RESULT: comp.security.firewalls passes 647:88
da...@dogwood.com
unmoderated group comp.security.firewalls passes 647:88
There were 647 YES votes and 88 NO votes, for a total of 735 valid votes.
There were 2 abstains and 10 invalid ballots.
For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES
and NO) votes. There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO
votes.
There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted.
If no serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the
moderator of news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly
thereafter.
Newsgroups line:
comp.security.firewalls Anything pertaining to network firewall security.
This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. For voting
questions only contact Dave Cornejo <da...@dogwood.com>. For questions
about the proposed group contact Dan Farmer <z...@fish.com>.
This CFV was also sent to the mailing list fire...@greatcircle.com
after it has been posted to Usenet.
CHARTER
The purpose of comp.security.firewalls is to serve as a central
location in which firewalls can be discussed and investigated.
Questions, comments, discoveries, code snippets and new product
information can be discussed, among other issues. It will be
unmoderated and open to discussion of all aspects of firewalls.
RATIONALE
There is a need for a newsgroup to directly educate, discuss, and
propogate information to the Internet community about firewalls,
because more and more sites are setting up firewalls, and many people
don't understand the technical or philosophical issues, can't spend
the time keeping up with the latest information, and don't have a
proper forum to discuss new ideas. There is currently no newsgroup
which is specifically for this fairly complex subject.
comp.security.firewalls Final Vote Ack
Voted Yes
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7342...@compuserve.com Chris Gesler
A.J.B...@reading.ac.uk Adrian Bassett
ad...@scr.siemens.com Jonathan Adair
ad...@math.tau.ac.il Adam Morrison
ad...@softlab.ece.ntua.gr yiorgos adamopoulos
adm...@servonet.com Systems Administration account
ad...@inms-db.os.dhhs.gov Alan Dowd
ad...@aber.ac.uk Adrian Shaw
afa...@us.itd.umich.edu Andrew Philip Fabbro
afc...@texas.net Al Castanoli
afl...@netcom.com Alana Flynn
ag...@freenet.carleton.ca Colin R. Leech
ahls...@mgi.com Dave Ahlstrand
ah...@MR.Net Andrew Hoag
aj...@corp.micrognosis.com Adam Jack
a...@xirion.nl Bert-Jan van Rein
ak...@hqst01fit.mmo.de Andreas Klar
Alan...@liverpool.ac.uk Alan Thew
al...@lscruz.scf.lmsc.lockheed.com Alan Strassberg
a...@io.org Allan Brown
al...@AugieDoggie.COM August Flassig
ali...@caere.com Alice Taylor
am...@mailer.york.ac.uk A Morris
amo...@explorer.csc.com Anna Moore
ana...@cs.utexas.edu Ananda M. Kar
Andrew.V...@jet.msk.su Andrew V. Kovalev
an...@btc.uwe.ac.uk
an...@coat.com Andy Behrens
andy...@mcs.com Andrew Deckowitz
ang...@vaxrio.ENET.dec.com Angela Fontes - S.I. Brazil 09-Aug-1995 1050
an...@ctt.bellcore.com
an...@alcor.concordia.ca Anne Bennett
Arjan...@nl.cis.philips.com Arjan de Vet
Arthur...@Smallworld.co.uk Arthur Chance
asa...@explorer.csc.com Adam Safier
a...@melbpc.org.au Ash Nallawalla
at...@HD.SE Anders Tall
ava...@coombs.anu.edu.au Darren Reed
b...@netcom.com Brian Court
b...@andromeda.ubis.de H-U. Baerwind
ba...@math.psu.edu Dave Barr
bar...@lamar.ColoState.EDU Jose Barria
Bart_van_Donselaar.ROLS#u#EUR...@notes.compuserve.com
bben...@rotten.camb.kenan.com Ben Bennett
bbe...@networking.stanford.edu
bbe...@cohn-wells.com Brad Benton
bbi...@harper.cc.il.us Bob Bieszk
bbr...@netcom.com Braun Brelin
bda...@magi.com Bob Davies
bdre...@plaind.com
be...@bedford.win-uk.net KEITH BENNETT
ben_...@qmailgw.Esy.COM Ben Ball
be...@desert.ihep.su Eugene B. Berdnikov
