Street Journal let the world
know of Reggie's drug use, the Celtics couldn't come out to deny it
because it was true. Paul Gaston's ignorant threat to sue the WSJ for
the stroy but subsequent inaction shows again proves that the story is
true.

Why doesn't Donna Lewis do something useful with her life? Although she
has no marketable skills other than being a gold-digger, she could
speak to people like Marcus Camby and tell him what could happen if he
continues his cocaine use.

If anyone should be sued, it should be Donna Lewis. The Celtics should
sue Donna Lewis for taking Reggie out of the hospital in the middle of
the night when he could barely walk because she didn't like what the
doctors said. Donna Lewis dragged Reggie around to various doctors
until she found some that said what she wanted to hear. Next to
cocaine, she's more guilty than anyone for causing Reggie's death.

Chris Hardy

unread,
May 5, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/5/96
to Tyee, high, school

I think that the super sonics will be in the nba finals with the bootie
bulls. If you have any suggestions please


Chris Hardy

unread,
May 5, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/5/96
to

I think that if your going to pick any two teams to be in the finals it
will be the stunning sonics that got past the first round after three
years of trying and the unbeatabulls because of Jordan back in the swing
of things and the Dennis Rodman scandle I mean what's up with his hair I
love the way the guy plays ball and the ablity to get in anyones face
even the refs but the attitude has to go. Plus Kemp and the sonics are
hungry the Rockets are going to be nooooooooo problem.

Ted Kezinskey


Chris Hardy

unread,
May 5, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/5/96
to

jack kavorkein


Rick Lopez <rlo...@dqimages.com> wrote:


>Jerold Day wrote:
>>
>> In article <317480...@pacific.telebyte.net>, Grizz

>> <glen...@pacific.telebyte.net> wrote:
>>
>> > Shaq is the perfect reason why the rim should be raised. You have someone
>> > that has trouble hitting the basket from 6 feet away and gets lots of

>> > points because he can dunk the ball. Dunking is about like shooting fish
>> > in a bucket. And about as exciting. It takes about as much skill. That's
>> > why they have the paint, that Shaq seems to spend a lot of time in because
>> > he is worthless outside of it. The paint is there to keep the game more

>> > challenging and fun to watch. Since the paint gets ignored it is time to
>> > raise the rim.
>>

Ted Kezinskey


DANIEL WEBER

unread,
May 5, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/5/96
to

Chris Hardy <cha...@pop.directnet.net> wrote:

>I think that the super sonics will be in the nba finals with the bootie
>bulls. If you have any suggestions please

I personally doubt it. Gary payton is the last problem personality
that needs to be discarded!!


Steve Dupuy

unread,
May 6, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/6/96
to


On 2 May 1996, Lance Goodthrust wrote:

> In article <3188E4...@uclink4.berkeley.edu>,


> Jon Wondrack <jo...@uclink4.berkeley.edu> wrote:
> >> > In article <317480...@pacific.telebyte.net>, Grizz
> >> > <glen...@pacific.telebyte.net> wrote:
> >> >
> >> > > Shaq is the perfect reason why the rim should be raised.
You have someone
> >> > > that has trouble hitting the basket from 6 feet away and gets lots of
> >> > > points because he can dunk the ball.
Dunking is about like shooting fish
> >> > > in a bucket. And about as exciting. It takes about as much skill.

If you don't think dunks are exciting, why the hell do you like
basketball? If Bball had no dunks it would quickly turn as boring as
baseball and hockey. Sports maybe you should think about switching to.

That's
> >> > > why they have the paint,

Why?

that Shaq seems to spend a lot of time in because
> >> > > he is worthless outside of it.

WHY would you take outside shots of a lower percentage when you can
dominate anybody in the NBA inside? Even you should be able to figure
that one out.

The paint is there to keep the game more
> >> > > challenging and fun to watch. Since the paint gets ignored it is time to
> >> > > raise the rim.

The paint is ignored, now?? Shaq doesn't ignore the paint, he's always
scoring in it. You just contradicted yourself, but I'm not surprised.

