Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss
Attention Publius : The Enigma HAS BEEN SOLVED <-- Click Here to watch the videos of me deciphering the enigma
2,271 views
Skip to first unread message
David Valentin
Nov 23, 2014, 7:09:09 PM11/23/14
to
11/23/14
Dear Publius,
I am in the process of recording and uploading ( What I believe to be ) the answer to the Publius Enigma. I have had this particular perspective towards The Division Bell for over a year. I held off on making the videos because the 20 year release of The Division Bell was coming out and I figured there might be a clue or two in the re-release. I was wrong. Then, the press released a statement that The Endless River was coming out. So, I held off, yet again, for the release of that album. I figured there might be a clue or two in that album, I was wrong, again. I figured those clues would only enforce the "Central Purpose" and "Designed Solution" that I had come across in The Division Bell.
You told us in the message that you left on the 8th of July, 1994 that The Division Bell was not like its predecessors. You also told us that it was going to be open to multiple interpretations. Although, you did tell us that there is a central purpose and designed solution to The Division Bell. You said the INGENIOUS PERSON who comes to recognize what the information POINTS TO - a unique prize was secreted. In the 20 years of following the news-feeds here on this group, this particular perspective has yet to be unveiled. I am confident in my answer due to the fact it sums up the process that is actually occurring within The Division Bell.
The first video that I made lays the facts out on the table. I introduce the audience to The Division Bell album, its record sales, the world tour, the airship, and then the mysterious Publius posts. Towards the end of the video I reveal how the album is dealing with Spiritual Possession. How Pink Floyd is possessing the fans that go to their concerts and listen to their albums. Many of the songs within the Division Bell collaborate together to construct a network that describes how the "Spirit" possesses the listener and integrates itself within the listener.
I know that there is going to be the usual jeers and ridicule to "flame" my posts. No one would have thought that Pink Floyd was on tour in mode to possess everyone and that their albums even talk about them doing it. I guess the Pink Floyd audience chooses not to see David Gilmour or the group involved in such an act. I don't care - either way. I am just calling a "Spade" a "Spade" and laying it all out on the table. Anyhow, the ball is going to be in your court, Publius. I know that I am right and it is time for you to come out of hiding and finish what was started.
The first video just lays the foundation and is not too detailed. I want to step everyone through my perspective "Step by Step". You told us that "Lyrics, artwork and music will take you there". So, I want to review the lyrics, artwork and music so that everyone can see what I am seeing. I am doing this so they will know for certain where I am coming from. Also, you did say that this was a "perplexing and intricate problem" followed by a "particularly complex solution". So, not many people would even know how to think along these lines, I'll take the time to show them and also show you that I know the answer.
Here is the 1st video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKx4Fp6iRnI
Expect MANY more videos to follow. I am just saying "Hello" and that I am here in mode solving the enigma. The next video will deal with the artwork in the Division Bell and where it took me. Talk to you soon!
David Valentin
Dear Publius,
I am in the process of recording and uploading ( What I believe to be ) the answer to the Publius Enigma. I have had this particular perspective towards The Division Bell for over a year. I held off on making the videos because the 20 year release of The Division Bell was coming out and I figured there might be a clue or two in the re-release. I was wrong. Then, the press released a statement that The Endless River was coming out. So, I held off, yet again, for the release of that album. I figured there might be a clue or two in that album, I was wrong, again. I figured those clues would only enforce the "Central Purpose" and "Designed Solution" that I had come across in The Division Bell.
You told us in the message that you left on the 8th of July, 1994 that The Division Bell was not like its predecessors. You also told us that it was going to be open to multiple interpretations. Although, you did tell us that there is a central purpose and designed solution to The Division Bell. You said the INGENIOUS PERSON who comes to recognize what the information POINTS TO - a unique prize was secreted. In the 20 years of following the news-feeds here on this group, this particular perspective has yet to be unveiled. I am confident in my answer due to the fact it sums up the process that is actually occurring within The Division Bell.
The first video that I made lays the facts out on the table. I introduce the audience to The Division Bell album, its record sales, the world tour, the airship, and then the mysterious Publius posts. Towards the end of the video I reveal how the album is dealing with Spiritual Possession. How Pink Floyd is possessing the fans that go to their concerts and listen to their albums. Many of the songs within the Division Bell collaborate together to construct a network that describes how the "Spirit" possesses the listener and integrates itself within the listener.
I know that there is going to be the usual jeers and ridicule to "flame" my posts. No one would have thought that Pink Floyd was on tour in mode to possess everyone and that their albums even talk about them doing it. I guess the Pink Floyd audience chooses not to see David Gilmour or the group involved in such an act. I don't care - either way. I am just calling a "Spade" a "Spade" and laying it all out on the table. Anyhow, the ball is going to be in your court, Publius. I know that I am right and it is time for you to come out of hiding and finish what was started.
The first video just lays the foundation and is not too detailed. I want to step everyone through my perspective "Step by Step". You told us that "Lyrics, artwork and music will take you there". So, I want to review the lyrics, artwork and music so that everyone can see what I am seeing. I am doing this so they will know for certain where I am coming from. Also, you did say that this was a "perplexing and intricate problem" followed by a "particularly complex solution". So, not many people would even know how to think along these lines, I'll take the time to show them and also show you that I know the answer.