bful...@ebicom.net Billy Fulgham
b...@ddi.digital.net Brian Hartsfield
bhu...@community.net Bill Husler
bill.r...@hawk.hcsc.com Bill Rominger
bi...@hugpar.actrix.gen.nz Bill Parkin
bi...@WLK.COM Bill Kennedy
bi...@individual.com Bill Heiser
birc...@pilot.njin.net Dan Shag Birchall
Bjorn.K...@Norway.ATTGIS.COM Bjorn Kringstad
b...@herbison.com B.J. Herbison
bkl...@pel.com
bla...@email.ip-groupe.fdn.fr Blaise Thauvin
b...@bne.ind.eunet.hu Balint Nagy Endre
Bo.Sod...@abc.se Bo S\vderberg
boe...@jupiter.fb12.TU-Berlin.DE Lars Boeger
bog...@bpb.it Massimo.Lanfranconi
BO...@delphi.com
bpo...@nyx10.cs.du.edu Brad Porter
Brad....@Eng.Sun.COM Brad Powell SunNetworks
bra...@u.washington.edu Scott Bradley
br...@graf.polymtl.ca Louis-Philippe Brais
bra...@orakelkasten.phil.uni-sb.de -mat- filid brandy
bre...@onto.network.com Greg Brennan
bri...@Kimbro.Com D. Brian Kimmel
Bryce_...@smtpgate.praxair.com Bryce Morgan
Buer...@ztl.ch Josef Buergler
bur...@primenet.com Trevor & Jennifer
bus...@primenet.com Fred Bushroe
b...@shadow.dbapic.com.au Barry W Anderson
by...@detroit.net Thom Byxbe
c60...@zone.arnold.af.mil Sean Fuller
ca...@puug.pt Carlos Canau
ca...@hdshq.com
car...@eup.udl.es Carles Mateu
ca...@acsu.buffalo.edu David J. Carr
Catheri...@mailbox.uq.oz.au Catherine Allen
CBAL...@hermes.massolant.navy.mil Coni Ballard - ISSM
cd...@mobile-gas.com Chuck Dean
cgsc...@psu.edu Carl Schott
char...@eng.pdc.com Chuck Harding
char...@ireq.hydro.qc.ca Charles Arsenault
Ch...@cclough.demon.co.uk Chris Clough
ch...@rivers.dra.hmg.gb Christopher Samuel
chr...@tufted.puffin.com Chris Jewell
cin...@clark.net Cynthia L Borodkin
c...@novell.com
c...@camcon.co.uk Carl Orsborn
ckc...@wtk.com.sg Chan Chung Kit
ckos...@csc.com Chris Kostick
cla...@Starbase.NeoSoft.COM Cameron Laird
cla...@ecid.cig.mot.com Justin Clancy
clst...@mailbox.syr.edu Chris Stamper
cmcu...@gatekeeper.cb.att.com
cm...@cs.nrl.navy.mil
cnew...@netix.demon.co.uk Chris Newport
cnj...@awod.com Charmaine Narciso-Jiao
coll...@richmond.infi.net Dayle L. Collins
colu...@euronet.nl Columbus
COOK_NANCY/DAL10_NMCOOK//US/MOBIL/B...@dal.mobil.com
co...@dash.com Chris Cota
cr...@killerbee.jsc.nasa.gov Craig Biggerstaff
cri...@magick.es.dupont.com Cristy
cro...@eno.Princeton.EDU Scott Cromar
cs6...@scitsc.wlv.ac.uk R.Arnold
cta...@border.com
CUE...@zorzal.metro.inter.edu
d.ale...@uclan.ac.uk David ALEXANDRE
d89...@stacken.kth.se Mattias =?ISO-8859-1?Q?=C5slund?=
dal...@cs.Buffalo.EDU Douglas A. Lewis
daniel....@arup.com Daniel Koopman
da...@miricle.its.unimelb.edu.au Daniel O'Callaghan
dar...@sandia.gov Declan A. Rieb
da...@melita.melita.com Dave Kennedy
davi...@glacial.tmr.com Bill Davidsen
dawa...@phoenix.Princeton.EDU David A. Wagner
d...@pluto.dragonsys.com Doug Paul
dbs...@ttl.pactel.com David B. Small
d...@SSDS.com Derrick \"4.29/lb\" Cole (Raleigh)
dcol...@iol.ie Declan Collins
den...@marlin.smartstar.com
des...@raven.engr.sgi.com Ellen S. Desmond
dev...@lifetech.com Evans, Doug
d...@si1.dod.gov.au David_Golding
dgam...@reach.com
did...@mca.com David Dolgin
di...@his.ecmc.edu Dill, Peter
d...@epx.cis.umn.edu
d...@autumn.com Dan Crimmins
djoh...@amgen.com Deron Johnson
djo...@bns.com Derek Jones
dkbfp-dev!rgi...@uunet.uu.net Richard Gibbs
d...@deathstar.lis.cch.com Matthew J. D'Errico
Don.R...@chipsi.com Donald L Ritchey
donath@abn_dev.abn.com Matt Donath
dop...@dpinfo.ci.lincoln.ne.us user
do...@ugcs.caltech.edu Dori Levanoni
dra...@cc.gatech.edu Musashi
dru...@gallien.in-chemnitz.de Thorsten Alteholz
ds...@intac.com David Shaw
dus...@syd.csa.com.au Dusan Baljevic
dwhi...@datlog.co.uk Dave Whitlow
e...@formel.com Ebe Ebsen
egg...@twinsun.com Paul Eggert
egre...@wsu.edu Ed Grether
ei...@netmarket.com Eiji Hirai
eise...@condor.sccs.swarthmore.edu Daniel Eisenbud