> >
> >What needs to happen is more backing in calls. Barkley has gotten away
> >with it his entire career and now Shaq is the new poster boy for throwing
> >your a$$ into the defender and slowly backing him under the basket and
> >then dunking on him. This takes no skill and pretty soon we'll have a
> >lot of 300 pound centers in the league doing the same thing. If of
> >course there are any more 300 lb. 7 feet tall basketball players out
> >there.

How many Magic games have you watched? 3? If you have watched them during
the season you would see that Shaq has many around the basket moves. If
being 7 feet and weighing a lot is
all it takes to back people in and score, as you claim. Why aren't Benoit
Benjamin, Bryant Reeves, Stanley Roberts, or Felton Spencer in the top of
the league in scoring?

My point is Hakeem, Robinson, and Ewing have finesse moves and
> >actually shoot the ball.

Shaq has a fade away, he has been using consistently since he came back
from injury.

Even Barkley has more of a game than bruising
> >on the blocks. I say make Shaq develop a real game instead of his the
> >crap he does now. Call the foul every time he moves a player more than
> >2-3 feet towards the basket by throwing his bulk at them.

Yeah, that's the solution. Whine about changing the rules. If you want to
force Shaq to develop a "real" game, how about stopping him from doing
what he's sucessful at? Problem is, you can't. With your logic, we should
make fadeaway jumpers illegal because nobody can stop Jordan's.

> >
> >Jon

>
> uhhh.... don't worry about shaq. how many rings does he have? none.
> and he won't get any until he learns how to shoot.

What was he in FG % this year. I think he's shooting just fine. How many
rings do Barkley or Robinson have? As for a center having to have an
outside shot to win a ring, you ever heard of Wilt or Russel??

Hakeem has the moves,
> and he ripped Shaq in the championship last year.


Hardly. Shaq had better fg% and rebounds than Hakeem in that series, and
Shaq was being double teamed, while Olajuwon was being played straight up.

people will continue
> to haq Shaq until he learns how to shoot. Barkley can hit his shots,
> that is why people don't haq him as much. don't raise the rim. you will
> ruin the game. raising the rim will only lead to more missed shots, and
> sloopy play. more banging and bruising on the inside where people are
> trying to get position for the rebounds. talk about boring.

This I agree with. If you have to talk about changing the rules of
basketball to make a certain player less effective, then that player is
probably kicking your teams ass, or your team can't stop what he does well.
The problem lies in your team, not the rules of the game.

Steve

klipp martin joseph

unread,
May 7, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/7/96
to

Followup-To: alt.sports.basketball.nba.atlanta-hawks,alt.sports.basketball.nba.boston-celtics,alt.sports.basketball.nba.char-hornets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.chicago-bulls,alt.sports.basketball.nba.dallas-mavs,alt.sports.basketball.nba.denver-nuggets,alt
.
: all it takes to back people in and score, as you claim. Why aren't Benoit
: Benjamin, Bryant Reeves, Stanley Roberts, or Felton Spencer in the top of
: the league in scoring?

Simple: Druggie, Breaking-into-the League, Old Guy, Old Guy

: My point is Hakeem, Robinson, and Ewing have finesse moves and
: > >actually shoot the ball.

: Shaq has a fade away, he has been using consistently since he came back
: from injury.

Because he can't risk getting fouled, thus going to the FREE THROW LINE
(Shaq: "Free? You can actually do something for free?")

: What was he in FG % this year. I think he's shooting just fine. How many

Look at the guys he was up there with, and then see no John Stockton, MJ,
Steve Kerr, Penny Hardaway, etc. Oh a big game is fine, but let's not
kid ourselves, the big guys have the advantage taking higher-percebtage
shots.

: Hardly. Shaq had better fg% and rebounds than Hakeem in that series, and

: Shaq was being double teamed, while Olajuwon was being played straight up.

