We stopped by Camping World in San Marcos over the weekend and when
done, my wife wanted to stop in next door at Beaudry RV to get an idea
on the pricing of a smallish RV (we've currently got a 22ft 5-er).
Anyway, the sales guy showed us several of the new & used RV's they have
(<35 ft). All were very nice, but the biggest drawback is that many of
them are gas, and I'm a bit concerned about their ability to traverse
mountain passes and other sorts of steep grades. Any comments?
Also, we ended up looking at (and driving) a 30ft Diesel pusher made by
Holiday Rambler. It was very nice and could make a better turn than my
'96 Chevy P/U (long bed+extended cab). The sales guy mentioned that
many of the diesel pushers are only available in the longer
configurations (>35 ft) by most manufacturers. Is this true? He
specifically mentioned that Bounders are only available in the 39ft in
the diesel configuration. Anyway, they of course were trying to get us
interested in buying one in the not-so-distant future. Their claim was
that now is a great time to buy since the interest rate is 2.99% for a
20yr loan. The price of the 30ft Diesel pusher was $129k.. That's about
double what I was thinking of in my head for our next "step" in RV'ing.
I do realize that I could get a gas model of similar size, etc for <$80k
that's perhaps a year or two old and has one or two slide-outs. Anyway,
does this sound like typical BS that sales guys are pushing these days?
I'm not sure if the 2.99% APR is one of those once in a life deals
(probably not), but it does sound low when compared with my credit union
rates (last I looked).
Anyway, the main reason that we are considering jumping into an RV from
a trailer is that my parents wrecked their rig last year and my mom is
leary of getting another to replace their totalled 5-er and truck (they
both fell asleep while driving in eastern Oregon). My wife & I were
thinking that if we got something a bit larger than our current setup,
that we could just go and pick them up and take them out for a week at a
time tooling around here and there as we all seeing the sights, etc.
Anyway, thanks in advance for any insights you can provide..
I purchased a 31 foot Fleetwood Terra in 2001. It was a gas (Ford V10)
chassis. It seemed to do pretty well on the road and wasn’t a bad coach (I
thought). We towed a 1993 Jeep Cherokee behind it and got about 9 mpg. Not
bad considering the towed vehicle and that I ran it at about 65 mph. We put
6K miles on it mostly on the east coast. We then had a business trip that
would take us from Baltimore to Albuquerque, Salt Lake city and then back to
Baltimore. A long trip to say the least. Anyway, going out west we
discovered that going up the mountains we would get down to about 40 mph and
going down the other side we had to be careful since the class A would lean
considerably on the curves. It didn’t become noticeable until we were in
the mountains and you could see over the side! I never went faster than 65
since the motor seemed to be working hard to hold that speed. We got in a
head wind at one point and could barley hold 50 mph.
When we got to SLC, we looked at, haggled, and then bought an Airstream Land
Yacht. It’s 36 feet with a slide and all the amenities. It has a 300hp CAT
and a Freightliner chassis on air ride. The Terra cost 49K and the list on
this Land Yacht was 176K. The difference (aside from the price) is
astounding. I had no idea how cheaply the Terra was made compared to this
Airstream. Going up and down the mountains was nothing for that CAT. We
pushed a headwind all the way across NE, and WY but it made little
difference to the CAT. Going down the mountains with a JAKE brake was
effortless. The JAKE would slow the rig almost to a stand still if I let
it. I seldom touched the brake going down. The quick release air ride is
outstanding. When you go around curves it remains level and when you have
to stop it sends air to the front bags to keep the coach level. Truly a
smooth ride. The Terra rode like a meat wagon compared to this one. I
averaged about 9 mpg at 75 mph. The diesel generator is very quiet, and the
power plant being in the rear makes the driver and passenger area quiet as
well.
You’ll get a ton of opinions here, so you’ll have to make up your own mind.
Personally, I wouldn’t buy anything but a diesel. I’ve read people talking
about the availability of diesel fuel and that’s just ridiculous. First, if
I am in a 36 foot class A I am not going to look for a 7-11 to fuel up in.
I use truck stops and with 700 miles between fuel-ups finding a truck isn’t
a big task.