el...@acsu.buffalo.edu Andrew W Elble
Emmanuelle...@epita.fr emmanuelle barbereau
er...@winternet.com Eric Pederson
esc...@mvision.com Eric Schult
e...@harvee.billerica.ma.us Eric S. Johansson
e...@senate.be Emmanuel Willems
f...@all.net Dr. Frederick B. Cohen
fe...@ullisys.pond.sub.org Felix Schroeter
fino...@vangogh.die.udec.cl Francisco Inostroza
fis...@wildfire.llnl.gov Richard A. Fischer
fis...@hollywood.engr.sgi.com William Fisher
Florent....@epita.fr florent chichery
f...@brd.ie Frank O'Dwyer
for...@wang.com Forrest Aldrich
fpde...@hgl.signaal.nl Vries F.P. de
fra...@MAIL.STATE.WI.US
Fred...@Ebay.Sun.COM Fred Lowe (Postm...@Sun.COM)
fr...@alfheim.actrix.gen.nz Bruce Clement
fri...@cs.uidaho.edu Deborah Frincke
fr...@wln.com Jason K Fry
fu...@jaist.ac.jp FUJIE Masanori =?ISO-2022-JP?B?GyRCRiM5PkA1QicbKEI=?=
fwilk...@riasmtp.riatax.com Forest Wilkinson
gal...@marie.mit.edu Stu Galley
Garry....@abii.com Garry Garrett
gd...@dcs.ed.ac.uk George Ross
g...@pa.dec.com Greg Skinner
ge...@insti.physics.sunysb.edu Eugene Tyurin
ger...@West.NL Gertjan van Oosten
gh...@iper.net Angelo Ghigi
gi...@nemeton.com.au Giles Lean
gil...@cam.nist.gov Judith F Gilsinn
g...@spaceworks.com Greg Sylvain
gonz...@sce.com Efrain Gonzalez
go...@nytimes.com Gordy Thompson
Gran...@Bentley.COM Gran Goza
grap...@acsu.buffalo.edu Matthew R. Grappone
gre...@hsvaic.hv.boeing.com Sarah Green
gr...@loose.apana.org.au Greg Patten
gr...@miles33.co.uk Greg Cannon - Net and Comms Team
gr...@ccr-p.ida.org Gary R. Gregg
g...@terminus.wccs.saic.com
g...@ecs.soton.ac.uk Glyn Simpson
g...@cuillin.org.uk Guy Dawson
GWW...@macblo.ca Gary Wong (604) 439-8682 Fax: 439-1032
gwyc...@midway.uchicago.edu Gerald Wyckoff
g...@CyberSAFE.COM Glen Zorn
h...@locus.com Hal Lockhart
Hans.v...@atf.cmg.nl Hans van Dijk
HAR...@INDYVAX.IUPUI.EDU James Harvey
ha...@actcom.co.il Avraham Hayam
HE...@finabo.abo.fi Kaj 'Hege' Haggman
h...@lec.dk
her...@cats.ucsc.edu
h...@hhdo.do.home.venture.net Henning Holtschneider
hir...@vnus.org Hiroshi Takahashi
hkia...@starnet.gov.sg Hay Kiang Hua
hoogervors...@technet.iaf.nl
Howard...@hmco.com Howard Beale/Corp/hmco
hr...@rocza.kei.com Helen Trillian Rose
ht...@foa.dk Henrik Tougaard
hu...@wwa.com Matt Hucke
hug...@afp.com Hugues Lafarge
h...@compulink.co.uk Hugo van der Sanden
hyg...@ecid.cig.mot.com Robert Hygate
i...@oms.co.za Ian Cooper
ida...@jesus.ox.ac.uk Illtud Daniel
i...@pcug.org.au Ian(Floyd) Patterson
if...@tpone.telepac.pt DCSI/IFT42
IL...@ACADVM1.UOTTAWA.CA Ian Fairweather
ing...@cs.duke.edu Robert E. Ingram
it...@cix.compulink.co.uk Nik Rosser
iv...@wadsworth.org Ivan Auger
iye...@ee.rochester.edu Manu Iyengar
ja...@eos.bony.com Jake Livni
ja...@ustc.ac.cn Zhang Huanjie
j...@bagend.atl.ga.us Jan Isley
ja...@to.icl.fi Jari Takala
ja...@peoplebank.co.uk Jason Aquilina
Jay.V...@uni.edu The Unix Guy
ja...@lscpdx.lattice.com Jay Lessert
jbar...@netdepot.com Joel Barrett
j...@microunity.com Jason Hendrix
jbl...@cisco.com Jeff Blaine
j...@nirvana.cr.mci.com
jb...@tiac.net Jim Byrd
jca...@sr.csg.com John Caruso
jcen...@panix.com Joe Centenni
j...@wcdssi.com John Guinasso
jcmu...@smurfland.cit.buffalo.edu Jeff Murphy
jcu...@mingus.clpccd.cc.ca.us Jim Cusick
jdal...@news.doas.state.ga.us J.D. Almand
jda...@cs.arizona.edu Jim Davis
je...@julia.icdc.fr Jean-Denis Gorin
je...@SDSC.EDU Jeff Makey
je...@noc.netins.net Jeffrey C. Ollie
je...@bugs-bunny.CS.Berkeley.EDU Jeff Wallace
je...@milford.iai.com James P. Egan
je...@West.NL Jelle van Zeijl
jennifer...@ac.com jennifer.l.wilson
jen...@aimla.com Jennine Townsend
je...@oskar.csl-gmbh.net Jens Baedeker
Jerald....@Corp.Sun.COM Jerald Josephs
jer...@auug.org.au Jeremy Bishop
je...@tcs.com Jerry Carlin
je...@scala.scala.com Randell Jesup
j...@abulafia.genmagic.com J. Eric Townsend
