Two million of six million is one third.
The reference to "two million children" is not supported by any
of the hundreds of photographs of Auschwitz. Nor is it supported by
the Holocaust's own testimonies. Not even to a tiny degree.
>
>You know,
>The Holocaust is a funny thing..
Kurt:
Please explain what is funny about this? Also, what is not true about it?
Are you calling this former SS man a liar?
If so, please provide your evidence that he is lying.
Interview with Franz Suchomel, SS Unterscharfuhrer by Claude Lanzmann:
---BEGIN QUOTE---
CL: What was Treblinka like then?
FS: It was operating at full capacity.
CL: Full capacity?
FS: Full capacity! The Warsaw ghetto was being emptied then. Three trains
arrived in two days, each with three, four, five thousand people aboard,
all from Warsaw. But at the same time, other trains came in from Kielce
and other places. So three trains arrived, and since the offensive against
Stalingrad was in full swing, the trainloads of Jews were left on a
station siding. What's more, the cars were French, made of steel. So that
while five thousand Jews arrived in Treblinka, three thousand were dead in
the cars. They had slashed their wrists, or just died. The ones we
unloaded were half dead and half mad. In the other trains from Kielce and
elsewhere, at least half were dead. We stacked them here, here, here, and
here. Thousands of people piled one on top of another on the ramp. Stacked
like wood. In addition, other Jews, still alive, waited there for two
days: the small gas chambers could not handle the load. They functioned
day and night in that period.
---END QUOTE---
_Shoah, An Oral History of the Holocaust_, Claude Lanzmann
Complete Text of the Film
Pantheon Books, NY
1985
ISBN 0-394-55142-7
Sara
--
"It's always nice to see a prejudice overruled by a deeper prejudice."
John Sayles, _Lone Star_
Everything you write is tired old "revisionist" crap,
some of it so stupid that even "revisionists" have
given up on it. To elaborate:
# The whole story is goofy: shipping Jews across hell's half
# acre to put them "gas chambers."
One obvious reason was that the murder in the Euthanasia
gas chambers in Germany was strongly protested by the
population and the clergy. Hence, the attempt to
hide it by transporting the victims to selected
locations outside of Germany, where all the massive
death camps were. Plus, most were Polish Jews who
were killed not far from where they lived.
# Stated plainly, it doesn't make sense.
Many historical events don't make sense. Stalin's murders
don't make sense. Pol Pot's murder of a million or more
of the elite of his nation doesn't make sense. You will
have to find a better argument.
# Genocide everywhere in history is done by bullet or starvation
# because that is what is more efficient.
Says who? Why not save ammunition during war time?
# I won't believe a kooky theory such as gas chambers
# when the Germans obviously had far more efficient methods
It was *extremely* efficient. A few Kgs of Zyklon killed
2,000 people. And the stuff was available and very cheap.
# -- unless there is substantial and real evidence for such
# an anomaly. But substantial and real evidence is precisely
# what the Holocausters -don't- have.
There's plenty of evidence, no less substantial and real than,
say, the bombing of Dresden.
# Aside from serious evidentiary contradictions (the structures
# of the so-called gas chambers,
Huh? What is this rubbish? What are the "contradictions"
regarding the structure of the gas chambers?
# Zyklon B is an insecticide, etc),
An insecticide which releases HCN, cyanide gas which is used
for 50 years or so to execute people in US prisons.
# and some highly suspicious testimony,
Which you will have for every historical event. Or haven't
you seen yet those testimonies about Dresden?
# Given the brutality which many German officers either were
# subjected to or threatened with under Allied custody pending
# the Nuremberg trial,
Garbage. Moreover so since most of the SS-men from the
death camps were tried by the German Legal System. You
don't even know this, right?
# along with the lack of evidence for the alleged millions
# of death (ashes not found),
Ashes and human remains in large quantities were actually
found in some of the camps. Now, show me the corpses/ashes
of two million Germans who allegedly died while being
evacuated into Germany after the war.
No excuses. SHOW ME THEIR CORPSES. Or admit it's a hoax.
That's your line.
Let's see you clowns play this game.
# along with the structural impossibilities of the so-called 'gas
# chambers' (would have killed the German soldiers themselves),
More outright garbage. There ARE cyanide traces on the walls of
these gas chambers. Even the "revisionists" agree cyanide gas was
used in them.
Posted/e-mailed.
-Danny Keren.
schw...@infinet.com wrote:
>In article <4ut6na$q...@newsbf02.news.aol.com>, kurt...@aol.com (Kurt
>Stele) wrote:
>>You know,
>>The Holocaust is a funny thing..
>Kurt:
>
>Please explain what is funny about this?
Webster Dictionary. Definition "funny": alternate definition (3) :
"warranting suspicion; deceitful underhanded. Example: "he won't stand
for funny stuff!"
Also, what is not true about it?
The whole story is goofy: shipping Jews across hell's half acre to put
them "gas chambers." Stated plainly, it doesn't make sense. Genocide
everywhere in history is done by bullet or starvation because that is what
is more efficient. I won't believe a kooky theory such as gas chambers
when the Germans obviously had far more efficient methods -- unless there
is substantial and real evidence for such an anomaly. But substantial and
real evidence is precisely what the Holocausters -don't- have.
Aside from serious evidentiary contradictions (the structures of the
so-called gas chambers, Zyklon B is an insecticide, etc), and some highly
suspicious testimony, the whole thing is goofy, and smacks of propaganda
and hysteria -- even Broadway.
That, taken with the Holocausters efforts to censor, thwart, and prohibit
serious discussion, indicate to me the theory of the Holocaust is probably
bogus
>Are you calling this former SS man a liar?
No, probably just another one of the Allied's tortured German captives.
>If so, please provide your evidence that he is lying.
Given the brutality which many German officers either were subjected to or
threatened with under Allied custody pending the Nuremberg trial, along
with the lack of evidence for the alleged millions of death (ashes not
found), along with the structural impossibilities of the so-called 'gas
chambers' (would have killed the German soldiers themselves),
why don't you prove he -wasn't- lying?
An "oral" history is about all you have. Real ("non-oral") history is
sorely lacking
Chuck Ferree wrote:
>
> t...@pacificnet.net (tom moran) wrote:
>
> >
> > "The Holocaust was the murder of six million Jews, including two
> >million children.
That's right...at least that many.
What's your point of going on with the numbers, Tom. Doesn't prove
anything to anybody. Just razzle-dazzle. Chezz, fella, you either
gotta come up with better stuff than this, or quit.
Chuck
Holocaust denial is a second murder of those same
> >six million. First their lives were extinguished; then their deaths.
Yeah, maybe something tangible is there, but I don't see it.
So I ask again...What's your point? Spit it out, Tom, spit it out>
Chuck
>
# Two million of six million is one third.
#
# The reference to "two million children" is not supported
# by any of the hundreds of photographs of Auschwitz. Nor is
# it supported by the Holocaust's own testimonies.
What do you mean by "nor is it supported by the Holocaust's
own testimonies"? Do you mean that witnesses don't mention
that many children were murdered? But they do say this.
One indication to the percentage of children among the
victims is the report by SS-Standartenfuehrer Jager about
the numbers of Jews murdered by his unit (Einsatzkommando 3),
in Lithuania, during July-November 1941. The report gives
a very accurate breakdown, by dates, and also classifies
the victims into Jewish men, women, and children.
Some typical entries:
[Source: 'The Good Old Days' - E. Klee, W. Dressen, V. Riess, The
Free Press, NY, 1988, p. 46-58].
The Commander of
the security police and
the SD
Einsatzkommando 3 Kauen [Kaunas], 1 December 1941
--------------------------
|Secret Reich Business! | 5 copies
-------------------------- 4th copy
Complete list of executions carried out in the EK 3 area
up to 1 December 1941
[...]
12.9.41 City of Wilna 993 Jews, 1,670 Jewesses, 771
Jewish children 3,334
17.9.41 City of Wilna 337 Jews, 687 Jewesses, 247
Jewish children and 4 Lith. Comm. 1,271
20.9.41 Nemencing 128 Jews, 176 Jewesses, 99
Jewish children 403
22.9.41 Novo-Wilejka 468 Jews, 495 Jewesses, 196
Jewish children 1,159
24.9.41 Riess 512 Jews, 744 Jewesses, 511
Jewish children 1,767
25.9.41 Jahiunai 215 Jews, 229 Jewesses, 131
Jewish children 575
27.9.41 Eysisky 989 Jews, 1,636 Jewesses, 821
Jewish children 3,446
30.9.41 Trakai 366 Jews, 483 Jewesses, 597
Jewish children 1,446
4.10.41 City of Wilna 432 Jews, 1,115 Jewesses, 436
Jewish children 1,983
6.10.41 Semiliski 213 Jews, 359 Jewesses, 390
Jewish children 962
9.10.41 Svenciany 1,169 Jews, 1,840 Jewesses, 717
Jewish children 3,726
16.10.41 City of Wilna 382 Jews, 507 Jewesses, 257
Jewish children 1,146
21.10.41 City of Wilna 718 Jews, 1,063 Jewesses, 586
Jewish children 2,367
[...]
<end quote>
Do the calculation. I can post the complete report.
-Danny Keren.
>Everything you write is tired old "revisionist" crap,
>some of it so stupid that even "revisionists" have
>given up on it. To elaborate:
>kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele) writes:
# The whole story is goofy: shipping Jews across hell's half
# acre to put them "gas chambers."
>One obvious reason was that the murder in the Euthanasia
>gas chambers in Germany was strongly protested by the
>population and the clergy. Hence, the attempt to
>hide it by transporting the victims to selected
>locations outside of Germany, where all the massive
>death camps were. Plus, most were Polish Jews who
>were killed not far from where they lived.
oh bullshit. When Reinhard Heydrich was killed, the Nazis had no
compunction about wiping out an entire Czechloslovakian village. When
they wanted to wipe a group a people out they simply did it. Hitler's
purge during the night of the long knives was done in the open. Hundred
of prisoners were summarily executed. If the Reich afforded little
privacy to the execution of its own people, it certainly wouldn't have
afforded any to the avowed -enemies- of their people, the jews -- clergy
approval or no.
The Reich was doing all manner of activities the clergy didn't approve of.
Clergy approval never stopped the Reich. "Clergy approval" certainly
wouldn't have compelled some goofy train-transportation scheme which
wasted precious German resources in transportation and inmate upkeep when
there were far more sensical ways to kill people.
"Gee dad, and I thought the Nazis were trying to fight a war."
># Stated plainly, it doesn't make sense.
>Many historical events don't make sense. Stalin's murders
>don't make sense. Pol Pot's murder of a million or more
>of the elite of his nation doesn't make sense. You will
>have to find a better argument.
you missed it -- it "doesn't make sense" in that the holohoax story would
have been -absurdly inefficient: not at all the way Stalin and Pol Pot's
exterminations were. Now those exterminations, in contrast to the
"holocaust, made complete, plausible sense, i.e., they were done by the
obvious and efficient means of killing -- by bullet and/or starvation.
With Stalin and Pol Pot, as opposed to the Holohoax, you had:
No trains.
No tattoos.
No insecticide.
No "death-camps."
No stories of jewish women cleaning stairs with their tongues.
In other words, no goofy bullshit.
Just killing.
If the Nazis wanted to exterminate the jews, they would have done so using
the most efficient means possible. If they had wanted to gas the jews
they would have used the most efficient gas availabe -- not Zyklon B!
Whenever the Nazis wanted to kill a group of people, whether it be French
resistance, or Czechoslovakians, or brownshirts, they did it the way every
other nation did it. They lined the people up and shot them dead.
But you want people to believe the nazis created some idiotic, inefficient
scheme for killing jews?
Must be that age-old jewish arrogance which fancies itself always entitled
to special treatment. ;)
># Genocide everywhere in history is done by bullet or starvation
># because that is what is more efficient.
>Says who? Why not save ammunition during war time?
Good one, Keren. Instead of using cheap bullets, let's use up our natural
resources in transporting Jews all over Europe. And let's waste even
-more- resources in "deathcamp" maintenance, along with the infrastructure
resources it would entail.
After all, they -were- trying to kill the jews.
Yeah, that's it. Let's create a huge elaborate and costly transportation
and housing scheme, instead of using our ammunition. Yeah, that's it.
How fucking dumb.
># I won't believe a kooky theory such as gas chambers
># when the Germans obviously had far more efficient methods
>It was *extremely* efficient. A few Kgs of Zyklon killed
>2,000 people. And the stuff was available and very cheap.
Zyklon-B as opposed to several other gasses available at the time was
ridiculously inefficient.
And I guess it is also just another coincidence that we have reams of
German documents that refer to Zyklon-B as insecticide.
I guess it takes a holohugger to make insecticide into "death gas" and
crematoria into "ovens."
># -- unless there is substantial and real evidence for such
># an anomaly. But substantial and real evidence is precisely
># what the Holocausters -don't- have.
>There's plenty of evidence, no less substantial and real than,
>say, the bombing of Dresden.
You love comparing the Holocaust to Dresden, but the analogy is
inapposite. For example, with Dresden we have the actual documents
authorizing the bombing. We don't have any with the Holocaust (except a
spurious document or two) to prove that the Reich's intent was to
exterminate the Jews systematically. Such a plan would have left a
prodigious paper trail, but none was found. Instead, we have evidence
showing something entirely different: a labor camp. You don't tatoo
someone you are going to exterminate -- no need to!
Again, how fucking dumb.
Virtually -noone- doubts Dresden. Yet there is growing movement of doubt
about the holocaust. Also, one is permitted to doubt Dresden to the
heavens, but noone is permitted to doubt the holocaust. People are
getting wise the suspicious nature of the Holohoax.
"Enforced orthodoxy is indicative of a theory that possesses little
merit."
Furthemore, noone is trying to supress the doubters of Dresden. Yet there
are powerful jewish forces that suppress and criminalize free speech in
Germany, and imprison revisionists. The international holocaust lobby
undoubtedly would like nothing better than to impose its Orwellian
thoughtcontrol in America.
These holohuggers are straight out of the fucking dark ages -- the enemies
of free thought if there ever were. They want to impose some Byzantine,
medieval faith upon us, by force.
That sort of thoughtcontrol may be OK in Israel, but we Whites want the
truth.
># Aside from serious evidentiary contradictions (the structures
># of the so-called gas chambers,
>Huh? What is this rubbish? What are the "contradictions"
>regarding the structure of the gas chambers?
Those inmate facilities weren't gas chambers. The design of the buildings
were inadequate for your silly gas chambers
># Zyklon B is an insecticide, etc),
>An insecticide which releases HCN, cyanide gas which is used
>for 50 years or so to execute people in US prisons.
yeah, and Raid has arsenic in it but only a moron would try to use Raid to
try to kill large groups of people systematically. Especially when the
"extermination" involves the large cost of housing and transporting
people, when all is needed are just a some bullets. A bomb could have
wiped out hundreds at a time.
Obviously, something else was going on here -- a labor camp.
DUH.
Even if -each bullet- costed fifty cents a piece (a bullet costs a minute
fraction of that), killing jews by shooting them would have been far more
efficient.
But instead you want me to believe that "Raid" was used, and that it was
all a big plot to wipe out the Jews using insecticide, using buildings
that couldn't have functioned as gas chambers.
So: why don't you tell me another one.
># and some highly suspicious testimony,
>Which you will have for every historical event. Or haven't
>you seen yet those testimonies about Dresden?
Again, the difference between Dresden testimony and Holocaust testimony is
that the latter is patently implausible. Showers as gas chambers? Ovens
as crematoria? Extermination by costly death-camps instead of shooting
them or starving them?
Give me a break. Sounds like more Hollywood to me.
There is nothing implausible about the firestorm at Dresden -- it was an
incendiary reaction, perfectly plausible. There are no anomalies involved
in the physical event of Dresden, no goofy shit. But the in the holocause
we have quite a different scenario.
However, even if Dresden -didn't- happen-, the Germans don't have a
"financial interest" in making other people believe in and feel guilty
about Dresden, the way the jews have a great financial interest in making
others believe in and feel guilty about the Great Holohock.
The jews' political/financial windfall from it, which has yielded monetary
rewards in the -billions-, makes the holohokum even -more- suspicious.
More and more people are beginning to realize this. It is a huge,
unparalled swindle.
But I do agree that you holohuggers definitely need to keep suppressing us
Holocaust doubters with harrassment and imprisonment if you have any hope
of keeping your little Holocaust story from crumbling. Because if the
world at large ever understood how ridiculous your tale is, and for a
moment grasped its patent absurdity, the Holohoax would be summarily
discarded.
What you holohuggers don't realize is that your suppression and oppression
of revisionists, your evictions from websites, your jewish money power
applied to silence others, your legal and physical terrorism, and your
attempts to stifle free debate are just causing the revisionist movement
to grow, and also alerting others to the stink of the Holocaust story,
which is quite smelly..
># Given the brutality which many German officers either were
># subjected to or threatened with under Allied custody pending
># the Nuremberg trial,
>Garbage. Moreover so since most of the SS-men from the
>death camps were tried by the German Legal System. You
>don't even know this, right?
yeah, the so-called "German Legal system." Of course the Allies had
-nothing- to do with that apparatus by the war's end, right? And I'm sure
they got a fair trial, just like at Nuremberg, too
># along with the lack of evidence for the alleged millions
># of death (ashes not found),
>Ashes and human remains in large quantities were actually
>found in some of the camps. Now, show me the corpses/ashes
>of two million Germans who allegedly died while being
>evacuated into Germany after the war.