Here is the 1st video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKx4Fp6iRnI
Expect MANY more videos to follow. I am just saying "Hello" and that I am here in mode solving the enigma. The next video will deal with the artwork in the Division Bell and where it took me. Talk to you soon!
David Valentin
PiBoy
Nov 28, 2014, 6:01:22 PM11/28/14
to
On Sunday, November 23, 2014 6:09:09 PM UTC-6, David Valentin wrote:
> 11/23/14
Hi David,
I was the one who post on your youtube channel this morning. I was sick yesterday and wake up at 4 with a fever. But well thanks for the video is an excellent material you have achieve.
And you make me think about the Publius enigma messages.
Prologue:
So the year is 1994:
DARPA project "Internet" was on his prime and universities were taken the project to continue and start to open for the public. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA
In parallel the BBS started to became popular http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulletin_board_system . And this were guys on their home computer that have this BBS and have the deamon service of the newsgroup. So they offer this service to the public to share software and messages. This was fun I used to have one and have two lines so other people could connect to my computer. One person will log onto this computer by phone lines and chat in this newsgroups. In the night the computers of different BBS will communicate and share their message. In this newsgroups on the internet, i think not on homes, have this deamon service of anonymous messages that is why the bootleg of the messages this was a deamon service. (Deamon were programs that performed something, like a program, thats what they were called, I don't know why).
So whit this prologue what I wanted to point out is that Publius was connected to a BBS by phone line. Also by that time the guys that were there also were connected by BBS. I remember that when noise appears and wanted to erase something also noise appear as strange characters. So I guess this is the noise that appeared on his messages and that is why he re-post them.
Note: The word Flame was used when someone was talking you dirt.
So after this prologue lets start.
Let talk about Publius messages:
"There is a central purpose and a design solution"
As an artist and us as spectators what do the artist is trying to communicate with its work? This is were the Listen, read, think and communicate come from. Talk about their art on this "The Division Bell"
"Leading the blind while I stared out the steel in your eyes"
The band leading their fans while you look at this messages on your computer screen burning your eyes. May be...
So on the blimp: they wanted to make noise with their fans on the united states. I mean they sold 3 million copy over there. WOW!
Here are my thoughts.
Cover artwork: A Church a Parliament? This is were people will join to communicate. It have been said it is a church so this is were the plaza is, where people will join to communicate. To share ideas and time.
"Cluster One"
Artwork: is some kind of astrology think looking and listening into space.
We as a human kind have spend millions to listen to the sky.
Song: The noise on the song is us listening in space. So is Pink Floyd listening in this newsgroup?
So this is - LISTEN-
"What Do You Want from Me"
Artwork: A disco ball where we join to listen to music. Fan and Band? A concert? May be.
Song: This is the band speaking. Communicating to their fans. Maybe because their "great music" is subject to multiple interpretations the fans have been asking a look of strange questions... ??? They are just making art...
- The message of Pink Floyd to their fans.
- Communicating
"Poles Apart"
Artwork: They are from UK right? They are poles apart from all. I think they were speaking to their FAN in USA. So Earth red, ocean blue, and space. From one person to the other the ocean is separating them.
Song: I can figure this out right but maybe is the band speaking about Sid and Roger. Baby crying? Is their project come mature or is it a baby?
- The message Pink Floyd have been delivering on their other art work about Sid about Roger?
"Marooned"
Artwork: Two people communicating and maybe the steel face is representing the BBS chat room, specially the alt.music.pink-floyd. Band, fans and the internet guys (BBS).
Song: Instrumental with some rumble noises. The phone connection?
"A Great Day for Freedom"
Artwork: Flowers: Computers. Water: space in between this computers. And their communications. Newspapers: Representing the old in a museum? Are they going to disappear?
Song: Freedom of communication? The information era is it starting?
Left my side? All digital now?
Are they been listening to their fans on the BBS? They cannot open up?
Is people going to lose the patriotism because know they are communicating to each other? This question arise listening of what they want to say as they are the artist and trying to communicate something to their fans. I mean this is what the 60s were all about right? One nation one world no war?
"Wearing the Inside Out"
Artwork: A guy in his home watching the TV and the other light is his computer. With this I guess Pink Floyd have been communicating in this chat room since 1994.
Song: Pink Floyd communicating with their fans. They are making this new album The Division Bell. Paler? May be they were on their homes and not even they will go out to take the sun light. They are reuniting to make this album...
"Take It Back"
Artwork: The out doors. The planing for the tour.
Song: Making planes for the tour. Did they needed money to go on tour? Is she the bank?
"Coming Back to Life"
Artwork: Going on tour crossing the sea. Hopping they don't die doing it? jajaja and American police reviving the guy?
Song: Speaking to Roger? Problems with the legal situation on the band?
"Keep Talking"
Artwork: People communicating in social circles.
Song: Planning Publius Enigma? Arising question from their fans to them? Publicity? I mean they are communicating to their fans by this BBS.
"Lost for Words"
Artwork: Fighting globes. The BBS "Flames"? The people on the alt.music.pink-floyd? are they so mean people?
Song: Silence because this will get ugly on the BBS. So their enemies are on the newsgroup? So Publius will open the door? Are they talking to the guys on this newsgroup? May be.