jfle...@halcyon.com Justin Fletcher
jhs...@ix.netcom.com JOHN HERBERT SMITH
j...@ics.forth.gr John Ioannidis
j...@telco.com Jim Blout
jim...@qnet.com CompuNerd
ji...@PE-Nelson.COM Jim Watt
Jim_Bo...@cargill.com
jjwe...@matsci.uah.edu Jeffrey J. Weimer
jke...@relay.nswc.navy.mil Fred Kerby - E06
jkr...@scientech.com Joshua Krage
j...@super.org Jeffrey M. Arnold
jmcg...@uoguelph.ca
jmen...@mcs.eds.com John Mendenhall
jmk...@infi.net John King
jmu...@acsu.buffalo.edu Joel Murphy
jne...@hazel.EnGarde.com Jason Newman
Joe_Be...@p501.f544.n109.z1.fidonet.org Joe Bergstein
jo...@clearspring.com John Opalko
jon...@io.org Jonboy
Joni.H...@Tele.telebox.fi
jos...@cis.ohio-state.edu Sudish Joseph
j...@tmp.medtronic.com Jot Powers
jow...@cadman.cit.buffalo.edu James R Owens
JP.Marti...@ecmwf.int Jean-Philippe Martin-Flatin
jp...@ix.netcom.com John P. McGraw
j...@access.digex.net Joseph R. Justice
js...@randr.com John R. Simpson
js...@andrew.cmu.edu Jeffrey B Stewart
jsc...@seodu.co.kr Choi Jaeseon
jso...@bdm.com Jim Sowers
jt...@gwl.com
jue...@prodata.de Juergen Mueller
jull...@lrc.epfl.ch Alexandre Julliard
j...@s-s-s.com James W. Klein
Karsten...@Informatik.TU-Chemnitz.DE Karsten Heinze
ka...@cogsci.uiuc.edu Asaf Kashi
k...@cci.dk Kim Boendergaard Poulsen
k...@world.std.com Khaja E Ahmed
ke...@ssd.fsi.com Keith Blanchette 515 MIS
ke...@hpcf.cc.utexas.edu Kelly Newcomb
ker...@forthnet.gr Aggelos D. Keromitis
ke...@class9.yankee.com Kevin E. St.John
k...@skypoint.com Kenneth H. Tetrick
ki...@kontu.bbs.fi Kimmo Jukarainen
kj...@rf.no Kjell Sivertsen
k...@ee.latrobe.edu.au Kevin Pye
kla...@sol.UVic.CA Melvin Klassen
kl...@heidelbg.ibm.com Peter Klee
kori...@cci.de ANDREAS KORITNIK
k...@crc.com Kevin P. Inscoe
kr...@schulung.netuse.de Kristian Koehntopp
ksp...@taiu.edu Philip Mire
kwe...@aaped.com Kevin Westby
l12...@proffa.cc.tut.fi Markus Linnala
lag...@sunny.health.state.mn.us Elbert LaGrew
la...@rahul.net Lance K. Chun
Laurent...@epita.fr laurent genier
Laurent...@der.edf.fr Laurent Vallee - IMA/ICI/ASR - CDD - 47656833
lawr...@combdyn.com Lawrence *The Dreamer* Chen
Le...@sp.ac.sg Lee Yee Poh/CC/SP_SF
lennart...@laatu3o.pp.fi Lennart L\vfberg
l...@lerami.lerctr.org Larry Rosenman
lheu...@dice.ucl.ac.be Olivier L'Heureux
l...@noc-gw.lanl.gov Leo Palmer
Lin...@NPD01.usace.army.mil Lin Wu
Lionnel...@epita.fr lionnel chaptal
lip...@obelix.htl-tex.ac.at
list-...@dream.hb.north.de Martin Schr"oder
l...@sweng.stortek.com Lon Jones
l...@gmsg.ch G. Lottaz
l...@sja.pc.my Low Peng Chiew
lpel...@ENSM-ALES.FR Laurent PELLISSIER
lpi...@intex.net S. Lane Pierce
lu...@namu20.gwdg.de Stefan Lucks
lur...@tiac.net Pete Lurie
lu...@edge.edge.net Jon Lusky
Lutz.Don...@Jena.Thur.De Lutz Donnerhacke
lyn...@sentinet.demon.co.uk Lyndon David
m.ta...@ELSEVIER.CO.UK Martin Taylor
Maarten...@kub.nl Maarten van Wijk
mac...@epsilon.eecs.nwu.edu Chris Walsh
mad...@mcs.com Douglas M. MacFarlane
m...@primenet.com Mike Gruen
MAHAJA...@Tandem.COM
ma...@gov.nt.ca David Mah
Marc.B...@hsc.fr.net Marc Baudoin
mar...@thor.ats.qc.ca Mark A. Freedman
Mark.Br...@Aus.Sun.COM Mark Broadbent - Partner Training Manager - Sun
mark....@jsc.nasa.gov
ma...@lewisham.demon.co.uk Mark Alexander
ma...@glyphic.com Mark Lentczner
mar...@ace.nl Markus van Dijk
Mark_W_...@smtp.bnr.com
mart...@vol.it marco tarquini
Martin....@Uni-Koeln.DE Martin Behland
mar...@worf.netins.net Perry Martin
Mathias...@swi.com.sg Mathias Koerber
mat...@imonics.com Matthew Stier - Imonics System
ma...@fsd.com W. C. 'Bill' Mauer
mba...@amex-trs.com Michael Barrett
mbl...@citenet.net whoelse
mcc...@netcom.com Michael McClary
mcc...@nawc690.chinalake.navy.mil Scott McClung
m...@24hour.abs.net Mark Christopher Davies
mcin...@cs.rice.edu Nathaniel McIntosh
MCL...@IGA.COM Isn't this just plug & play?!?