The point you keep missing over and over is that the deaths of Germans at
Dresden and after the war were not from -implausible- causes, the way the
alleged "deaths" of the holohoax victims were. There is nothing
implausible about masses of Germans starving from deliberate Allied/Soviet
design. There is nothing inherently suspicious about those circumstances.
However, there -is- much inherently suspicious about your (fantasy) tale
of disguised shower heads, and insecticide, and extermination by
"deathcamps," and secret extermination plans that everyone about knew but
nobody talked about, and Germans who were too dumb to use bullets but too
smart to have their "Extermination plan" discovered.
C'mon guys. Just admit it.
>No excuses. SHOW ME THEIR CORPSES. Or admit it's a hoax.
>That's your line.
>Let's see you clowns play this game.
see the above
># along with the structural impossibilities of the so-called 'gas
># chambers' (would have killed the German soldiers themselves),
>More outright garbage. There ARE cyanide traces on the walls of
>these gas chambers. Even the "revisionists" agree cyanide gas was
>used in them.
yeah, and not in anywhere near the traces which could support a finding
they were used as gas chambers. But, ODDLY ENOUGH, the traces -do-
support the finding that they came from delousing fugimant. Gee.
But holohuggers are notorious for obstinately refusing to connect the
dots. There's still too much money to be made in Shoah
Kurt Stele
>kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele) writes:
>Everything you write is tired old "revisionist" crap,
>some of it so stupid that even "revisionists" have
>given up on it. To elaborate:
># The whole story is goofy: shipping Jews across hell's half
># acre to put them "gas chambers."
>One obvious reason was that the murder in the Euthanasia
>gas chambers in Germany was strongly protested by the
>population and the clergy. Hence, the attempt to
>hide it by transporting the victims to selected
>locations outside of Germany, where all the massive
>death camps were. Plus, most were Polish Jews who
>were killed not far from where they lived.
Therefore they transported people from France and Greece and Italy to
gas them in Poland. Now that is really bright. But of course, from
the French presentation at the IMT, we know there was not "religious"
selection of note. But it happened nevertheless.
># Stated plainly, it doesn't make sense.
>Many historical events don't make sense. Stalin's murders
>don't make sense. Pol Pot's murder of a million or more
>of the elite of his nation doesn't make sense. You will
>have to find a better argument.
Of course they make sense. What are you talking about?
># Genocide everywhere in history is done by bullet or starvation
># because that is what is more efficient.
>Says who? Why not save ammunition during war time?
Stupid shit. Today military ball 9mm rounds cost 11 cents each. For
6 million dead from ALL causes that is $660,000 dollars. Instead they
rounded up, transported to Poland and built FOUR special huge
buildings instead of spending the money on that many bullets.
># I won't believe a kooky theory such as gas chambers
># when the Germans obviously had far more efficient methods
>It was *extremely* efficient. A few Kgs of Zyklon killed
>2,000 people. And the stuff was available and very cheap.
Not by any rational calculation but let me see your calculations for
the amount needed to kill in 10-15 minutes. Please be specific in
your response. I want to see your calculations and assumptions.
If you have not made them, you are misrepresenting, i.e. lying, about
what you are talking about.
># -- unless there is substantial and real evidence for such
># an anomaly. But substantial and real evidence is precisely
># what the Holocausters -don't- have.
>There's plenty of evidence, no less substantial and real than,
>say, the bombing of Dresden.
You may be the first to post it. Please do.
># Aside from serious evidentiary contradictions (the structures
># of the so-called gas chambers,
>Huh? What is this rubbish? What are the "contradictions"
>regarding the structure of the gas chambers?
The gas chambers were discovered in the last five years. The first
two were LK I and II. The second pair were the undressing rooms at II
and IV. LK III and IV were never used (occording to the latest
mythology) as gas chambers but there was no change in design. If I
and II were "perfect" gas chambers then III and IV were also but
without any of the "design features" imagined by the holohuggers.
># Zyklon B is an insecticide, etc),
>An insecticide which releases HCN, cyanide gas which is used
>for 50 years or so to execute people in US prisons.
Over 70 actually but the "eyewitness" descriptions of US executions do
not match those of SS executions in any manner other than dead
eventually.
># and some highly suspicious testimony,
>Which you will have for every historical event. Or haven't
>you seen yet those testimonies about Dresden?
Have you ever learned to tell the difference between physical evidence
and testimony?
># Given the brutality which many German officers either were
># subjected to or threatened with under Allied custody pending
># the Nuremberg trial,
>Garbage. Moreover so since most of the SS-men from the
>death camps were tried by the German Legal System. You
>don't even know this, right?
You have just contradicted your fellow holohuggers. Want to give some
names? Hoess for example?
># along with the lack of evidence for the alleged millions
># of death (ashes not found),
>Ashes and human remains in large quantities were actually
>found in some of the camps.
We have been over that. They were never looked for much less found.
Now, show me the corpses/ashes
>of two million Germans who allegedly died while being
>evacuated into Germany after the war.
>No excuses. SHOW ME THEIR CORPSES. Or admit it's a hoax.
>That's your line.
>Let's see you clowns play this game.
Find one corpes that dies of cyanide poisoning. Post the forensic
evidence.
># along with the structural impossibilities of the so-called 'gas
># chambers' (would have killed the German soldiers themselves),
>More outright garbage. There ARE cyanide traces on the walls of
>these gas chambers. Even the "revisionists" agree cyanide gas was
>used in them.
Where are the baseline samples as it has been stipulated that morgues
would have been fumigated.
Here's Keren with one of his eyewitness testimony documents.
Notice I say "one". Do I know if it's a forgery? Do I know if the
Germans were reporting on the citizens rage against the Jews? Keren
offers one, uncertainty. Photographs are far more certain. Hundreds of
photographs of camps interees that don't support the claim that 1/3 of
the Holocaust victims could be children.
All the photographs of the arrival and "selection" of people to
Auschwitz, all those in the camp should show this ratio. Yet they
don't. You better come up with something more than one little
uncertain document.
> schw...@infinet.com wrote:
>
> >Are you calling this former SS man [Franz Suchomel, as filmed in
Claude Lanzmann's _Shoah_] a liar?
>
> No, probably just another one of the Allied's tortured German captives.
>
> >If so, please provide your evidence that he is lying.
>
> Given the brutality which many German officers either were subjected to or
> threatened with under Allied custody pending the Nuremberg trial
[snip]
> why don't you prove he -wasn't- lying?
Please read the book or rent the film _Shoah_. You will see that
Suchomel is being interviewed by Claude Lanzmann, the director of the
film, and is speaking of his own free will, in the early 1980s. Suchomel
spoke to Lanzmann under one condition: that Lanzmann would not reveal his
identity. Other than breaking that promise (Lanzmann shows Suchomel's
face and identifies him by name), the interviews involved no trickery:
Lanzmann did not torture Suchomel, Suchomel was not being prosecuted, and
no courts were involved. All the film shows is a former Nazi guard,
speaking freely because he thinks he will be anonymous, telling of what he
did during the war.
Do you still want to call him a liar?
----------------------
Marty Kelley (mke...@U.Arizona.EDU) "When we visit each other,
we always check out what's on our friends' bookshelves. It's
the academic equivalent of dogs sniffing each other's butts"
--J. Champagne
# Either you are a fraud with the PhD claim or you know
# the even basic arithmetic is contrary to your claims.
#
# There is nothing in between.
#
# You are a fraud.
You are a little zero, hardly educated, who has achieved
nothing in his life and had to retire at the age of 46,
for reasons which are quite obvious for everyone
following your articles here.
You are a failure, a loser, a frustrated, vulgar, stupid
51-year-old punk who can only find common language with
teenage Nazi punks, who are your natural colleagues.
You have proved that you don't know anything about
chemistry, history, diesel engines, arithmetic...
Your feelings of inferiority and frustration drive
you crazy; that's why the fact that I have a Ph.D - which
I never made a lot of mention of - is a source of
endless anger for you.
Face it pal, you're a zero. A nothing. A failure. And
it's only going to grow worse as you get older.
-Danny Keren.
--
In Message-ID: <4n0ik8$1...@dfw-ixnews10.ix.netcom.com>, Matt Giwer
suggested that documents about a "gas chamber" and "gassing cellar"
in the Birkenau crematoriums didn't count, as they were really due
to "a morbid sense of humor" of the SS men who authored the documents.
>t...@pacificnet.net (tom moran) writes:
>Some typical entries:
>[...]
>[...]
><end quote>
But you never will. Your math. Your calculations.
>-Danny Keren.
You do the calculation. It appears you are unable to do the least bit
of math, yet that is your "PhD" or at least your claim. You have yet
to post anything even vaguely smelling of arithmetic.
Either you are a fraud with the PhD claim or you know that the even
basic arithmetic is contrary to your claims.
There is nothing in between.
You are a fraud.
> kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele) foams at the mouth:
>
[snip]
> # Now those exterminations, in contrast to the "holocaust,
> # made complete, plausible sense, i.e., they were done by the
> # obvious and efficient means of killing -- by bullet
> # and/or starvation.
>
> The Nazis starved, shot, or overworked to death half
> of the victims. The rest were killed in gas chambers.
>
> All your empty rhetoric can't hide the fact that killing
> with poison gas was very cheap, very efficient, and
> saved ammunition.
Indeed. On average 0.02 Reichmarks (1992: $.08) per victim. A rifle
cartridge cost more than that.
[snip]
> # Zyklon-B as opposed to several other gasses available at the
> # time was ridiculously inefficient.
>
> All you stupid "revisionists" can do is repeat this like
> a lame-brained parrot. The gas was very cheap, very easy
> to handle, and they had a great deal of experience using it.
>
> The same gas, HCN, is used to execute people in US
> prisons. A natural choice.
Indeed. It seems there is some discord in the denier camp on this issue.
According to Mr. Kreiberg (a denier) in article
<hQx4oOev...@login.dknet.dk>:
"...HCN is much more poisonous than car exhaust. In the US
execution gas chambers the convicted have only to inhale the HCN once or
twice, and he is gone."
Well, either HCN is or it is not an efficient homicidal agent. It cannot
be _both_ efficient and inefficient at the same time! Perhaps the deniers
should put their little heads together and straighten this out amonst
themsleves before exposing themselves to further ridicule?
> # I guess it takes a holohugger to make insecticide into
> # "death gas" and crematoria into "ovens."
>
> I guess it takes a stupid "revisionist" to make unfounded
> claims about technical matters without proving his point.
Indeed. It is probably worth pointing out that nerve gaents such as Tabun,
Sarin, and Soman were developed from "mere" insecticides by the Nazis. Not
to mention that such highly lethal nerve agents, such as VX, can with a
modicum of effort be developed through "dual use" programs in the same
factories were common insecticides are produced because the manufacturing
process is similar between the two. (Remember the U.S. concern that Libya
was clandestinely developing nerve agents?)
[snip]
Mark
posted/e-mailed
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Gradually it was disclosed to me that the line separating good and evil passes
not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties--but
right through every human heart--and all human hearts."
-- Alexander Solzhenitsyn, "The Gulag Archipelago"
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[snip]
> And by the way, when are you going to respond to the testimony of Franz
> Suchomel, which I posted a few days ago.
Probably as soon as he grows some pubic hair....
Mark
>In article <Dw90y...@world.std.com>, dke...@world.std.com (Daniel
Keren)
>wrote:
>> kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele)wrote:
>>
>> # Now the exterminations [of Stalin and Pol Pot], in contrast to the
"holocaust,
>> # made complete, plausible sense, i.e., they were done by the
>> # obvious and efficient means of killing -- by bullet
>> # and/or starvation.
>>
>> The Nazis starved, shot, or overworked to death half
>> of the victims. The rest were killed in gas chambers.
>>
>> All your empty rhetoric can't hide the fact that killing
>> with poison gas was very cheap, very efficient, and
>> saved ammunition.
>Indeed. On average 0.02 Reichmarks (1992: $.08) per victim. A rifle
>cartridge cost more than that.
>Mark
Care to show your calculations in achieving $.08?
Why don't you do your calculations over again, this time factoring in, as
you should have done before, the costs of -everything else- involved in
"gassing" prisoners under the circumstances.
You're saying that shipping prisoners across the European continent by
train, during a war, to tag them, house them, and then gas them, using up
valuable resources in energy, manpower, and cost of upkeep and "deathcamp"
administration, is -cheaper- then just shooting them dead on the spot?
what total bullshit
Kurt Stele
# Therefore they transported people from France and Greece
# and Italy to gas them in Poland.
A relatively small number; most victims were Poles,
or Soviet Jews murdered close to where they lived.
# Stupid shit.
You don't have to use such words just because this is
what you learned at home.
# Today military ball 9mm rounds cost 11 cents each. For
# 6 million dead from ALL causes that is $660,000 dollars.
Bullets are necessary items during the war. Why waste
them if you can kill the people with Zyklon?
# Not by any rational calculation but let me see your
# calculations for the amount needed to kill in 10-15 minutes.
For the largest gas chambers? 4 Kg would definitely
be enough. What is your figure?
# The gas chambers were discovered in the last five years.
This is such an insane and stupid comment that there's
no use reading this anymore. They were found immediately
after the war. You're simply out of your mind.
You've been a bad boy, and the .sig returns.
>On 15 Aug 1996, Kurt Stele wrote:
>> schw...@infinet.com wrote:
>>
>> >Are you calling this former SS man [Franz Suchomel, as filmed in
>Claude Lanzmann's _Shoah_] a liar?
>> why don't you prove he -wasn't- lying?
>Please read the book or rent the film _Shoah_. You will see that
>Suchomel is being interviewed by Claude Lanzmann, the director of the
>film, and is speaking of his own free will, in the early 1980s. Suchomel
>spoke to Lanzmann under one condition: that Lanzmann would not reveal his
>identity. Other than breaking that promise (Lanzmann shows Suchomel's
>face and identifies him by name), the interviews involved no trickery:
>Lanzmann did not torture Suchomel, Suchomel was not being prosecuted, and
>no courts were involved. All the film shows is a former Nazi guard,
>speaking freely because he thinks he will be anonymous, telling of what
he
>did during the war.
>Do you still want to call him a liar?
Yes.
I'm calling him a liar.
You can pay anyone to say anything -- especially given the money-power of
the jews.
Holocaust contains within it a tortured host of circumstantial and
evidentiary contradictions, impossibilities, and absurdities (disguised
showerheads, Zyklon B "the insecticide," crematoria as "ovens,"
the-transport-tag-house-and-then-gas rather than just shoot 'em"
allegation, the "any old barnhouse can be a gas chamber!" hypothesis, the
everybody knew about the holocaust plan yet nobody ever wrote it down"
theory, etc, etc, ad infinitum, ad nauseam)
Yet all the holohoax has to back it up is eyewitness testimony -- and even
that being from -interested- witnesses, and at an ex post facto court of
"justice."
Well, judging from the circumstances as a whole,
that ain't shit.
Kurt Stele
> But you want people to believe the nazis created some idiotic, inefficient
> scheme for killing jews?
>
> Must be that age-old jewish arrogance which fancies itself always entitled
> to special treatment. ;)
Yeah, that must be it.
My grandparents and all their relatives were entitled to special treatment.
Thah's why they were forced, naked, to dig their own grave before being
machine-gunned into it.
I bet you think that's REAL funny, huh, Kurt?
And by the way, when are you going to respond to the testimony of Franz
Suchomel, which I posted a few days ago.
Chuck Ferree wrote:
No, Kurt...(now there's a Cherman name!!!)
The Nazis were so stupid that they kept killing Jews right up until we
stopped them, with firepower. They proved their stupidity so many
times, and remember their stupidity cost them a potental victory.
Buncha dumb-shits, now and worse then!
Chuck
>
>
> what total bullshit
you got this part right, Kurt. My God whatta dummy
Chuck
>
> Kurt Stele
# oh bullshit. When Reinhard Heydrich was killed, the
# Nazis had no compunction about wiping out an entire
# Czechloslovakian village. When they wanted to wipe
# a group a people out they simply did it. Hitler's
# purge during the night of the long knives was done
# in the open.
You're talking about different orders of magnitude here.
# Now those exterminations, in contrast to the "holocaust,
# made complete, plausible sense, i.e., they were done by the
# obvious and efficient means of killing -- by bullet
# and/or starvation.
The Nazis starved, shot, or overworked to death half
of the victims. The rest were killed in gas chambers.
All your empty rhetoric can't hide the fact that killing
with poison gas was very cheap, very efficient, and
saved ammunition.
# With Stalin and Pol Pot, as opposed to the Holohoax,
# you had:
#
# No trains.
No trains? How were all these people deported to Siberia
and to the camps in Cambodia? They walked all the way
to Siberia?
# No tattoos.
Only those spared for work were tattooed.
# No insecticide.
Stop with this bloody rubbish already. It was a cheap
way with which to kill many people. So it was used.
# No "death-camps."
You heard it here, folks. No death camps in Stalin's
USSR and Pol Pot's Cambodia.
# No stories of jewish women cleaning stairs with
# their tongues.
No sadism? Have you read about recent war crimes in Bosnia?
# If they had wanted to gas the jews they would have
# used the most efficient gas available -- not Zyklon B!
Ok, let's here it. What gas do you think they should
have used?
# But you want people to believe the nazis created some
# idiotic, inefficient scheme for killing jews?
No. I think they used a rather efficient scheme.
# Zyklon-B as opposed to several other gasses available at the
# time was ridiculously inefficient.
All you stupid "revisionists" can do is repeat this like
a lame-brained parrot. The gas was very cheap, very easy
to handle, and they had a great deal of experience using it.