YMMV!
Gas versus diesel is no longer the issue as it used to be before the V-10
engines, and gas units usually are much lighter in weight as well
> Also, we ended up looking at (and driving) a 30ft Diesel pusher made by
> Holiday Rambler. It was very nice and could make a better turn than my
> '96 Chevy P/U (long bed+extended cab). The sales guy mentioned that
> many of the diesel pushers are only available in the longer
> configurations (>35 ft) by most manufacturers. Is this true? He
> specifically mentioned that Bounders are only available in the 39ft in
> the diesel configuration. Anyway, they of course were trying to get us
> interested in buying one in the not-so-distant future. Their claim was
> that now is a great time to buy since the interest rate is 2.99% for a
> 20yr loan. The price of the 30ft Diesel pusher was $129k.. That's about
> double what I was thinking of in my head for our next "step" in RV'ing.
> I do realize that I could get a gas model of similar size, etc for <$80k
> that's perhaps a year or two old and has one or two slide-outs. Anyway,
> does this sound like typical BS that sales guys are pushing these days?
> I'm not sure if the 2.99% APR is one of those once in a life deals
> (probably not), but it does sound low when compared with my credit union
> rates (last I looked).
>
The standard diesel chassis start at 36' and will go up in 2' increments up
to 45' there are some manufactures that will make custom chassis, and
considering that manufacturers like freightliner, Spartan and Prevost spend
millions developing this chassis, I would not trust any chassis developed by
RV manufacturers that lack the funds and resources for good quality control.
BTW 2.99% financing is likely to be as low as it gets, however I would
seriously question the 20 year term.
Wade
--
Jim Walker
Northern Virginia
X-Addict <bit...@not-here.com> wrote in message
news:MPG.17a5dc7c1...@news.centrilink.net...
http://www.rexhall.com/Motorhomes/Clipper/clipper_dies_floorplan.htm
http://www.rexhall.com/Motorhomes/Vision/VISION.htm
"X-Addict" <bit...@not-here.com> wrote in message
news:MPG.17a5dc7c1...@news.centrilink.net...
Yes, we have a '99 Winnebago Adventure 37G and tow a Honda Accord, 4 down.
We have been over the Rockies and back 3 times. Yellowstone, Northern and
Southern Idaho and Denver to Utah on I-70. Yes we slow down a bit, but we
realize we're in a 37 MH, not a sports car. We get an average of 7.25 MPG.
The V10 does a very good job and we can maintain a solid 65 (maybe more
sometimes) on most roads.
>
> Also, we ended up looking at (and driving) a 30ft Diesel pusher made by
> Holiday Rambler.
> The price of the 30ft Diesel pusher was $129k.. That's about
> double what I was thinking of in my head for our next "step" in RV'ing.
> I do realize that I could get a gas model of similar size, etc for <$80k
> that's perhaps a year or two old and has one or two slide-outs.
I've always said that the Lotto is designed for those who don't understand
math. So is the hype of the diesel pusher.
Yur gonna hear all kinds of rationalizing about how the diesel gets better
mileage. True, maybe 2 more MPG. How much fuel can you buy for $30,0000,
$40,000 or $50,000. You do that math. You will never own it long enough or
drive it far enough to pay for the additional cost of the diesel.
You'll also hear that the diesel will last a million miles. That means that
over the 20 year life of your loan you'll have to drive it 50,000 miles a
year to reach that milestone. That means 4166 miles a month. Doesn't leave
much time to camp. The average MH is driven *less than* 8,000 miles a year.
One of the worst things you can do to a diesel engine is not use it.
The cost of maintenance on the diesel will be more than double that of a gas
V10.
The gas and diesel units will have about the same NCC (if chosen carefully)
and about the same towing capacity. Why? The diesel engine, frame, tranny
all weigh more than a gas unit. In addition to make the cost of the diesel
look like a better value the mfrs add a lot of heavy stuff to the coach.
Tile floors, corian counters etc. and in the end have no more carrying
capacity than a gas unit.
It's your money, you can spend it any way you want, but don't be fooled by
fluff and invalid arguments in favor of the diesel unit.