m...@EnGarde.com Mike Neuman
meh...@muenchen.photogrammetrie.de Gerhard Mehldau
Mei...@fel.tno.nl J.J.H.MEIJERS 417/3G13/3-2
m...@mfltd.co.uk Mark Knam
me...@eridani.zfe.siemens.de Veronika Meyer
mfu...@cisco.com Mike Fuller
m...@cs.tu-berlin.de Markus Freericks
m...@cvsd.cv.com Michael Noble
mh...@raven.phs.com Mike Hatz
michael...@il.us.swissbank.com Michael Gabriel
mi...@tmx.com.au Michael Young
Mikael....@abo.fi Mikael Salonaho
Mikaiiro...@Tele.telebox.fi
mi...@novell.co.uk Mike Convey
mi...@sebank.se Michael Evans
mi...@gopher.dosli.govt.nz Mike Williams
Mike_Will...@notes.compuserve.com
mi...@nx.com Michael Aichlmayr
min...@wind.es.dupont.com Mike Minnich
mitu...@tsi.co.jp
MI...@pjm.com Mix, S.R.
m...@sophos.com Matthew J Brown
mjc...@HiWAAY.net Mark Cecil
m...@iwi.com Marcus J. Ranum
m...@graphics.cornell.edu Mitch Collinsworth
mken...@ib.cdu.itg.telecom.com.au Michael Kennedy
mk...@usaid.gov Melanie Kinn
m...@netcom.com Matthew Deter
m...@RedBrick.COM M Mike Taksar KC6ZPS
mmu...@ernsty.co.uk Mike Murphy
mon...@metasystems.com
mo...@easi.com Rob Moore, EA Systems Inc., (510)748-4878
mpod...@osf1.gmu.edu Mark A Podracky
m...@alpharel.com Mike Murphy
mr...@escape.ca Morgan Ross
msat...@jungle.com Michael Sattler, San Francisco
msm...@pluto.njcc.com Mark Smith
mth...@ix.netcom.com Michael Thayer
mu...@Informatik.Uni-Bremen.DE Wilhelm Mueller
mu...@bi.fish.com Muffy
murk...@pwfl.com Richard Murkland
mus...@natasha.tele.iastate.edu Dan Engholm
MWR...@tntech.edu Mike Renfro
mwwh...@telepath.com Ender Wiggin
myu...@orlando.loral.com Murray Yutzy
na...@mips.pfalz.de Christian Weisgerber
n...@olympus.net Ned Schumann
ne...@medcom.se Neil Costigan
ne...@spl.co.za Neil Thompson
ne...@wwa.com Nesta Stubbs
news...@fnma.com Walter Rowe
nho...@toppoint.de Norbert Hoffmann
ni...@hedgehog.demon.co.uk Niall Teasdale
nie...@ted.hcst.com Ted Nieland
nier...@ntasbda03.matra-com.fr Sylvain NIERVEZE
n...@checkpoint.com
nm...@soc.bbnplanet.com Nathan J. Mehl
nmo...@wintermute.win.net Noel C. Morgan
no...@gdc.com Nehemia Noti
npek...@starnet.gov.sg Ng Pek Yong
nysd...@lori.albany.net Erik Ossenfort
ok...@monad.swb.de Olaf Kirch
ol...@mailhost.uni-koblenz.de Olaf Hermans
ol...@niksula.hut.fi Olev Kartau
oli...@fritz.co.traverse.com Christopher Oliver
o...@yoyo.neu.sgi.com Ove Hansen
ov...@techunix.technion.ac.il Oved Ben-Aroya
P.S....@durham.ac.uk Peter Craig
P.van...@telecom.ptt.nl
pa...@faxil.leeds.ac.uk Michael Clarkson
pak0%pka...@gte.com Paul A. Karger
pas...@mathworks.com Dave Pascoe
p...@tandem.com
paul.cr...@csc-eng.demon.co.uk Admin|Paul Crutchley X1452
Paul....@dssc.slg.eds.com Paul Rogers
pa...@emdcs.com Paul Russo
pa...@hawksbill.sprintmrn.com Paul Ferguson
pa...@turbosoft.com.au Paul Brooks
pa...@geko.com.au Paul Burgess
pba...@sedona.intel.com Paul Balyoz -FT-~
p...@protocom.com Paul Henninger
pca...@netcom.com Paul Caloca
p...@sable.ox.ac.uk Paul Leyland
p...@ic.net phil reed
p...@nkn.edu Paul Atkinson
pe...@bonkers.taronga.com Peter da Silva
pet...@airdata.com Peter Gregory
pe...@camail.ca.nmp.nokia.com
pfco...@amhux3.amherst.edu Peter F. Couvares
ph...@wharton.upenn.edu Phil Brandenberger
pho...@neuromancer.ultranet.com Buckaroo Banzai!