"High Hopes"
Artwork: A guy walking on a desert land walking to their future? A factory leaving the land?
Song: Before electronics they were magnets. This was something magic. So this is the band telling a story about who they are. The new are of communications. Is like they were farm boys but have embrace change and walking to this new world. The bells is the church are of a church to go to the plaza is this the BBS newsgroup?
I guess the theme of The Division Bell is the album about the making of The Division Bell and Publius Enigma and the BBS newsgroup.
As a conclusion the price is that they were here in this alt.music.pink-floyd speaking to their fans.
The question is: Are they still here?
I guess this was the secret. They were talking in here with their fans.
With Love,
PiBoy
> 11/23/14
Hi David,
I was the one who post on your youtube channel this morning. I was sick yesterday and wake up at 4 with a fever. But well thanks for the video is an excellent material you have achieve.
And you make me think about the Publius enigma messages.
Prologue:
So the year is 1994:
DARPA project "Internet" was on his prime and universities were taken the project to continue and start to open for the public. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA
In parallel the BBS started to became popular http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulletin_board_system . And this were guys on their home computer that have this BBS and have the deamon service of the newsgroup. So they offer this service to the public to share software and messages. This was fun I used to have one and have two lines so other people could connect to my computer. One person will log onto this computer by phone lines and chat in this newsgroups. In the night the computers of different BBS will communicate and share their message. In this newsgroups on the internet, i think not on homes, have this deamon service of anonymous messages that is why the bootleg of the messages this was a deamon service. (Deamon were programs that performed something, like a program, thats what they were called, I don't know why).
So whit this prologue what I wanted to point out is that Publius was connected to a BBS by phone line. Also by that time the guys that were there also were connected by BBS. I remember that when noise appears and wanted to erase something also noise appear as strange characters. So I guess this is the noise that appeared on his messages and that is why he re-post them.
Note: The word Flame was used when someone was talking you dirt.
So after this prologue lets start.
Let talk about Publius messages:
"There is a central purpose and a design solution"
As an artist and us as spectators what do the artist is trying to communicate with its work? This is were the Listen, read, think and communicate come from. Talk about their art on this "The Division Bell"
"Leading the blind while I stared out the steel in your eyes"
The band leading their fans while you look at this messages on your computer screen burning your eyes. May be...
So on the blimp: they wanted to make noise with their fans on the united states. I mean they sold 3 million copy over there. WOW!
Here are my thoughts.
Cover artwork: A Church a Parliament? This is were people will join to communicate. It have been said it is a church so this is were the plaza is, where people will join to communicate. To share ideas and time.
"Cluster One"
Artwork: is some kind of astrology think looking and listening into space.
We as a human kind have spend millions to listen to the sky.
Song: The noise on the song is us listening in space. So is Pink Floyd listening in this newsgroup?
So this is - LISTEN-
"What Do You Want from Me"
Artwork: A disco ball where we join to listen to music. Fan and Band? A concert? May be.
Song: This is the band speaking. Communicating to their fans. Maybe because their "great music" is subject to multiple interpretations the fans have been asking a look of strange questions... ??? They are just making art...
- The message of Pink Floyd to their fans.
- Communicating
"Poles Apart"
Artwork: They are from UK right? They are poles apart from all. I think they were speaking to their FAN in USA. So Earth red, ocean blue, and space. From one person to the other the ocean is separating them.
Song: I can figure this out right but maybe is the band speaking about Sid and Roger. Baby crying? Is their project come mature or is it a baby?
- The message Pink Floyd have been delivering on their other art work about Sid about Roger?
"Marooned"
Artwork: Two people communicating and maybe the steel face is representing the BBS chat room, specially the alt.music.pink-floyd. Band, fans and the internet guys (BBS).
Song: Instrumental with some rumble noises. The phone connection?
"A Great Day for Freedom"
Artwork: Flowers: Computers. Water: space in between this computers. And their communications. Newspapers: Representing the old in a museum? Are they going to disappear?
Song: Freedom of communication? The information era is it starting?
Left my side? All digital now?
Are they been listening to their fans on the BBS? They cannot open up?
Is people going to lose the patriotism because know they are communicating to each other? This question arise listening of what they want to say as they are the artist and trying to communicate something to their fans. I mean this is what the 60s were all about right? One nation one world no war?
"Wearing the Inside Out"
Artwork: A guy in his home watching the TV and the other light is his computer. With this I guess Pink Floyd have been communicating in this chat room since 1994.
Song: Pink Floyd communicating with their fans. They are making this new album The Division Bell. Paler? May be they were on their homes and not even they will go out to take the sun light. They are reuniting to make this album...
"Take It Back"
Artwork: The out doors. The planing for the tour.
Song: Making planes for the tour. Did they needed money to go on tour? Is she the bank?
"Coming Back to Life"
Artwork: Going on tour crossing the sea. Hopping they don't die doing it? jajaja and American police reviving the guy?
Song: Speaking to Roger? Problems with the legal situation on the band?
"Keep Talking"
Artwork: People communicating in social circles.
Song: Planning Publius Enigma? Arising question from their fans to them? Publicity? I mean they are communicating to their fans by this BBS.
"Lost for Words"
Artwork: Fighting globes. The BBS "Flames"? The people on the alt.music.pink-floyd? are they so mean people?