Hakeem won. Face it, admit it, and go home. :)

klipp martin joseph

unread,
May 7, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/7/96
to

Followup-To: alt.sports.basketball.nba.atlanta-hawks,alt.sports.basketball.nba.boston-celtics,alt.sports.basketball.nba.char-hornets,alt.sports.basketball.nba.chicago-bulls,alt.sports.basketball.nba.dallas-mavs,alt.sports.basketball.nba.denver-nuggets,alt
.
: all it takes to back people in and score, as you claim. Why aren't Benoit
: Benjamin, Bryant Reeves, Stanley Roberts, or Felton Spencer in the top of
: the league in scoring?

Simple: Drug addict, Breaking-into-the-League, Old Guy, & Old Guy.

: Shaq has a fade away, he has been using consistently since he came back
: from injury.

...because he knows that he can't risk being fouled, as that would send
him to the FREE THROW LINE (Shaq: "Free? You can do something for
free??).


: Hardly. Shaq had better fg% and rebounds than Hakeem in that series, and
: Shaq was being double teamed, while Olajuwon was being played straight up.

Hakeem won. Face it, admit it, and go home.


: This I agree with. If you have to talk about changing the rules of

: basketball to make a certain player less effective, then that player is
: probably kicking your teams ass, or your team can't stop what he does well.
: The problem lies in your team, not the rules of the game.

: Steve

Was not Shaq the guy who, after he was fouled by Matt Geiger in the
pre-season, said the refs need to watch out for people fouling him, and
they better call guys who guard him more tightly to prevent such an
instance from happening again? Sounds like he needs zebra to babysit
his ass on the floor, because if it were to get bruised, it might make
those stupid Shaq-fu moves more difficult to do in front of the kiddie
camera.

Steve Dupuy

unread,
May 8, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/8/96
to

>
> : This I agree with. If you have to talk about changing the rules of
> : basketball to make a certain player less effective, then that player is
> : probably kicking your teams ass, or your team can't stop what he does well.
> : The problem lies in your team, not the rules of the game.
>
> : Steve
>
> Was not Shaq the guy who, after he was fouled by Matt Geiger in the
> pre-season, said the refs need to watch out for people fouling him, and
> they better call guys who guard him more tightly to prevent such an
offense from happening again?


Hackster artists who can't play defense such as Geiger or anyone else for
that matter, should not be allowed to get away with blatant fouls on
anybody. The hack should have been intentional. He didn't get anywhere
near the ball. Anyway, the point is Shaq was not calling for a change in
rules, just that the current ones be enforced.

Steve

Donald Moore

unread,
May 10, 1996, 3:00:00 AM5/10/96
to

In article <4mdrbl$7...@dfw-ixnews10.ix.netcom.com>,
bu...@ix.netcom.com(SUX 2 BU) wrote:

> If it weren't for basketball, the dead Reggie Lewis and his ghetto born
> wife would be selling the drugs that killed Reggie Lewis on a street
> corner.

What wrong with you? The last letter in your name is definitely wrong.
You must really have such a high opinion of yourself - it's almost
laughable!

If you don't like black Americans why don't you follow another sport
besides basketball? Why don't you take your little boy racist statements
to the KKK newsgroup or some other like group of high intellect? You're a
sad case; it's too bad YOU don't know it.

Ryan C Grant

unread,
Jun 4, 1996, 3:00:00 AM6/4/96
to

mjpr...@bitstream.net (Matt Propes) wrote:

>I can't believe Rodman didn't receive a longer suspension. I'm not
>condoning either Van Exel or Rodman, but I think headbutting is worse than
>throwing a punch.

I don't agree. Rodman's action was a headbutt, barely; the ref's head
didn't even move. Nick's litle forearm sent the ref flying into the
scorers table, although I think there was a little acting on his part.


Ryan C Grant

unread,
Jun 4, 1996, 3:00:00 AM6/4/96
to

>mjpr...@bitstream.net (Matt Propes) wrote:

I apologize for having posted this again. I cleaned out my buffer and
accidently reposted most of the messages I have ever posted before.


It is loading more messages.
0 new messages