We need to take some credible people on bus tours of Iraq and see what
their impressions are.
LZ
>
> Jack Kelly: There's a war on / Better to fight the hard-core killers
> in Iraq
>
> Sunday, August 24, 2003
>
> There is no development in Iraq that the news media do not treat as a
> setback, so it comes as no surprise that crepe is being hung by the
> cartload in the wake of the suicide truck bombing of the United
> Nations compound in Baghdad.
>
> Jack Kelly is national security writer for the Post-Gazette
> (jke...@post-gazette.com).>
>
> As I write this two days after the bombing, Nexis indicates there
> already have been 183 news stories printed that use the word "chaos"
> to describe the situation in Iraq, 33 that use the word "quagmire" and
> four that use both.
>
> Television is worse. The "CBS Evening News" broadcast Aug. 20 a report
> by Mark Phillips which Mickey Kaus said in his Slate.com column was
> "so jaw-droppingly one-sided and opportunistically defeatist" that it
> "makes the BBC look like 'The O'Reilly Factor.' "
>
> "Phillips outlines U.S. goals in Afghanistan and Iraq . . . and then
> asserts flatly that 'chaos and blood, not security and democracy, have
> been the result,' " Kaus said. The only authorities Phillips cited for
> this conclusion were two leaders of radical Islamic groups (neither of
> them Iraqi).
>
> "That's it. No attempt to even summarize what the Bush administration
> might credibly argue that it's achieved, much less to actually film
> somebody saying it," Kaus wrote. "Even as an antiwar document, this
> was bad journalism."
>
> "Judging from news reports . . . some might think my native Iraq was
> in a terrible mess. Not so," wrote Ayad Rahim in The Washington Times.
>
> "Except for the isolated contract killings and sabotage, the country
> is calm and experiencing improved conditions day by day," Rahim said.
> "A general who previously served in Kosovo said things are happening
> in Iraq after three months that didn't happen after 12 months in
> Kosovo."
>
> "There is another Iraq the media virtually ignore," wrote Marine Lance
> Cpl. John Guardino. "It has been a model of success. The streets are
> safe, petty and violent crime are low, water and electrical services
> are almost universally available, and ordinary Iraqis are beginning to
> clean up and rebuild their neighborhoods. . . . A deep level of mutual
> trust and respect has developed between the Marines and the populace
> here in central and southern Iraq."
>
> The bombing of the U.N. complex, and the earlier bombing of the
> Jordanian embassy, actually are indications the United States is
> succeeding in Iraq.
>
> The original strategy of the terrorists was what might be called the
> Mogadishu strategy. Kill a few Americans and they'll leave, as they
> did in Somalia in 1993.
>
> The terrorists killed a few Americans and we didn't leave. And the
> terrorists discovered a downside to attacking Americans. Americans
> shoot back. As I write this, Central Command is reporting that Ali
> Hassan al Majid, who orchestrated the gassing of the Kurds, No. 5 in
> the deck of 55, has been taken into custody. Saddam's sons Uday and
> Qusay are burning in hell. Saddam is running like hell. The Mogadishu
> strategy hasn't worked.
>
> The terrorists have discovered that if they attack Americans, they'll
> probably get killed. So they've shifted to softer targets. But though
> this reduces military danger, it increases political risk.
>
> "Baghdad residents condemned the bombing, drawing a distinction
> between terrorism against humanitarian workers and the guerrilla
> attacks on U.S. soldiers, which many Iraqis consider legitimate
> resistance to foreign occupation," the Knight Ridder news service
> said.
>
> Guerrillas must swim in a sea of at least some popular support. The
> sea is drying up.
>
> Journalists are beginning to note, and lament, that Iraq is becoming a
> magnet for al-Qaida types. "It would appear the very terrorism the war
> in Iraq was meant to combat is now being drawn into the country with
> renewed vigor and no lack of targets," wailed UPI senior editor Claude
> Salhani.
>
> As usual, journalists are putting a negative spin on a mostly positive
> development. To win the war on terror, we have to kill the hard-core
> terrorists. It is better to fight them in Iraq, where our soldiers can
> kill them without reading them their Miranda rights first, than it is
> to wait for them to strike in Chicago or New York.
>