The same gas, HCN, is used to execute people in US
prisons. A natural choice.
# I guess it takes a holohugger to make insecticide into
# "death gas" and crematoria into "ovens."
I guess it takes a stupid "revisionist" to make unfounded
claims about technical matters without proving his point.
# You love comparing the Holocaust to Dresden, but the
# analogy is inapposite. For example, with Dresden we have
# the actual documents authorizing the bombing. We don't have
# any with the Holocaust (except a spurious document or two)
# to prove that the Reich's intent was to exterminate the Jews
# systematically.
There are many more such documents.
# You don't tatoo someone you are going to exterminate --
# no need to!
Which is why only those spared as "fit for work" were
tattooed, not those gassed upon arrival.
# That sort of thoughtcontrol may be OK in Israel, but we
# Whites want the truth.
Bwawawa. "We Whites".
# Those inmate facilities weren't gas chambers. The design of
# the buildings were inadequate for your silly gas chambers
Stop repeating this like some dumb little Nazi. PROVE it.
# But instead you want me to believe that "Raid" was used,
# and that it was all a big plot to wipe out the Jews using
# insecticide, using buildings that couldn't have functioned
# as gas chambers.
Prove that they couldn't function as gas chambers.
# Again, the difference between Dresden testimony and Holocaust
# testimony is that the latter is patently implausible.
Yes, sure. "Puddles of melted human flesh, four foot deep".
People "glowing orange and disintegrating". People "turning
into a fine layer of gray ashes", all these, BTW, without the
fire even touching them. All these are "testimonies" about
Dresden.
You claim that a major portion of Holocaust-related
testimonies are impossible? Prove it.
# The point you keep missing over and over is that the deaths
# of Germans at Dresden and after the war were not from
# -implausible- causes,
Garbage. You claim 6 million corpses should be presented. You
now show me the millions of corpses of Germans who allegedly
died after the war ended, and in the bombing raids.
Fair is fair. Show us the corpses.
# yeah, and not in anywhere near the traces which could support
# a finding they were used as gas chambers. But, ODDLY ENOUGH,
# the traces -do- support the finding that they came from
# delousing fugimant. Gee.
And Dresden could have caught fire and burned down. Like
Chicago. It happens you know.
Moreover, you began by claiming that using these facilities
as gas chambers would have "killed the German soldiers
themselves". If this idiotic conjecture was true, than
using them as delousing chambers would also kill them; it's
the same gas.
-Danny Keren.
> You are a fraud.
This comes from a person who claims that cynanide gas should be used
in morgues to kill flies.
--YFE
> >Some typical entries:
> >[Source: 'The Good Old Days' - E. Klee, W. Dressen, V. Riess, The
> > Free Press, NY, 1988, p. 46-58].
> >The Commander of
> >the security police and
> >the SD
> >Einsatzkommando 3 Kauen [Kaunas], 1 December 1941
> >--------------------------
> >|Secret Reich Business! | 5 copies
> >-------------------------- 4th copy
> > Complete list of executions carried out in the EK 3 area
> > up to 1 December 1941
> >12.9.41 City of Wilna 993 Jews, 1,670 Jewesses, 771
> Here's Keren with one of his eyewitness testimony documents.
No l'il tommy it is a written report by the murderers of their murders. It is
acceptable anywhere as very solid evidence unless you can shoiw otherwise.
Your silly suspicions do not not count.
> Notice I say "one". Do I know if it's a forgery? Do I know if the
> Germans were reporting on the citizens rage against the Jews?
Unfortunately you know very little.
> All the photographs of the arrival and "selection" of people to
> Auschwitz, all those in the camp should show this ratio. Yet they
> don't. You better come up with something more than one little
> uncertain document.
l'il tommy is a an anti-Semite, a liar and a coward. About that there is
no uncertainty whatsoever. And I can prove it as well.
--YFE
>kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele) writes:
># oh bullshit. When Reinhard Heydrich was killed, the
># Nazis had no compunction about wiping out an entire
># Czechloslovakian village. When they wanted to wipe
># a group a people out they simply did it. Hitler's
># purge during the night of the long knives was done
># in the open.
>You're talking about different orders of magnitude here.
># Now those exterminations, in contrast to the "holocaust,
># made complete, plausible sense, i.e., they were done by the
># obvious and efficient means of killing -- by bullet
># and/or starvation.
>The Nazis starved, shot, or overworked to death half
>of the victims. The rest were killed in gas chambers.
It is amazing they were not bright enough to starve, shoot or overwork
the other half.
>All your empty rhetoric can't hide the fact that killing
>with poison gas was very cheap, very efficient, and
>saved ammunition.
Which was cheaper than the transportation system and the camps.
They were even dumb enough to ship them all the way from France just
to gas them in Poland. Or would not the French "stand for it"?
># With Stalin and Pol Pot, as opposed to the Holohoax,
># you had:
>#
># No trains.
>No trains? How were all these people deported to Siberia
>and to the camps in Cambodia? They walked all the way
>to Siberia?
The starvation was done on site in the Ukraine.
># No tattoos.
>Only those spared for work were tattooed.
One more assertion that only the undocumented were gassed without
explaining how the undocumented were counted.
># No insecticide.
>Stop with this bloody rubbish already. It was a cheap
>way with which to kill many people. So it was used.
So are bullets. So is CO2 from putting them in a room and sealing it.
After all, there was no hurry as the cremation was the bottleneck
according to you folks.
># No "death-camps."
>You heard it here, folks. No death camps in Stalin's
>USSR and Pol Pot's Cambodia.
Not in the Ukraine, not run by Pol Pot.
># No stories of jewish women cleaning stairs with
># their tongues.
>No sadism? Have you read about recent war crimes in Bosnia?
It appears you believe in the stair cleaning story.
># If they had wanted to gas the jews they would have
># used the most efficient gas available -- not Zyklon B!
>Ok, let's here it. What gas do you think they should
>have used?
CO2, free from breathing. If you want it faster, dump some burning
coke down your "induction columns." It is not as though it is all
that hard to do it cheaper.
># But you want people to believe the nazis created some
># idiotic, inefficient scheme for killing jews?
>No. I think they used a rather efficient scheme.
You mean like the mass electrocutions? or the steaming?
># Zyklon-B as opposed to several other gasses available at the
># time was ridiculously inefficient.
>All you stupid "revisionists" can do is repeat this like
>a lame-brained parrot. The gas was very cheap, very easy
>to handle, and they had a great deal of experience using it.
In the Nizkor approved story of the first usage, a contractor did all
the fumigation until Fritsch had a bright idea, i.e. no experience.
We can go into the other stories later.
>The same gas, HCN, is used to execute people in US
>prisons. A natural choice.
But something as foolish as ZB is not used and would be quite a
riduculous way to go about it.
But you know that.
># I guess it takes a holohugger to make insecticide into
># "death gas" and crematoria into "ovens."
>I guess it takes a stupid "revisionist" to make unfounded
>claims about technical matters without proving his point.
Your demonstrated technical knowledge here is on a par with your
demonstrated math knowledge, zero.
># You love comparing the Holocaust to Dresden, but the
># analogy is inapposite. For example, with Dresden we have
># the actual documents authorizing the bombing. We don't have
># any with the Holocaust (except a spurious document or two)
># to prove that the Reich's intent was to exterminate the Jews
># systematically.
>There are many more such documents.
Two, neither clear, amidst all the rest with no such indication.
># You don't tatoo someone you are going to exterminate --
># no need to!
>Which is why only those spared as "fit for work" were
>tattooed, not those gassed upon arrival.
Admitting again there were no records of those "gassed" but not
exlpaining how the "gassed" were determined to be different from the
31 million who vanished without a trace.
># That sort of thoughtcontrol may be OK in Israel, but we
># Whites want the truth.
>Bwawawa. "We Whites".
># Those inmate facilities weren't gas chambers. The design of
># the buildings were inadequate for your silly gas chambers
>Stop repeating this like some dumb little Nazi. PROVE it.
You claim HCN is used in US gas chambers as though it was the same as
ZB. Therefore there is a need to demonstrate that
1) these morgues were useful for gassing
and
2) that they overcome the differences between US gas chambers and ZB
in application.
And that if just the beginning. You folks started "discovering" the
morgues were really gas chambers about four years ago. You folks
claim they have obvious features for mass extermination chambers. Yet
since these are the only ones ever built there is a lot more needed to
substantiate the claim of obvious.
># But instead you want me to believe that "Raid" was used,
># and that it was all a big plot to wipe out the Jews using
># insecticide, using buildings that couldn't have functioned
># as gas chambers.
>Prove that they couldn't function as gas chambers.
You home can function as a gas chamber. Prove it is not.
You folks bear the burden of making the claim.
You folks have never met that burden.
># Again, the difference between Dresden testimony and Holocaust
># testimony is that the latter is patently implausible.
>Yes, sure. "Puddles of melted human flesh, four foot deep".
>People "glowing orange and disintegrating". People "turning
>into a fine layer of gray ashes", all these, BTW, without the
>fire even touching them. All these are "testimonies" about
>Dresden.
>You claim that a major portion of Holocaust-related
>testimonies are impossible? Prove it.
Some day you may be intelligent or honest enough to admit there is a
difference between physical evidence and testimony. If you believe
they are the same, you should accept Jesus into your heart.
># The point you keep missing over and over is that the deaths
># of Germans at Dresden and after the war were not from
># -implausible- causes,
>Garbage. You claim 6 million corpses should be presented. You
>now show me the millions of corpses of Germans who allegedly
>died after the war ended, and in the bombing raids.
>Fair is fair. Show us the corpses.
But of course, you first. And after all of these years, nothing.
># yeah, and not in anywhere near the traces which could support
># a finding they were used as gas chambers. But, ODDLY ENOUGH,
># the traces -do- support the finding that they came from
># delousing fugimant. Gee.
>And Dresden could have caught fire and burned down. Like
>Chicago. It happens you know.
And all of those gassed Jews could have been invented out of the 31
million unaccounted for. It happened, you know.
>In article <Dw90y...@world.std.com>, dke...@world.std.com (Daniel Keren)
>wrote:
>> kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele) foams at the mouth:
>>
>[snip]
>> # Now those exterminations, in contrast to the "holocaust,
>> # made complete, plausible sense, i.e., they were done by the
>> # obvious and efficient means of killing -- by bullet
>> # and/or starvation.
>>
>> The Nazis starved, shot, or overworked to death half
>> of the victims. The rest were killed in gas chambers.
>>
>> All your empty rhetoric can't hide the fact that killing
>> with poison gas was very cheap, very efficient, and
>> saved ammunition.
>Indeed. On average 0.02 Reichmarks (1992: $.08) per victim. A rifle
>cartridge cost more than that.
1) How much more did a 9 mm cartridge cost? In the '70s I could get
surplus 9 mm cartridges for eight cents without looking around.
2) How much total ZB was required? And while you are at it post
your complete calculation of the cost.
3) You will not do either nor will the math PhD who has never posted
one article using arithmetic.
>[snip]
>> # Zyklon-B as opposed to several other gasses available at the
>> # time was ridiculously inefficient.
>>
>> All you stupid "revisionists" can do is repeat this like
>> a lame-brained parrot. The gas was very cheap, very easy
>> to handle, and they had a great deal of experience using it.
>>
>> The same gas, HCN, is used to execute people in US
>> prisons. A natural choice.
>Indeed. It seems there is some discord in the denier camp on this issue.
>According to Mr. Kreiberg (a denier) in article
><hQx4oOev...@login.dknet.dk>:
>"...HCN is much more poisonous than car exhaust. In the US
>execution gas chambers the convicted have only to inhale the HCN once or
>twice, and he is gone."
>Well, either HCN is or it is not an efficient homicidal agent. It cannot
>be _both_ efficient and inefficient at the same time! Perhaps the deniers
>should put their little heads together and straighten this out amonst
>themsleves before exposing themselves to further ridicule?
HCN in ZB form is what is at issue here. Please address it in your
calculations.
>> # I guess it takes a holohugger to make insecticide into
>> # "death gas" and crematoria into "ovens."
>>
>> I guess it takes a stupid "revisionist" to make unfounded
>> claims about technical matters without proving his point.
>Indeed. It is probably worth pointing out that nerve gaents such as Tabun,
>Sarin, and Soman were developed from "mere" insecticides by the Nazis. Not
>to mention that such highly lethal nerve agents, such as VX, can with a
>modicum of effort be developed through "dual use" programs in the same
>factories were common insecticides are produced because the manufacturing
>process is similar between the two. (Remember the U.S. concern that Libya
>was clandestinely developing nerve agents?)
How about free CO2?
>mvan...@rbi.com (Mark Van Alstine) wrote:
>>In article <Dw90y...@world.std.com>, dke...@world.std.com (Daniel
>Keren)
>>wrote:
>>> kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele)wrote:
>>>
>>> # Now the exterminations [of Stalin and Pol Pot], in contrast to the
>"holocaust,
>>> # made complete, plausible sense, i.e., they were done by the
>>> # obvious and efficient means of killing -- by bullet
>>> # and/or starvation.
>>>
>>> The Nazis starved, shot, or overworked to death half
>>> of the victims. The rest were killed in gas chambers.
>>>
>>> All your empty rhetoric can't hide the fact that killing
>>> with poison gas was very cheap, very efficient, and
>>> saved ammunition.
>>Indeed. On average 0.02 Reichmarks (1992: $.08) per victim. A rifle
>>cartridge cost more than that.
>>Mark
>Care to show your calculations in achieving $.08?
>Why don't you do your calculations over again, this time factoring in, as
>you should have done before, the costs of -everything else- involved in
>"gassing" prisoners under the circumstances.
>You're saying that shipping prisoners across the European continent by
>train, during a war, to tag them, house them, and then gas them, using up
>valuable resources in energy, manpower, and cost of upkeep and "deathcamp"
>administration, is -cheaper- then just shooting them dead on the spot?
>what total bullshit
Well done again.
>mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
># Either you are a fraud with the PhD claim or you know
># the even basic arithmetic is contrary to your claims.
>#
># There is nothing in between.
>#
># You are a fraud.
>You are a little zero, hardly educated, who has achieved
>nothing in his life and had to retire at the age of 46,
>for reasons which are quite obvious for everyone
>following your articles here.
>You are a failure, a loser, a frustrated, vulgar, stupid
>51-year-old punk who can only find common language with
>teenage Nazi punks, who are your natural colleagues.
>You have proved that you don't know anything about
>chemistry, history, diesel engines, arithmetic...
>Your feelings of inferiority and frustration drive
>you crazy; that's why the fact that I have a Ph.D - which
>I never made a lot of mention of - is a source of
>endless anger for you.
>Face it pal, you're a zero. A nothing. A failure. And
>it's only going to grow worse as you get older.
And, as noted, you are incapable of basic arithmetic and have never
posted any. And the only alternative is that you know the math is
against your gassing fantasies and refuse to post because of that.
If you are what you claim to be, then the latter is true.
>-Danny Keren.
>--
>In Message-ID: <4n0ik8$1...@dfw-ixnews10.ix.netcom.com>, Matt Giwer
>suggested that documents about a "gas chamber" and "gassing cellar"
>in the Birkenau crematoriums didn't count, as they were really due
>to "a morbid sense of humor" of the SS men who authored the documents.
McVay, Ken (KM214)
1B Systems Management Limited
5-1601 Bowen Road
Nanaimo, British Columbia V9S 1G7
CA
Record last updated on 02-Apr-96.
Please be advised that this whois server only contains DOD
Information.
All INTERNET Domain, IP Network Number, and ASN records are kept in
the Internet Registry, RS.INTERNIC.NET.
Omigod! I think Dr. Keren had better pack it in.
:> The reference to "two million children" is not supported by any
:>of the hundreds of photographs of Auschwitz. Nor is it supported by
:>the Holocaust's own testimonies. Not even to a tiny degree.
Gee, that's funny. I just took a look at a couple of Auschwitz ramp pictures
and lo and behold, there were children in the photo.
In what way is any figure related to children not supported by "any of the
hundreds of photographs of Auschwitz"? Would you be happy if there were 2
million separate photographs of children at Auschwitz? The fact is that the
children rarely lasted long enough to be photographed.
--
Gord McFee
I'll write no line before its time
# You're saying that shipping prisoners across the European
# continent by train,
You must have serious reading problems. It was explained to
you, a few times, that the large majority of the victims
were Polish and Soviet Jews, who were not transported over
large distances.
A very simple reason for not shooting, say, the Greek and
French Jews right there where they lived, was because
the Nazis tried to keep the operation secret. When the
Jews found out that they were being sent to their death,
they rebelled (as in Warsaw). Shooting huge numbers of
Jews in the streets of Paris would have alerted the
others of the Nazis' plans.
# during a war, to tag them, house them, and then gas them,
Can't you read? It was explained to you that those gassed
upon arrival - the very large majority - were not tagged
nor housed, but killed immediately.
-Danny Keren.
# And, as noted, you are incapable of basic arithmetic
# and have never posted any.
I gave my figure: 4 Kg of Zyklon-B, in a 500 m^3 gas
chamber, will kill the victims within minutes.
Post your figure.
# Are you aware of any other insecticide at the time?
#
# Learn some history. That was the age of flypaper. You do
# know that that is, do you not?
You were told, many times, that the inventory list
mentions:
1) A gas-tight door for cellar I, none for cellar II.
2) 14 shower-heads for cellar I, none for cellar II.
Can you explain why one "morgue" required a gas-tight
door, and the other didn't?
Can you explain why one "morgue" required shower-heads,
and the other didn't?