If, in the long run what you want to be able to do is piss higher up the
brag tree than the guy with a gas unit, admit it and spend the $.
All of the above is IMO
--
http://home.attbi.com/~bigtent
Our web site about RVs, and a work in progress.
Jim and Mona Steele
You slowed "down a bit"... my V10 2001 Ford went from 65 to 40 going up the
hill. And, I'll wager that my 31' Terra weighed a lot less than your 37G.
In fact it weighed 14K (-/+). You must be burning alcohol (or drinking it).
>
> I've always said that the Lotto is designed for those who don't understand
> math.
Original comment, I always wondered who started that! But let's be
realistic here, ANY RV is a horrible "investment". You put BIG dollars into
something that just loses money every year. Sounds like the stock market,
but worse.
> Yur gonna hear all kinds of rationalizing about how the diesel gets better
> mileage. True, maybe 2 more MPG. How much fuel can you buy for $30,0000,
> $40,000 or $50,000.
a bunch, I guess.
> You'll also hear that the diesel will last a million miles.
Go to http://www3.nadaguides.com/ and do a value on your gas rig. When it
asks you for the mileage it has a statement next to it that states:
"optional - NOT for Diesel Engines". You want to know why? See the above
statement.
>
> The cost of maintenance on the diesel will be more than double that of a
gas
> V10.
You only have to do it 1/2 as often. "You do the math..."
>
> The gas and diesel units will have about the same NCC (if chosen
carefully)
> and about the same towing capacity.
That's a joke, right?
>
> It's your money, you can spend it any way you want, but don't be fooled by
> fluff and invalid arguments in favor of the diesel unit.
>
> If, in the long run what you want to be able to do is piss higher up the
> brag tree than the guy with a gas unit, admit it and spend the $.
>
Actually, this guy left out a lot of important information. The frames
built by Freightliner, air ride, air brakes, engine brakes, torque, etc etc
etc... but the BEST part of all is the AIR HORNS!
You'll never regret buying a diesel pusher - if you can afford it.
> > The V10 does a very good job and we can maintain a solid 65 (maybe more
> > sometimes) on most roads.
>
> You slowed "down a bit"... my V10 2001 Ford went from 65 to 40 going up
the
> hill. And, I'll wager that my 31' Terra weighed a lot less than your 37G.
> In fact it weighed 14K (-/+). You must be burning alcohol (or drinking
it).
>
Yup I call that a bit. If I slow down from 65 to 40 for 50 miles of a 3800
mile trip, it's insignificant. There are trucks going slower than me and I'm
OK with that. As I said, it's not a sports car and I'm not in a race to get
there.
> >
> > I've always said that the Lotto is designed for those who don't
understand
> > math.
>
> Original comment, I always wondered who started that! But let's be
> realistic here, ANY RV is a horrible "investment". You put BIG dollars
into
> something that just loses money every year. Sounds like the stock market,
> but worse.
I would not for a second refer to an RV as an investment. It's pleasure and
we spend a lot of money on it.
>
> > Yur gonna hear all kinds of rationalizing about how the diesel gets
better
> > mileage. True, maybe 2 more MPG. How much fuel can you buy for $30,0000,
> > $40,000 or $50,000.
>
> a bunch, I guess.
Ya, at the $40,000 level about 29,000 gallons.
>
> > You'll also hear that the diesel will last a million miles.
>
> Go to http://www3.nadaguides.com/ and do a value on your gas rig. When it
> asks you for the mileage it has a statement next to it that states:
> "optional - NOT for Diesel Engines". You want to know why? See the above
> statement.
I still say that the huge cost difference will never, ever be recovered.
Can't happen.
>
> >
> > The cost of maintenance on the diesel will be more than double that of a
> gas
> > V10.
>
> You only have to do it 1/2 as often. "You do the math..."
It costs me $43.00 for an oil change. I've compared with my brother who owns
a diesel. I'm way, way ahead on maintenance cost.
>
> >
> > The gas and diesel units will have about the same NCC (if chosen
> carefully)
> > and about the same towing capacity.
>
> That's a joke, right?