Song: Silence because this will get ugly on the BBS. So their enemies are on the newsgroup? So Publius will open the door? Are they talking to the guys on this newsgroup? May be.
"High Hopes"
Artwork: A guy walking on a desert land walking to their future? A factory leaving the land?
Song: Before electronics they were magnets. This was something magic. So this is the band telling a story about who they are. The new are of communications. Is like they were farm boys but have embrace change and walking to this new world. The bells is the church are of a church to go to the plaza is this the BBS newsgroup?
I guess the theme of The Division Bell is the album about the making of The Division Bell and Publius Enigma and the BBS newsgroup.
As a conclusion the price is that they were here in this alt.music.pink-floyd speaking to their fans.
The question is: Are they still here?
I guess this was the secret. They were talking in here with their fans.
With Love,
PiBoy
Message has been deleted
David Valentin
May 24, 2015, 6:10:02 PM5/24/15
to
To Publius, and all my friends, family, and respected colleagues around the world, the time has come. The task of finishing the videos for the "Unraveling the Publius Enigma" video series is finally complete. I want to thank everyone for their patience as I worked on these videos. I am not at all in any way a cartoonist. You will see that I made some pretty elaborate cartoons to describe the actions and interactions that are occurring within six of the Division Bell songs. I firmly believe that the cartoons would be a helpful aid in the process of easily understanding the complexities of the Division Bell concept. I hope that you find the videos entertaining and that they help you in your quest to understanding the Publius Enigma. If you can, try to watch these videos on a smart TV or on your home computer monitor. I will be displaying text in some of the videos. The text would appear small on your smartphone, if you did end up watching the videos on your phones. I went the extra mile and filmed all the videos in 1920 x 1080 resolution, high Def, baby! The images should be as sharp as a tack! No pixelating when I am on the job! As always, I will be here to answer any questions or comments that you might have in the material that I have provided within the videos. Please, watch the videos from part 1 all the way in order to part 19. If you are in the need for some quick entertainment, watch the music videos first. Those cartoons were fun to make and I can't help but laugh every time I watch them. The Uncle Custard clue is solved in part 18. If you skip to that video first you will spoil the surprise! So, without further ado here is the links to the videos, enjoy!
P.S.
Hey, Publius............GOTCHA! I think it's time we had our little talk now, wouldn't you say so? The world has been waiting 20 years. Don't let them down. In the videos I reveal the "Central Purpose" and then go into great detail on the "Designed Solution". Make sure to watch "Part 3 : The Silence Triad". Watching that quick video will let you know I know what is up! So, the ball is truly in your court. Here I am!
UNRAVELING THE PUBLIUS ENIGMA VIDEO SERIES:
Part 1 : The Messages - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKx4Fp6iRnI
Part 2 : The Artwork - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zrMixM750-I
Part 3 : The Silence Triad - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IoAquInBTCA
Part 4 : The Timeline - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYTwEsrwkfM
Part 5 : What Do You Want From Me Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EpUX8-Su8ss
Part 6 : What Do You Want From Me Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zI8jnqTqfy8
Part 7 : Poles Apart Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=trMP1AnAaxQ
Part 8 : Poles Apart Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rk4IFNGhQPg
Part 9 : Wearing The Inside Out Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=edS8SWOKCEk
Part 10 : Wearing The Inside Out Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1wQpWBaA_V0
Part 11 : Keep Talking Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n55LLCtL73o
Part 12 : Keep Talking Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_QwnPaobHk
Part 13 : Lost For Words Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XDbNiJpLbdg
Part 14 : Lost For Words Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wXCgcM09KDE
Part 15 : Coming Back To Life Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1aOb1A_E0xg
Part 16 : Coming Back To Life Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iwv31P-0X5g
Part 17 : Conclusion Part 1 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FmGX9M1EB6k
Part 18 : Conclusion Part 2 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9a6d7GnXaJ4
Part 19 : Conclusion Part 3 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zH4khQe4HcQ
P.S.
Hey, Publius............GOTCHA! I think it's time we had our little talk now, wouldn't you say so? The world has been waiting 20 years. Don't let them down. In the videos I reveal the "Central Purpose" and then go into great detail on the "Designed Solution". Make sure to watch "Part 3 : The Silence Triad". Watching that quick video will let you know I know what is up! So, the ball is truly in your court. Here I am!
UNRAVELING THE PUBLIUS ENIGMA VIDEO SERIES:
Part 1 : The Messages - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKx4Fp6iRnI
Part 2 : The Artwork - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zrMixM750-I
Part 3 : The Silence Triad - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IoAquInBTCA
Part 4 : The Timeline - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYTwEsrwkfM
Part 5 : What Do You Want From Me Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EpUX8-Su8ss
Part 6 : What Do You Want From Me Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zI8jnqTqfy8
Part 7 : Poles Apart Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=trMP1AnAaxQ
Part 8 : Poles Apart Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rk4IFNGhQPg
Part 9 : Wearing The Inside Out Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=edS8SWOKCEk
Part 10 : Wearing The Inside Out Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1wQpWBaA_V0
Part 11 : Keep Talking Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n55LLCtL73o
Part 12 : Keep Talking Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_QwnPaobHk
Part 13 : Lost For Words Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XDbNiJpLbdg
Part 14 : Lost For Words Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wXCgcM09KDE
Part 15 : Coming Back To Life Music Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1aOb1A_E0xg
Part 16 : Coming Back To Life Explained - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iwv31P-0X5g
Part 17 : Conclusion Part 1 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FmGX9M1EB6k
Part 18 : Conclusion Part 2 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9a6d7GnXaJ4
Part 19 : Conclusion Part 3 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zH4khQe4HcQ
keepta...@gmail.com
Mar 3, 2017, 7:38:31 AM3/3/17
to
denises...@yahoo.com
Oct 11, 2018, 9:38:09 AM10/11/18
to
It's been solved. Https://PubliusEnigmaSolved.com
denises...@yahoo.com
Oct 11, 2018, 3:28:59 PM10/11/18
to
The answer is in Syds question.