phof...@proper.com Paul Hoffman
phr...@mtolympus.ari.net Fred Vaughn
pivo...@nesirs01.iaea.or.at Lorri Pivornik 2940
pke...@winternet.com Paul Keusemann
plm...@ak.msmail.dtt.co.nz Marriott, Paul
pmay...@ix.netcom.com Paul Mayerowitz
p...@crosfield.co.uk Phil Davis
pnh...@mclo10.med.navy.mil Bob Resino
po...@fireball.ucdmc.ucdavis.edu Tom Poage
poul.b...@cyberstore.ca Poul Bendsen
p...@cs.man.ac.uk Paul Quare
pr...@csc.com Perry Rapp
pri...@cs.monash.edu.au GLen Pringle
psh...@nowhere.esd.sgi.com Ping-Shun Huang
psi...@primenet.com Chris Eastes
psutc...@SIP.Unisys.COM Paul Sutcliffe, Jr.
pu...@limeil.cea.fr Francis PUECH
p...@cacs.usl.edu Pirawat Watanapongse
pwa...@mbi.moody.edu Paul D. Walker
Quentin....@SEMATECH.Org Quentin Fennessy
quil...@spartan.pprd.abbott.com Edward Quillen
ra...@rssd.hk.olivetti.com Raju M. Daryanani
r...@iti.gov.sg Ram S Kidambi
ram...@scr.siemens.com Ramesh Viswanathan
Raphael...@eed.ericsson.se
rap...@research.canon.oz.au Andrew Raphael
rdda...@facso.navfac.navy.mil
r...@pine.cse.nau.edu Randy D Palmer
rea...@opennet.net.au Reagan Blundell
rein...@eclac.cl Cristian Reinhardt
rh...@cygnus.arc.nasa.gov Robert Haas
rhou...@ids.net Russell C. Houldin
ri...@loki.chiron.com Eric Hall
ri...@bcm.tmc.edu Richard H. Miller
ri...@man.net Rick Duff
ri...@vansys.com Rick Vandenberg
rind...@igd.fhg.de Jochen Rindfrey
r...@us.net
Roberto...@STO4.wmdata.se Piludu, Roberto
rob...@keltia.freenix.fr Ollivier Robert
robi...@next532-2.gsfc.nasa.gov Scott Robinson
ro...@anubis.network.com Rob Peglar
rode...@ibcinc.com Roderick Schertler
rog...@cod.nosc.mil Rollo D. Rogers
rohre...@corona.navy.mil Rohren.Mark
Romain....@epita.fr romain jacotin
rom...@cadvision.com Keith Roman
ro...@ac.upc.es Rosa M. Castro
ro...@teleport.com Lucas Rose
r...@eel.ufl.edu Mahesh Ramachandran
r...@nelson.dinoco.de Rolf Schulz
rsa...@gumby.dsd.TRW.COM Raymond Sasaki
rta...@ait.nrl.navy.mil Randy Taylor
ru...@panix.com Bob Russo
rwil...@ccnet.com Bob Wilkins n6fri
rwil...@traveller.com Richard Williams
s.vang...@student.utwente.nl Sjoerd
sac...@cesi.it Sacchi Annamaria
sach...@ppg.com Sacherich, Larry
salt...@shore.net Mark Saltzman
s...@inf.enst.fr Samuel Tardieu
san...@aryabhat.cs.umsl.edu Sanjiv K. Bhatia
sa...@next2.togliatti.su S.A. TsYbanov
sbl...@corp.tivoli.com Steve Blair
sche...@fdma.com Michael S. Scheidell
schm...@omega.physik.fu-berlin.de Martin Schmachtel
sc...@jaycor.com Scott Brehm
Scot...@world.std.com Scott Blanchette
sco...@onramp.net Steve Cowles
sdes...@vanguard.hmp.com Scott Deshaies
sd...@isma.demon.co.uk Stephen Dunne
secu...@kt.tu-cottbus.de Security Admin
s...@aplcomm.jhuapl.edu Steve Parr
sgi...@amex-trs.com
sgo...@ll.mit.edu Sam Gorton
sgr...@Direct.CA Shayne Gregg
shap...@asu.edu Shapard Wolf
shei...@actcom.co.il Ofer Sheinkin
shi...@tembel.org Michael Shields
shim...@cs.nps.navy.mil timothy shimeall
shub...@srd.bt.co.uk Steve Hubbard
silv...@nutecpa.nutec.tche.br
si...@darkmere.midland.co.nz Simon Lyall
s...@sunthing.sjsinc.com Stefan Jon Silverman
SKI...@us.oracle.com Scott Kister
Smedley_A_Ri...@mobile1.bam.com
smi...@nmc.ed.ray.com Kevin Ruddy
sp...@xor.lax.primenet.com Stephen Anspach
s...@tntv7.ntrs.com Steve Bonine
spi...@orb.nashua.nh.us Spider Boardman
sp...@doi.cgd.pt Simao Onofre
squi...@summit.bor.ohio.gov Stephen Quinlan
sr...@igt.com Srini Seetharam
s...@tad.eds.com Sean S. Dowd
stem...@CC.IMS.DISA.MIL Dion Stempfley
st...@ergon.CH Sten Gunterberg
st...@morgan.com John(Scott) Stensland
ste...@elvisti.kiev.ua Andrew V. Stesin
st...@ecf.toronto.edu Steve Kotsopoulos
st...@miranova.moonvalley.com Steven L. Baur
st...@Watt.COM Steve Watt -- KD6GGD
ste...@valeglamcb.gov.uk Steve Durbin
ste...@wni.com Steve Green
ste...@nova.East.Sun.COM Steve Kouvo - SunExpress IR
stev...@cs.man.ac.uk Mik Stevens
st...@uni-paderborn.de
st...@gw1.phibred.com Bud Stowe
Swenso...@mm.rdd.lmsc.lockheed.com Swenson Steve
swh...@xwing.wcape.gov.za Sean White
sw...@tds.com John Swift
swi...@gwdg.de switzel
sy...@rose.cnc.ac.cn
sys...@ocelot.Gsu.EDU Keith Campbell
tab...@rad.cadix.co.jp T. Tabuki - CADIX Inc.
