My opinion is that the guys they tout the most never seem to prosper.
Their successful rookies over the years were guys you didn't hear about
them until spring training. I don't remember them praising Alonso or
Nimmo when they were minor leaguers. Even going back as far as Gooden.
Strawberry was the last guy I remember who lived up to the hype. You can
add Seaver and Ryan if we're nitpicking; albeit Ryan came into his own
with California. I don't remember them hyping Koosman or Cleon Jones.
Cross fingers and hope for the best