Any chance you'll even reply to this question, oh 163-IQ'ed?
[...]
# Well done again.
Giwer has a friend. Of course, it's a little Nazi who says
that he wishes the Holocaust *did* take place, and who
makes claims about as idiotic as Giwer's; for instance,
that using HCN in the gas chambers would have "killed
the German soldiers themselves" - this, while (as even
"revisonists" admit) HCN was indeed used in the chambers,
as the cyanide compounds on their walls prove.
For other examples, see replies to "kurtstele". Personally,
I suspect it's a Giwer alias; he sounds too much like him,
and the probability of nature making two mistakes like
this is not too high.
>dke...@world.std.com (Daniel Keren) wrote:
>>t...@pacificnet.net (tom moran) writes:
>>
>># Two million of six million is one third.
>>#
>># The reference to "two million children" is not supported
>># by any of the hundreds of photographs of Auschwitz. Nor is
>># it supported by the Holocaust's own testimonies.
>>
>>What do you mean by "nor is it supported by the Holocaust's
>>own testimonies"? Do you mean that witnesses don't mention
>>that many children were murdered? But they do say this.
>>
>>One indication to the percentage of children among the
>>victims is the report by SS-Standartenfuehrer Jager about
>>the numbers of Jews murdered by his unit (Einsatzkommando 3),
>>in Lithuania, during July-November 1941. The report gives
>>a very accurate breakdown, by dates, and also classifies
>>the victims into Jewish men, women, and children.
>>
>>Some typical entries:
>>
>>[Source: 'The Good Old Days' - E. Klee, W. Dressen, V. Riess, The
>> Free Press, NY, 1988, p. 46-58].
>>
>>The Commander of
>>the security police and
>>the SD
>>Einsatzkommando 3 Kauen [Kaunas], 1 December 1941
>>
>>--------------------------
>>|Secret Reich Business! | 5 copies
>>-------------------------- 4th copy
>>
>> Complete list of executions carried out in the EK 3 area
>> up to 1 December 1941
>>
>>[...]
>>[...]
>>
>><end quote>
>>
>>Do the calculation. I can post the complete report.
>>
>>
>>-Danny Keren.
>>
> Here's Keren with one of his eyewitness testimony documents.
>Notice I say "one". Do I know if it's a forgery? Do I know if the
>Germans were reporting on the citizens rage against the Jews? Keren
>offers one, uncertainty. Photographs are far more certain. Hundreds of
>photographs of camps interees that don't support the claim that 1/3 of
>the Holocaust victims could be children.
> All the photographs of the arrival and "selection" of people to
>Auschwitz, all those in the camp should show this ratio. Yet they
>don't. You better come up with something more than one little
>uncertain document.
What is also interesting is the missing demographics showing the 0-17
years of age fraction of the population. 1/3 is something you would
expect to find in third world countries. 1/4 or less is what you
expect to find in industrialized countries.
But then, Jews are always special and anything found about the
Holocaust is always true and over rides any comparison to normal
reality.
>> mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
>> You are a fraud.
> This comes from a person who claims that cynanide gas should be used
>in morgues to kill flies.
Are you saying that flies and maggots are immune?
Have you found something saying that it only works on lice?
What would you suggest? SS guards with fly swatters?
Are you aware of any other insecticide at the time?
Learn some history. That was the age of flypaper. You do know that
# They were even dumb enough to ship them all the way from
# France just to gas them in Poland. Or would not the French
# "stand for it"?
I responded to this in my reply to "kurtstele".
# Not in the Ukraine, not run by Pol Pot.
What about the gulags? How many people were shipped
there by trains? The Soviets could do it, and the
Nazis couldn't?
## Ok, let's here it. What gas do you think they should
## have used?
# CO2, free from breathing. If you want it faster, dump
# some burning coke down your "induction columns." It is
# not as though it is all that hard to do it cheaper.
Too slow.
Funny thing is the following. Suppose the Nazis would have
killed people that way. Then, as we know well, the
"revisionists" would be saying "why kill people with
such slow, idiotic, primitive methods, when you have
numerous quantities of Zyklon-B around, which can do
the job within minutes, and is very cheap?".
## The same gas, HCN, is used to execute people in US
## prisons. A natural choice.
# But something as foolish as ZB is not used and would be
# quite a riduculous way to go about it.
Look, you sorry imbecile. It makes no difference. It releases
the same gas - HCN - which is used to kill people in gas
chambers in US prisons.
Can't you miserable drecks understand that it doesn't
matter what the source of the gas is? That it will kill
people nontheless?
## There are many more such documents.
# Two, neither clear, amidst all the rest with no
# such indication.
This, from someone who claimed Belsen camp was in Poland.
I told you already, you don't know anything.
There are many more than two documents proving an
extermination plan.
# You folks started "discovering" the
# morgues were really gas chambers about four years ago.
You demonstrate your insanity once again. The location
of the Birkenau gas chambers was well-known since
the liberation.
# You home can function as a gas chamber. Prove it is not.
There are no witnesses who say it functioned as a gas chamber.
There are no cyanide compounds on the walls.
There are no documents which prove it was used as a gas
chamber.
Stop being such a fool.
-Danny Keren.
MG> And, as noted, you are incapable of basic arithmetic and have
MG> never posted any. And the only alternative is that you know the
MG> math is against your gassing fantasies and refuse to post
MG> because of that.
A presumption based on your fantasies, Matt.
The gassing is fact.
++GMAIL 1.3++ We keep on laughing at you Matt.
--
|Fidonet: Alec Grynspan 1:2424/13
|Internet: al...@gryn.org
MG> The rock is shipping them to gas them to save bullets.
MG> The hard place is not gassing them in place.
MG> You are invited to invent a way out of the middle.
The answer is simple.
You have been 100% wrong to date.
You have stated that it makes no sense.
Therefore - it's the optimal solution.
GET REAL, MATT!
Most of the victims lived in Eastern Europe.
The heaviest level of antipathy against Jews was in Eastern Europe.
Moving the victims out of the country where there might be
resistance let people fool themselves that it really was
"resettlement".
The building of chambers elsewhere was not as efficient, given the
number of victims and their location.
The use of guns required hardened troops who would quickly be
useless for anything else - as had already happened.
Your one bullet per victim calculation was nonsense. They were using
several, due to the use of machine guns. Cost was significantly
higher than you've calculated.
The extermination camps were adjoining slave labour camps. Kill off
the unfit immediately and work the rest to death - a simple formula.
The amount of graft that could be involved was far higher with the
use of special constructs and laundering methods than simple
shooting or localised gas chambers.
Finally, there doesn't have to be a logical reason. The Nazi
mentality was monomaniacal and saw efficiencies that no one else
would consider an efficiency.
With the amount of physical evidence that you have already admitted
to knowing exists, the use of such "IT MAKES NO SENSE!! IT MAKES NO
SENSE!!" because it doesn't match your view of reality is childish.
GROW UP, MATT!
++GMAIL 1.3++ Have you had a CAT scan lately? You may need it!!
>mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
># Therefore they transported people from France and Greece
># and Italy to gas them in Poland.
>A relatively small number; most victims were Poles,
>or Soviet Jews murdered close to where they lived.
75,000 from france is relatively small and for no purpose whatsover.
># Stupid shit.
>You don't have to use such words just because this is
>what you learned at home.
You re the math wizard who has never posted a calculation.
># Today military ball 9mm rounds cost 11 cents each. For
># 6 million dead from ALL causes that is $660,000 dollars.
>Bullets are necessary items during the war. Why waste
>them if you can kill the people with Zyklon?
Why waste the cost of transportation when those same trains can be
used to transport war materiel to the front? Wasting the trains on
people just to kill them in Poland was contrary to the war effort,
despite the cost.
And then, as any room will do for killing people, why not use a room
in France? Remember the "farmstead" that was first used at Auschwitz
for gassing? Are you saying that France, Italy and Greece had no
suitable "farmsteads"?
If you insist upon gas instead of bullets, there is still not need to
ship anyone any place. Any old farmstead will do. Or do you disagree
with the Auschwitz FAQ that Nizkor carries? If so, what is your
disagreement with it in this regard?
The rock is shipping them to gas them to save bullets.
The hard place is not gassing them in place.
You are invited to invent a way out of the middle.
># Not by any rational calculation but let me see your
># calculations for the amount needed to kill in 10-15 minutes.
>For the largest gas chambers? 4 Kg would definitely
>be enough. What is your figure?
I am interested in seeing your calculations. But we both know you
have done none. So why do you make it up?
># The gas chambers were discovered in the last five years.
>This is such an insane and stupid comment that there's
>no use reading this anymore. They were found immediately
>after the war. You're simply out of your mind.
Quite nonsensical. Not one document known in the 1940s refers to
them. Nothing Hoess or Gerstein says mentions them. Nothing at the
IMT mentions them.
>You've been a bad boy, and the .sig returns.
And I respond with a secret identity.
>-Danny Keren.
>--
>In Message-ID: <4n0ik8$1...@dfw-ixnews10.ix.netcom.com>, Matt Giwer
>suggested that documents about a "gas chamber" and "gassing cellar"
>in the Birkenau crematoriums didn't count, as they were really due
>to "a morbid sense of humor" of the SS men who authored the documents.
>On 15 Aug 1996, Kurt Stele wrote:
>> schw...@infinet.com wrote:
>>
>> >Are you calling this former SS man [Franz Suchomel, as filmed in
>Claude Lanzmann's _Shoah_] a liar?
>>
>> No, probably just another one of the Allied's tortured German captives.
>>
>> >If so, please provide your evidence that he is lying.
>>
>> Given the brutality which many German officers either were subjected to or
>> threatened with under Allied custody pending the Nuremberg trial
>[snip]
>> why don't you prove he -wasn't- lying?
>Please read the book or rent the film _Shoah_. You will see that
>Suchomel is being interviewed by Claude Lanzmann, the director of the
>film, and is speaking of his own free will, in the early 1980s. Suchomel
>spoke to Lanzmann under one condition: that Lanzmann would not reveal his
>identity. Other than breaking that promise (Lanzmann shows Suchomel's
>face and identifies him by name), the interviews involved no trickery:
>Lanzmann did not torture Suchomel, Suchomel was not being prosecuted, and
>no courts were involved. All the film shows is a former Nazi guard,
>speaking freely because he thinks he will be anonymous, telling of what he
>did during the war.
>Do you still want to call him a liar?
How much was he paid for the interview?
Moran and Giwer, ask many stupid questions, and make many silly
statements, but they never, ever offer anything tangable in the way of
proof. Arguing with either one of these turkeys, is like arguing with
a lamp post. The main difference being the lamp post might shed some
light. Not these turkeys.
Chuck
[Giwer's invasion of another's privacy snipped]
Gee Matty poo, it's nice to know that, when in a drunken rage, can
repeat a post you have made several times in the past. But now prove that you
can explain some of your past lie. For example, why don't we start with your
statement that there were convictions of Germans at Nuremberg for massacring
Polish soldiers at Katyn Woods and that several defendants were hung for that
crime.
--YFE
>kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele) writes:
># You're saying that shipping prisoners across the European
># continent by train,
>You must have serious reading problems. It was explained to
>you, a few times, that the large majority of the victims
>were Polish and Soviet Jews, who were not transported over
>large distances.
>A very simple reason for not shooting, say, the Greek and
>French Jews right there where they lived, was because
>the Nazis tried to keep the operation secret. When the
>Jews found out that they were being sent to their death,
>they rebelled (as in Warsaw). Shooting huge numbers of
>Jews in the streets of Paris would have alerted the
>others of the Nazis' plans.
After the Polish jews -did- find out about the "secret extermination plan"
why did the nazis -continue- to send them to the camps anyway? If
according to Keren the reason for inconveniently locating the camps
hundreds of miles away was "to keep the extermination plan a secret" then
why would there be any need to continue transporting them to the camps
just to be killed there instead of nearby at no expense, since the jews in
Poland already "found out" about the "secret extermination plan"?
If the Germans -really- wanted to exterminate the jews then the Germans
would not concoct some ludicrous and costly inter-continental train
transportation scheme just to keep it a secret for fear of a jewish
-armed- rebellion -- that's actually a laughable thought. Why would the
Germans give two shits if the jews or any other group in occupied
territory for that matter opposed the Reich's policies? The Nazis ruled
Europe with an iron fist. They was no need for the nazis to fear a
reprisal from "armed jews."
You'll have to come up with a better attempt then that to explain why an
army purportedly dedicated to wiping out jews instead transports them
across hell's half acre in trains using valuable resources, and then tags
them, and then feeds them, paying the costs of upkeep and camp maintenance
-- instead of just shooting them dead.
If the Nazis wanted jews dead they would have simply executed the jews
with bullets, not gas -- the way the nazis executed everyone else.
If the nazis wanted to exterminate jews in Paris secretly, the nazis could
have taken them -outside- of Paris, lined them up, and shot them dead.
If the nazis -really- wanted to exterminate jews, they certainly didn't
-need- to transport jews hundreds of miles in -fear- of an uprising from
them.
Obviously the reasons for the camps being located so far away was not
Keren's cheesy explanation that the nazis were "scared" the jews would
find out about the "secret extermination plan" and stage an armed revolt
against the Reich.
How would rounding up the jews for train transportation be any less of
"secret" then rounding up the jews for execution -2- miles away instead?
Either way the prisoners would have no idea where they were going.
That's almost as dumb as the explanation Keren gave before that the nazis
used "gas chambers" located hundres of miles away instead of using a
firing squad on site because the nazis were scared of clergy disapproval.
># during a war, to tag them, house them, and then gas them,
>Can't you read? It was explained to you that those gassed
>upon arrival - the very large majority - were not tagged
>nor housed, but killed immediately.
and it was explained to you that those so-called "gas chambers" are
nothing more than post-WWII jewish hoaxes. It was impossible for those
buildings as they were designed and according to their structure for them
to operate as functional gas chambers.
Kurt Stele
# After the Polish jews -did- find out about the "secret
# extermination plan" why did the nazis -continue- to send
# them to the camps anyway?
This was near the end; by the time the rebellion in Warsaw
Ghetto broke out, most of Poland's Jews were already dead.
# If the Germans -really- wanted to exterminate the jews then
# the Germans would not concoct some ludicrous and costly
# inter-continental train transportation scheme just to keep
# it a secret for fear of a jewish -armed- rebellion -- that's
# actually a laughable thought.
Not at all. The Warsaw Ghetto rebellion was a major problem
for the Nazis. It took them a long time to crush it, and
they had to use large military resources, which had to be
diverted from the front - artillery, etc. But then again,
this is the first time you've heard about the rebellion,
right?
Moreover, by promising the Jews they're going to be "resettled",
the Nazis reduced the number of Jews who tried to escape
the deportation plan.
Possibly, the major fallacy of your idiotic theory is the
fact that the Jews *were* transported. No one denies that;
not even the craziest "revisionist". So, all these trains
*were* used to deport the Jews of France, Holland, Greece,
Hungary. What your "revisionist" fuehrers say is exactly
what the Nazis told the Jews: that they're being sent to
the Ukraine or deeper into the USSR. But that, mein kliene
dummkopf, would result in the Nazis wasting *even more*
resources than deporting the Jews to the death camps, which
were closer to France, Greece, Holland, Hungary; right?
# If the nazis -really- wanted to exterminate jews, they
# certainly didn't -need- to transport jews hundreds of miles
# in -fear- of an uprising from them.
Sorry, nazi-boy. They *did* transport them. Fact. Even
your fuehrers admit this.
# and it was explained to you that those so-called "gas
# chambers" are nothing more than post-WWII jewish hoaxes. It
# was impossible for those buildings as they were designed and
# according to their structure for them to operate as functional
# gas chambers.
And it was explained to you, you tiresome, stupid nazi-boy,
that you have to *prove* that it was impossible to use
them as gas chambers. You simply keep repeating this,
without offering any proof or reason whatsoever.
It was possible to use HCN gas in these chambers, and
the best proof for this is the fact that there are still
cyanide compounds on their walls. Even your fuehrers
admit this. They admit HCN gas was used in these chambers.
Why you just give up and admit you're wrong? you'll still
be "White", which is, according to your articles, of crucial
importance to you.
-Danny Keren.
>mvan...@rbi.com (Mark Van Alstine) wrote:
>
>>In article <Dw90y...@world.std.com>, dke...@world.std.com (Daniel
>Keren)
>>wrote:
>
>>> kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele)wrote:
>>>
>>> # Now the exterminations [of Stalin and Pol Pot], in contrast to the
>"holocaust,
>>> # made complete, plausible sense, i.e., they were done by the
>>> # obvious and efficient means of killing -- by bullet
>>> # and/or starvation.
>>>
>>> The Nazis starved, shot, or overworked to death half
>>> of the victims. The rest were killed in gas chambers.
>>>
>>> All your empty rhetoric can't hide the fact that killing
>>> with poison gas was very cheap, very efficient, and
>>> saved ammunition.
>
>>Indeed. On average 0.02 Reichmarks (1992: $.08) per victim. A rifle
>>cartridge cost more than that.
>
>>Mark
>
>Care to show your calculations in achieving $.08?
>
>Why don't you do your calculations over again, this time factoring in, as
>you should have done before, the costs of -everything else- involved in
>"gassing" prisoners under the circumstances.
>
>You're saying that shipping prisoners across the European continent by
>train, during a war, to tag them, house them, and then gas them, using up
>valuable resources in energy, manpower, and cost of upkeep and "deathcamp"
>administration, is -cheaper- then just shooting them dead on the spot?