denises...@yahoo.com
Oct 15, 2018, 8:18:54 PM10/15/18
to
Publius wrote the clues steel, steer, crank and be prepared to travel.
Those are car clues.
Boxing glove in artwork with 3 ties. MIchigan is the mitten or glove state
Tour program hold page with cities listed, point of cape on the other side
Points to Detroit
Gilmour said he had an emotional moment in Detroit during a interview
Detroit was chosen as the city where the DSOTM was played in its entirety
I was given a gift of TDB to help me tell my story for Justice..the Enigma was
Invented to get more people to hear about it. But there is a prize and I'm willing to share
whatever parts of it I can if people will help me get the story out into the public
Fans were suppose to believe me and help me get my story out for justice.
I came here to share the gift with fans years ago.
GIlmour and others are waiting for you to help me.
Https://PubliusEnigmaSolved.com
Those are car clues.
Boxing glove in artwork with 3 ties. MIchigan is the mitten or glove state
Tour program hold page with cities listed, point of cape on the other side
Points to Detroit
Gilmour said he had an emotional moment in Detroit during a interview
Detroit was chosen as the city where the DSOTM was played in its entirety
I was given a gift of TDB to help me tell my story for Justice..the Enigma was
Invented to get more people to hear about it. But there is a prize and I'm willing to share
whatever parts of it I can if people will help me get the story out into the public
Fans were suppose to believe me and help me get my story out for justice.
I came here to share the gift with fans years ago.
GIlmour and others are waiting for you to help me.
Https://PubliusEnigmaSolved.com
innertide
Oct 18, 2018, 6:46:31 AM10/18/18
to
yuh tenks fer shure-ing
divisionb...@gmail.com
Aug 1, 2019, 3:42:12 AM8/1/19
to
myriadsmallcreature
Aug 1, 2019, 2:29:14 PM8/1/19
to
So, what was your prize?
E. Nygma
Aug 1, 2019, 7:02:08 PM8/1/19
to
Man, I sure love me a good kook fight.
myriadsmallcreature
Aug 1, 2019, 7:53:02 PM8/1/19
to
David worked so hard. He deserves a prize.
comcou...@gmail.com
Aug 3, 2019, 5:59:43 AM8/3/19
to
even if you were onto something there is always more phat organic textiles in your way.
myriadsmallcreature
Aug 3, 2019, 9:11:35 AM8/3/19
to
On Saturday, August 3, 2019 at 4:59:43 AM UTC-5, comcou...@gmail.com wrote:
> even if you were onto something there is always more phat organic textiles in your way.
No man also seweth a piece of new cloth upon an old garment; else the new piece that filleth it up agreeth not with the old: it taketh away from the old, and the rent is made worse.
> even if you were onto something there is always more phat organic textiles in your way.
If your purpose is to solve the Publius Enigma, no one is in your way.
If your purpose is to persuade others, obstacles may arise.
Hello?
E. Nygma
Aug 3, 2019, 10:18:55 AM8/3/19
to
Team-building exercises are constructed the same way in office environments. You get various departments to work individually on approaching a particular challenge and then compare the results, usually by a panel of judges, with the promise of some reward for the group. The reward is usually relatively lame compared to the effort (free pizza parties are the standard), on the premise that the "real" reward is supposed to be the bonding between team members (and thus the departments).
myriadsmallcreature
Aug 3, 2019, 11:07:01 AM8/3/19
to
This [i]may[/i], and I don't use the word 'may' haphazardly, this may say more about you than the Publius Enigma. For that matter, I don't use the word 'obstacles' haphazardly. Obstacles may arise.
Like Jesus' parables, the Publiis' messages may seem to mean one thing, but actually mean something different.
To put it in a way you might grasp, while the Enigma approximates cybernetics, in a system of self and other, you could say, the steersman is always shown [i]alone[/i] in the boat, at the oar, and needs no consensus. Indeed consensus is the end, in one program, and not the means.
A solitary enterprise which benefits from feedback, but needs none.
Now, the Bodhisattva vow, that's a whole nother thing altogether.
Like Jesus' parables, the Publiis' messages may seem to mean one thing, but actually mean something different.
To put it in a way you might grasp, while the Enigma approximates cybernetics, in a system of self and other, you could say, the steersman is always shown [i]alone[/i] in the boat, at the oar, and needs no consensus. Indeed consensus is the end, in one program, and not the means.
A solitary enterprise which benefits from feedback, but needs none.
