Utter and complete mystery that Led Zeppelin didnt perform these songs live when Bonham was alive
Ivan "Maximus" Lendl
- Not only was this song never performed, this song was never
released on a studio album. And this in my opinion is one of the best
rock songs ever
2. Ramble On
- They never performed this song completely. And this is usually
considered their best song ever. And this has one of the most amazing
interplay between Jones and Page and also the sweetest bassline ever
3. Your Time Is Gonna Come
- This song continues to be underrated. I don't know why. This is one
of my favorite song from the debut album
4. Gallows Poke
- only performed once apparently. And soundboard versions of this
performance don't exist. I would have loved to see Page play the
banjo.
5. Bron Yr Aur
- same as Gallows Pole. A great melodic instrumental by Page and I
think their best instrumental
6. Good Times Bad Times
- the thundering first song from their first album. I wonder why they
didn't play this entirely ever.
7. Livin Lovin Maid
- what a great dancy song! Don't know why they didnt perform this one
either
8. Down By The Seaside
- another ballad type song which is very melodic. Ignored for some
reason
9. Fool in the Rain
- Best song from their late era. Curiously underrated by the band
themselves
10. Hats off To Roy Harper
- again another great song which is ignored these days.
6sicks...@gmail.com
wrote:
No big mystery, they just weren't that good It helped for them to play
stuff the stole from other bands, so they could watch them do it first
Ivan "Maximus" Lendl
wrote:
you are a genius... not
Ivan Maximus Lendl
>
The Who fan? Jealous much?
Ivan Maximus Lendl
> Oh my god, you're back. And the same old redundant crap. Could you
> possibly be more pathetic?
I don't think this topic has ever been explored... TROLL
6sicks...@gmail.com
>
> - Show quoted text -
A who fan? Like what? it's some sort of pissant popularity contest?
Why would I be "Jealous" of anything in this context you pathetic
shithead? What is your mission, exactly, troll boy?
BTW: Saw both bands live, guess which one could be counted on to 'get
it right' night after night? Here's a hint: it had nothing to do with
witchcraft or gangsters.
Ivan Maximus Lendl
The Who fans have been total bitches for a long time when it comes to
Led Zeppelin. This debate has been going on since the 70s. Who is the
better hard rock band? The Who were good live but didnt have enough
great songs. Thats why they didnt sell even 1/10th of what Zeppelin
sold. Their fans are still sore about it.
> Why would I be "Jealous" of anything in this context you pathetic
> shithead? What is your mission, exactly, troll boy?
Ignorant fool.
>
> BTW: Saw both bands live, guess which one could be counted on to 'get
> it right' night after night? Here's a hint: it had nothing to do with
> witchcraft or gangsters.- Hide quoted text -
Hint: You are biased Who fanboi.
crazytimes
wrote:
> 9. Fool in the Rain
> - Best song from their late era. Curiously underrated by the band
> themselves
They played this song on their last tour...
The other songs you mentioned either weren't their favorites, or were
throwaway/afterthoughts to them...
6sicks...@gmail.com
>
> - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -
Oh and while we're at it, perhaps you can refute the following:
1. "The Song Remains The Same" had to have sections re-shot due to
live suckage and they still hit more clams than a snowplow on rehoboth
beach in the released version of the film.
2. They stole A LOT from other artists. And were very successfully
sued because of that.
3. They SUCKED LIVE and most people who say them were disappointed.
Unless they were fanboi types sitting home jacking off over pictures
of Robert Plant in his tight pants.
Ivan Maximus Lendl
Bullshit. That was towards the end of the tour and they were tired.
Why pick the bad days? There were 100 better concerts that Led
Zeppelin performed. You are just trying to be an ass,
>
> 2. They stole A LOT from other artists. And were very successfully
> sued because of that.
Other artists? Like ones born 20 years earlier? And how much did they
borrow? Some riffs and lyrics? On how many songs? Borrowing is a blues
tradition, dummy.
>
> 3. They SUCKED LIVE and most people who say them were disappointed.
> Unless they were fanboi types sitting home jacking off over pictures
> of Robert Plant in his tight pants.- Hide quoted text -
You sound very gay.