>
Clue #1: The state didn't pay for it. As Hilberg shows in his
_Destruction of the European Jews_ the funding for the one way tickets
was paid for by the Jews themselves. Confiscated property and moneys
made it possible to take the state off the hook.
They did try shooting them dead, but the reports from those in the
field showed that the shooters were stressed out about it. They had to
come up with a different way. Shooting was taking a psychological
price out of the soldiers and local police forces assigned to do the
shootings. I suggest you read the histories by Christopher Browning.
_Ordinary Men_ comes to mind.
>what total bullshit
Yes, you are full of this substance. You obviously have done very
little research into the available records that explain how it was all
done and paid for.
Mike Curtis E-mail mcu...@inetport.com
For More Information try The Nizkor Project
Nizkor (USA) An Electronic Holocaust Educational Resource
Over 100Megs of data: http://www.almanac.bc.ca/cgi-bin/ftp.pl?
Europe: ftp://nizkor.iam.uni-bonn.de/pub/nizkor/
Nizkor Web: http://www.almanac.bc.ca/ (Under construction - permanently!)
> > This comes from a person who claims that cynanide gas should be used
> >in morgues to kill flies.
> Are you saying that flies and maggots are immune?
No I am saying the obvious. The only way that it would be effective
would be if it was used continually. This would make it impossible for the room to be
used as morgue unless you want the morgue attendents to be working in clouds of
cynanide gas.
> Have you found something saying that it only works on lice?
I have found nothing that suggests that it should be used continually in an
environment in which people work.
> What would you suggest? SS guards with fly swatters?
How about flypaper?
> Are you aware of any other insecticide at the time?
Flypaper works very well.
> Learn some history.
This from a man who believes that Washington's encampment at Valley
Forge did not occur during the American Revolution.
> That was the age of flypaper. You do know that
> that is, do you not?
Of course. that would be one practical solution. A far better one -- both
cheaper and more practical -- than having cynanide gas continuously circulating
around the room. Do you know of a single morgue in the U.S. that used your
solution?
--YFE
> What is also interesting is the missing demographics showing the 0-17
> years of age fraction of the population. 1/3 is something you would
> expect to find in third world countries. 1/4 or less is what you
> expect to find in industrialized countries.
While one cannot expect a reasonable degree of rationality from Matty
poo -- a man who once announced that distributions of 3-0 and 283-5 were within
the limits of a normal demographic distribution -- one can expect that he can at least
understand what demography is. The figures referred to are not demography --
which concerns the study of the characteristics of populations. There is no claim
the vicitms of nazi murders followed demographic patterns. What the figures refer to
is the age distribution of the murder victims. The question is, therefore, are there
factors which would explain a higher rate of death overall in children. There is
some overlap and this type of study might be done by demographers but it is more
likely that would be in the sphere of epidemiology.
It would help, Matty poo, if you knew which science you were insulting
with your ignorance.
--YFE
>mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
># They were even dumb enough to ship them all the way from
># France just to gas them in Poland. Or would not the French
># "stand for it"?
>I responded to this in my reply to "kurtstele".
You did not. Please repost your claim.
># Not in the Ukraine, not run by Pol Pot.
>What about the gulags? How many people were shipped
>there by trains? The Soviets could do it, and the
>Nazis couldn't?
The Soviets documented every one of them and also recorded the death
of every one of them and there is no disagreement in the numbers. If
you do not invent gassing the Nazi numbers agree with the registered.
>## Ok, let's here it. What gas do you think they should
>## have used?
># CO2, free from breathing. If you want it faster, dump
># some burning coke down your "induction columns." It is
># not as though it is all that hard to do it cheaper.
>Too slow.
As you know the "cremation" was the bottleneck. There was no need for
speed when cremation could not keep up.
>Funny thing is the following. Suppose the Nazis would have
>killed people that way. Then, as we know well, the
>"revisionists" would be saying "why kill people with
>such slow, idiotic, primitive methods, when you have
>numerous quantities of Zyklon-B around, which can do
>the job within minutes, and is very cheap?".
So you presume they could tell the future? How strange.
>## The same gas, HCN, is used to execute people in US
>## prisons. A natural choice.
># But something as foolish as ZB is not used and would be
># quite a riduculous way to go about it.
>Look, you sorry imbecile. It makes no difference. It releases
>the same gas - HCN - which is used to kill people in gas
>chambers in US prisons.
Not in the same time frame as you well know a a mathematician even
though your REFUSE to post any calculations.
>Can't you miserable drecks understand that it doesn't
>matter what the source of the gas is? That it will kill
>people nontheless?
NOT as described by your favorite witnesses as you well know.
>## There are many more such documents.
># Two, neither clear, amidst all the rest with no
># such indication.
>This, from someone who claimed Belsen camp was in Poland.
>I told you already, you don't know anything.
>There are many more than two documents proving an
>extermination plan.
There are still only two.
># You folks started "discovering" the
># morgues were really gas chambers about four years ago.
>You demonstrate your insanity once again. The location
>of the Birkenau gas chambers was well-known since
>the liberation.
You are requested to post that in explicite form from any or all of
the IMT records. Please show explicitely that they were described in
testimony.
But you know that we have been over this and NOT ONE post desecribed
the LKs in any manner of interest. You know it but you post to the
contrary, knowingly doing so.
># You home can function as a gas chamber. Prove it is not.
>There are no witnesses who say it functioned as a gas chamber.
What do witnesses matter? Have you never heard of the McMartain Day
Care Center trial?
>There are no cyanide compounds on the walls.
What does that matter? And how do you know, oh one data point lover?
>There are no documents which prove it was used as a gas
>chamber.
It meets the criteria.
>Stop being such a fool.
Learn some arithmetic you lying bastard.
>kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele) wrote:
And you really believe that the railraods were the only onew who stood
up to the Nazis and demanded Reichmarks in payment else they would not
do as ordered.
You have a very strange view of a Fuehrerstadt.
>They did try shooting them dead, but the reports from those in the
>field showed that the shooters were stressed out about it. They had to
>come up with a different way. Shooting was taking a psychological
>price out of the soldiers and local police forces assigned to do the
>shootings. I suggest you read the histories by Christopher Browning.
>_Ordinary Men_ comes to mind.
Excuse me but it would take only one pathological type to operate the
machinegun after they were lined up.
But to follow your line of reasoning, on Jewish Sonderkommandos could
stomach gassing thousands at a time.
Is this another manner in which Jews are superior to Germans even if
they are German?
>> mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
> [Giwer's invasion of another's privacy snipped]
McVay, Ken (KM214)
1B Systems Management Limited
5-1601 Bowen Road
Nanaimo, British Columbia V9S 1G7
CA
Record last updated on 02-Apr-96.
Please be advised that this whois server only contains DOD
Information.
All INTERNET Domain, IP Network Number, and ASN records are kept in
the Internet Registry, RS.INTERNIC.NET.
> Gee Matty poo, it's nice to know that, when in a drunken rage, can
>repeat a post you have made several times in the past. But now prove that you
>can explain some of your past lie. For example, why don't we start with your
>statement that there were convictions of Germans at Nuremberg for massacring
>Polish soldiers at Katyn Woods and that several defendants were hung for that
>crime.
> --YFE
McVay, Ken (KM214)
>> mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
> [Giwer's invasion of another's privacy snipped]
McVay, Ken (KM214)
1B Systems Management Limited
5-1601 Bowen Road
Nanaimo, British Columbia V9S 1G7
CA
Record last updated on 02-Apr-96.
Please be advised that this whois server only contains DOD
Information.
All INTERNET Domain, IP Network Number, and ASN records are kept in
the Internet Registry, RS.INTERNIC.NET.
=====
This is information he gave freely in full knowledge that it would be
pubic information else he is an ignorant fool.
>> mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
> [Giwer's invasion of another's privacy snipped]
McVay, Ken (KM214)
1B Systems Management Limited
5-1601 Bowen Road
Nanaimo, British Columbia V9S 1G7
CA
Record last updated on 02-Apr-96.
Please be advised that this whois server only contains DOD
Information.
All INTERNET Domain, IP Network Number, and ASN records are kept in
the Internet Registry, RS.INTERNIC.NET.
> Gee Matty poo, it's nice to know that, when in a drunken rage, can
>repeat a post you have made several times in the past. But now prove that you
>can explain some of your past lie. For example, why don't we start with your
>statement that there were convictions of Germans at Nuremberg for massacring
>Polish soldiers at Katyn Woods and that several defendants were hung for that
>crime.
> --YFE
> and it was explained to you that those so-called "gas chambers" are
> nothing more than post-WWII jewish hoaxes. It was impossible for those
> buildings as they were designed and according to their structure for them
> to operate as functional gas chambers.
Kurt:
Is Suchomel lying?
---BEGIN QUOTE---
CL: What was Treblinka like then?
FS: It was operating at full capacity.
CL: Full capacity?
FS: Full capacity! The Warsaw ghetto was being emptied then. Three trains
arrived in two days, each with three, four, five thousand people aboard,
all from Warsaw. But at the same time, other trains came in from Kielce
and other places. So three trains arrived, and since the offensive against
Stalingrad was in full swing, the trainloads of Jews were left on a
station siding. What's more, the cars were French, made of steel. So that
while five thousand Jews arrived in Treblinka, three thousand were dead in
the cars. They had slashed their wrists, or just died. The ones we
unloaded were half dead and half mad. In the other trains from Kielce and
elsewhere, at least half were dead. We stacked them here, here, here, and
here. Thousands of people piled one on top of another on the ramp. Stacked
like wood. In addition, other Jews, still alive, waited there for two
days: the small gas chambers could not handle the load. They functioned
day and night in that period.
---END QUOTE---
_Shoah, An Oral History of the Holocaust_, Claude Lanzmann
Complete Text of the Film
Pantheon Books, NY
1985
ISBN 0-394-55142-7
Sara
--
"It's always nice to see a prejudice overruled by a deeper prejudice."
John Sayles, _Lone Star_
# First you agreed the LK was one large room. You also
# agreed that I and II were identical.
Oh, God almighty. Have mercy on us. He claims to have
an IQ of 163, but he still can't figure this out, after
posting here for a year or so.
Look:
Kremas II & III each had two large underground cellars.
The ones in Krema II are referred to as cellars I & II
of Krema II.
The ones in Krema III are referred to as cellars I & II
of Krema III.
But cellars I & II were *not* identical. Cellar I was the gas
chamber, which is why the inventory list shows it had a gas-tight
door and shower-heads; II was the so-called "undressing room",
which is why it didn't have a gas-tight door and shower-heads.
Ok? Is it *finally* clear?
# You folks NEVER suggested there were showerheads in any
# of them.
Which means "I can't recall seeing that on alt.revisionism".
It's a well-known fact. It is mentioned in the testimonies.
They are mentioned in the inventory list. It's on the web.
# You will never explain how ZB got through showerheads.
It didn't. In these Kremas, the only goal of the shower-heads
was to fool the victims. The Zyklon was inserted via the
wiremesh devices.
-Danny Keren.
----
For a summary of the "revisionist" position, look at what
Nazi propagandist and "revisionist", Kurt Stele, wrote:
From: kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele)
Message-Id: <4ut4ht$p...@newsbf02.news.aol.com>
# The Holocaust is a funny thing..
# When you hear about it, you wish it never happened..
# When you discover it's a hoax ya kind of wish it did!
# Kurt Stele
## I responded to this in my reply to "kurtstele".
# You did not. Please repost your claim.
Once again: the claim "why would they have used up
resources in transporting the Jews" is void, because
they *did* transport them. "Revisionists" claim they
were transported deep into the USSR, which would
have wasted *more* resources than transporting them
to the death camps, which were closer.
# Not in the same time frame as you well know a a
# mathematician even though your REFUSE to post any
# calculations.
My figure for the amount of Zyklon-B in a 500 m^3 room,
enough to cause swift death (15 minutes or so), is
4 Kg. Post your figure.
## There are many more than two documents proving an
## extermination plan.
# There are still only two.
There are many more. Many such documents are posted on
this newsgroup. Try counting with *all* your fingers. I
know it's difficult for you, but try.
# Learn some arithmetic you lying bastard.
I'm sorry that you're a zero, a nothing, a miserable
failure, and an imbecile. But it ain't my fault. So don't
take it out on me, please.
>In article <4v81ab$4...@newsbf02.news.aol.com>, kurt...@aol.com (Kurt
>Stele) wrote:
>> and it was explained to you that those so-called "gas chambers" are
>> nothing more than post-WWII jewish hoaxes. It was impossible for those
>> buildings as they were designed and according to their structure for
them
>> to operate as functional gas chambers.
>Kurt:
>
>Is Suchomel lying?
yes. You can pay anyone to say anything, especially given jewish
money-power
Kurt Stele
>Finally, there doesn't have to be a logical reason.
It's not that there has to be a logical reason.
It's that there has to be an -illogical- reason.
The Holocaust positively -requires- that the nazis be illogical, goofy,
and stupid.
Otherwise their theory can't even get off the ground
>The Nazi mentality was monomaniacal and saw efficiencies that no one else
>would consider an efficiency.
Perhaps the truth is really the reverse: the -jew holohugger- is
monomaniacal in his paranoic and implacable -hatred- of nazis, which is
why the holohugger clings to fantasies about "disguised shower heads" and
"death by Raid."
But I think the Holohoax will eventually be exposed at large.
Despite this holohugger nonsense.
Kurt Stele
[Giwer's post listing Ken McVay's address TWICE deleted]
What is the purpose of this, Mr. Giwer?
Dsrs
> schw...@infinet.com wrote:
>
> >Kurt:
> >
> >Is Suchomel lying?
>
> yes. You can pay anyone to say anything, especially given jewish
> money-power
And your proof that Franz Suchomel was paid to lie is...?
Oh, right, I forgot. Because You Say So.
----------------------
Marty Kelley (mke...@U.Arizona.EDU) "When we visit each other,
we always check out what's on our friends' bookshelves. It's
the academic equivalent of dogs sniffing each other's butts"
--J. Champagne
>mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
># Are you aware of any other insecticide at the time?
>#
># Learn some history. That was the age of flypaper. You do
># know that that is, do you not?
>You were told, many times, that the inventory list
>mentions:
>1) A gas-tight door for cellar I, none for cellar II.
>2) 14 shower-heads for cellar I, none for cellar II.
>Can you explain why one "morgue" required a gas-tight
>door, and the other didn't?
>Can you explain why one "morgue" required shower-heads,
>and the other didn't?
>Any chance you'll even reply to this question, oh 163-IQ'ed?
Time travel does wonders for you folks.
First you agreed the LK was one large room. You also agreed that I
and II were identical.
You folks NEVER suggested there were showerheads in any of them.
Now you would attempt to divert the discussion with these claims.
And you will never post complete plans in support of your claim.
You will never explain how ZB got through showerheads.
You will never post an LK related claim of showerheads that has any
credibility. Even Spielberg made a joke of that one.
>--
>In Message-ID: <4n0ik8$1...@dfw-ixnews10.ix.netcom.com>, Matt Giwer
>suggested that documents about a "gas chamber" and "gassing cellar"
>in the Birkenau crematoriums didn't count, as they were really due
>to "a morbid sense of humor" of the SS men who authored the documents.
>> mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
>> On 17 Aug 1996 01:17:52 GMT, ya...@enter.net (Yale F. Edeiken) wrote:
>> > This comes from a person who claims that cynanide gas should be used
>> >in morgues to kill flies.
>
>> Are you saying that flies and maggots are immune?
> No I am saying the obvious. The only way that it would be effective
>would be if it was used continually. This would make it impossible for the room to be
>used as morgue unless you want the morgue attendents to be working in clouds of
>cynanide gas.
It would be equally impossible for Sonderkommandos to be working in a
half hour while eating and smoking without gas masks.
So what is your problem? As to continually, is not that what you are
claiming for gassing? If not. what is the difference?
>> Have you found something saying that it only works on lice?
> I have found nothing that suggests that it should be used continually in an
>environment in which people work.
Nor did I ask that question.
>> What would you suggest? SS guards with fly swatters?
> How about flypaper?
Does not attract maggots.
>> Are you aware of any other insecticide at the time?
> Flypaper works very well.
On non-flying maggots? What a fool!
>> That was the age of flypaper. You do know that
>> that is, do you not?
>
>Of course. that would be one practical solution. A far better one -- both
>cheaper and more practical -- than having cynanide gas continuously circulating
>around the room. Do you know of a single morgue in the U.S. that used your
>solution?
What in the hell are you talking about, consiglieri?
> kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele) wrote:
>
> >mvan...@rbi.com (Mark Van Alstine) wrote:
> >
> >>In article <Dw90y...@world.std.com>, dke...@world.std.com (Daniel
> >Keren)
> >>wrote:
> >
> >>> kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele)wrote:
> >>>
> >>> # Now the exterminations [of Stalin and Pol Pot], in contrast to the
> >"holocaust,
> >>> # made complete, plausible sense, i.e., they were done by the
> >>> # obvious and efficient means of killing -- by bullet
> >>> # and/or starvation.
> >>>
> >>> The Nazis starved, shot, or overworked to death half
> >>> of the victims. The rest were killed in gas chambers.
> >>>
> >>> All your empty rhetoric can't hide the fact that killing
> >>> with poison gas was very cheap, very efficient, and
> >>> saved ammunition.
> >
> >>Indeed. On average 0.02 Reichmarks (1992: $.08) per victim. A rifle
> >>cartridge cost more than that.
> >
> >>Mark
> >
> >Care to show your calculations in achieving $.08?
Care to show that your mouth is connected to your brain?