t...@abalon.se Thomas Althoff
taw...@skat.usc.edu Ta-Wei Li
TBR...@lifetech.com Braun, Thomas
tew...@spider.lloyd.com Thomas Ewing
tf...@inforamp.net terry finn
t...@psp.co.uk Thomas F Lee
tfre...@attmail.com Tim Freeman
tho...@soulcage.inmind.com Tim Hogard
Thomas....@efrei.fr Thomas Parmelan
ti...@kt.tu-cottbus.de Tilo Schuerer
t...@osa.com.au Tim Adam
tman...@ccmail.adhc.com Todd A. Mancini
tmi...@umabnet.ab.umd.edu Thomas H Miller
t...@mindspring.com Tony James
t...@cse.ucsc.edu Tom M. Kroeger
tm...@cam.ac.uk Toby Speight
tmu...@aigtc.com Tom Mullen
tmu...@hernsvr.med.osd.mil Tim Murphy
tne...@immuno.imvs.sa.gov.au Tom Nemeth
t...@silverlock.dgim.doc.ca Thomas Erskine
to...@aalnet.aland.fi Thomas Holmstrom
Tom_C...@notes.pw.com
Tonny....@netman.dk Tonny Madsen
Tony....@ecmwf.int Tony Bakker
to...@miles33.co.uk Antony D Jones
tors...@ramsey.saar.de Torsten Blum
tpi...@mcs.kent.edu Thomas L. Picray
tpi...@pinnacle.co.uk Tony Piper
tpr...@ford.com
t...@tpone.telepac.pt Tiago Rodrigues Antao
tsur...@cyber.ict.pwr.wroc.pl Tomasz Surmacz
tty...@wheel.dcn.davis.ca.us Tim Tyler
tvm...@icdc.delcoelect.com Thomas V. Myers
tw%hasas...@Germany.EU.net Thomas Welsch
t...@sics.se Tommy Wallo
twe...@netcom.com Tabor J. Wells
tyk...@cwis.unomaha.edu Brad L. Littlejohn
UDS...@DSIBM.OKLADOT.STATE.OK.US Mike Andrews
ug...@sirius.dk Michael Ugilt
un04!mthomps1%manukau...@iconz.co.nz Matthew Thompson
unc...@io.org Matthew Carrick
va...@rcmnext.usr.dsi.unimi.it Valeriano Bedeschi
val...@i2s.com Mike Vallee
van...@sfu.ca Peter Van Epp
v...@shore.net Vin McLellan
Vincent...@hsc.fr.net Vincent Archer
v...@rz.uni-jena.de Karl Kleine
wad...@POSC.org Dave Waddell
wa...@kegs.saic.com Jeff Wade x5117
wa...@hzd-net.de Bernd Waldbauer S4
wan...@kingkong.escape.de Ulf Bahrenfuss
war...@worlds.com Warren Burstein
war...@dns2.psns.navy.mil Rex Warren
Warren_Moore%CB...@notes.cbis.com Warren Moore
wcra...@express.tiac.net Will Crawford
wd...@grouper.mkt.hcsc.com William 'doc' Holliday
wel...@cassens.com Phillippe Welsh
wendell...@MENTORG.COM Wendell Ruotsi
wes...@berlin.snafu.de Wolfram Esser
weyg...@teleport.com Brian & Mary Weygandt
wil...@rom.oit.gatech.edu Will Day
wils...@superman.msfc.nasa.gov Bob Wilson
wom...@aquilagroup.com Christopher M. Conway
woy...@mitre.org Daniel W. Woycke
x92...@hp138.rz.ruhr-uni-bochum.de Jost Krieger
yama...@cqt.com Bob Yamaguchi
yi...@bbb.com.au Yitao
zar...@deepthought.sv.vtcom.fr Benjamin Ryzman
z...@bi.fish.com d
zo...@serome.serome.co.kr Danny Yang
zo...@v-connect.com Zoran Vasiljevic
Voted No
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ad...@bwh.harvard.edu Adam Shostack
Alain....@imag.fr
avo...@TIS.COM Frederick M Avolio
a...@iis.ee.ethz.ch Adam W. Feigin
bar...@databus.com Barney Wolff
BAS...@nwkadm.pgh.wec.com
bbo...@brent.llu.edu Brent E. Boyko
bdb...@maverick.erenj.com Bryan D. Boyle
bil...@altair.raxco.com Bill Webster
bon...@delta.eecs.nwu.edu Robert Bonomi
bwa...@musings.com Brad Walker
can...@masc38.rice.edu Michael Pearlman
ca...@lapse.lvsun.COM Carl Shapiro 454-4862
c...@hyperk.com Dale Cook
Chris....@newsedge.com Chris Brenton
ch...@deltacom.mindspring.com Christopher L. Smith
csa...@urc.tue.nl Michiel Wijers
del...@mocha.bunyip.com David Holmes
d...@unlinfo.unl.edu Dave Furstenau
d...@saa-cons.co.uk Dave Roberts
DMKE...@aol.com
Don_L...@dg-webo.webo.dg.com Donald B. Lehman
dsc...@eng.dowjones.com Dave Scott
EHE...@usasmtp.usagroup.org Ed Hepker
e...@gumby.bridgewater.ne.hcc.com Edward J.M. Carley Jr.