Now, the Bodhisattva vow, that's a whole nother thing altogether.
myriadsmallcreature
Aug 3, 2019, 11:09:12 AM8/3/19
to
Meditate on the differences between puzzle, riddle and enigma.
Comprehensive coverage in threads below.
Comprehensive coverage in threads below.
Message has been deleted
comcou...@gmail.com
Aug 4, 2019, 2:35:56 AM8/4/19
to
who tells you that? maybe the enigma begs to NOT be solved, fucking asshat.
and that is why. i have already solved it by all means.
and that is why. i have already solved it by all means.
myriadsmallcreature
Aug 4, 2019, 5:19:02 AM8/4/19
to
On Sunday, August 4, 2019 at 1:35:56 AM UTC-5, comcou...@gmail.com wrote:
> who tells you that? maybe the enigma begs to NOT be solved, fucking asshat.
>
> and that is why. i have already solved it by all means.
Nina, how have you been?
> who tells you that? maybe the enigma begs to NOT be solved, fucking asshat.
>
> and that is why. i have already solved it by all means.
comcou...@gmail.com
Aug 5, 2019, 3:36:36 AM8/5/19
to
in what distinction?
HumbleBob2
Aug 5, 2019, 3:50:45 AM8/5/19
to
Seems like a couple of people here already feel like they've solved it and don't seek feedback or validation but seem content on maintaining the illusion that they've found the answer.
I don't pretend to have solved the Enigma, but I still feel as though I've learned something that a lot of people don't seem to comprehend.
What did I learn? I dunno, a lot of stuff that's hard to explain.
I have a theory that the Enigma is only supposed to be solved up to a certain point. To pinpoint the solution on the nose is to completely change the way you see the Universe.
Yes, I still think it has something to do with aliens, mind control and a host of esoteric subjects, but I think the TRUE answer is something unique and tailor-made for the individual to experience.
That doesn't explain why Publius's messages were focused on communication as a means to solving the Enigma.
I don't see much communication going on here. I see this guy David, who believes he's solved the Enigma, thwarting naysayers and sticking to his story. Good for him.
However, I think that for true discourse to begin we need to question what we think we know about the Enigma.
I've been trying to get answers and thoughts in this group for a while now without much luck.
Ant seems to be the only one who takes on information and reassembles his thoughts in a way that ecourages more thinking to be done about the Enigma.
Sure, Ant seems to be another one who believes they've solved the mystery but is clever enough not to state something so controversial.
We should ALL be holding the position that we don't know what the fuck is going on. We need help from Publius and it's been to long a time to suggest that he will ever show up again, oh well.
That just leaves it up to us to guess which path to take next.
If only we could all be following the same threads at the same time, trying to solve this thing together, but it seems like communication has been the GREATEST obstacle of all the obstacles that have popped up along the way.
No, I haven't been here since the beginning, but I DO believe that the Publius Enigma is one, perhaps the strongest one, indication that there are people out there that simply know something that we don't.
And we're still not seeing it.
What is it?
I don't pretend to have solved the Enigma, but I still feel as though I've learned something that a lot of people don't seem to comprehend.
What did I learn? I dunno, a lot of stuff that's hard to explain.
I have a theory that the Enigma is only supposed to be solved up to a certain point. To pinpoint the solution on the nose is to completely change the way you see the Universe.
Yes, I still think it has something to do with aliens, mind control and a host of esoteric subjects, but I think the TRUE answer is something unique and tailor-made for the individual to experience.
That doesn't explain why Publius's messages were focused on communication as a means to solving the Enigma.
I don't see much communication going on here. I see this guy David, who believes he's solved the Enigma, thwarting naysayers and sticking to his story. Good for him.
However, I think that for true discourse to begin we need to question what we think we know about the Enigma.
I've been trying to get answers and thoughts in this group for a while now without much luck.
Ant seems to be the only one who takes on information and reassembles his thoughts in a way that ecourages more thinking to be done about the Enigma.
Sure, Ant seems to be another one who believes they've solved the mystery but is clever enough not to state something so controversial.
We should ALL be holding the position that we don't know what the fuck is going on. We need help from Publius and it's been to long a time to suggest that he will ever show up again, oh well.
That just leaves it up to us to guess which path to take next.
If only we could all be following the same threads at the same time, trying to solve this thing together, but it seems like communication has been the GREATEST obstacle of all the obstacles that have popped up along the way.
No, I haven't been here since the beginning, but I DO believe that the Publius Enigma is one, perhaps the strongest one, indication that there are people out there that simply know something that we don't.
And we're still not seeing it.
What is it?
myriadsmallcreature
Aug 5, 2019, 8:34:08 AM8/5/19
to
On Monday, August 5, 2019 at 2:36:36 AM UTC-5, comcou...@gmail.com wrote:
> in what distinction?
As in, how do you feel? Overall.
Refresh my memory: What is your solution to the Publius Enigma?
> in what distinction?
As in, how do you feel? Overall.