> >Why don't you do your calculations over again, this time factoring in, as
> >you should have done before, the costs of -everything else- involved in
> >"gassing" prisoners under the circumstances.
Why don't you pay attention? I origionally posted these caluclation in a
post to the threas "Re: Here We Go Again (Re: Evil Holocaust Revisionism)"
(Message ID: <mvanalst-100...@rbi144.rbi.com>).
You can find it in DejaNews at:
[snip]
Mark
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Gradually it was disclosed to me that the line separating good and evil passes
not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties--but
right through every human heart--and all human hearts."
-- Alexander Solzhenitsyn, "The Gulag Archipelago"
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> > No I am saying the obvious. The only way that it would be effective
> >would be if it was used continually. This would make it impossible for the room
to be
> >used as morgue unless you want the morgue attendents to be working in clouds
of
> >cynanide gas.
> It would be equally impossible for Sonderkommandos to be working in a
> half hour while eating and smoking without gas masks.
Which seems to be an invention of the revisionazis.
> So what is your problem? As to continually, is not that what you are
> claiming for gassing? If not. what is the difference?
It most certainly not what historians of the Holocaust claim.
> > I have found nothing that suggests that it should be used continually in
an
> >environment in which people work.
> Nor did I ask that question.
Then learn how to ask relevant questions.
> > How about flypaper?
>
> Does not attract maggots.
Simple law of nature, Matty poo: No flies, no maggots. Or do you believe
in spontaneous generation. Learn some science Matty poo.
> >> Are you aware of any other insecticide at the time?
>
> > Flypaper works very well.
>
> On non-flying maggots? What a fool!
No files, no maggots.
> >> That was the age of flypaper. You do know that
> >> that is, do you not?
> >
> >Of course. that would be one practical solution. A far better one -- both
> >cheaper and more practical -- than having cynanide gas continuously circulating
> >around the room. Do you know of a single morgue in the U.S. that used your
> >solution?
> What in the hell are you talking about, consiglieri?
Morgues in the United States. You do know what a morgue is, don't
you? To repeat, do you know of a single morgue that is regularly flooded with
cyanide gas to kill flies?
--YFE
>mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
># dke...@world.std.com (Daniel Keren) wrote:
>## I responded to this in my reply to "kurtstele".
># You did not. Please repost your claim.
>Once again: the claim "why would they have used up
>resources in transporting the Jews" is void, because
>they *did* transport them. "Revisionists" claim they
>were transported deep into the USSR, which would
>have wasted *more* resources than transporting them
>to the death camps, which were closer.
I said simply that you did not respond and invited you to repost your
claimed response. It appears you are conceding that I am correct.
>In article <4v81ab$4...@newsbf02.news.aol.com>, kurt...@aol.com (Kurt
>Stele) wrote:
>> and it was explained to you that those so-called "gas chambers" are
>> nothing more than post-WWII jewish hoaxes. It was impossible for those
>> buildings as they were designed and according to their structure for them
>> to operate as functional gas chambers.
>Kurt:
>
>Is Suchomel lying?
>
>---BEGIN QUOTE---
>
>CL: What was Treblinka like then?
>
>FS: It was operating at full capacity.
>
>CL: Full capacity?
>
>FS: Full capacity! The Warsaw ghetto was being emptied then. Three trains
>arrived in two days, each with three, four, five thousand people aboard,
>all from Warsaw. But at the same time, other trains came in from Kielce
>and other places. So three trains arrived, and since the offensive against
>Stalingrad was in full swing, the trainloads of Jews were left on a
>station siding. What's more, the cars were French, made of steel. So that
>while five thousand Jews arrived in Treblinka, three thousand were dead in
>the cars. They had slashed their wrists, or just died. The ones we
>unloaded were half dead and half mad. In the other trains from Kielce and
>elsewhere, at least half were dead. We stacked them here, here, here, and
>here. Thousands of people piled one on top of another on the ramp. Stacked
>like wood. In addition, other Jews, still alive, waited there for two
>days: the small gas chambers could not handle the load. They functioned
>day and night in that period.
>
>---END QUOTE---
>
>_Shoah, An Oral History of the Holocaust_, Claude Lanzmann
>Complete Text of the Film
>Pantheon Books, NY
>1985
>ISBN 0-394-55142-7
I will be keeping this one. I did not keep the proof that Jews were
loaded on board with weapons or that they were suicidal.
[deleted]
:>>The Nazis starved, shot, or overworked to death half
:>>of the victims. The rest were killed in gas chambers.
:>
:> It is amazing they were not bright enough to starve, shoot or overwork
:>the other half.
It is amazing that Giwer is too dense to understand that the Nazis were bright
enough to realize that they could kill more Jews, more quickly and less
expensively, by using gas than by shooting, while at the same time sparing the
murderers the pain of killing innocent men, women and children. Of course,
that level of "brightness" is beyond Giwer's reach. But we knew that.
[deleted]
--
Gord McFee
I'll write no line before its time
>dke...@world.std.com (Daniel Keren) wrote:
>
>>kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele) writes:
>
>># You're saying that shipping prisoners across the European
>># continent by train,
>
>>You must have serious reading problems. It was explained to
>>you, a few times, that the large majority of the victims
>>were Polish and Soviet Jews, who were not transported over
>>large distances.
>
>>A very simple reason for not shooting, say, the Greek and
>>French Jews right there where they lived, was because
>>the Nazis tried to keep the operation secret. When the
>>Jews found out that they were being sent to their death,
>>they rebelled (as in Warsaw). Shooting huge numbers of
>>Jews in the streets of Paris would have alerted the
>>others of the Nazis' plans.
>
>After the Polish jews -did- find out about the "secret extermination plan"
>why did the nazis -continue- to send them to the camps anyway?
Who would stop them from doing so?
> If
>according to Keren the reason for inconveniently locating the camps
>hundreds of miles away was
In reading _Anatomy_ there is a suggestion that Auschwitz was
convenient and central to the war effort. It was also central to where
most all the Jews were. They were inconvenient to other overrun
countries. I do suggest you study a bit of WW2 before you open your
keyboard.
>"to keep the extermination plan a secret" then
>why would there be any need to continue transporting them to the camps
>just to be killed there instead of nearby at no expense, since the jews in
>Poland already "found out" about the "secret extermination plan"?
>
Who was to stop them?
>If the Germans -really- wanted to exterminate the jews then the Germans
>would not concoct some ludicrous and costly inter-continental train
>transportation scheme just to keep it a secret for fear of a jewish
>-armed- rebellion -- that's actually a laughable thought.
Wh says so? Who saus it was vastly intercontinental? You?
> Why would the
>Germans give two shits if the jews or any other group in occupied
>territory for that matter opposed the Reich's policies?
Exactly. They did care about their own people. They did care about
support from their people. They already were forced to suspend the
euthanasia programs (in some cases it just went into hiding) because
of complaints from the Catholic Churches and families.
> The Nazis ruled
>Europe with an iron fist. They was no need for the nazis to fear a
>reprisal from "armed jews."
>
Most of them were in the ghettos and later camps, yes.
>You'll have to come up with a better attempt then that to explain why an
>army purportedly dedicated to wiping out jews instead transports them
The army wasn't necessarily dedicated to this prospect. But I see you
are busy building straw men and ludicrous history in you posts.
>across hell's half acre in trains using valuable resources, and then tags
>them,
They had to identify them as workers, yes. The others were shot or
gassed.
> and then feeds them,
I guess you missed the pictures from Belsen, Dachau, and Buchenwald.
> paying the costs of upkeep and camp maintenance
>-- instead of just shooting them dead.
>
We've been through this. You seem to not understand the problems human
being have in murdering other human beings up close.
>If the Nazis wanted jews dead they would have simply executed the jews
>with bullets, not gas -- the way the nazis executed everyone else.
>
Prove it. Show us the documentation.
>If the nazis wanted to exterminate jews in Paris secretly, the nazis could
>have taken them -outside- of Paris, lined them up, and shot them dead.
>
Source?
>If the nazis -really- wanted to exterminate jews, they certainly didn't
>-need- to transport jews hundreds of miles in -fear- of an uprising from
>them.
>
Source?
>Obviously the reasons for the camps being located so far away was not
>Keren's cheesy explanation that the nazis were "scared" the jews would
>find out about the "secret extermination plan" and stage an armed revolt
>against the Reich.
>
Source for your contentions?
>How would rounding up the jews for train transportation be any less of
>"secret" then rounding up the jews for execution -2- miles away instead?
>Either way the prisoners would have no idea where they were going.
>
Who says it was? Most everyoine really knew what was going on.
>That's almost as dumb as the explanation Keren gave before that the nazis
>used "gas chambers" located hundres of miles away instead of using a
>firing squad on site because the nazis were scared of clergy disapproval.
>
Source to support your contentions?
Heaven forbid!
I know what it is about you that galls Giwer, Dr. Keren. The only Dr. he is
used to talking to is the one that says "Matt, are remembering to take your
medication?".
That we're easily amused?
Bill
# Your creation is far from clear. Which of your two
# non-"cellars" are the aerial photos of?
If you were not mentally retarded, you would see them
by now. They are right there in the photo.
http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi?camps/auschwitz/images/Krema3.jpg
Did you really graduate from a university 30 years ago?
How come? I've never seen an idiot like you, in any
university I've ever been at.
# They are not underground, they are not cellars.
Yes they are, and their remains are still there today.
Look, there is not even a fellow "revisionist" of yours
who is making such idiotic claims as you are. Have you
totally flipped?
All the other nazi-boys agree that there were two such
large underground cellars. None of them is stupid and
crazy enough to deny it. Only you.
# (Do not forget your folks have already insisted that
# Leikenkellar means morgue not that it is a cellar, in
# english that is.)
It's "keller", you imbecile, and it means "cellar" in German,
as you could have guessed were you not a stupid monkey.
## It's a well-known fact. It is mentioned in the testimonies.
## They are mentioned in the inventory list. It's on the web.
# Only at the ones in Germany which were not gas chambers as
# you well know.
No, you damned senile ape. I'm talking about testimonies
and inventory list for Auschwitz.
http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi?camps/auschwitz/images/Invntry.jpg
There were gas chambers in Germany, BTW.
You're a senile piece of rotting dreck. It's amazing that there
was someone kind enough to employ a monkey like you till you
were 46 years old. You're the most stupid piece of trash I saw
in my life.
-Danny Keren.
[Nothing worth quoting]
You have failed to explain your claim that using cyanide
gas in the gas chambers would "kill the German soldiers
outside", this, while there are cyanide compounds on the
walls of the gas chambers, proving cyanide gas was indeed
used in them.
Still waiting for your answer. You claim to belong to a
"superior race". So why can't you answer a simple question?
You're just another little nazi monkey, right?
Where do all these creatures come from? Who forgot to
lock the zoo?
-Danny Keren.
why not.
The Holohoax seeks to its vindicate its explicit absurdities by relying on
the "trustworthy" foundation of -hearsay-.
But if it is all based on eyewitness testimony then anybody's word's as
good as the next.
The Holohoax is overwhelming premised on -eyewitness testimony- much of
which were gathered from biased or interested witnesses, or witnesses
under duress, and at a court of victors' vanquish.
Not even the sort of conditions which usually produces reliable testimony.
The -real- evidence for the holohoax is lacking -- other than the strange
and tortured inferences made by the holohuggers which again are not backed
by documentation or other forms of hard, real evidence.
The holohuggers' unusual conclusions are only based on the evidentiarily
slim reed of "eyewitness testimony" and that being from mainly interested
or coerced sources.
In fact the hard evidence and administrative documentation we -do- have
from the nazis contradicts that the nazis were deliberately trying to
"exterminate" the jews.
The holohuggers try to get around this by claiming "the nazis never wrote
it down"
yet the nazis wrote -everything else- down,
again we are "ordered" to accept an anomaly
which should instantly raise our suspicion
but what is most notable is that we are asked to premise our belief in
that anomaly
upon something so unreliable as eyewitness testimony -alone-
and even eyewitness testimony presented under conditions hostile to
producing reliable eyewitness testimony.
In other words, jewish Holohuggers want us to believe their witnesses
just because -they- say so
in spite of substantial evidentiary problems
and jewish holohuggers also continue censoring, harrassing, and
imprisoning
anyone who doubts the holocaust,
repressing the dissent of others
just like nazis.
Why don't YOU prove he -wasn't- paid off?
Kurt Stele
> mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
>
snip]
> # (Do not forget your folks have already insisted that
> # Leikenkellar means morgue not that it is a cellar, in
> # english that is.)
This from the boob who, in article
<4m736d$9...@dfw-ixnews2.ix.netcom.com>, claimed that Leichenkeller meant:
"Keller = cellar. Leichen = Leichen."
> It's "keller", you imbecile, and it means "cellar" in German,
> as you could have guessed were you not a stupid monkey.
Indeed. To taunt the Giwer-boob imbecile further: Leichen = corpse. Keller
= cellar. Ergo, Leichenkeller means, literally, "corpse cellar." That
translates to "morgue" in English.
This, of course, did not preclude the Nazis and construction crew from
refering to L.Keller 1 and/or 2 as cellar 1 and/or 2. Or C1 and/or C2.
But, of course, the Giwer-boob imbecile knew this (at one point) as he had
his face rubbed in it like a scolded puppy. Obviously, the Giwer-boob
imbecile's advancing senile dementia is taking its toll....
That we like easy (and stupid) targets to ridicule?
> You can pay anyone to say anything -- especially given the money-power of
> the jews.
>
Suchomel was not paid for his statements. If you have evidence to the
contrary, PROVE IT.
> Holocaust contains within it a tortured host of circumstantial and
> evidentiary contradictions, impossibilities, and absurdities (disguised
> showerheads, Zyklon B "the insecticide," crematoria as "ovens,"
> the-transport-tag-house-and-then-gas rather than just shoot 'em"
> allegation, the "any old barnhouse can be a gas chamber!" hypothesis, the
> everybody knew about the holocaust plan yet nobody ever wrote it down"
> theory, etc, etc, ad infinitum, ad nauseam)
>
> Yet all the holohoax has to back it up is eyewitness testimony -- and even
> that being from -interested- witnesses, and at an ex post facto court of
> "justice."
>
Suchomel was not in a "ex post facto court of 'justice.'"
If you think Suchomel is a liar, PROVE IT.
> Well, judging from the circumstances as a whole,
>
> that ain't shit.
And obviously, neither are you. You're just full of accusations and
unproven idiocies.
No Jew paid Suchomel. No one paid him to tell his story.
So where is your PROOF that he is a) paid and b) lying.
Sara
>I'm sorry that you're a zero, a nothing, a miserable
>failure, and an imbecile. But it ain't my fault. So don't
>take it out on me, please.
you holohuggers sure dedicate a lot of time and bandwidth to someone who
supposedly is "a zero, a nothing, a miserable failure, and an imbecile."
What does that say about you?
If Matt is such a nothing, a miserable failure, and an imbecile, why don't
you holohuggers just find something better to do with your time?
I think alt.religions or alt.fantasy is open.
Both would fit you holohuggers.
Kurt Stele
>In article <4v9cm6$1...@sjx-ixn3.ix.netcom.com>, mgi...@ix.netcom.com
>(Matt Giwer) wrote:
>[Giwer's post listing Ken McVay's address TWICE deleted]
>What is the purpose of this, Mr. Giwer?
I am simply curious what it is all about. After yesterday's mail
bombing from gryn.org, owned by the only person here who talks about
his Mossad connections, it has become a very interesting subject.
Can you explain it? What is the connection between kmcvay and the US
DOD? Why was he carried there? Why did a org owned by a man with
Mossad connections send the mail bomb regarding it?
You tell me. What is going on here? As Ross Perot said, I am all
ears.
Are you not curious in the least? I certainly am. And if I post it
often enough someone might come up with the answer. Do you have an
answer?
=====
Whois Ken McVay?
===
McVay, Kenneth (KM1343) kmc...@NIZKOR.ALMANAC.BC.CA
462 - 1150 North Terminal Avenue
Nanaimo, BC V9S 5T8
CA
1-604-382-0615
Record last updated on 18-Jul-96.
The InterNIC Registration Services Host contains ONLY Internet
Information
(Networks, ASN's, Domains, and POC's).
Please use the whois server at nic.ddn.mil for MILNET Information.
=====
The following was deleted from nic.ddn.mil some time between 17 July
1996 and 19 August 1996. However, as of 19 August 1996 the email
address still worked. It was originally captured on 17 July 1996.
===
>mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
># First you agreed the LK was one large room. You also
># agreed that I and II were identical.
>Oh, God almighty. Have mercy on us. He claims to have
>an IQ of 163, but he still can't figure this out, after
>posting here for a year or so.
>Look:
>Kremas II & III each had two large underground cellars.
Not according to any drawing or picture on Nizkor or posted here.
Beyond that, why make it up?
>The ones in Krema II are referred to as cellars I & II
>of Krema II.
>The ones in Krema III are referred to as cellars I & II
>of Krema III.
Not in anything posted here before your post.
>But cellars I & II were *not* identical. Cellar I was the gas
>chamber, which is why the inventory list shows it had a gas-tight
>door and shower-heads; II was the so-called "undressing room",
>which is why it didn't have a gas-tight door and shower-heads.
>Ok? Is it *finally* clear?
Your creation is far from clear. Which of your two non-"cellars" are
the aerial photos of? They are not underground, they are not cellars.
(Do not forget your folks have already insisted that Leikenkellar
means morgue not that it is a cellar, in english that is.)
And all this time you folks were insisting that those aerial pictures
were of the gas chamber without reservation.