Ivan Maximus Lendl
> On Nov 10, 3:42 pm, "Ivan \"Maximus\" Lendl" <zepflo...@gmail.com>
> wrote:
>
> > 9. Fool in the Rain
> > - Best song from their late era. Curiously underrated by the band
> > themselves
>
> They played this song on their last tour...
They did?
>
> The other songs you mentioned either weren't their favorites, or were
> throwaway/afterthoughts to them...
Ramble On is not their favorite? Why include it in every compilation?
I have seen Good Times Bad Times in many compilations as well. I
woudnt call any of those songs throwaways. They are all excellent. If
I was talking about Ozone Baby, then thats another thing.
richforman
Yeah, this is gonna get real boring real quick Rajamus, but I will
throw in that I saw Plant do what I thought was a very nice and
interesting "reimagined" take on "Ramble On" when I saw him open for
the Who a few years back, I thought his band was very modern/
contemporary/forward-looking, not nostalgia-based.
richforman
Ivan Maximus Lendl
TCA
On Jul 28, 7:49 am, "Ivan \"Maximus\" Lendl" zepf...@gmail.com wrote:
My last post in newsgroups
yeah I moving on... got more important things to do! had fun all
these years, but I have realized that newsgroups are all about
bitching and fighting with others. its not fun anymore. I am too old
for this shit. There are too many psychotic people in here and I don't
wanna deal with them.
BYE!
___________________________________________________
RichL
> Oh my god, you're back. And the same old redundant crap. Could you
> possibly be more pathetic?
He's your biggest fan!
Jim Beam
> ___________________________________________________
>
> My last post in newsgroups
> yeah I moving on... got more important things to do! had fun all
> these years, but I have realized that newsgroups are all about
> bitching and fighting with others. its not fun anymore. I am too old
> for this shit. There are too many psychotic people in here and I don't
> wanna deal with them.
>
> BYE!
> ___________________________________________________
Don't let the door hit you in the ass.
6sicks...@gmail.com
You are the Led Zep expert huh? Ever heard Taurus by Spirit? Or maybe
you want to suck on this one for a while:
http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/ledzep1.html
http://www.artandpopularculture.com/Led_Zeppelin_copyright_controversy
Blues tradition is for blues artists, stealing whole songs is a
british tradition going back to the skiffle days and Lonnie Donnegan
who ripped off Libba Cotton amongst others.
Go lie down.
gemjack
wrote:
Yes, but which *year* was this one written?
-gj
Ivan "Maximus" Lendl
Okay Zeppelin suck, now fuck off.
TCA
"gemjack" <geminij...@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1qdkf51g2k5hhnu3k...@4ax.com...
2010 by the look of things!
TCA
"Jim Beam" <Tenbee...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:e2d492e7-a045-4fbd...@l13g2000yqb.googlegroups.com...
> Don't let the door hit you in the ass.
Try keep up.... Jim.
May I suggest a few less swillies of an evening..... especially around the
time the lecky goes online in your neck of the red woods...?
progea
arnab.z@gmail
wrote:
>___________________________________________________
>On Jul 28, 7:49 am, "Ivan \"Maximus\" Lendl" zepflo...@gmail.com wrote:
>My last post in newsgroups
>yeah I moving on... got more important things to do! had fun all
>these years, but I have realized that newsgroups are all about
>bitching and fighting with others. its not fun anymore. I am too old
>for this shit. There are too many psychotic people in here and I don't
>wanna deal with them.
>BYE!
>___________________________________________________
Hey Raja, explain this.
who?
Nobody knows for sure it's Raja. Can we call this follow the
leader? Jeez.
stuth...@comcast.net
Zeppelin made up a standard setlist for a tour, and rarely deviated
from it, especially after 1972.
Plus, when one-third of your concert, and well over an hour is devoted
to wanking on two songs and a crappy drum solo, you don't get to play
more songs.
>
> 4. Gallows Poke
> - only performed once apparently. And soundboard versions of this
> performance don't exist. I would have loved to see Page play the
> banjo.
Why? Jimmy Page was a crappy banjo player. Jerry Garcia could
actually PLAY the banjo.
stuth...@comcast.net
>
> - Show quoted text -
People who listen to music made in the last 30 years.
williemeikle
I do.
Steven Sullivan
--
-S
We have it in our power to begin the world over again - Thomas Paine