Refresh my memory: What is your solution to the Publius Enigma?
calvin...@gmail.com
Feb 10, 2020, 8:34:16 PM2/10/20
to
I'm New to the game of legends and mysteries, but am really interested in huge legends and puzzles. Would someone mind clarifying this fight for the answer to the enigma? Didn't Publius say the only way it could be solved is with collaboration? If so, why does David claim to have the answer why he's obviously denying collaboration? There may be more to it, but this is my current standpoint
E. Nygma
Feb 10, 2020, 9:26:57 PM2/10/20
to
On Monday, February 10, 2020 at 8:34:16 PM UTC-5, calvi...@gmail.com wrote:
> I'm New to the game of legends and mysteries, but am really interested in huge legends and puzzles. Would someone mind clarifying this fight for the answer to the enigma? Didn't Publius say the only way it could be solved is with collaboration? If so, why does David claim to have the answer why he's obviously denying collaboration? There may be more to it, but this is my current standpoint
The simplest answer is that David Valentin was a nutjob. Most people who think they've got the solution are.
> I'm New to the game of legends and mysteries, but am really interested in huge legends and puzzles. Would someone mind clarifying this fight for the answer to the enigma? Didn't Publius say the only way it could be solved is with collaboration? If so, why does David claim to have the answer why he's obviously denying collaboration? There may be more to it, but this is my current standpoint
I have to give him credit, though. He put in a LOT of hours making those video essays (and that's a generous description) and the animations, especially.
Maybe Non-Humble Humble Bob was right. As fascinated as I am by the kooky answers people have, maybe I should be nicer to the crazies.
Legends and mysteries? You mean in general? Like, just looking up crazy shit on the Internet?
Antimony James
Oct 30, 2020, 3:47:54 AM10/30/20
to
David, your videos are relatively well made but they are much sound and fury signifying nothing.
Is anyone else from the old publiusenigma.com still around? A_rod77, Nina, Big, Chinagreenelvis, Big, Myriadsmallcreatures, hell I,d love to hear Little's madness again.
Hit me up in twitter if you are antiminyjames on there.
Let's keeping talking, I think we're seeing the Enigma unfold around us.
Is anyone else from the old publiusenigma.com still around? A_rod77, Nina, Big, Chinagreenelvis, Big, Myriadsmallcreatures, hell I,d love to hear Little's madness again.
Hit me up in twitter if you are antiminyjames on there.
Let's keeping talking, I think we're seeing the Enigma unfold around us.
Antimony James
Oct 30, 2020, 3:50:40 AM10/30/20
to
Sorry I'm @antimonyjames on twitter, damn typos.
myriadsmallcreature
Oct 30, 2020, 4:58:47 PM10/30/20
to
Time is passing so quickly, I can't keep up.
myriadsmallcreature
Oct 30, 2020, 5:08:02 PM10/30/20
to
> Is anyone else from the old publiusenigma.com still around? A_rod77, Nina, Big, Chinagreenelvis, Big, Myriadsmallcreatures, hell I,d love to hear Little's madness again.
Almost identical to a post from laughing freeman some years back. If so, a shout out.
a_rod_777
Nov 20, 2020, 12:14:42 PM11/20/20
to
On Friday, October 30, 2020 at 2:58:47 PM UTC-6, myriadsmallcreature wrote:
> Time is passing so quickly, I can't keep up.
Time is relative my old friend. Precisely why immortality is not only attainable but a fundamental staple of existence.
> Time is passing so quickly, I can't keep up.
We are never going anywhere except through our own endless halls of illusions we impose on our self.
I often hope you are doing well. I will always remain indebted to all of you and your willingness and kindness in providing selflessly, the tools that were needed to achieve such a monumental task of the mind.
Truly blessings shine down on us. Just look around you.
Who do you think rattled that lock?
Believe it or not, it makes little difference, but they do talk about us in secret circles and what we uncovered and were able to bring forth for the world to behold. Not that I ever needed anyone's verification, but I have received it from multiple channels far outside this sphere of influence. Some might even say we have become somewhat legends in the underground world of Angels and Demons and the webs they weave.
Cheers to you all The New Order of the Knights of the Round Table. You have healed the King and in the process healed the land.
For the King was never a single man, but rather the symbol of Truth that must be championed in order that the world may be renewed in the conscious flame of Gnosis and The Kingdom of Heaven on Earth made manifest and anew once again.
Indeed Sir Antimony James . . . we are still here, guarding the Grail.
David Romero
Jan 30, 2023, 1:51:51 AM1/30/23
to
El domingo, 23 de noviembre de 2014 a las 18:09:09 UTC-6, David Valentin escribió:
> 11/23/14
>
> Dear Publius,
>
> I am in the process of recording and uploading ( What I believe to be ) the answer to the Publius Enigma. I have had this particular perspective towards The Division Bell for over a year. I held off on making the videos because the 20 year release of The Division Bell was coming out and I figured there might be a clue or two in the re-release. I was wrong. Then, the press released a statement that The Endless River was coming out. So, I held off, yet again, for the release of that album. I figured there might be a clue or two in that album, I was wrong, again. I figured those clues would only enforce the "Central Purpose" and "Designed Solution" that I had come across in The Division Bell.
>
> You told us in the message that you left on the 8th of July, 1994 that The Division Bell was not like its predecessors. You also told us that it was going to be open to multiple interpretations. Although, you did tell us that there is a central purpose and designed solution to The Division Bell. You said the INGENIOUS PERSON who comes to recognize what the information POINTS TO - a unique prize was secreted. In the 20 years of following the news-feeds here on this group, this particular perspective has yet to be unveiled. I am confident in my answer due to the fact it sums up the process that is actually occurring within The Division Bell.