I can see it now, someone is going to spring something entirely new
and claim it was always known by everyone.
># You folks NEVER suggested there were showerheads in any
># of them.
>Which means "I can't recall seeing that on alt.revisionism".
Which means it was never here.
>It's a well-known fact. It is mentioned in the testimonies.
>They are mentioned in the inventory list. It's on the web.
Only at the ones in Germany which were not gas chambers as you well
know.
># You will never explain how ZB got through showerheads.
>It didn't. In these Kremas, the only goal of the shower-heads
>was to fool the victims. The Zyklon was inserted via the
>wiremesh devices.
Crematoria are not gas chambers. There are no wire mesh devices. You
are not a legitimate BA candidate.
>On Sat, 17 Aug 1996 21:14:19 GMT, dke...@world.std.com (Daniel Keren)
>wrote:
>
>>mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
>
>># They were even dumb enough to ship them all the way from
>># France just to gas them in Poland. Or would not the French
>># "stand for it"?
>
>>I responded to this in my reply to "kurtstele".
>
> You did not. Please repost your claim.
>
Good grief, Matt. First you say he didn't post it and then you ask him
to RE-POST his claim! You really are not trying to make a bit of
sense, are you?
>># Not in the Ukraine, not run by Pol Pot.
>
>>What about the gulags? How many people were shipped
>>there by trains? The Soviets could do it, and the
>>Nazis couldn't?
>
> The Soviets documented every one of them and also recorded the death
>of every one of them and there is no disagreement in the numbers. If
>you do not invent gassing the Nazi numbers agree with the registered.
>
Where is this documentation, Matt?
>
>>## Ok, let's here it. What gas do you think they should
>>## have used?
>
>># CO2, free from breathing. If you want it faster, dump
>># some burning coke down your "induction columns." It is
>># not as though it is all that hard to do it cheaper.
>
>>Too slow.
>
> As you know the "cremation" was the bottleneck. There was no need for
>speed when cremation could not keep up.
>
Right. They burned them in pits.
>
> Not in the same time frame as you well know a a mathematician even
>though your REFUSE to post any calculations.
>
Apples and oranges, Matt.
>>Can't you miserable drecks understand that it doesn't
>>matter what the source of the gas is? That it will kill
>>people nontheless?
>
> NOT as described by your favorite witnesses as you well know.
>
Danny has a favorite witness? I never noticed. He uses so many.
# In fact the hard evidence and administrative documentation
# we -do- have from the nazis contradicts that the nazis were
# deliberately trying to "exterminate" the jews.
http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi?orgs/german/einsatzgruppen/
images/report-51.jpg
A report to Hitler, mentions that over 360,000 Jews
were executed during August-November 1942.
http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi?people/w/wetzel.erhard/
images/wetzel-lohse-01.jpg and images/wetzel-lohse-02.jpg
Letter from Dr. Wetzel to Lohse, about the plan to kill
with poison gas Jews "unfit for work".
There is a lot more "administrative documentation"
of this type.
You want to try something else? Like claiming that all
the Jews escaped on Zundel's UFO's to the South Pole?
That would make more sense than what you have suggested
so far.
-Danny Keren.
----
For a summary of the "revisionist" position, look at what
Nazi propagandist and "revisionist", Kurt Stele, wrote:
From: kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele)
Message-Id: <4ut4ht$p...@newsbf02.news.aol.com>
# The Holocaust is a funny thing..
# When you hear about it, you wish it never happened..
# When you discover it's a hoax ya kind of wish it did!
# Kurt Stele
>mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
># Your creation is far from clear. Which of your two
># non-"cellars" are the aerial photos of?
>If you were not mentally retarded, you would see them
>by now. They are right there in the photo.
>http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi?camps/auschwitz/images/Krema3.jpg
How can a cellar be in plain view on an aerial photo? Are you saying
that a plane can be directly over house and get a picture of the
cellar? X-rays?
>Did you really graduate from a university 30 years ago?
>How come? I've never seen an idiot like you, in any
>university I've ever been at.
What is a cellar? Where did you get the idea it was a cellar? It was
a morgue, remember? The Keller in Leichenkeller is misleading,
remember?
># They are not underground, they are not cellars.
>Yes they are, and their remains are still there today.
The picture Nizkor uses without the permission of Pressac shows it
partially above ground and free standing. The artist's conception
that Nizkor pirated from some place shows it not a cellar and
partially above ground. The picture of how it looks today that Nizkor
pirated from someplace else shows no indication of anything that was
built on top of it so it does not qualify as a cellar. The aerial
photos Nizkor pirated from another source show them from above so they
are not underground and are the cellars of no other building.
Are you unfamiliar with the Nizkor resources? I find them very
valuable for their support of the revisionist point of view. You
should become familiar with them.
It only qualifies as a "cellar" if one works with Leichenkellar but
does not use the translation morgue. That was explained to me many,
many months ago when I used the literal translation of the word. Are
you saying that the literal translation is now in favor with the
holohuggers?
>Look, there is not even a fellow "revisionist" of yours
>who is making such idiotic claims as you are. Have you
>totally flipped?
You should become more familiar with the Nizkor materials that are
useed without the approval of the authors or their estates before you
make such sweeping claims.
>All the other nazi-boys agree that there were two such
>large underground cellars. None of them is stupid and
>crazy enough to deny it. Only you.
Ah, yes. Undergound and clearly visible on all the above ground
pictures.
># (Do not forget your folks have already insisted that
># Leikenkellar means morgue not that it is a cellar, in
># english that is.)
>It's "keller", you imbecile, and it means "cellar" in German,
>as you could have guessed were you not a stupid monkey.
But as I was informed by you among many, Leichenkeller means morgue
and NOT moldy cellar. When did you change? A morgue can be on the
top floor of a building. A morgue does not have to be under the main
structure.
>## It's a well-known fact. It is mentioned in the testimonies.
>## They are mentioned in the inventory list. It's on the web.
># Only at the ones in Germany which were not gas chambers as
># you well know.
>No, you damned senile ape. I'm talking about testimonies
>and inventory list for Auschwitz.
>http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi?camps/auschwitz/images/Invntry.jpg
>There were gas chambers in Germany, BTW.
Tell it to Wiesel and Wiesenthal. When you have their agreement, get
back to me. At the moment, they agree with me, not you.
>You're a senile piece of rotting dreck. It's amazing that there
>was someone kind enough to employ a monkey like you till you
>were 46 years old. You're the most stupid piece of trash I saw
>in my life.
For a mathematician who has never posted even multiplication that is
rather difficult to support.
BTW: these are the real dimensions
length width height
30 7.75 2.5
meaning 581.25 cubic meters, not 500.
And have you posted your calculation as yet?
>-Danny Keren.
>In Message-ID: <4n0ik8$1...@dfw-ixnews10.ix.netcom.com>, Matt Giwer
>suggested that documents about a "gas chamber" and "gassing cellar"
>in the Birkenau crematoriums didn't count, as they were really due
>to "a morbid sense of humor" of the SS men who authored the documents.
=======================
Whois Ken McVay?
===
McVay, Kenneth (KM1343) kmc...@NIZKOR.ALMANAC.BC.CA
462 - 1150 North Terminal Avenue
Nanaimo, BC V9S 5T8
CA
1-604-382-0615
Record last updated on 18-Jul-96.
The InterNIC Registration Services Host contains ONLY Internet
Information
(Networks, ASN's, Domains, and POC's).
Please use the whois server at nic.ddn.mil for MILNET Information.
=====
The following was deleted from nic.ddn.mil some time between 17 July
1996 and 19 August 1996. However, as of 19 August 1996 the email
address still worked. It was originally captured on 17 July 1996. It
disppeared just prior to a 256 copy mailbomb from gryn.org saying that
it was false information. The owner of gryn.org, Alec Grynspan,
openly brags about having been in the Mossad, i.e. Israeli
intelligence.
Ever seen Monty Python and the Holy Grail?
If I do not go away they will taunt me again a third time.
They are very silly.
>Kurt Stele (kurt...@aol.com) wrote:
>: dke...@world.std.com (Daniel Keren) wrote to mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt
>: Giwer):
>:
>: >I'm sorry that you're a zero, a nothing, a miserable
>: >failure, and an imbecile. But it ain't my fault. So don't
>: >take it out on me, please.
>:
>: you holohuggers sure dedicate a lot of time and bandwidth to someone who
>: supposedly is "a zero, a nothing, a miserable failure, and an imbecile."
>:
>: What does that say about you?
>That we're easily amused?
That you are very silly to think there is something to be gained by
it.
>In article <DwG8t...@world.std.com>, dke...@world.std.com (Daniel Keren)
>wrote:
>> mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
>>
>snip]
>> # (Do not forget your folks have already insisted that
>> # Leikenkellar means morgue not that it is a cellar, in
>> # english that is.)
>This from the boob who, in article
><4m736d$9...@dfw-ixnews2.ix.netcom.com>, claimed that Leichenkeller meant:
>"Keller = cellar. Leichen = Leichen."
But now Danny-boy is telling me that Keller mean cellar.
>> It's "keller", you imbecile, and it means "cellar" in German,
>> as you could have guessed were you not a stupid monkey.
>Indeed. To taunt the Giwer-boob imbecile further: Leichen = corpse. Keller
>= cellar. Ergo, Leichenkeller means, literally, "corpse cellar." That
>translates to "morgue" in English.
It is good for you to remind him of this exchange as he does not
appear to remember it nor his part in it. Now that it suits his
pruposes he makes the same insistance I originally did.
Is it not interesting that he now agrees with me?
>This, of course, did not preclude the Nazis and construction crew from
>refering to L.Keller 1 and/or 2 as cellar 1 and/or 2. Or C1 and/or C2.
>But, of course, the Giwer-boob imbecile knew this (at one point) as he had
>his face rubbed in it like a scolded puppy. Obviously, the Giwer-boob
>imbecile's advancing senile dementia is taking its toll....
Of course you now have two boobs with the same opinion. How much did
the doc charge?
No mailbomb was sent, matt. you're totally delusional.
> Can you explain it? What is the connection between kmcvay and the US
> DOD? Why was he carried there? Why did a org owned by a man with
> Mossad connections send the mail bomb regarding it?
Again - no mailbomb was sent.
No connections exist.
Repetition without basis triggers an interesting effect, Matt.
>
> You tell me. What is going on here? As Ross Perot said, I am all
> ears.
>
Repetition and repeated non-sequiturs gets the same effect, Matt.
> Are you not curious in the least? I certainly am. And if I post it
> often enough someone might come up with the answer. Do you have an
> answer?
You've been given your answer.
No mailbomb was sent, Matt.
No mailbomb was threatened, Matt.
There are new medications for this problem. See your doctor immediately!
Surely a free clinic can get you to the charity ward, if nothing else!
# How can a cellar be in plain view on an aerial photo?
You can see its boundaries. You can go to Auschwitz and see
that the cellars are still there.
Listen, this is simply too much. As I said, there is not
even a "revisionist" crazy and stupid enough to deny that
each of these Kremas (II & III) had two large underground
cellars. Enough is enough.
# The Keller in Leichenkeller is misleading, remember?
Keller means cellar. It is not misleading. Enough is enough.
## There were gas chambers in Germany, BTW.
# Tell it to Wiesel and Wiesenthal. When you have their
# agreement, get back to me. At the moment, they agree with
# me, not you.
No. Wiesenthal said that the extermination camps were
not in Germany but in Nazi-occupied Poland. But some of
the German camps also had homicidal gas chambers. However,
these camps (Mauthausen, Neuengamme, Natzweiler and
others) are usually not classified as extermination
camps, because there was far less killing in them
than in the camps in Poland. In some of these gas chambers,
"only" a few hundred people were murdered.
The "Institute for Contemporary History", for instance,
also classifies these camps as "concentration camps", in
its summary which details the gas chambers in them.
Enough is enough, Giwer.
-Danny Keren.
---
>mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) wrote:
>>On Sun, 18 Aug 1996 14:21:06 GMT, mcu...@inetport.com (Mike Curtis)
>>wrote:
>>
>>
>>>Clue #1: The state didn't pay for it. As Hilberg shows in his
>>>_Destruction of the European Jews_ the funding for the one way tickets
>>>was paid for by the Jews themselves. Confiscated property and moneys
>>>made it possible to take the state off the hook.
>>
>> And you really believe that the railraods were the only onew who stood
>>up to the Nazis and demanded Reichmarks in payment else they would not
>>do as ordered.
>Actually, Matt, they demanded the currency of their nation rather than
>Reichsmarks. This is documented by Hilberg whom you obviously have not
>read.
Excuse me. Just who was it who could tell the Nazis that they would
not accept Reishsmarks?
In fact the "story" was first presented (BTW: this is very old, is
that why you think you can get away with changing the subject?) as an
insistance upon Reichsmarks by the railroads. Now you want to change
it to wanting payment in their own currency.
Gee, how primitive these people were. They actually wanted cash, as
in paper. They did not take a Nazi check which, as you know, could
have been deposited in any back for payment in the local currency. Or
do you believe that if you receive a check made out for Yen that your
bank will give you Yen?
>> You have a very strange view of a Fuehrerstadt.
>That's your unsubstantiated view.
You are claiming that mere railroads could stand up to the Reich where
nations could not. The Nazis are quite fortunate they did not attack
the railroads or they would have lost the war the first day.
>>>They did try shooting them dead, but the reports from those in the
>>>field showed that the shooters were stressed out about it. They had to
>>>come up with a different way. Shooting was taking a psychological
>>>price out of the soldiers and local police forces assigned to do the
>>>shootings. I suggest you read the histories by Christopher Browning.
>>>_Ordinary Men_ comes to mind.
>> Excuse me but it would take only one pathological type to operate the
>>machinegun after they were lined up.
>There were those. I didn't say everyone, Matt.
Then there was no reason to ship people hundreds of miles simply to
gas them. But do not forget, when Auschwitz gassed 3 million fewer, 3
million more were shot. With the Auschwitz revision that
"psychological toll" explanation just lost an order of magnitude worth
of interest.
All the field troops had to do was squeeze an extra 1.6 million out of
those who had shot 4 million and there was no need to build four huge
gas chambers and Krema facilities.
And as to the toll ... call for fresh volunteers from the Russian
Front.
Of course if you have lesser numbers, please post them. I have asked
more than once but no one responded with them.
>> But to follow your line of reasoning, on Jewish Sonderkommandos could
>>stomach gassing thousands at a time.
>I never said they could. The idea I get is they became numbed to it.
That is what I said.
>This is what some survivors have testified to. They didn't really have
>much of a future to look forward to at the time of their duties did
>they.
I have no idea what they had to look forward to. After all, they
slept right in the gas chambers, remember? I wonder where they ate?
>> Is this another manner in which Jews are superior to Germans even if
>>they are German?
>Is this a new subject brought up by you. I don't recall discussing
>this point.
Of course you did. Jews can better stomach complicity in murder than
Germans.
# But now Danny-boy is telling me that Keller mean cellar.
Well, it does. Sorry about that. Are you about to "revise"
the German language?
-Danny Keren.
>mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) wrote:
>>On Sat, 17 Aug 1996 21:14:19 GMT, dke...@world.std.com (Daniel Keren)
>>wrote:
>>
>>>mgi...@ix.netcom.com (Matt Giwer) writes:
>>
>>># They were even dumb enough to ship them all the way from
>>># France just to gas them in Poland. Or would not the French
>>># "stand for it"?
>>
>>>I responded to this in my reply to "kurtstele".
>>
>> You did not. Please repost your claim.
>>
>Good grief, Matt. First you say he didn't post it and then you ask him
>to RE-POST his claim! You really are not trying to make a bit of
>sense, are you?
I am certain that a gosh awful for real PhD can speak for himself.
>>># Not in the Ukraine, not run by Pol Pot.
>>
>>>What about the gulags? How many people were shipped
>>>there by trains? The Soviets could do it, and the
>>>Nazis couldn't?
>>
>> The Soviets documented every one of them and also recorded the death
>>of every one of them and there is no disagreement in the numbers. If
>>you do not invent gassing the Nazi numbers agree with the registered.
>Where is this documentation, Matt?
In the gulags themselves with master files in Moscow. There have even
been film crews in the Gulags and interviews with some people who have
been there so long they have decided they are too old to leave. I
particularly remember the interview with the Japanese man who was sent
there prior to WW II.
You should watch the documentaries more often. You would know more.
Or are you referring to the SS documentation? Read the damned
newsgroup. I brought it up months ago that it was simple to find
those that were gassed, simply compare the registration and death
records.
I was informed that those who were gassed immediately were not
registered. Or are you now claiming that those who were gassed
immediately were registered? Just what is it you are claiming?
>>>## Ok, let's here it. What gas do you think they should
>>>## have used?
>>
>>># CO2, free from breathing. If you want it faster, dump
>>># some burning coke down your "induction columns." It is
>>># not as though it is all that hard to do it cheaper.
>>
>>>Too slow.
>>
>> As you know the "cremation" was the bottleneck. There was no need for
>>speed when cremation could not keep up.
>Right. They burned them in pits.
Even before that claimed time which at Auschwitz was only when the
Kremas were down for repair in any event. Even at the most optimistic
estimates there is no value to speed of gassing when 15 minutes kills
a day's worth of cremations. So what is the value of gassing speed?
No matter how fast the cremations the process of simply loading them
takes longer than the gassing time. Even hauling a few thousand to
the pits takes longer than the gassing times reported. So what is the
rush?