e...@wilcox.com Edgar R. Allen
fut...@pseudonym.com Futplex
Garry....@COM.PACPOWER.nswgovpower.telememo.au Tel \(02\)268-6160
go...@Compatible.COM Steve Goldhaber
gu...@gss.is Gulli Kristjansson
har...@harker.com Robert Harker
HERT...@HOSP.STANFORD.EDU Gene Hertel (415)725-4528
hic...@pad-thai.cam.ov.com Mark Hickey
hit...@primenet.com HiTech
hog...@rge.com Brett M Hogden
i...@jerboa.com Ian Poynter
ice...@access.mbnet.mb.ca Oliver Friedrichs
ich...@galstar.com Igor Chudov
igj...@proteknw.demon.co.uk Ian Gresley-Jones
ja...@leicester.ac.uk J.A. Hayes
ja...@olymp.fer.uni-lj.si Jan Bervar
jcar...@wellspring.us.dg.com Jim Carroll
j...@TIS.COM Jody C Patilla
jen...@Ando.Com Thomas Jenkins
jochen....@rrze.uni-erlangen.de Jochen Gentzsch
jon...@cat.com Terry Jones
jw...@hydra.dra.hmg.gb John Wood
ka...@hopf.dnai.com Karl Wiebe
Kevin....@isltd.insignia.com Kevin Quinlan
knep...@cuug.ab.ca Marc Knepppers
long-...@CS.YALE.EDU
LO...@p01.uci.com Jensen, Lonn (UCI)
lowenth...@tandem.com L Bruce Lowenthal
ma...@odb.rhein-main.de Joerg Maass
MA...@mtl.marconi.ca Harold March
mfra...@seawest.seachange.com Michael Francis
m...@reston.ans.net
m...@tiaa-cref.org marty shannon
n...@knoware.nl Niels Bjergstrom
of...@pha.pvt.cz Ondrej Fousek
o...@hyperk.com Dr.Mark Oliver
pcu...@ticl.co.uk Peter Curran
pet...@murphy.com Peter Gutmann
pf2...@ci.deere.com Paul A. Fisher
ri...@rer.com Rich Miller
ro...@hpwrc712.mayfield.hp.com Rod Bachelor
rol...@technet.sg Roland Yeo
ru...@uhics.ics.Hawaii.Edu
s...@bio.atv.dk Søren Adelholm Brandbyge
sc...@Disclosure.COM Scott Barman
sha...@celene.rain.com Shawn Instenes
sma...@turing.toronto.edu Smarasderagd
spa...@ZONE.NET Peter C. Norton
stai...@bga.com Dwight Brown
sta...@laa.com Gary Stanny
t-j...@microsoft.com Jonathon Tidswell
tb...@svcs.mmc.com Tom Bush
tke...@eplrx7.es.duPont.com
to...@uwe.ac.uk Tom Johnson
Tom.Ce...@shrmed.com Tom Ceresini
Tom_G...@DGC.ceo.dg.com
vi...@dsi.unimi.it David Vincenzetti
we...@tungsten.seattle.geoworks.com Eric Weber
wee...@mci.net Steve Weeber
weis...@netcom.com Bob Weissman
wide...@cc.helsinki.fi Risto Widenius
willia...@damark.com william.wells
zdj2...@rpool1.rus.uni-stuttgart.de Roman Huber
Abstained
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
crou...@flidh101.delcoelect.com Kenneth P Crouch
jb...@data.fls.dk Jan Bruun Andersen/JBAN
Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
cjre...@sinnfree.sinnfree.org Chuck Renaud
! No vote statement in message
di...@netcom.com Doug Krause
! No vote statement in message
DPRI...@ci.phoenix.az.us Pristavec
! No vote statement in message
ke...@stud.uni-frankfurt.de Markus Kehm
! No vote statement in message
marg...@aifs.org.au Margaret Sayce
! No vote statement in message
rhar...@freenet.calgary.ab.ca Reg Harbeck
! No vote statement in message
ro...@badgers.demon.co.uk Tom Brock
! Invalid address
ro...@world1.worldbit.com worldbit Admin
! Invalid address
shar...@usaor.net Tom Pendergast
! No vote statement in message
v...@relevantum.fi Keinanen Vesa
! No vote statement in message