>
> The first video that I made lays the facts out on the table. I introduce the audience to The Division Bell album, its record sales, the world tour, the airship, and then the mysterious Publius posts. Towards the end of the video I reveal how the album is dealing with Spiritual Possession. How Pink Floyd is possessing the fans that go to their concerts and listen to their albums. Many of the songs within the Division Bell collaborate together to construct a network that describes how the "Spirit" possesses the listener and integrates itself within the listener.
>
> I know that there is going to be the usual jeers and ridicule to "flame" my posts. No one would have thought that Pink Floyd was on tour in mode to possess everyone and that their albums even talk about them doing it. I guess the Pink Floyd audience chooses not to see David Gilmour or the group involved in such an act. I don't care - either way. I am just calling a "Spade" a "Spade" and laying it all out on the table. Anyhow, the ball is going to be in your court, Publius. I know that I am right and it is time for you to come out of hiding and finish what was started.
>
> The first video just lays the foundation and is not too detailed. I want to step everyone through my perspective "Step by Step". You told us that "Lyrics, artwork and music will take you there". So, I want to review the lyrics, artwork and music so that everyone can see what I am seeing. I am doing this so they will know for certain where I am coming from. Also, you did say that this was a "perplexing and intricate problem" followed by a "particularly complex solution". So, not many people would even know how to think along these lines, I'll take the time to show them and also show you that I know the answer.
>
> Here is the 1st video:
> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKx4Fp6iRnI
>
> Expect MANY more videos to follow. I am just saying "Hello" and that I am here in mode solving the enigma. The next video will deal with the artwork in the Division Bell and where it took me. Talk to you soon!
>
> David Valentin
Dear David
Some time ago I discover your videos about the Publius Enigma messages but now they are private. Will you put them online again? I'm really interested in watching them
Thank you so much!
> 11/23/14
>
> Dear Publius,
>
> I am in the process of recording and uploading ( What I believe to be ) the answer to the Publius Enigma. I have had this particular perspective towards The Division Bell for over a year. I held off on making the videos because the 20 year release of The Division Bell was coming out and I figured there might be a clue or two in the re-release. I was wrong. Then, the press released a statement that The Endless River was coming out. So, I held off, yet again, for the release of that album. I figured there might be a clue or two in that album, I was wrong, again. I figured those clues would only enforce the "Central Purpose" and "Designed Solution" that I had come across in The Division Bell.
>
> You told us in the message that you left on the 8th of July, 1994 that The Division Bell was not like its predecessors. You also told us that it was going to be open to multiple interpretations. Although, you did tell us that there is a central purpose and designed solution to The Division Bell. You said the INGENIOUS PERSON who comes to recognize what the information POINTS TO - a unique prize was secreted. In the 20 years of following the news-feeds here on this group, this particular perspective has yet to be unveiled. I am confident in my answer due to the fact it sums up the process that is actually occurring within The Division Bell.
>
> The first video that I made lays the facts out on the table. I introduce the audience to The Division Bell album, its record sales, the world tour, the airship, and then the mysterious Publius posts. Towards the end of the video I reveal how the album is dealing with Spiritual Possession. How Pink Floyd is possessing the fans that go to their concerts and listen to their albums. Many of the songs within the Division Bell collaborate together to construct a network that describes how the "Spirit" possesses the listener and integrates itself within the listener.
>
> I know that there is going to be the usual jeers and ridicule to "flame" my posts. No one would have thought that Pink Floyd was on tour in mode to possess everyone and that their albums even talk about them doing it. I guess the Pink Floyd audience chooses not to see David Gilmour or the group involved in such an act. I don't care - either way. I am just calling a "Spade" a "Spade" and laying it all out on the table. Anyhow, the ball is going to be in your court, Publius. I know that I am right and it is time for you to come out of hiding and finish what was started.
>
> The first video just lays the foundation and is not too detailed. I want to step everyone through my perspective "Step by Step". You told us that "Lyrics, artwork and music will take you there". So, I want to review the lyrics, artwork and music so that everyone can see what I am seeing. I am doing this so they will know for certain where I am coming from. Also, you did say that this was a "perplexing and intricate problem" followed by a "particularly complex solution". So, not many people would even know how to think along these lines, I'll take the time to show them and also show you that I know the answer.
>
> Here is the 1st video:
> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKx4Fp6iRnI
>
> Expect MANY more videos to follow. I am just saying "Hello" and that I am here in mode solving the enigma. The next video will deal with the artwork in the Division Bell and where it took me. Talk to you soon!
>
> David Valentin
Dear David
Some time ago I discover your videos about the Publius Enigma messages but now they are private. Will you put them online again? I'm really interested in watching them
Thank you so much!
E. Nygma
Apr 13, 2023, 6:03:32 AM4/13/23
to
It's over nine hours of him reading things and saying, "Hmm, that's interesting," but not having any actual responses or thoughts. He just shoehorns in a conclusion that David Gilmour was using magic powers to use demon possession on his audiences. He put crazy amounts of time and work into making animations to illustrate this, which is the most impressive part. The rest is basically nonsense, which is what most theories turn out to be.
0 new messages