If cremation and gassing took the same amount of time for the same
number of bodies then there would be a premium on the speed of both if
there was an expectation of being overwhelmed by shipments.
But as we know from the stories, there was not a design expectation of
being overwhelmed with shipments as they mention these as a response
to too many being shipped.
Don't you pay attention to what is posted?
>> Not in the same time frame as you well know a a mathematician even
>>though your REFUSE to post any calculations.
>Apples and oranges, Matt.
I am certain he can speak for himself.
>>>Can't you miserable drecks understand that it doesn't
>>>matter what the source of the gas is? That it will kill
>>>people nontheless?
>>
>> NOT as described by your favorite witnesses as you well know.
>>
>Danny has a favorite witness? I never noticed. He uses so many.
He can speak for himself.
>Mike Curtis E-mail mcu...@inetport.com
>Nizkor Web: http://www.almanac.bc.ca/ (Under construction - permanently!)
They will never get it right.
>kurt...@aol.com (Kurt Stele) wrote:
Is it not the dogma that those inconvenient, overrun countries is
where most of them came from?
If not, pray tell where they did come from?
>>"to keep the extermination plan a secret" then
>>why would there be any need to continue transporting them to the camps
>>just to be killed there instead of nearby at no expense, since the jews in
>>Poland already "found out" about the "secret extermination plan"?
>>
>Who was to stop them?
The secret was out but they wanted it kept a secret but everyone knew
about it but it was a secret.
When have you done calculations? Shall we go back to the issue of
cremation energy you ran away from?
> You do the calculation. It appears you are unable to do the least bit
>of math, yet that is your "PhD" or at least your claim. You have yet
>to post anything even vaguely smelling of arithmetic.
I remember your laughable attempt to compute the energy needed to deal
with the water in a corpse. Want to return to that issue? We're still
waiting for your calculations.
> Either you are a fraud with the PhD claim or you know that the even
>basic arithmetic is contrary to your claims.
>
> There is nothing in between.
>
> You are a fraud.
Matt Giwer is a confessed liar.
http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/g/giwer-matt/lies/lie-openly-admitted.html
http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/g/giwer-matt/index-lies.html
--
Mike Stein The above represents the Absolute Truth.
POB 10420 Therefore it cannot possibly be the official
Arlington, VA 22210 position of my employer.
>In article <4vaqb4$9...@newsbf02.news.aol.com>,
>Kurt Stele <kurt...@aol.com> wrote:
>>al...@gryn.org (Alec Grynspan) wrote:
>>
>>>Finally, there doesn't have to be a logical reason.
>>
>>It's not that there has to be a logical reason.
>>
>>It's that there has to be an -illogical- reason.
>>
>>The Holocaust positively -requires- that the nazis be illogical, goofy,
>>and stupid.
> They decided that Jewish babies and geriatric cases were a threat to
>the safety of the Reich and spent valuable resources to transport them
>across Europe in the middle of a war - to hold them prisoner, according
to
>your claims.
> Is that illogical, goofy, and stupid enough for you?
> Killing them on the spot may have been more efficient than shipping
>them to be killed (ignoring, of course, the desire to maintain "plausible
>deniability" at least), but killing them on arrival is still more
>efficient and sensible than what you claim was done.
> Most efficient and sensible, even if you are illogical, goofy and
>stupid enough to believe that the 18-50 year olds were a real threat,
>would be to give the kids to the geezers and let them fend for themselves
>in place.
Gee, armies of Pol Pot, Stalin, and Mao Tse Tung weren't illogical, goofy,
and stupid, and did commit genocide by the normal convenient means of
bullets and starvation, without resorting to goofy gas chambers.
Neither were these armies "too sensitive."
Yet you want us to believe the Germans were too goofy and too sensitive to
do the same had they wanted to?
No army in -history- has ever behaved as illogical, goofy, and stupid as
the Purported Germans of the Holohoax legend.
Yet holohuggers want us to believe in it and not even dare question this
pablum
Kurt Stele
>On Sun, 18 Aug 1996 14:21:06 GMT, mcu...@inetport.com (Mike Curtis)
>wrote:
>
>
>>Clue #1: The state didn't pay for it. As Hilberg shows in his
>>_Destruction of the European Jews_ the funding for the one way tickets
>>was paid for by the Jews themselves. Confiscated property and moneys
>>made it possible to take the state off the hook.
>
> And you really believe that the railraods were the only onew who stood
>up to the Nazis and demanded Reichmarks in payment else they would not
>do as ordered.
>
Actually, Matt, they demanded the currency of their nation rather than
Reichsmarks. This is documented by Hilberg whom you obviously have not
read.
> You have a very strange view of a Fuehrerstadt.
>
That's your unsubstantiated view.
>>They did try shooting them dead, but the reports from those in the
>>field showed that the shooters were stressed out about it. They had to
>>come up with a different way. Shooting was taking a psychological
>>price out of the soldiers and local police forces assigned to do the
>>shootings. I suggest you read the histories by Christopher Browning.
>>_Ordinary Men_ comes to mind.
>
> Excuse me but it would take only one pathological type to operate the
>machinegun after they were lined up.
>
There were those. I didn't say everyone, Matt.
> But to follow your line of reasoning, on Jewish Sonderkommandos could
>stomach gassing thousands at a time.
>
I never said they could. The idea I get is they became numbed to it.
This is what some survivors have testified to. They didn't really have
much of a future to look forward to at the time of their duties did
they.
> Is this another manner in which Jews are superior to Germans even if
>they are German?
>
Is this a new subject brought up by you. I don't recall discussing
this point.
>
Mike Curtis E-mail mcu...@inetport.com
For More Information try The Nizkor Project
Nizkor (USA) An Electronic Holocaust Educational Resource
Over 100Megs of data: http://www.almanac.bc.ca/cgi-bin/ftp.pl?
Europe: ftp://nizkor.iam.uni-bonn.de/pub/nizkor/
They decided that Jewish babies and geriatric cases were a threat to
the safety of the Reich and spent valuable resources to transport them
across Europe in the middle of a war - to hold them prisoner, according to
your claims.
Is that illogical, goofy, and stupid enough for you?
Killing them on the spot may have been more efficient than shipping
them to be killed (ignoring, of course, the desire to maintain "plausible
deniability" at least), but killing them on arrival is still more
efficient and sensible than what you claim was done.
Most efficient and sensible, even if you are illogical, goofy and
stupid enough to believe that the 18-50 year olds were a real threat,
would be to give the kids to the geezers and let them fend for themselves
in place.
Sorry for pointing out that you didn't think things through.
Posted/emailed.
Letting the Jews stay right where they were would have been cheaper
than the camps. If they were that irrational, how can you suddenly say
_that_ is too irrational, but _that_ is too irrational?
> They were even dumb enough to ship them all the way from France just
>to gas them in Poland. Or would not the French "stand for it"?
They seemed to want to maintain the fiction. You scoff at the secret
that was not a secret, but you obviously forget the "secret" bombing of
Cambodia.
>># With Stalin and Pol Pot, as opposed to the Holohoax,
>># you had:
>>#
>># No trains.
>
>>No trains? How were all these people deported to Siberia
>>and to the camps in Cambodia? They walked all the way
>>to Siberia?
>
> The starvation was done on site in the Ukraine.
Buzzer there. Those were not Stalin's only victims.
>># No tattoos.
>
>>Only those spared for work were tattooed.
>
> One more assertion that only the undocumented were gassed without
>explaining how the undocumented were counted.
Railroad records. Subtract the registered from the shipped and you
have the number undocumented. Of course you are too illiterate to realize
or too dishonest to admit that the term "undocumented" means those
undocumented _at the camp_.
>># No insecticide.
>
>>Stop with this bloody rubbish already. It was a cheap
>>way with which to kill many people. So it was used.
>
> So are bullets. So is CO2 from putting them in a room and sealing it.
Proof positive: US gas chambers are a myth. Look at the trouble and
expense they allegedly go to when it would be much cheaper and easier to
let the person sit in the chamber and suffocate.
If your argument proves the Nazis did not do what they did, it also
proves that San Quentin does not do what it does. Sorry about that.
>After all, there was no hurry as the cremation was the bottleneck
>according to you folks.
Invalid reasoning. It takes far fewer people resources to keep
control over dead bodies than live people. Dead bodies can safely be left
to wait to be burned. You forget the problem of the people out in the
woods waiting to enter the chambers at peak times. They must be kept
under control. Your proposal keeps them out there longer.
And that is not the only reason to want them dead quickly even if they
cannot be burned immediately.
>># No "death-camps."
>
>>You heard it here, folks. No death camps in Stalin's
>>USSR and Pol Pot's Cambodia.
>
> Not in the Ukraine, not run by Pol Pot.
The USSR was more than the Ukraine. Are you being stupid or being
dishonest?
And Stalin didn't run the Siberian camps - not personally. Are
you playing dishonest word games, or are you really that ignorant?
>># No stories of jewish women cleaning stairs with
>># their tongues.
>
>>No sadism? Have you read about recent war crimes in Bosnia?
>
> It appears you believe in the stair cleaning story.
It appears you believe it is impossible. What physical laws does it
violate? List them.
>># If they had wanted to gas the jews they would have
>># used the most efficient gas available -- not Zyklon B!
>
>>Ok, let's here it. What gas do you think they should
>>have used?
>
> CO2, free from breathing. If you want it faster, dump some burning
>coke down your "induction columns." It is not as though it is all
>that hard to do it cheaper.
Again, your argument is equally valid against the existence of US gas
chambers - i.e., not at all.
>># But you want people to believe the nazis created some
>># idiotic, inefficient scheme for killing jews?
>
>>No. I think they used a rather efficient scheme.
>
> You mean like the mass electrocutions? or the steaming?
Like what they used. Stay on topic.
>># Zyklon-B as opposed to several other gasses available at the
>># time was ridiculously inefficient.
>
>>All you stupid "revisionists" can do is repeat this like
>>a lame-brained parrot. The gas was very cheap, very easy
>>to handle, and they had a great deal of experience using it.
>
> In the Nizkor approved story of the first usage, a contractor did all
>the fumigation until Fritsch had a bright idea, i.e. no experience.
So what? Everything which was done or invented was done or invented
for the first time once. Your point?
>We can go into the other stories later.
>
>>The same gas, HCN, is used to execute people in US
>>prisons. A natural choice.
>
> But something as foolish as ZB is not used and would be quite a
>riduculous way to go about it.
Please explain why. The unsupported assertion of a confessed liar
is not acceptable.
http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/g/giwer-matt/lies/lie-openly-admitted.html
http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/g/giwer-matt/index-lies.html
> But you know that.
>># I guess it takes a holohugger to make insecticide into
>># "death gas" and crematoria into "ovens."
>
>>I guess it takes a stupid "revisionist" to make unfounded
>>claims about technical matters without proving his point.
>
> Your demonstrated technical knowledge here is on a par with your
>demonstrated math knowledge, zero.
That leaves you in the negative six figures.
>>There are many more such documents.
>
> Two, neither clear, amidst all the rest with no such indication.
What is unclear about "Vergasungskeller?"
>># You don't tatoo someone you are going to exterminate --
>># no need to!
>
>>Which is why only those spared as "fit for work" were
>>tattooed, not those gassed upon arrival.
>
> Admitting again there were no records of those "gassed" but not
>exlpaining how the "gassed" were determined to be different from the
>31 million who vanished without a trace.
Because they were traced to Auschwitz on the trains but could not be
traced beyond that point. Or do you think the Nazis shipped them there
and then just turned them loose to wander the countryside?
>># That sort of thoughtcontrol may be OK in Israel, but we
>># Whites want the truth.
>
>>Bwawawa. "We Whites".
>
>># Those inmate facilities weren't gas chambers. The design of
>># the buildings were inadequate for your silly gas chambers
>
>>Stop repeating this like some dumb little Nazi. PROVE it.
>
> You claim HCN is used in US gas chambers as though it was the same as
>ZB.
That is just one more lie or illiteracy from you.
>Therefore there is a need to demonstrate that
>
> 1) these morgues were useful for gassing
You have admitted this already! You have claimed they were fumigated.
But whatever is inside them gets exposed to cyanide. If lice can
die inside that room, so can people.
You have already proved the point you asked proof for but you are too
stupid and/or dishonest to see it.
> and
>
> 2)that they overcome the differences between US gas chambers and ZB
>in application.
There is nothing to overcome. Release Zyklon in a room full of lice,
the lice die. Release the same Zyklon in the same room when it's full of
people, the people die even faster. No problem. The Zyklon doesn't care
what's in the room.
> And that if just the beginning. You folks started "discovering" the
>morgues were really gas chambers about four years ago. You folks
>claim they have obvious features for mass extermination chambers. Yet
>since these are the only ones ever built there is a lot more needed to
>substantiate the claim of obvious.
Once again, you admitted they got it right for delousing. But once
you admit that, you admit they could have been used for people as well -
even more easily! So once again you have defeated your own argument.
>># But instead you want me to believe that "Raid" was used,
>># and that it was all a big plot to wipe out the Jews using
>># insecticide, using buildings that couldn't have functioned
>># as gas chambers.
>
>>Prove that they couldn't function as gas chambers.
>
> You home can function as a gas chamber. Prove it is not.
It has no cyanide traces.
> You folks bear the burden of making the claim.
>
> You folks have never met that burden.
But since you are a known and confessed liar you are expected to
repeat that claim no matter what.
http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/g/giwer-matt/lies/lie-openly-admitted.html
http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/g/giwer-matt/index-lies.html
You have never backed up your claims about matters such as cremation
energy. You ran away from the issue when it became clear you were wrong.
But you know that.
>># Again, the difference between Dresden testimony and Holocaust
>># testimony is that the latter is patently implausible.
>
>>Yes, sure. "Puddles of melted human flesh, four foot deep".
>>People "glowing orange and disintegrating". People "turning
>>into a fine layer of gray ashes", all these, BTW, without the
>>fire even touching them. All these are "testimonies" about
>>Dresden.
>
>>You claim that a major portion of Holocaust-related
>>testimonies are impossible? Prove it.
>
> Some day you may be intelligent or honest enough to admit there is a
>difference between physical evidence and testimony.
Who has said otherwise? You are lying about what was said before. I
have mentioned this twice before and yet you repeat your lie, which by now
must be deliberate.
Rather you did not understand the definition of evidence. Not
"physical evidence" but "evidence" with no qualifier in front of it.
>If you believe
>they are the same, you should accept Jesus into your heart.
>
>># The point you keep missing over and over is that the deaths
>># of Germans at Dresden and after the war were not from
>># -implausible- causes,
>
>>Garbage. You claim 6 million corpses should be presented. You
>>now show me the millions of corpses of Germans who allegedly
>>died after the war ended, and in the bombing raids.
>
>>Fair is fair. Show us the corpses.
>
> But of course, you first. And after all of these years, nothing.
>
>># yeah, and not in anywhere near the traces which could support
>># a finding they were used as gas chambers. But, ODDLY ENOUGH,
>># the traces -do- support the finding that they came from
>># delousing fugimant. Gee.
>
>>And Dresden could have caught fire and burned down. Like
>>Chicago. It happens you know.
>
> And all of those gassed Jews could have been invented out of the 31
>million unaccounted for. It happened, you know.
Show where they went. We have documentation a million went to
Auschwitz. You say the ashes were never found. But the live people were
never found either. You have no physical evidence they are alive, either.
You claim they were not gassed and did not die at Auschwitz from any other
means, as the ashes are not there. Therefore they must have gone
somewhere. Why can you not find them?
What do you gain from being exposed as a lying fool?
http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/g/giwer-matt/lies/lie-openly-admitted.html
http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/g/giwer-matt/index-lies.html
I know you've made statements - more than one, in point of fact - but
since you admit that you are willing to lie, why should anyone believe any
of them?
# you holohuggers sure dedicate a lot of time and
# bandwidth to someone who supposedly is "a zero, a
# nothing, a miserable failure, and an imbecile."
Because, in spite of all this, he is still the most
active and most smart "revisionist" on the net.
-Danny Keren.
> > I am simply curious what it is all about. After yesterday's mail
> > bombing from gryn.org, owned by the only person here who talks about
> > his Mossad connections, it has become a very interesting subject.
> No mailbomb was sent, matt. you're totally delusional.
You don't know how delusional the poor boy is getting. Recently Matty
poo sent me some e-mail for reasons known only to him. It was the fourth time
Matty poo has done so (again, for reasons known only to him). When I wrote
Matty poo asking that he not do so, Matty poo fired back that it was a forgery put
out by those evil conspirators at your posting site (I checked the header, it was
from Matty poo).
You're treading on dangerous ground. Matty poo might strain his back
looking for you under his bed. Then he'll threaten to sue you and you will get an
ulcer and some quack will put a tube down your throat to diagnose it. I suggest
you accomodate his delusions and stop being.
--YFE
Good. Since we are into this, I shall post Mr. Giwer's father's name, address
and telephone number each time he repeats this post.
I am e-mailing this to Mr. Giwer, so he can be sure to read it.
--
Gord McFee
I'll write no line before its time
Fine. The Nazis were illogical, goofy and stupid.
:>Otherwise their theory can't even get off the ground
:>
:>>The Nazi mentality was monomaniacal and saw efficiencies that no one else
:>>would consider an efficiency.
:>
:>Perhaps the truth is really the reverse: the -jew holohugger- is
:>monomaniacal in his paranoic and implacable -hatred- of nazis, which is
:>why the holohugger clings to fantasies about "disguised shower heads" and
:>"death by Raid."
Funny. Those Jewish "fantasies" are supported by Adolf Eichmann.
Get your mommy to read you the book.