Nope, not a joke. Take a look at most of the mid line rigs. Not talking
Prevost. NCC ranges from 1,800 to around 4,500.
My Adventure has a NCC of 3,900 lbs.
>
> >
>
> Actually, this guy left out a lot of important information. The frames
> built by Freightliner, air ride, air brakes, engine brakes, torque, etc
etc
> etc... but the BEST part of all is the AIR HORNS!
>
> You'll never regret buying a diesel pusher - if you can afford it.
>
Probably not. But he and you will lose more in the long run than the gas
guys. If the RV mfrs make, lets say for the sake of argument 10% on a rig,
which do you think they want you to buy. The $150,000 one or the $80,000
one.
> Safari Trek is about 30' and it is diesel. I haven't heard about the HR
>30' diesel. Maybe their web site will clarify. I recommend a diesel for
>several reasons. They include, fuel economy, long term reliability, air
>brakes, and exhaust brakes. A pusher will be quieter than a front engine
>class A.
Things are changing. Did the Safari factory tour today, and all of the
Treks in process were gas. Asked the tour guide and she said she
thought they hadn't made more than 6 Trek diesels this year.
--
Don Bradner
Posting today by satellite from
Ol Jo RV Park in Cave Junction, OR
Travelogue: www.arcatapet.net/travel.cfm
Gotta' agree with all that you said.. but for speaking an unspoken truth, I'm
sending you another couple of sandbags for the roof of your bunker... you might
want to don the asbetstos and kevlar undies also..<G>
Mark
I had a 2001 Fleetwood Terra. It would scare you when you met a truck going
the opposite direction, going down a mountain, or even when a truck passed
you on the interstate. Haven't had that feeling since I got this diesel
pusher...
jack
So it's not that we haven't been in the hills and on the highways. My wife
drives the rig about 1/2 the time and she has no problems.
Maybe your problem was that you had such a small coach with a lighter
frame/body. But our experience has been nothing like yours.
Just one opinion,
Barrie B
"X-Addict" <bit...@not-here.com> wrote in message
news:MPG.17a5dc7c1...@news.centrilink.net...
Hmm.. I checked out their site (http://www.shippsrv.com) and they are
selling the 36' version of the SAME RV that we looked at (the Ambassador
series) and if you were able to get it for just over $120k, then the
$129 price is way too high for the 6ft smaller version.. Perhaps Shipps
would sell it for closer to $100?
BTW: Anyone know the difference between the Holiday Rambler Neptune
series and the Ambassador series? Shipps has a 32PBD (32') with two
slides (enty level so they claim) for just over $118k.. Which means
that you should be able to get it under $100 based on the above
figures..? As for Shipps, did you need to haggle quite a bit to get
that price? Thanks for any info you can provide!
The relationship is similar to the Cayman and the Knight on the Monaco
models.
Hope that helps.
Ron
On Tue, 23 Jul 2002 15:32:36 -0700, X-Addict <bit...@not-here.com>
wrote:
Best of all, the rig cost new $89,000. Can't beat the price, and the
quality is there. I'd suggest you give one a try before buying. I've put
another 10K in it for such things as inverter, solar panels, towing system
etc. I'm not too concerned about resale value, because this is my first and
last RV. It will be my retirement home, and hell, I may decide to get
buried in it. That story might hit the six o'clock news!
"Tom G in CA" <nospam4me@donteventry> wrote in message
news:ukakjod...@corp.supernews.com...
> Last October I purchased a 36 foot Rexhall American Clipper (twin to the
> Vision) diesel pusher. It has a Cummins 260 hp engine with Allison 5
speed.
> I've logged 8000 miles, many of those miles towing my car. I've found the
> rig to be reliable and that the engine is adequate to handle the varied
> driving conditions that I encounter. I've driven in the Sierra Nevada
> mountains and other hilly terrain. On seven percent grades, I'll slow to
> 35-40 mph. I can see a 330 HP engine would have advantages handling the
> mountains, but I'm satisfied with my 260. My average mpg has been 9.
clip
Check with a dealer to see if this engine HP could be increased via
software. Some of them can. My RV service man said that he knew the 275
can be increased up to about 325 via software.
Ed